VOX POPULI: ‘Self-serving theatrics' warp political spats over Ishiba
Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba has declared, 'I will not step down,' defying a growing chorus of voices within his own Liberal Democratic Party calling for his resignation following the LDP-Komeito coalition's recent electoral defeat.
Ishiba is reportedly furious with lawmakers from the now-defunct LDP faction once led by former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe (1954-2022), many of whom are leading the charge for his ouster.
'Who dragged the LDP into such disrepair? All they ever think about is themselves,' he is said to have complained.
But if that's truly how he feels, why didn't he confront them earlier?
Within the ruling party, criticism has intensified in the wake of the electoral pasting, with some members saying, 'It's unacceptable that no one is taking responsibility.'
That's a valid argument. But if so, why have they been turning a blind eye to their own role in downplaying scandals such as the unreported political funds accumulated by certain LDP factions and the party's murky ties with the Unification Church, formally called the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification?
Do they truly believe that simply replacing the party leader will resolve the deep-rooted issues it faces?
Opposition party leaders have also taken a hard line, declaring, 'The public has delivered a vote of no confidence to the Ishiba Cabinet.'
But if that's truly the case, why didn't they introduce a no-confidence motion themselves much earlier? They certainly had ample opportunities to act.
It's often said that politicians are a reflection of the people. We don't expect them all to be model citizens or wise statesmen.
But if today's Nagatacho—Japan's political nerve center—is a mirror of ourselves, it's hard not to sigh. The endless infighting and self-serving theatrics have left the public weary and disillusioned.
Politics, as political philosopher Masao Maruyama (1914-1996) once observed, drawing on the thoughts of Meiji Era (1868-1912) educator and writer Yukichi Fukuzawa (1835-1901), is ultimately 'a choice between degrees of badness.'
Expecting the best from politics often ends in disappointment. In his essay 'Seijiteki Handan' (On political judgment), Maruyama, a leading figure in postwar political thought, argued that what truly matters is choosing the path that is 'even slightly less bad.'
The LDP will convene an informal meeting of its lawmakers from both houses of the Diet on July 28. What will be said there? We should watch closely and commit this cacophonous theater of self-interest to memory.
Democracy, though often winding, allows for self-correction. When we change, the reflection we see in the mirror will change as well.
—The Asahi Shimbun, July 28
* * *
Vox Populi, Vox Dei is a popular daily column that takes up a wide range of topics, including culture, arts and social trends and developments. Written by veteran Asahi Shimbun writers, the column provides useful perspectives on and insights into contemporary Japan and its culture.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Japan Times
2 hours ago
- Japan Times
Why Ishiba refuses to quit even amid intense pressure for him to go
Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba faces intense pressure within the Liberal Democratic Party to take responsibility for three election defeats by resigning. But he remains at bat following his third strike as the head of the LDP — the party's July 20 Upper House election loss. Ishiba's first strike came after becoming LDP president in September last year, when he led the party to a Lower House election a month later in which it lost its majority. The second strike came when the LDP was dealt a huge blow in the Tokyo Metropolitan Assembly election in June, during which it lost nine seats and was relegated to becoming the second-largest party in the assembly, behind Tokyo Gov. Yuriko Koike's Tomin First no Kai (Tokyoites First). In a meeting with party executives and angry LDP lawmakers on Monday, Ishiba resisted calls for him to resign, saying he would stay on as party president and prime minister in order to prevent a political vacuum from forming. 'It's important that public opinion and our party's views are aligned,' Ishiba said, adding that an appropriate decision on his future would be made with these and other factors in mind. Recent media polls suggest that the public is not as anxious as many in the LDP to see Ishiba resign over the electoral losses, which past party presidents have often done. The LDP is also expected to complete its own evaluation of the Upper House results, and why it lost, by mid-August. Ishiba is likely to wait until the party's conclusions are official before formally deciding his future. Ishiba says that his insistence on remaining, at least for now, is also due to specific policy issues. On Tuesday, he told reporters that he wanted to make sure the 15% tariff deal with the U.S. is implemented. He said it was vital to examine the impact of the agreement on the roughly 4,300 domestic items covered by it. Pro-Ishiba demonstrators concerned about who might succeed him in the event that he steps down urge the prime minister to stay on during the rally on Friday. | AFP-JIJI Another reason Ishiba isn't bowing to pressure to resign is a busy August schedule. He'll likely attend events related to the 80th anniversary of the end of World War II, such as memorial services for victims of atomic bombings in Hiroshima on Aug. 6 and Nagasaki on Aug. 9, as well as a ceremony commemorating Japan's war dead on Aug. 15. The Bon summer holidays follow soon after, and then Ishiba will welcome African leaders to the Tokyo International Conference on African Development that takes place from Aug. 20 to Aug. 22. Once August ends, any push for a leadership change becomes tricky as the political world prepares for the opening of the autumn session of parliament. The timeline is sure to be on the minds of LDP members seeking to oust Ishiba as quickly as possible. These include Sanae Takaichi, a former economic security minister and a conservative, and Toshimitsu Motegi, a veteran leader and a former party secretary-general. Both are trying to boost their standings within the party and among the public by criticizing Ishiba, who is in no hurry to let either of his rivals take over. While many LDP members agree Ishiba needs to go, the party — still reeling from the three election losses — has not rallied around a single rival candidate due to its own internal divisions. To win an LDP presidential election, a candidate needs to win a majority of votes from party parliamentarians and local chapters in the first round, or in a runoff between the top two first-round finishers. Yet even if an Ishiba rival manages to rally enough supporters to win the LDP presidency, the prime minister job is not guaranteed due to the party's lack of any parliamentary majority. Anyone replacing Ishiba would have to secure votes from at least one of the main opposition parties to become prime minister. For that to happen, LDP executives and opposition parties would first need to hammer out a deal right after a presidential election takes place. That could prove difficult to do quickly before the start of the autumn session of parliament, and would risk internal dissent within the LDP as well as create political problems for an opposition party leader who must convince members to vote for an LDP candidate to become prime minister rather than one of their own. Many want to see Ishiba strike out, but replacing him may not guarantee a more stable LDP or a more stable political situation. Staff writer Gabriele Ninivaggi contributed to this report.
The Mainichi
2 hours ago
- The Mainichi
Tokyo stocks drop for 3rd day amid Japan political uncertainty
TOKYO (Kyodo) -- Tokyo stocks ended lower Tuesday for a third consecutive trading day on selling amid political uncertainty in Japan and ahead of a U.S. monetary policy meeting and other key events. The 225-issue Nikkei Stock Average fell 323.72 points, or 0.79 percent, from Monday at 40,674.55. The broader Topix index finished 22.09 points, or 0.75 percent, lower at 2,908.64. On the top-tier Prime Market, decliners were led by transportation equipment, machinery and securities house issues. The U.S. dollar fluctuated in the 148 yen range in Tokyo without clear direction, amid a lack of new incentives. The stock market continued to face selling pressure by investors locking in gains after last week's surge on a Japan-U.S. trade agreement, with auto shares and heavyweight semiconductor-related issues notably falling. "Stocks fell as investors regained calmness about the trade deal that resulted in a 15 percent U.S. tariff (on Japanese imports) and political situations remaining very unclear" in Japan, said Masahiro Ichikawa, chief market strategist at Sumitomo Mitsui DS Asset Management Co. Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba insists on remaining in office despite calls within his party for him to step down following the ruling coalition's major setback in the latest national election. Investors were also cautious before major economic events later this week, including policy meetings of the U.S. and Japanese central banks as well as releases of earnings results and U.S. jobs data, brokers said.
Japan Today
3 hours ago
- Japan Today
Japan ruling party eyes plenary meeting amid rift over PM resignation
Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba attends a press conference at the headquarters of the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) in Tokyo. Japan's ruling Liberal Democratic Party decided Tuesday to hold a plenary meeting of its parliamentary members soon, as Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba insists on remaining in office despite calls from among his party to step down following a devastating national election loss. The joint plenary meeting of members of both houses of the Diet is one of the LDP's decision-making bodies. A similar gathering was held on Monday in a less formal setting where many members called on Ishiba, the LDP president, to step down. The upcoming gathering could put further pressure on Ishiba, who has stressed the need to avoid a political vacuum at a time when the nation is facing a host of challenges, including the imposition of U.S. tariffs on Japanese imports. "It all comes down to explaining myself carefully, sincerely and without running away," Ishiba said. LDP Secretary General Hiroshi Moriyama told reporters that details, such as the date and agenda of the meeting, have yet to be set. Asked whether a joint plenary meeting has the authority to call for a snap party leadership election, Moriyama said it would involve a "very complex" process. The gathering is designated as a forum to discuss and decide in a majority vote on "particularly important" matters regarding the party's management and Diet affairs, according to the party's rules. In an emergency situation, such as when the head of the LDP resigns during a presidential term, a joint plenary meeting can elect a new party chief, substituting for a party convention. Although the ruling bloc no longer holds a majority in either chamber of parliament, a newly elected LDP president would still have a chance of becoming prime minister as the party and its smaller coalition partner Komeito are the largest force in the more powerful House of Representatives. Some LDP members have been collecting signatures to urge the leadership to hold a formal plenary meeting in their bid to hold Ishiba accountable. On Monday, LDP lawmakers from both houses of parliament held a meeting with party executives to discuss the outcome of the recent election and vent their feelings toward the leadership. It lasted well over four hours. The LDP's internal wrangling is expected to continue at a busy time for the government. An extraordinary Diet session will begin on Friday to select the upper house's new president following the July 20 election, which resulted in the LDP-Komeito bloc losing its majority and smaller opposition parties, including rightwing populist party Sanseito, increasing their presence. Ishiba is scheduled to explain to parliament the details of a trade agreement recently reached between Japan and the United States. The Japanese prime minister will also attend ceremonies to mark the U.S. atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki as well as the end of World War II. By the end of August, the LDP is set to complete an internal review of the upper house election setback. Moriyama, the party's No.2 executive, has hinted at stepping down after the review. © KYODO
