![[UPDATED] Govt's Pre-Q procurement method lacks transparency, Auditor General finds](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fassets.nst.com.my%2Fimages%2Farticles%2FGovtProcurement21_NSTfield_image_socialmedia.var_1753070913.jpg&w=3840&q=100)
[UPDATED] Govt's Pre-Q procurement method lacks transparency, Auditor General finds
Auditor-General Datuk Wan Suraya Wan Mohd Radzi said open tenders were better to ensure transparency and accountability in procurement.
The recommendation was made following findings in the Auditor-General's Report 2/2025, which uncovered manipulation and a lack of transparency in the Pre-Q process introduced by the Finance Ministry in 2023 and 2024.
"Some companies that failed to meet the initial evaluation criteria were still invited to participate and were even selected during the final round," she said in a statement.
The report audited the use of the Pre-Q method in several ministries, including the Energy Transition and Water Transformation Ministry, the Rural and Regional Development Ministry, and the Works Ministry.
At the Energy Transition and Water Transformation Ministry, a tender process involving the procurement of a government office building project saw the selection of a contractor who had failed to meet the requirements in the first stage of screening.
The audit found that a company which had not completed its Pre-Q application properly, including failing to provide mandatory supporting documents, was still allowed to advance to the second stage of evaluation.
Despite receiving a "Not Recommended" status from the technical evaluation committee, the company was still invited to participate in the second stage and was eventually awarded the project.
At the Rural and Regional Development Ministry, a tender process involving the procurement of a government office building project saw the selection of a contractor who had failed to meet technical requirements in the first stage of screening.
Despite not complying with the technical capability criteria, the project was still allowed to advance to the second stage of evaluation.
The ministry's internal justifications for allowing this were not in line with the Treasury's Pre-Q procurement circulars.
Wan Suraya warned that such deviations could result in "non-compliant decisions that jeopardise the credibility of procurement exercises."
The auditor-general concluded that the Pre-Q procurement method, as implemented, had failed to meet its original objectives of screening for quality and improving competition.
"Some companies that failed to meet the initial evaluation criteria were still invited to participate and were even selected during the final round," said Wan Suraya.
She recommended that the Finance Ministry consider abolishing the method altogether and reverting to the open tender approach to safeguard the integrity of government procurement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
4 hours ago
- New Straits Times
PAC to summon 3 ministries, Felcra over AG's findings
KUALA LUMPUR: The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) will summon three ministries and a government agency over matters flagged in the Auditor General's Report 2/2025 on the activities of ministries, departments, statutory bodies and federal government-owned companies. PAC chairman Datuk Mas Ermieyati Samsuddin said the committee will call the Rural and Regional Development Ministry and Felcra Bhd to provide an explanation regarding the management of palm oil plantation procurement. "The committee will also summon the Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Ministry to provide an explanation regarding the management of price control and cooking oil subsidies, as well as the Finance Ministry to brief on the governance of the tender procurement committee. "The date of the proceedings and briefings for all three related matters will be determined later," she said in a statement. She said the PAC proceedings on the issues highlighted in the report will focus on topics identified as involving the 3Ps: misappropriation, abuse of power, and waste, as well as 1K, which is leakages. Earlier today, Mas Ermieyati said the committee received a briefing from the AG regarding the reports, which were tabled in the Dewan Rakyat on Monday and debated on Wednesday. Meanwhile, Mas Ermieyati said the PAC will table two follow-up action reports by two ministries on July 28 and July 29. "First, on the Home Ministry's follow-up actions on the recommendations of the PAC report regarding the procurement of the Foreign Workers Centralised Management System. "Second, on the Rural and Regional Development Ministry, Sarawak Rural Water Supply Department, and the Sabah State Water Department's follow-up actions on the recommendations of the PAC report regarding the management of rural water supply projects in Sarawak and Sabah."
Malaysiakini
5 hours ago
- Malaysiakini
Mindef to develop system to monitor contract performance
PARLIAMENT | The Defence Ministry will develop a contract monitoring system to enhance efficiency and transparency in the management of asset and project procurement, including earlier enforcement of actions against project delays. Deputy Defence Minister Adly Zahari said the move followed findings in the 2025 Auditor-General's Report Series 2, which highlighted weaknesses in the enforcement of contract terms, particularly concerning the issue of late penalties.
The Star
5 hours ago
- The Star
Govt approves RM14.39mil grant to Suhakam for 2023 operational costs
KUALA LUMPUR: The government, through the Finance Ministry, has approved a grant of RM14.39mil to the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam) in 2023 to cover operating expenses and meet the objectives of its establishment. Deputy Finance Minister Lim Hui Ying said the grant is the highest amount approved by the government. "The grant is intended to cover operating expenses, fixed allowance of Suhakam commissioner, emoluments, operations rental, utilities, implementation of Suhakam's annual programmes and activities, as well as the purchase of assets such as vehicles on a one-off basis. "The granting of the fund is based on the 2023 Budget review session, as well as Suhakam's expenditure performance and the government's financial capacity at that time," she said when winding up the Debate on the Motion for the Suhakam 2023 Annual Report and Financial Statement for MoF at the Dewan Rakyat here on Thursday (July 24). Meanwhile, she also welcomed the proposal by William Leong Jee Keen (PH-Selayang) and Hassan Abdul Karim (PH-Pasir Gudang) to increase the allocation to Suhakam as stated in the report presented. Therefore, Lim said the government would consider appropriate allocations for Suhakam's needs subject to the current government's capacity. "Since the establishment of Suhakam in 2000, the government has never failed to provide allocations. The government is always committed to ensuring that Suhakam can operate and fulfil its establishment objectives," said Lim. – Bernama
