Trump's DOJ ramps up push to strip naturalized Americans of citizenship
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
The US Department of Justice has directed its civil division to expand efforts to revoke the citizenship of naturalized Americans , especially in cases involving serious crimes or fraud. According to a June 11 internal memo reviewed by NPR, the department has made denaturalization one of its top five enforcement priorities.Assistant Attorney General Brett A. Shumate wrote, "The Civil Division shall prioritize and maximally pursue denaturalization proceedings in all cases permitted by law and supported by the evidence."The initiative, which targets individuals who were not born in the US, comes as nearly 25 million immigrants hold naturalized status, according to 2023 government data.The policy shift has already seen results. On June 13, a judge ordered the revocation of US citizenship from Elliott Duke, a military veteran originally from the UK, who had been convicted for distributing child sexual abuse material. Duke, who uses they/them pronouns, admitted to engaging in the illegal activity before obtaining US citizenship. NPR reported that Duke, now stateless, had relinquished UK citizenship during the naturalization process and struggled to secure legal representation during the civil proceedings.The use of civil litigation — rather than criminal prosecution — has raised legal and constitutional concerns. Cassandra Robertson, a law professor at Case Western Reserve University, told NPR, "Stripping Americans of citizenship through civil litigation violates due process and infringes on the rights guaranteed by the 14th Amendment." She added that civil denaturalization carries a lower burden of proof and does not provide the right to government-funded legal counsel.Critics say this approach revives tactics last used extensively during the McCarthy era and risks creating unequal classes of citizenship. 'It is kind of, in a way, trying to create a second class of US citizens,' said Sameera Hafiz of the Immigrant Legal Resource Center, speaking to NPR.Supporters, such as Hans von Spakovsky from the Heritage Foundation, defended the move. 'Anyone who has abused the privilege of the opportunity of becoming a US citizen should have that citizenship revoked,' he told NPR. He dismissed due process concerns by stating that civil proceedings do not require taxpayer-funded counsel.Legal scholars warned that the DOJ memo's language grants wide discretion to pursue denaturalization in broad categories such as national security violations or government-related fraud. Steve Lubet, professor emeritus at Northwestern University, told NPR, 'Many of the categories are so vague as to be meaningless.'The practice of denaturalization was significantly curtailed after a 1967 Supreme Court ruling, but efforts resumed during the Obama administration under Operation Janus. Under former President Donald Trump 's first term, the process expanded further, and with Trump back in office, the policy is now being aggressively pursued once again.Robertson remains skeptical of how many cases will meet the government's criteria. 'If they're really intending maximal enforcement,' she told NPR, 'they're going to end up focusing on people who have not committed any serious infraction.'The Department of Justice and the Trump administration declined NPR's requests for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
Trump's student loan forgiveness overhaul may block immigrants, transgender support groups & more — here's what's changing
Donald Trump plans changes to student loan forgiveness. Some groups may lose access if the Education Department labels them as engaging in 'illegal activities'. The focus is on immigration, terrorism, and transgender issues. Advocates worry about political punishment. The changes could affect hospitals, schools, and nonprofits. The new rules are expected by July 2026, after public comments. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Who decides what's 'illegal'? Millions already got help from this program Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Trump says some groups are harmful Government didn't give clear answers Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads FAQs Trump is changing student loan forgiveness rules. He wants to stop giving loan forgiveness to some groups and organizations. The rule targets immigrant and transgender support groups. These groups might lose access to student loan help if the government says they're involved in 'illegal activities', claims Education Department wrote a draft plan for the change. It would let the Secretary of Education decide which groups are doing something 'illegal.' The draft focuses on 3 big things: immigration, terrorism, and transgender issues, as per the report by Associated are the main areas the government is watching to decide what counts as 'illegal.' Advocates are worried this gives too much power to the government. Betsy Mayotte from the Institute of Student Loan Advisors said it might be used for 'political punishment', as per the 1 million Americans have already had loans canceled under this program. These include teachers, nurses, firefighters, and more. The Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program started in 2007, according to the report by Associated forgives the rest of your student debt if you work 10 years in public service and make 120 payments. Right now, nonprofits that work in education, law, or health also qualify. This includes groups that help transgender youth or immigrants, as per the said in March the program supports 'activist organizations' that harm national security. He ordered changes to remove groups he says break the law, especially those that support immigrants or transgender youth, according to the report by Associated PressHis plan could force many people to leave their jobs or lose loan forgiveness. If your job becomes 'ineligible,' your loan progress stops. Big groups like hospitals, schools, and nonprofits could all be affected, as per if just one department in a hospital helps transgender kids, the whole hospital might become ineligible. The draft says 'illegal activities' include things like helping undocumented immigrants or giving hormone therapy to minors, as stated by Associated if these are legal in some states, they could still be called illegal under this plan. This means even cities or states that don't work closely with immigration officials could be Dobson from Slippery Rock University warned that 'entire cities' could lose access. The plan gives the Education Secretary final say, even without a court case. There doesn't need to be a legal conviction — just a decision from the department, as mentioned in the report by Associated said this could cause doctor and nurse shortages. Emeka Oguh from PeopleJoy said the rule might hurt hospitals and clinics if used too broadly. Some experts asked the department for clear examples, but got vague answers. For example, it's unclear how schools teaching diversity (DEI) lessons will be judged, as stated in the also a new rule where employers must 'certify' they don't break laws. If they mess up the paperwork, employees could lose loan relief. The Department said they are open to making changes. But they still have the power to shape the final rule however they want, according to the report by Associated final rule will go through public comments and should be ready by July 2026. This means people can speak up before it becomes official. Last week, the Department said they are keeping Trump's promise. They said they're working to make sure the program doesn't help lawbreaking organizations, as per the that help immigrants or transgender youth could lose access if labeled as doing 'illegal activities' by the Education new rules are expected to take effect in July 2026, after public comments are reviewed.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Trump's student loan forgiveness overhaul may block immigrants, transgender support groups & more — here's what's changing
Who decides what's 'illegal'? Millions already got help from this program Live Events Trump says some groups are harmful Government didn't give clear answers FAQs (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel Trump is changing student loan forgiveness rules. He wants to stop giving loan forgiveness to some groups and organizations. The rule targets immigrant and transgender support groups. These groups might lose access to student loan help if the government says they're involved in 'illegal activities', claims Education Department wrote a draft plan for the change. It would let the Secretary of Education decide which groups are doing something 'illegal.' The draft focuses on 3 big things: immigration, terrorism, and transgender issues, as per the report by Associated are the main areas the government is watching to decide what counts as 'illegal.' Advocates are worried this gives too much power to the government. Betsy Mayotte from the Institute of Student Loan Advisors said it might be used for 'political punishment', as per the 1 million Americans have already had loans canceled under this program. These include teachers, nurses, firefighters, and more. The Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program started in 2007, according to the report by Associated forgives the rest of your student debt if you work 10 years in public service and make 120 payments. Right now, nonprofits that work in education, law, or health also qualify. This includes groups that help transgender youth or immigrants, as per the said in March the program supports 'activist organizations' that harm national security. He ordered changes to remove groups he says break the law, especially those that support immigrants or transgender youth, according to the report by Associated PressHis plan could force many people to leave their jobs or lose loan forgiveness. If your job becomes 'ineligible,' your loan progress stops. Big groups like hospitals, schools, and nonprofits could all be affected, as per if just one department in a hospital helps transgender kids, the whole hospital might become ineligible. The draft says 'illegal activities' include things like helping undocumented immigrants or giving hormone therapy to minors, as stated by Associated if these are legal in some states, they could still be called illegal under this plan. This means even cities or states that don't work closely with immigration officials could be Dobson from Slippery Rock University warned that 'entire cities' could lose access. The plan gives the Education Secretary final say, even without a court case. There doesn't need to be a legal conviction — just a decision from the department, as mentioned in the report by Associated said this could cause doctor and nurse shortages. Emeka Oguh from PeopleJoy said the rule might hurt hospitals and clinics if used too broadly. Some experts asked the department for clear examples, but got vague answers. For example, it's unclear how schools teaching diversity (DEI) lessons will be judged, as stated in the also a new rule where employers must 'certify' they don't break laws. If they mess up the paperwork, employees could lose loan relief. The Department said they are open to making changes. But they still have the power to shape the final rule however they want, according to the report by Associated final rule will go through public comments and should be ready by July 2026. This means people can speak up before it becomes official. Last week, the Department said they are keeping Trump's promise. They said they're working to make sure the program doesn't help lawbreaking organizations, as per the that help immigrants or transgender youth could lose access if labeled as doing 'illegal activities' by the Education new rules are expected to take effect in July 2026, after public comments are reviewed.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
'Evil personified': Melinda French Gates' old interview on Epstein viral as DOJ, FBI close case
Melinda Gates said Bill Gates' association with Jeffrey Epstein was one of the reasons behind their divorce. The old video of Melinda French Gates from 2022 in which Melinda called Jeffrey Epstein 'evil personified' went viral Monday after the US administration brought the curtains down on the Epstein case. In the interview, Melinda blamed Bill Gates' relationship with convicted pedophile Epstein as one of the reasons for their divorce. Melinda revealed in the CBS interview that she had met Epstein once, as she wanted to see who this person was. "And I regretted it the second I stepped in the door. He (Epstein) was abhorrent. He was evil personified. I had nightmares about it afterwards, so my heart breaks for these young women," Melinda said adding that she made it clear to Bill that she did not like Epstein and his association with Epstein at all. — JDunlap1974 (@JDunlap1974) Melinda wrote about this experience in her memoir "The Next Day" that in 2019, NYT published a deeply disturbing article suggesting that Bill Gates had not only betrayed the marriage but also Melinda's values. NYT also reported that Epstein threatened to expose Bill's alleged affair with Russian bridge player Mila Antonova in 2017, after Bill declined to join Epstein's multi-billion-dollar charitable fund with JPMorgan Chase. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like An engineer reveals: One simple trick to get internet without a subscription Techno Mag Learn More Undo But Bill Gates was not accused of any sex offence and also expressed regret for his association with Epstein. "In retrospect, I was foolish to spend any time with him. I think I was quite stupid. I thought it would help me with global health philanthropy. In fact, it failed to do that. It was just a huge mistake," Bill Gates said. Bill and Melinda finalized their divorce in August 2021 after 27 years of their marriage. While Americans expected many more big names to come out of the stacks of files and documents and the exact nature of their relationship with Epstein, the FBI and the Department of Justice issued a joint an unsigned memo announcing that there was no incriminating Epstein client list. The investigation also concluded that Epstein died by suicide and was not murdered in jail. MAGA activists had a major meltdown over the announcement and they called it a cover-up.
