
Official India jobless data is not accurate, say top independent economists: Reuters poll
India is the world's fastest-growing major economy at an annual rate of 7.4% in the January-March quarter, but so far growth has failed to create enough well-paying jobs for the millions of young people entering the workforce each year.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government is now more than one year into a third term after losing a commanding majority, partly blamed on discontent among youth over their future prospects.
Over 70% of independent economists polled over the last month, 37 of 50, said the official unemployment rate, at 5.6% in June, is inaccurate. In a Reuters survey last year most economists flagged chronic joblessness as the government's biggest challenge.
Experts say outdated definitions of what constitutes a job in a country of more than 1.4 billion people are distorting the true scale of unemployment and underemployment.
"The whole thing to me is really throwing dust in your eyes. You say this is the unemployment rate, the growth rate — quite often, they don't make much sense. We have a massive employment problem and that is not reflected in the data," said Pranab Bardhan, professor emeritus of economics at the University of California, Berkeley.
"Most Indian workers are underemployed. If you are able-bodied and you did not work for any time, not even one hour in the last six months, unless you are rich, how did you feed yourself?... So you scrounge around and do something. And then you are employed. Now what does that employment mean?" asked Bardhan.
The Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS), opens new tab, which estimates India's official employment and unemployment data, counts anyone working even one hour a week as employed.
The Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation defended the credibility of its labour force data and its representation of India's labour market dynamics, saying the PLFS uses Computer-Assisted Personal Interviews to improve data quality and reduce errors, and noted international agencies use its data in their reporting.
While it is difficult to provide an alternate estimate of the jobless rate, 17 experts surveyed did, giving a median of 10%, ranging from 7% to as high as 35%.
For years, India published official unemployment rates of around 4%, partly because statisticians counted unpaid family labour and subsistence work as employment.
Experts argue this diverges from international norms and makes the jobless rate incomparable with other countries.
And it is not just academics and career labour market experts who are concerned about data accuracy.
"Unemployment is one of our big challenges and I don't believe the government data reflects the true ground situation," said Duvvuri Subbarao, Reserve Bank of India Governor from 2008-2013.
Subbarao said the kind of jobs being created also matters. As high-growth sectors like finance and IT tend to be less labour-intensive, he called for a sharper policy focus on manufacturing, which holds greater potential for large-scale employment.
About a quarter of experts polled had no problem with the accuracy of official jobless data.
"No one in the world has perfect employment data. People assume the U.S. labour force survey is perfect. It's not. Our PLFS is very robust now. People just don't want to believe it," said Surjit Bhalla, former executive director for India at the International Monetary Fund.
But several experts said even if methodologically sound, official figures fail to capture deeper challenges.
On its current path, India will take at least two decades to match the female labour force participation rates of other G20 countries, the survey found.
A lack of strong job creation is also showing up in stagnating wages.
"We are home to some of the big dollar billionaires… the wealth of some of the elite has been growing dramatically over the past decade. But real wages are not growing. Half of the workers are getting less than they got even 10 years ago. To me, these are not signs of a healthy economy," said Jayati Ghosh, professor at the University of Massachusetts Amherst.
"We should be prioritising good quality employment generation," she said.
Asked what the government should prioritise to create more high-quality jobs, several said improving education and skills, promoting private investment and reducing regulatory hurdles.
"Stop selling the narrative that farm jobs growth (is) to be read as jobs growth. Adopt an industrial policy, with a manufacturing strategy that is horizontal in nature, not a PLI type picking winners tactic, that is clearly failing," said Santosh Mehrotra, professor at the University of Bath.
PLI (Production Linked Incentive) is a subsidy scheme to boost domestic manufacturing. The government scaled back the scheme just four years after its launch.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Reuters
5 minutes ago
- Reuters
New Ghana mining laws to shorten licence periods, boost community investment
ACCRA, July 23 (Reuters) - Ghana plans to shorten mining licence durations and mandate direct revenue-sharing with local communities in its most sweeping mining law reforms in nearly two decades, details of which were announced by a government minister on Wednesday. The planned overhaul reflects a broader trend across West Africa, where governments are rewriting mining codes to capture more value from rising commodity prices. Ghanaian Lands and Natural Resources Minister Emmanuel Armah Kofi Buah said the changes, which include scrapping automatic renewal of some licences - will apply only to future contracts, a departure from the stance in Mali and Burkina Faso where military-led governments have applied reforms retroactively, 'In Ghana, we don't do retrospective laws,' Buah said at a presentation in the capital, Accra. 'Existing agreements are sanctified and will be respected.' He added that the overhaul of the Minerals and Mining Act and mining policy was 85% complete following extensive stakeholder consultations. Ghana, Africa's top gold producer, expects output to rise to 5.1 million ounces this year. Major miners in the country include Newmont (NEM.N), opens new tab, Gold Fields (GFIJ.J), opens new tab, AngloGold Ashanti (AU.N), opens new tab, Zijin ( opens new tab, Asante Gold ( opens new tab, and Perseus ( opens new tab. It also exports bauxite and manganese with plans to start lithium production. Under the proposed law changes, prospecting licences would no longer be held indefinitely, and the maximum term for mining leases would be reduced from 30 years to a shorter period agreed by the government and firms. Companies failing to meet environmental, social or production obligations would lose the right to automatic licence renewal. In a major shift, the government plans to abolish development agreements, in which companies send money to the central government. Instead, companies will be required to sign agreements committing a fixed percentage of gross mineral sales revenue to fund local development projects as the government seeks to address long-standing grievances from communities that they have seen little benefit from mining operations. The reforms also propose a three-tier mineral rights regime, introducing a new medium-scale licence category to bridge the gap between large multinational operators and small-scale artisanal miners. Another key change under consideration is the reduction or abolition of stability agreements, which currently offer up to 15 years of tax and regulatory protection to large investors. Future agreements would be limited to capital recovery periods for major investments.


Reuters
8 minutes ago
- Reuters
India to start market coupling for power exchanges from January
July 23 (Reuters) - India's power regulator on Wednesday said it had decided to begin implementing market coupling in a phased manner for electricity trading from January. Market coupling is an economic model used in energy markets to create a single, uniform price for electricity across different trading platforms or exchanges. The regulator's move is aimed at improving price discovery and system efficiency. The Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) said in an order that the day-ahead market segment of all power exchanges will be coupled using a common system. Under the new system, power exchanges will take turns acting as the market coupling operator. Grid-India will serve as a backup and audit operator. The CERC said it would consider coupling the real-time market and other segments like the term-ahead market at a later stage, after more pilot runs and consultations. All power exchanges have been directed to share data with Grid-India and the CERC to support the rollout, the regulator said. The CERC said it would issue further orders based on the progress of implementation. Currently, the Indian Energy Exchange ( opens new tab is the country's most prominent platform for electricity spot price discovery. However, with the introduction of market coupling, other power exchanges will also act as market couplers. Analysts say this could reduce the IEX's dominance in price discovery and affect its market share.


Reuters
8 minutes ago
- Reuters
Hamas hands its response on ceasefire proposal to mediators, official close to talks says
July 23 (Reuters) - Hamas has handed its response on the ceasefire proposal to mediators, a Palestinian official close to the talks told Reuters on Wednesday. The official did not immediately disclose the content of the response.