
Expert reveals chilling theory behind the one question that remains to be answered after Erin Patterson was found guilty of murdering three of her in-laws... 'Why?'
On Monday afternoon, a jury found the mother-of-two killed Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson, by serving them poisoned beef Wellingtons during a lunch served at her Leongatha home on July 29, 2023.
Only Heather's husband, Pastor Ian Wilkinson, survived Patterson's plot and she will also serve a prison sentence for his attempted murder.
The burning questions that remains surrounding the case that has gained global attention, is why would Patterson carry out such an act and, less so, why did she think that she could get away with it.
Psychologist Mary Hahn-Thomsen has provided her expert opinion, suggesting that Patterson could see the world very differently to most people.
'Though I have not personally assessed Patterson, insight may be gained by considering her world view from the perspective of the narcissist,' she wrote for The Age.
'Most of us start life believing we are the centre of the universe, then through a series of reality checks, we learn we are merely a bit player.
'It's reasonable to consider that Patterson learnt a different lesson – one in which her survival depended on her remaining at the centre of her world with everything and everyone else revolving around her.'
She explained that a narcissist craves attention and acceptance but that their view of themselves is so fragile that any potential rejection can brutally shake their sense of self to the core.
Patterson attempts to ingratiate herself to her friends and extended family would have been on the surface pleasant but perhaps also tinged with awkwardness and an air of falseness that would have been 'palpable'.
She said Patterson's use of 'confabulation' where facts are distorted to suit their beliefs and objectives and well as even all out lying are typical hallmarks of a narcissistic personality.
Patterson was so confident she would be found not guilty of murder that she covered her Leongatha home in black plastic tarps for privacy once the trial ended.
The black tarps covering her home were installed on June 30 - just one week before the verdict was delivered.
Seated at the back of courtroom four of the Supreme Court of Victoria, sitting at the Latrobe Valley Magistrates' Court, Patterson, dressed in a paisley shirt, appeared stunned as her fate was sealed on Monday afternoon.
Asked to deliver a verdict, the jury foreperson - one of only five women to sit on the original 15-person panel - simply stated, 'guilty'.
The verdict produced an audible gasp from those within the packed courtroom, which included members of the Patterson clan..
She can expect to spend the next decades of her life caged within the walls of Dame Phyllis Frost Centre in Melbourne's west alongside a rogue's gallery of female killers.
On her weekly trips back there, Patterson had come to loathe the Chicken Cacciatore meals provided to her en route because the dish 'had mushrooms in it'.
Once caged, she can expect to be kept in an isolation cell for her own protection for the foreseeable future due to her high profile and the frailty of her elderly victims.
It can now be revealed Patterson's two children had continued to see their mother behind bars while she awaited trial, unwilling to accept she could murder their grandparents and aunt.
Patterson could be heard asking about them during breaks in the trial, asking a woman to ensure her now 16-year-old son was given 'extra hugs'.
Patterson, who took the stand for eight days during her trial, claimed she had not intentionally poisoned her lunch guests.
She claimed deaths of three members of her estranged husband Simon's family were a terrible accident, and she may have accidentally included foraged mushrooms in the meal.
Prosecutors laid out an extensive circumstantial case during the trial in Morwell, regional Victoria, to prove the poisoning event was deliberate.
This included evidence from sole lunch survivor Ian Wilkinson, who said Patterson had served individual beef Wellingtons to her guests on different plates to her own.
The prosecution accused Patterson of telling a series of lies to police, including that she did not forage for mushrooms in the meal and did not own a dehydrator.
She lied about it to public health investigators, who were searching to find the source of poisonous mushrooms after Patterson claimed they may be from an Asian store.
Patterson lied to doctors, nurses and toxicologists while they were trying to identify why her lunch guests were sick and save their lives at hospital.
She revealed for the first time that she enjoyed foraging for wild mushrooms when she was in the witness box, admitting she started mushrooming in 2020 during the pandemic.
'They tasted good and I didn't get sick,' she told the jury about preparing and eating wild fungi for the first time.
After hearing more than two months of evidence, a jury of 14 was whittled down to 12 jurors who retired to deliberate on their verdicts one week ago, on June 30.
They returned after deliberating for seven days with a four guilty verdicts, convicting the 50-year-old woman of three murders and one attempted murder.
Patterson now faces a sentence of up to life in prison.
She will return to the court for a pre-sentence hearing later this year.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Morning Mail: US attack on Australian ‘freeloading', mushroom trial's ‘ghoulish fascination', Demon downed
Morning everyone. Powerful American lobby groups are trying to persuade the Trump administration to retaliate against what they believe are the Australian government's 'unfair' tactics in controlling the pharmaceutical market. We are also unpicking the stories behind the verdict in the Erin Patterson mushroom murder case and how the Northern Territory coroner invoked two centuries of colonisation in her Kumanjayi Walker verdict. Elsewhere, Alex de Minaur is out of Wimbledon and left wondering what might have been. Demon downed | Australia lost its last singles representative at Wimbledon when Alex de Minaur (pictured) lost to Novak Djokovic in four thrilling sets – although the Sydneysider's 6-1 winning margin in the first set initially raised hopes that he could overcome the Serbian great. 'Ghoulish fascination' | After 10 weeks watching the Erin Patterson trial, our reporter Nino Bucci writes today about the combination of laborious detail and ghoulish fascination and how the case hinged on the absence of motive versus her self-confessed lies. Meanwhile, the key exhibits from the case such as the beef wellingtons themselves and the infamous dehydrator can be shown for the first time. Australian 'freeloading' | Some of the most influential lobby groups in Washington are pushing the US to retaliate against Australia's treatment of American exporters, pointing to drug approvals and domestic manufacturing incentives as proof of unfair 'freeloading'. Cyber contact | A potential cybercriminal has made contact with Qantas, the airline has confirmed, after a major attack on its network exposed the personal records of up to 6 million customers. Zoo reopens | A zoo in Queensland where a woman lost her arm after being attacked on Sunday by a lioness will reopen today after insisting the animal 'was not hungry' or maltreated. Moscow mystery | Russia's former transport minister (above right) has been found dead in his car from a gunshot just hours after he was sacked by Vladimir Putin. Officials said it appeared that Roman Starovoit had killed himself. But Russian media, including the local edition of Forbes, have reported that Starovoit may have died as early as Friday evening. Thought bubble | Tony Blair's thinktank worked with a project developing a postwar Gaza plan that included the creation of a 'Trump Riviera' and a manufacturing zone named after Elon Musk. In the West Bank, Palestinians fear a new Israeli directive will give a green light for settlers to demolish villages in Masafer Yatta where residents keep watch at night for attacks. And elsewhere in the Middle East, the Iranian president has said that Israel attempted to assassinate him by bombarding an area in which he was holding a meeting. 'Lifetime of pain' | A paramedic who tricked a woman into having an abortion by secretly inserting drugs inside her during sex has been sentenced to 10 years in prison by a court in Scotland. Tariff trouble | Donald Trump has risked stoking a trade war with Japan and South Korea after revealing plans to impose tariffs of 25% on both countries from 1 August. India landslides | India's mountainous state of Himachal Pradesh has been left reeling after it was hit by rainstorms, flash floods and landslides, with dozens of people reported missing. Mushroom trial: Erin Patterson found guilty Justice and courts reporter Nino Bucci speaks to Reged Ahmad about how the Erin Patterson verdict was reached and what comes next. Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $ The death of Kumanjayi Walker in the Northern Territory town of Yuendumu in 2019 centred on 3.1 seconds between the first and second shots fired by then police officer Zachary Rolfe. But the state's coroner, Elisabeth Armitage, evoked centuries of pain in the Indigenous communities to make her 638-page report about how future deaths could be avoided. The case provides an obvious lesson in truth-telling, writes Lorena Allam. From Meera Sodha's vegan microwave chocolate, miso and banana mug cakes to Benjamina Ebuehi's grilled bananas with bourbon butter (above), and from Felicity Cloake's rhubarb crumble to Ravneet Gill's tinned cherry bakewell pudding, we pick eight winter warmer puddings to help you look forward to the winter nights. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Rugby league | The decision to bring Josh Papalii out of Origin retirement to bolster Queensland's forward line is the key talking point as both sides prepare for the series finale in Sydney tomorrow night. Formula One | Lando Norris has called his battle for world championship with Oscar Piastri as 'exhausting' in the wake of his controversial win at the British Grand Prix. Rugby union | Lion coach Andy Farrell has picked his strongest combination to date for his squad's match against the Brumbies tomorrow night as the countdown shortens ahead of the Test series against the Wallabies. The verdict in the Erin Patterson case is the lead in all the major outlets with the Age backgrounder claiming that 'one word on a tax form' sparked the murders, while the Herald Sun claims to be 'inside her mind'. A woman mauled by a lion at Darling Downs zoo is a relative of the zoo's owner, the Courier Mail reports. An elder has responded to the Kumanjayi Walker inquest findings by releasing a single demanding change, the NT News reports. Economy | The RBA's interest rate decision will announced at 2.30pm. Tasmania | A sentence is due for a racehorse trainer found guilty of hitting a horse with a whip 46 times in four minutes. Foreign affairs | Gareth Evans will speak at a webinar about Pacific region security. If you would like to receive this Morning Mail update to your email inbox every weekday, sign up here, or finish your day with our Afternoon Update newsletter. You can follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland. And finally, here are the Guardian's crosswords to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow. Quick crossword Cryptic crossword


Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
New anguish for Idaho victim Kaylee Goncalves' family that's left her dad 'looking as bad as the prosecutor'
The grieving family of an Idaho murder victim is trying to return more than $85,000 of trial travel donations after killer Bryan Kohberger entered a plea deal many deemed unjust. Kaylee Goncalves ' father wants to give back every penny raised for his family - saying he would never cheat generous donors as Latah County prosecutors cheated his family out of a trial. The heartbroken father, Steve Goncalves, told TMZ people have urged him to keep the money because they are also frustrated Kohberger entered a merciful plea deal. But Steve confirmed to the outlet he will not 'bait and switch these beautiful people like [lead prosecutor] Bill Thompson did to our family.' The fundraiser, started in September 2024, was created for the Goncalves family to be able to attend Kohberger's trial. 'We are looking to find an Airbnb or a house for rent that will house all 10 Goncalves family members as well as their small pets for at least those three months,' the page reads. The fundraiser was closed before the quadruple-murder entered a plea deal on Wednesday. This means the family has to independently return the money and cannot do so through GoFundMe. As per the agreement Kohberger made with prosecutors, he pleaded guilty to brutally stabbing University of Idaho students Kaylee, 21, Xana Kernodle, 20, Maddie Mogen, 21, and Ethan Chapin, 20 inside their off-campus residence. In exchange for his admission, the 30-year-old was spared the death penalty and will likely spend the rest of his life in prison. The deal has sparked outrage from the young victims' families, who do not believe this was an adequate for the extent of his heinous crimes. 'He deserved life on death row,' Kaylee's mom, Kristi Goncalves, wrote ahead of his sentencing, which is set for later this month. 'People say that the Goncalves don't want justice, they want vengeance.' She added: '[Kohberger] did not show Kaylee ANY tell us we should be happy with life in prison without parole as he will never get out (how is that not a win they ask) well the death penalty also means life on death row. 'We knew it would be decades before he ever would face the firing squad. We knew that his execution was not going to happen anytime soon, BUT his life on DEATH ROW while serving his time would have been much worse than serving his time as life in prison.' The Goncalves, who have been particularly vocal about their dissatisfaction with Kohberger's legal fate, have even called upon the public to hold Judge Steven Hippler responsible for the ruling. Hippler, the judge who made the controversial call, has been slammed with angry calls and voicemails ever since. Angry observers also lashed out at the Latah County Prosecuting Attorney's office, leaving one-star reviews in protest of the deal. 'Horrible Horrible people work here!! They all need to be fired for what they did, no justice for any of the 4 college students,' one reviewer wrote. 'What part about Bryan Kohberger needs to die do you not understand?' another fumed. 'I had a traffic ticket and the prosecutor went after me harder than you went after Kohberger,' a third person said. Kohberger will be sentenced for the November 13, 2022 murders on July 23 at Ada County Court.


Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Man, 20, is charged with murder as tributes are paid to 'rising star' scientist
A man yesterday appeared in court accused of the murder of a scientist who was found injured on a city street. Kyler Rattray appeared in private at Dundee Sheriff Court on a single murder charge. The 20-year-old, from Dundee, made no plea and was remanded in custody. He is set to appear in court again within eight days. It comes after Dr Fortune Gomo, 39, was found on Dundee's South Street on Saturday afternoon. Emergency crews arrived at around 4.25pm but the scientist, originally from Zimbabwe, was pronounced dead at the scene. Her family yesterday spoke of their shock at the death of Dr Gomo, who had graduated with a PhD from Dundee University and recently started working for Scottish Water. Brother Regis Nyatsanza, speaking from Harare in Zimbabwe, said she would have soon turned 40 and they had been discussing how she might celebrate. She was the oldest of four siblings, he said, and described her as the 'deputy parent' of the family. Mr Nyatsanza told the BBC: 'Two weeks ago we were laughing about throwing her a big 40th birthday bash but she said she had achieved most of what she wanted. 'After all the struggle she had everything she wanted and so she was going to have a quiet celebration.' Dr Gomo, who is believed to have had a ten-year-old daughter, was an expert in water conservation and led efforts to improve water and food security in both Scotland and sub-Saharan Africa. She was hailed as a 'rising star' in her field. Scottish Water director of environment planning and assurance, Professor Simon Parsons, said: 'Fortune was an exceptional scientist and a senior service planner in our water resources planning section based in Dundee where, having joined us in February, she had already become a highly valued and respected member of our team.' Dundee local police commander Chief Superintendent Nicola Russell said yesterday: 'Our enquiries are continuing and we are confident that nobody else was involved and there is no wider threat to the public. 'I am also acutely aware of misinformation being shared on social media and would urge the public not to speculate on the circumstances or post anything which could compromise a future court case.' First Minister John Swinney said: 'I am desperately saddened by the news of the death of Dr Fortune Gomo and extend my sympathies to her family, friends and colleagues.'