Government and HSE appear to hate doctors, new head of the IMO says
Government
and the
HSE
appear to hate doctors, the incoming president of the
Irish Medical Organisation
(IMO) has said.
Speaking to hospital consultants at the IMO's annual conference in Killarney on Saturday, Dr Anne Dee said they were 'working in a system that is impossible' and were being 'blamed for its failings'.
'You are easy targets in that regard,' Dr Dee told the national meeting of consultants held as part of the IMO conference.
'I can never understand why the Government absolutely appears to hate doctors and why the HSE appears to hate doctors. It does appear to be kind of sad.'
READ MORE
Consultants at the conference were angry at comments by the Minister for Health
Jennifer Carroll MacNeill
several weeks ago that more consultants needed to
work at weekends
to deal with hospital congestion.
Consultants believed that they were being scapegoated for the overcrowding and trolley crises in hospitals.
The new IMO president also said at another event at the conference that non-consultant hospital doctors were not being treated with a lot of respect.
In a subsequent statement issued on Saturday afternoon Dr Dee said her earlier comments to hospital consultants were 'not directed' at the chief executive of the HSE
Bernard Gloster
who spoke at the conference in a question and answer sessions with doctors for an hour.
[
HSE told to shift staff working patterns
Opens in new window
]
'But I do feel strongly that there is an underlying hostility towards doctors on the part of many, many people in the HSE and the
Department of Health
,' she said.
'We see that in the blame game these people play where they blame doctors for all the woes of the health services and imply that everything would be perfect if it wasn't for doctors. The reality of course is that there are systemic issues; bed shortages, lack of resources and lack of doctors which are the underlying issues. They see us as an inconvenience, a nuisance, slow to change.
'For our part we find that hurtful and disappointing and it clearly impacts on the already poor morale of doctors around the country.'
Dr Lisa Cunningham, a consultant in emergency medicine in Mayo, said she was a senior decision maker in a hospital who had 'felt the absolute point of the finger from the Minister and in certain narratives as well from the Department of Health and our HSE employers that we are to blame for the trolley crisis'.
The Minister said in March that she had been 'quite alarmed' by the growth in the number of patients waiting on trolleys after the St Brigid's bank holiday weekend in February.
She said she had asked the HSE to provide a deeper analysis of hospital consultant rostering in all acute hospitals, to cover a focused analysis of future periods' rostering of senior decision makers in the evenings, on weekends and public holidays, initially covering St Patrick's weekend.
The Minister said subsequently that the number of patients waiting on trolleys after the St Patrick's Day bank holiday was down by more than 60 per cent compared the figure for the Tuesday following the St Brigid's bank holiday.
However, Dr Cunningham told the conference that she had worked the St Patrick's weekend and it was 'one of the quietest we had in quite some time'.
'It was unusual. It was a really unusual weekend. The numbers on trolleys were not reflective of my input that weekend nor of my colleagues around the country.'
Mr Gloster said there had been no intention on his part to point fingers at emergency medicine consultants or any of their colleagues.
'The first place I have to point the finger is at myself. I am the CEO of the HSE. The reality is that I am ultimately responsible for how that system functions in the lives and experiences of five and a half million people.
'I can assure you that I have no interest in pointing the finger at you or your colleagues in emergency medicine or at any other part of the system. But I do have an interest in pointing the finger at all of us together to sort it out,' Mr Gloster told Dr Cunningham.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Agriland
16 hours ago
- Agriland
HSE advises public not to touch sick or dead wild birds
The Health Service Executive (HSE) is advising the public not to touch or handle any sick or dead wild birds, because of the risks of avian influenza (bird flu). The warning follows confirmation from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) that bird flu had been discovered in a backyard flock in Co. Donegal. There are no trade implications for the Irish poultry industry in relation to this detection, due to the very small size of the flock. Bird flu is a type of influenza that primarily affects wild birds and poultry, and which can also occasionally infect some mammals and humans. Highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) is a type of avian influenza that can cause high levels of illness and deaths in birds. Of the many strains of HPAI viruses, the H5N1 virus is widely regarded as the most serious for both birds and humans. Since 2003, there have been nearly 1,000 human cases of H5N1, half of whom have died. According to the HSE it is "very unusual for people to catch bird flu, but it can happen". "Currently, it is hard to catch avian influenza from a bird or animal, and there is no evidence that it can be passed between people, but if the virus mutates (changes) this may happen in the future," the executive said. As the H5N1 HPAI virus is circulating in wild birds in Ireland, the HSE is reiterating the advice issued by DAFM to the public, including: Do not to touch sick or dead wild birds; Do not touch wild bird feathers or droppings; Avoid contact with surfaces contaminated with wild bird droppings; DAFM requests that all sick/dead wild birds are reported via the Avian Check app. While not all dead birds will be collected for testing, reporting is greatly appreciated and provides important information to support surveillance and risk assessment activities. The HSE added that if a person picks up or handles sick or dead wild birds that are found to be infected with avian influenza, they will be monitored for a period of 10 days. The person may be offered antiviral medication and vaccination if they are considered to be at risk.
Agriland
a day ago
- Agriland
Bird flu case detected in Donegal backyard flock
Avian influenza, otherwise known as 'bird flu' has been discovered in a backyard flock in Co. Donegal. Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Martin Heydon has today (Thursday, July 31) confirmed that there are no trade implications for the Irish poultry industry in relation to this detection, due to the very small size of the flock. Minister Heydon said: 'A bird from a very small backyard flock in Co. Donegal has tested positive for the H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza, following a post-mortem examination carried out in my department's Regional Veterinary Laboratory in Sligo. "Following this result, the other birds in the flock have now been euthanised. I would like to extend my sympathies to the flock owner.' Moving to reassure poultry farmers and the Irish poultry industry, Minister Heydon stated: 'As this flock was very small and was not involved in commercial poultry activity, under the legislation this incident is not an outbreak of avian influenza. "Therefore, this does not affect Ireland's disease-free status in respect of avian influenza and there are no trade implications or restriction zones," the minister added. He has emphasised the importance of biosecurity as the single most effective way to prevent the virus spreading from wild birds into poultry, or between poultry flocks. "This incident highlights the ongoing risk posed by avian influenza and is a reminder to all who keep poultry, whether commercial holdings or those who have some backyard hens, to stay aware and take precautions to prevent contact with or contamination from wild birds," Minister Heydon said. People are advised to report any suspicions of avian influenza to the local Regional Veterinary Office without delay. In recent weeks, there have been a number of cases of avian influenza detected in wild birds in Ireland, mainly sea birds in coastal areas. In 2025, a total of 41 cases of avian influenza in wild birds have been detected. The minister has reiterated the importance of taking precautions to protect public health: 'I have a clear message for the public, especially for those who may encounter dead birds on beaches this summer - do not touch or pick up dead wild birds, and keep pet dogs on a leash in areas where there are sick or dead wild birds.' The HSE-HPSC has advised that the risk to public health from the strain of avian influenza currently circulating (Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza subtype H5N1) is considered low for the general public, and low to medium for occupationally exposed people.
Agriland
a day ago
- Agriland
Wales Aims to Be Tb Free by 2041 How is It Working to Achieve This
In the second instalment in Agriland's new series, Silent spread – Ireland's TB battle, we examine the Welsh Government's target to be officially TB-free by 2041 and how it plans to achieve this. It has highlighted new policies and a "strengthened partnership approach' as among the key tools in its strategy to eradicate the disease. There are farmers across the UK and beyond experiencing the hardship that comes with TB, including Welsh farmers, who seek an eradication programme that brings real change. Farmers in Ireland share the same pain, as they await a number of new measures for a revamped TB control plan to be announced this year. The Welsh Government has told Agriland it is "committed to accelerating action to meet the target of a TB-free Wales by 2041". "We are determined to eradicate bovine TB in Wales, and recognise the impact on farms, farmers and their families," the government said. 'We've listened to the concerns raised over different aspects of bovine TB and will continue to work in partnership with the industry, as set out in our five-year delivery plan. 'This includes the work of the Technical Advisory Group, who have already provided their expert advice on specific topics. "We have made significant changes to our policy approach - the latest on inconclusive reactor policies was announced in May." The new "farmer-led" TB Programme Board is also now in place with governance arrangements complete, the Welsh Government said. According to the latest survey of agriculture and horticulture in Wales, over 90% of the land area is given over to farming. The landscape, soil quality and climate of Wales limit the use to which its land can be put. Most of Wales is hilly or mountainous and this, combined with relatively poor soil quality and a wet climate, means that much of the land is restricted to the grazing of sheep and cattle. A lot of the farms in Wales would be considered family farms - most of the day-to-day work on the farm is carried out by the farmer and their immediate family. There are 1.09 million cattle and calves in Wales - a small decline from 1.12 million in 2023. In the UK, TB policy in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland is devolved. In Wales, bovine TB policy is developed by the Welsh Government, with the Animal and Plant Health Agency (APHA) managing operational delivery. Compulsory measures for bovine TB have been in place in Great Britain since the 1950s. The Welsh Government established a TB Eradication Programme in 2008, introducing, among other measures, annual herd testing in order to increase surveillance. In 2017, Wales implemented a refreshed programme, with a regionalised approach to TB creating low, intermediate and high TB areas, based on disease incidence. In the different areas, a more local level approach can be taken when necessary. Between 2021 and 2022, a consultation took placed on a further refreshed TB eradication programme, after which the Wales TB Eradication Programme Delivery Plan March 2023 to March 2028 was published. This is the second delivery plan, and sits under the overall Wales TB Eradication Programme. The Technical Advisory Group is a group providing independent, expert advice to the Welsh Government on the TB eradication programme. It met for the first time in April 2024, considering on-farm slaughter arrangements in the first instance. Following the group's recommendations, changes were made to the existing policy immediately to reduce the number of cattle that need to be slaughtered on-farm. The group has also considered evidence in respect of inconclusive reactor policy, considered TB data and evidence gaps in respect of wildlife. Meanwhile, the Programme Board provides strategic recommendations to Welsh Government on bovine TB, using advice from the Technical Advisory Group. In order to move or trade cattle, herds need to be free from infection and classified as 'Officially TB Free (OTF)' in Wales. Herds are classified as OTF unless the herd's status is unknown because: of overdue TB testing; there's suspicion the herd might be infected; or the herd has a TB breakdown, meaning one or more animals fail a TB test. The Wales TB Eradication Programme Delivery Plan explains that cattle herds are tested at least annually in Wales, with herds in the 'Intensive Action Area in west Wales tested every six months'. Contiguous testing can take place in some areas of Wales in herds that are neighbouring a TB incident. The Welsh TB delivery plan outlines that cattle moving within and from the high and intermediate areas require a clear pre-movement test. "Furthermore, cattle moving into the low TB area from higher incidence areas need a clear post-movement test between 60-120 days after arrival." For farmers with cattle slaughtered due to TB, full compensation is paid in most cases. Typically the market value of an animal slaughtered for TB will be paid as compensation. The maximum amount of compensation that will be paid for an animal is £5,000. The Deputy First Minister for Wales Huw Irranca-Davies, in an update in recent months, said that the current TB picture in Wales is 'varied'. 'Over the 12 months to December 2024, the latest TB statistics show short- and longer-term decreases in new herd incidence. But, conversely, we saw an increase in the number of TB-affected cattle slaughtered last year,' he told the Welsh parliament. 'I understand that this can appear alarming, but much of the rise in 2024 is attributable to the targeted use of the highly sensitive gamma interferon blood test. 'It's important to understand that using this gamma test alongside a standard skin test can improve the identification of TB infection within herds." Deputy First Minister for Wales Huw Irranca-Davies He said that this should ultimately lead to a reduction in infection rates - minimising the risk of disease spread and of recurring breakdowns in the longer term. 'However, more gamma testing, coupled with an increased positivity rate of cattle, has indeed increased the number of animals slaughtered for bovine TB control during 2024," he added. The Welsh Government with the APHA collect and publish key metrics of the disease in the country. The UK Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) also releases official statistics. In Wales, there were 619 new TB incidents in the 12 months to March 2025, an increase of 2% compared with the previous 12 months when there were 607 new incidents, DEFRA statistics show. New herd incidents in Wales, January 2008 to December 2024. Source: Welsh Government / DEFRA There were 13,174 animals slaughtered for TB control in the 12 months to March 2025, an increase of 17.7% compared with the previous 12 months when there were 11,194 animals slaughtered. The overall trend for animals slaughtered due to bovine TB control is variable - much of a rise since 2014 is attributable to increased use of high-sensitivity testing. It is recognised in the Welsh TB programme delivery plan that badgers have the potential to play a role in the transmission of bovine TB to and from cattle and between other badgers. 'Respecting the programme for government commitment to forbid the culling of badgers to control bovine TB in cattle, the Welsh Government is pursuing a badger vaccination policy.' Wildlife is among the key areas that the TB Eradication Technical Advisory Board and the Programme Board are considering as part of their work programmes. Farmers can avail of a grant to help support the cost of vaccinating badgers on their land. The delivery plan outlines that a 'passive TB surveillance regime is maintained for non-bovine species such as camelids, goats and farmed deer'. Last year, Wales made changes to its on-farm slaughter policy with the aim of reducing the numbers of cattle slaughtered. 'The main reasons cattle may be slaughtered on-farm for TB control purposes are either because they are not able to travel on welfare grounds, particularly if in late pregnancy, or as a consequence of medicine withdrawal periods,' the Welsh Government said. Since the changes were brought in, farmers are 'able to choose to delay the removal of a cow or heifer in the last 60 days of pregnancy and animals that have given birth in the previous seven days, subject to biosecurity conditions to protect other cattle in the herd'. Since the introduction of the new policy, on-farm slaughter has been avoided through agreed delayed removal of approximately a quarter of the animals – 242, from 111 individual herds –which would previously have been slaughtered on-farm. In May this year, a change in inconclusive reactor (IR) policies was announced, to take effect from this autumn. The Deputy First Minister for Wales Huw Irranca-Davies explained: 'Evidence shows these resolved standard IR cattle are higher risk than other cattle because a larger proportion of them go on to become TB reactors at a later point. 'Currently this risks such resolved standard IR cattle with undetected infection being moved and spreading TB to other herds – a key concern raised by industry. 'Under new arrangements, these cattle will be restricted to their herd with only licenced movements permitted direct to slaughter, or into an approved finishing unit." Following the recent announcement of new changes, NFU Cymru, the organisation representing farmers in Wales, said that 'while improvements to partnership working and targeted revisions to government bovine TB policy are encouraging, further significant change is still needed to rid Wales of this terrible disease'. 'NFU Cymru continues to call for a comprehensive eradication strategy that deals with this disease wherever it exists.'
