New Orleans pushes to legalize police use of ‘facial surveillance'
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
In an emailed statement, a police spokesperson said the department 'does not surveil the public,' and that surveillance is 'not the goal of this ordinance revision.' But the word 'surveillance' appears in the proposed ordinance dozens of times, including explicitly giving police authority to use 'facial surveillance.'
Advertisement
Many police departments use AI to help them identify suspects from still images taken at or near the scene of a crime, but New Orleans police have already taken the technology a step further. Over the past two years, the department relied on a privately owned network of cameras equipped with facial recognition software to constantly monitor the streets for wanted people and automatically ping an app on officers' mobile phones to convey the names and locations of possible matches, The Post reported last month.
Advertisement
In April, after The Post requested public records about this system, New Orleans Police Superintendent Anne Kirkpatrick paused the automated alerts and ordered a review into how officers used the technology and whether the practice violated local restrictions on facial recognition.
David Barnes, a New Orleans police sergeant overseeing legal research and planning, who wrote the proposed ordinance, said he hopes to complete the review and share his findings before the City Council vote. The facial recognition alerts are still paused, he said Wednesday.
There are no federal regulations around the use of AI by local law enforcement. New Orleans was one of many cities to ban the technology during the policing overhauls passed in the wake of the Black Lives Matter protests of 2020, with the City Council saying it had 'significant concerns about the role of facial recognition technologies and surveillance databases in exacerbating racial and other bias.' Federal studies have shown the technology to be less reliable when scanning people of color, women, and older people.
New Orleans partly rolled back the restrictions in 2022, letting police use facial recognition for searches of specific suspects of violent crimes, but not for general tracking of people in public places. Each time police want to scan a face, they must send a still image to trained examiners at a state facility and later provide details about these scans to the city council — guardrails meant to protect the public's privacy and prevent software errors from leading to wrongful arrests.
Advertisement
Now, city leaders want to give police broad access to the technology with fewer limitations, arguing that automated surveillance tools are necessary for fighting crime. Violent crime rates in New Orleans, like much of the country, are at historic lows, according to Jeff Asher, a consultant who tracks crime statistics in the region. But facial recognition-equipped cameras have proven useful in a few recent high-profile incidents, including the May 16 escape of 10 inmates from a local jail and the New Year's Day attack on Bourbon Street that left 14 dead.
'Violent crime is at an all-time low but mass murders and shootings are at an all-time high,' Oliver Thomas, one of two council members sponsoring the ordinance, said in an interview this week. 'This is a tool to deal with some of this mass violence and mass murders and attacks.'
After The Post informed Thomas there were 310 fatal and nonfatal shootings in New Orleans last year — by far the lowest number in the 14 years the city council has published these statistics on its online crime data dashboard — he acknowledged that shootings are down and partly attributed the decline to his work with young people and ex-offenders.
Nora Ahmed, the legal director for the ACLU of Louisiana, said council members are using public concern over recent news to justify the widespread adoption of facial recognition technology, or FRT — a powerful technology with the potential to strip people of their rights.
'In the name of making FRT available for a once-in-a-decade jail break, this bill opens up FRT to being used by federal and state entities, and enterprising local police departments,' Ahmed said in a text message. 'This type of surveillance should not exist in the United States period.'
Advertisement
The new ordinance would give police the ability to use 'facial surveillance' and 'characteristic tracking' systems to actively monitor the streets looking for people with warrants or people under investigation. It would require them to continue sharing data about facial searches to the City Council and begin reporting details about the software they use and its accuracy.
While the ordinance says police cannot use facial surveillance tools to target abortion seekers or undocumented immigrants, Ahmed says those protections are 'paper thin' and worries officers would find ways around them.
It's not clear whether New Orleans plans to keep working with Project NOLA, a privately funded nonprofit group that has provided automated facial recognition alerts to officers despite having no contract with the city. Barnes, the police sergeant, said Project NOLA would need to come into a formal data-sharing agreement with the city if it wanted to continue sending automated alerts to officers who have logged into a Project NOLA system to receive them. Under the new ordinance, Project NOLA could also be required to publish information about all of its searches to the city council.
Such data reporting could be complicated with a live facial recognition system, in which cameras are constantly scanning every face in their vicinity. With hundreds of cameras potentially scanning thousands of faces a day, Project NOLA, or the city, could theoretically need to report information about millions of facial recognition scans in each of its quarterly data reports the department is required to provide to the City Council.
Bryan Lagarde, Project NOLA's founder, declined to comment this week, saying he was on vacation.
Advertisement
New Orleans's embrace of the term 'surveillance' — which appears 40 times in the text of the proposed ordinance — appears at odds with statements made by Kirkpatrick, the city's top police official. In an interview last month, Kirkpatrick said she believes governments should be prevented from surveilling their citizens, especially when they are in public exercising their constitutional rights.
'I do not believe in surveilling the citizenry and residents of our country,' Kirkpatrick said at the time. 'Surveilling is an invasion of our privacy.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Virginia Beach police threaten legal action against ‘pop up' events next week
VIRGINIA BEACH — The Virginia Beach Police Department said it will pursue 'all legal means' to prevent or shut down several unsanctioned events next week at the Oceanfront and other parts of the city. The events — part of 'DMV Senior Week' — are planned to be a week of ticketed parties each night starting Tuesday. Each night has a theme, including 'Wet N Wild Party' and 'Project X.' Another, called The Beach Week, was planned to start June 19. Social media posts about the events have circulated online for weeks. Police said Friday the department have contacted the promoters about getting official permits for the events but 'attempts have been ignored.' 'As a result, these non-permitted events will not take place and VBPD will proactively enforce all applicable laws and ordinances regarding special events,' the statement says. Online ads for the parties don't list a specific location, rather a ticket purchase is required to learn the address. Prices ranged from $100 for the week of events to $15 an event. The police department 'will pursue all legal means' to recover the cost of extra law enforcement and other emergency services caused by the events, according to the police statement. Last week, Police Chief Paul Neudigate told the City Council he's concerned about a recent surge in unruly crowds and a proliferation of firearms at the Oceanfront. The chief wants the ability to initiate a midnight curfew when needed and other measures to curb 'pop-up' events. The City Council will discuss the possible next steps publicly soon, Mayor Bobby Dyer said. 'We're weighing the options,' the mayor said on Friday. 'We're looking at best practices in other cities to see what works.' Virginia Beach recently promoted a new public service announcement and social media marketing campaign, 'Good Vibes Only: Virginia Beach.' Its message centers on the city being open to positive energy not bad behavior. Hoteliers and other business owners have already expressed reservations about a curfew, which would apply to everyone, not just minors. 'Whatever we do, we don't want to hurt business,' Dyer said. Eliza Noe, Stacy Parker, 757-222-5125,
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Mystery man Mr. Cash Drop hides money around New Jersey — here's who he is and why he's doing it
It's virtually impossible to make a quick buck nowadays. Unless, of course, you're a New Jerseyan, like Cassi Fitzgerald and husband James, who can sniff out strategically-stashed cash like bloodhounds. 'We found $500,' Cassi, a 20-something from Jersey City, told The Post of their gold strike — a payday, scored in late May, after a 60-minute, 10-person paper chase along the two-mile promenade that overlooks the Hudson River at Liberty State Park. The couple's windfall, however, can't simply be attributed to sheer dumb luck. Instead, all credit is due to a mystery man named Sam — better known as 'Mr. Cash Drop' to his 125,000 social media fans. 'I just go around, hide [varying sums of] cash at different locations, post a video teasing where the money is, then wait for my followers to show up and find it,' Sam, 42, a newcomer to the Garden State, told The Post. He's even used capital from his own coffers for his triweekly calls to action. 5 Cassi and James Fitzgerald found $500 hidden by Mr. Cash Drop. Courtesy Cassi and James Fitzgerald. 'People are so excited to win,' he said of those who've been lucky enough to locate the loot, sometimes up to $500. 'They're like, 'Oh man, you don't know how much this really helps out.'' The millennial isn't some eccentric millionaire who gets his jollies from watching the have-nots search high and low for dough. He's simply a warehouse logistics manager who duct tapes banknotes to beach railings by the Jersey Shore or hides them under rocks in suburbia or sticks them between the well-manicured bushes that line the walkways of northern New Jersey hotspots. Sam says his cash drops are all in good funds. He and his New Jersey native girlfriend, Trina, started their humanitarian hobby in late March, flying up and down the turnpike, arbitrarily selecting cities, townships and neighborhoods for their finders-keepers merriment. 5 The viral account gives clues to find the random spot around the Garden State. @findthecashnewjersey 'I just do this for fun because it is fun to watch these people come out and find money,' said the benefactor, who prefers staying out of the spotlight, for fear crooks might mistake him for some sort of plain-clothes millionaire. Sam, the Good Samaritan Sam is among the growing army of do-gooders responsible for the buzzy 'cash scavenger hunt' trend. It's a viral movement that sees altruists, from NYC to San Diego and everywhere in between, tucking away moolah near local landmarks for eagle-eyed residents to retrieve. Parlaying Instagram and TikTok into money-race starting points, the semi-anonymous game masters give their digital disciples video clues as to where they've placed the currency. What's up-for-grabs can range from $50 to over $500. And within minutes, virtual viewers in the vicinity spill into the streets, seeking that sweet green. 5 'People are so excited to win,' he said. 'They're like, 'Oh man, you don't know how much this really helps out.'' @findthecashnewjersey The mysterious masterminds behind the Instagram account @FindCashNY, which recently awarded $500 to one of its 120,000 followers in Brooklyn's Prospect Park, did not immediately respond to The Post's request for a comment. But, like Sam, they're part of the rising craze that's lining the pockets of everyday folks struggling to make ends meet amid the ongoing inflation crisis, high-cost of living headache and tariff catastrophes. Subscribers to his verified Instagram page for $4.99 per month, as did Cassi and James, are granted exclusive access to his $500 drops. 5 Sam has been helping out local businesses with the stunt, too. @findthecashnewjersey But for most of his high-stakes hunts, Sam solicits sponsorships from NJ-based businesses, such as pet shops and pizzerias, whose owners put up the big bucks in exchange for shoutouts on his profiles. Just for fun However, the working-class philanthropist Sam doesn't profit from the stunt — and did dip into his own pockets for the treasure race Cassi and James won last month. 'Once I saw that the cash drop was local, we jumped in the car with our seven-month-old baby and went straight to Liberty State Park,' said Cassi, a logistics specialist. After duking it out with their fellow competitors, James, a private baseball and softball hitting instructor, finally found the $500 taped to the bottom rail of the fence by the river. The breadwinner posed for a pic with the prize, as well as a golden ticket Sam had handmade for the event, with the Statue of Liberty as his backdrop. 5 James, a private baseball and softball hitting instructor, finally found the $500 taped to the bottom rail of the fence by the river. Courtesy Cassi and James Fitzgerald. 'I was ready to scream and shout, 'We got it!'' Cassi laughed. 'But my husband wanted to keep a low profile.' The new parents are saving their spoils in a rainy day fund for the baby. 'It's really cool that there are good people in the world, like Sam, who are doing kind acts like this,' said Cassi. And selfless saint of New Jersey says he's more than happy to keep up the good work. 'I plan to do it until the fun runs out.'
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
No Kings Day protesters could top 75K in NYC, as NYPD, Port Authority increase presence
More than 1,500 'No Kings Day' rallies are expected to disrupt hundreds of cities in all 50 states Saturday, protesting President Trump as the Army's 250th anniversary military parade takes place in Washington, DC. A map on shows planned demonstrations across the US and Canada in what organizers call 'a national day of action and mass mobilization in response to the increasing authoritarian excesses and corruption of the Trump administration.' Jamie Bauer, a representative of No Kings, told The Post that crowds could exceed 75,000 in New York City alone. Advertisement 7 New York City protesters could exceed 75,000 as 'No Kings Day' rallies are expected to disrupt hundreds of cities in all 50 states Saturday — protesting President Trump as the Army's 250th anniversary military parade takes place in Washington, DC. A No King's demonstration was also held in NYC in April (above). In the summer of 2020, the largest protest over the death of George Floyd drew 25,000 people. A law enforcement source told The Post they 'have to be prepared for those kinds of numbers on Saturday.' The Port Authority is also beefing up security at the George Washington Bridge and Lincoln and Holland tunnels, as well as bus terminals and PATH stations. Advertisement The No Kings site notes that 'folks should stay on sidewalks and not block any traffic.' 7 More than 1,500 rallies are planned across the US as well as Canada. The law-enforcement source said the NYPD is less concerned about planned groups like Rise and Resist and more worried about unannounced potential 'troublemakers' in the mix. Here's where and when No Kings Day events are scheduled in NYC: Manhattan Advertisement The city main march planned is set to take place at 2 p.m. EST at Bryant Park and move down Fifth Avenue to Madison Square Park. 7 NYC's main protest will begin in Bryant Park. Tamara Beckwith A second 'spur march' will form one block north, at Grace Plaza. It will be 'a New Orleans-inspired funeral second line parade as a unique artistic delegation,' according to organizers. Another rally is planned at Columbia University, specifically for Columbia faculty, staff, students and alumni, at 1 p.m. outside the school's gate at 116th and Broadway. Demonstrators then plan to 'travel' to Bryant Park, and organizers have instructed attendees to bring a MetroCard. Advertisement A spokesperson for Columbia told The Post the demonstration is expected to occur off school grounds, and therefore is being managed by the NYPD. 7 A No Kings demonstration is planned for the gates outside Columbia University, which has seen many pro-Palestine rallies since Hamas's Oct. 7, 2023 attacks in Israel. James Keivom Brooklyn A No Kings Brooklyn protest is scheduled for 1 p.m. at a 'private' location, reported by Patch to be at Cadman Plaza West and Johnson Street. A stationary rally is also planned at Grand Army Plaza at 1p.m. Queens Demonstrators will meet at 12:30 p.m. at MacDonald Park in Forest Hills before marching along Queens Boulevard to Maple Grove Park, where a second rally is planned. 7 A No Kings demonstration, including a protester from Queens, took place in Longmont, Colorado, in April. Chris Goodwin/desrowVISUALS/Shutterstock Staten Island At 1 p.m., a No Kings protest is planned at 1698 Victory Boulevard, between Fairview Avenue and Manor Road, in Castleton Corners. No Kings is orchestrated by the 50501 Movement — short for 50 protests, 50 states, one movement — a grassroots group that reportedly formed on Reddit. They have held several No Kings rallies this year, including in on President's Day. Advertisement 'The No Kings movement is committed to a non-violent, peaceful expression of our horror at this administration's blatant and dangerous disregard for the Constitution,' Bauer said. 'The NYPD has been respectful of our first amendment rights in the past, and we don't expect that to change.' Long Island protests are planned in Port Washington, Mineola, Huntington, Babylon, Patchogue, Port Jefferson, Riverhead, Hampton Bays, Sag Harbor, Orient and East Hampton. 7 There have already been several No Kings rallies this year, including this one in Philadelphia. AP Nearby marches will take place in Weehawken, Yonkers and Jersey City. Advertisement Other 'flagship' rallies are planned in Philadelphia, Chicago, Houston, Phoenix, Charlotte and Atlanta. 'From city blocks to small towns, from courthouse steps to community parks, we're taking action to reject authoritarianism—and show the world what democracy really looks like,' organizers declared on their website. Protest organizers have dubbed the Army parade, which coincides with President Donald Trump's 79th birthday, 'a made-for-TV display of dominance for [Trump's] birthday.' That event, which will travel down the National Mall, reportedly will include uniforms, arms and vehicles from every major American war, starting with the Revolutionary War and including Abrams tanks and P-51 Mustangs. Advertisement 7 Saturday's protests will be held at the same time as a Washington, DC, parade celebrating the US Army's 250th anniversary. The day is also President Donald Trump's birthday. AP No Kings pledged not to hold a rally in DC, after President Trump warned that protesters at the military parade would face 'very heavy force.' 'Instead of allowing this birthday parade to be the center of gravity, we will make action everywhere else the story of America that day: people coming together,' the group's site says. Advertisement While there is no mention of masks on the No Kings site, attendees are encouraged to sign up for individual protests with their name, email and phone number. Organizers emphasized 'a commitment to nonviolent action' on the signup, saying, 'We expect all participants to seek to de-escalate any potential confrontation with those who disagree with our values.'
