India vs England: Was Ben Stokes Right To Offer Early Draw? ICC Rules And Team India's Response Explained
Also Read: Explained: Why India Can't Withdraw From Asia Cup 2025 Fixture Against Pakistan – BCCI's Hands Tied
So, who was right? Was Stokes justified in wanting to end early? Or did India have every right to chase personal milestones within the laws of the game?
The ICC Rule Explained: What Does Law 16.1.1 Say?
According to ICC Test Match Playing Conditions, Clause 16.1.1 states:
"A match is drawn if no result is possible and both captains agree to terminate play."
Importantly, this is not mandatory. It's a mutual decision — and a captain has every right to decline the offer. In this case, India exercised that right, with Jadeja and Sundar closing in on well-earned centuries after saving the match.
India had lost only four wickets and were 75 runs ahead. The pitch was docile. The threat of collapse had passed. The team was safe — but the batters still had personal landmarks within reach. The match situation allowed it. The ICC rules allowed it. And so did the unwritten rules of Test cricket pride.
Stokes Offers Draw, India Declines — Tension Follows
Ben Stokes, nursing niggles and mindful of his bowling unit's workload, decided enough was enough. England had bowled 257.1 overs across five days. Archer and Woakes were visibly fatigued. Liam Dawson, the left-arm spinner, had bowled long spells exploiting the rough.
Stokes offered the draw under Law 16.1.1 — and when India declined, frustration took over.
Stokes turned to Jadeja and sarcastically asked:
'Jaddu, you want to get a Test hundred against Harry Brook and Joe Root?'
The remark, caught on stump mic, sparked immediate criticism. Was it fair for Stokes to question India's intent when the law clearly permitted them to continue?
Gavaskar, Gambhir, Manjrekar: The Verdict from Indian Legends
Veteran commentator Sunil Gavaskar was quick to defend India.
'If a batter has weathered two sessions and saved the game, why shouldn't he aim for a century?'
Gautam Gambhir, India's head coach, echoed the sentiment:
'They deserved that hundred. They fought hard. You don't walk off just because the opposition is tired.'
Sanjay Manjrekar didn't hold back:
'Stokes behaved like a spoilt kid. Everything won't go your way just because you ask nicely.'
Brook's Bowling and the Protest in Disguise
After India declined the draw offer, England made a mockery of the final overs. Harry Brook, not a frontline bowler, sent down underarm lobs at 60 kmph. Jadeja responded by launching one for six to complete his century. Sundar followed soon after with his maiden Test hundred. Only then did India agree to shake hands.
Was this England's passive-aggressive protest? Or was it a moment of sportsmanship gone wrong?
What Does the ICC Rule Say About This?
Crucially, nowhere in the ICC rules is there a stipulation that batters must accept a draw if offered. Nor is there any provision for enforcing one without mutual agreement. Law 16.1.1 exists to allow a draw — not force one. India, having secured the draw on merit, played well within the framework.
In fact, continuing to bat — while seemingly milestone-driven — also served strategic goals. With just three days before the final Test at The Oval, India kept England's tired bowlers in the field longer. Tactical? Yes. Petty? Not at all.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
7 minutes ago
- India.com
Blame Game In England Camp After Oval Defeat: Ben Stokes Reacts To Missing Final Test As India Level Series 2-2
In a contest that epitomised the thrill of Test cricket, India edged out England by just 6 runs in the final Test at The Oval, squaring the inaugural Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy 2-2. Despite holding the edge at the start of Day 5, needing just 35 runs with four wickets in hand, England fell agonisingly short—thanks to a fiery burst from Mohammed Siraj and Prasidh Krishna, who combined to take the last four wickets in dramatic fashion. This nail-biting result capped off a fiercely fought five-match series that saw both teams trade blows across different venues. But it was India's spirited comeback in the final hour that stole the headlines—and left England skipper Ben Stokes with mixed emotions. Stokes, ruled out of the final Test due to a shoulder injury, made his presence felt in the post-match presentation with a heartfelt reflection. "It's always difficult when you can't participate in a game like this. Another hard-fought game, right down to the wire, and both teams gave it absolutely everything,' said the England all-rounder. The absence of their talismanic captain was keenly felt, especially as England's tail was exposed to India's pace battery under immense pressure. While Ollie Pope led in his absence, the emotional void was undeniable. 'I'm bitterly disappointed we couldn't get over the line. But I'm incredibly proud of the heart, energy, and resilience this team showed,' added Stokes. Chris Woakes' Bravery Epitomizes England's Spirit One of the most stirring moments of Day 5 came when Chris Woakes, nursing a shoulder injury, walked out to bat with his left arm in a sling—determined to fight until the end. Stokes didn't hold back his admiration for the courage displayed. 'He spent yesterday thinking about which way around he was going to bat,' said Stokes. 'We've got guys who've gone out there and played with broken fingers and broken feet. It shows how much playing for England means to these players.' Woakes' gesture resonated with fans worldwide, symbolising the grit and passion that defined this Test series. Siraj's Five-Fer Seals the Deal for India While England's fightback was valiant, it was Mohammed Siraj who turned the game on its head. His relentless aggression with the second new ball rattled the hosts, finishing with a match-winning five-wicket haul. Prasidh Krishna's timely strikes from the other end ensured England never quite recovered from the early blows. Siraj's performance, particularly on a final-day pitch offering little help, drew comparisons to some of India's finest overseas fast-bowling efforts in recent years. His consistency under pressure added a heroic layer to India's dramatic win. Stokes on India-England Rivalry: 'Emotions Are a Part of It' Addressing the heated moments between players during the series, Stokes was candid but composed. 'India vs England is always emotional. We won't go to bed crying about what was said on the field, and neither would the Indians. That's just part of the passion.' This mature take on sledging and on-field banter adds depth to the modern-day India-England rivalry, now among the most fiercely contested matchups in international cricket.
India.com
7 minutes ago
- India.com
Stuart Broad Mocks Washington Sundar's Prediction After India's Defeat In 3rd Test vs England
In a series filled with fierce competition, riveting comebacks, and high-stakes drama, the India vs England 2025 Test series has lived up to the billing — and then some. But amid the intense cricketing action, it was a tongue-in-cheek remark from England's veteran pacer Stuart Broad that stole headlines ahead of the decisive final day at The Oval. Speaking to Sky Sports, Broad cheekily named his "favourite moment" from the series — and it had less to do with wickets or runs and more to do with confidence gone awry. 'Washington Sundar said after Day 4 at Lord's that 'India would definitely win this Test'. Then he chipped one back to Jofra Archer and went back for a duck. It did make me smile,' Broad said with a grin. His comment was aimed at Washington Sundar's bold assertion before India's fourth innings collapse in the third Test. With India needing just 193 to win and four wickets down by stumps on Day 4, Sundar's confidence seemed justified. But cricket has its own script. India's Painful Collapse at Lord's: The Turning Point? The Lord's Test, now etched in memory for both fans and players, was perhaps the most pivotal game of the series. India, needing a modest total to secure a win, looked poised for a stunning chase with Ravindra Jadeja leading a gritty lower-order fightback alongside Jasprit Bumrah and Mohammed Siraj. But England's disciplined attack held their nerve. India eventually fell short by 22 runs — a narrow defeat that could haunt them if England complete the 3-1 series win on Day 5 of the ongoing fifth Test. Series Decider at The Oval: England on the Brink, India Clinging On Heading into the final day at The Oval, England need just 35 runs to win the match and the series. Joe Root (105) and Harry Brook (111) delivered masterclasses in pressure batting, stitching together a 195-run stand that swung momentum heavily in England's favour. Despite rain and bad light delaying the inevitable, the equation is simple: England are favourites, but India — needing four wickets — will throw everything at the hosts in a bid to square the series 2-2. Currently, Jamie Smith (2*) and Jamie Overton (0*) are at the crease with England on 339/6 chasing 374. What Washington Sundar's Moment Teaches Us While Stuart Broad's remark may come off as playful banter, it highlights the psychological battles within Test cricket. Confidence can galvanize a team — or backfire spectacularly. Sundar, known for his composure under pressure, made a brave call. But as Broad's quip underlines, in cricket, results speak louder than words. Still, the 2025 series has been a revelation for young Indian talents. Shubman Gill's maturity, Ravindra Jadeja's resilience, and Jasprit Bumrah's aggressive spells have all provided bright spots — even as England's tactical superiority and batting depth have often tilted the balance. Day 5: One Hour to Decide a Series As fans gear up for a nerve-wracking final day, the spotlight will be on how India's bowlers approach the task. Can Bumrah produce magic with the second new ball? Will Ravichandran Ashwin, whose role has been subdued this series, step up? Or will England's batters calmly finish the chase? Whatever happens, this IND vs ENG series — capped off by Stuart Broad's humorous jab — has reminded fans why Test cricket remains the ultimate test of skill, character, and unpredictability.
Hindustan Times
7 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
'Hats off to…': Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella's praise after India's miraculous Oval test win against England
Google CEO Sundar Pichai made his commentary debut last week during Day 3 of the fifth and final Test between India and England at The Oval in London. A known cricket enthusiast, Pichai joined veteran broadcaster Harsha Bhogle in the commentary box during India's second innings. Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella (left); India captain Shubman Gill and pacer Mohammed Siraj after India's victory against England in the fifth and final test match at the Oval on Monday. (ANI) Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella, another cricket enthusiast, couldn't resist expressing his views after India's miraculous victory in the final test on Monday. Taking to social media platform X, Satya Nadella called it a testament to the enduring charm of Test cricket. Nadella's post summarises the essence of the thrilling five-match series, which ended in a 2-2 draw after 25 days of intensely-fought battle on the grounds of England. "25 days. 5 battles. Scores tied 2-2. This isn't just a game — it's Test Cricket in all its timeless glory. A series for the ages. Hats off to IND & ENG for the drama, grit, and greatness,' wrote Nadella, praising both Indian and English sides. England versus India 2025 will go down as one of cricket's greatest test series of all time. More than 7,000 runs were scored, including a record-equalling 21 individual centuries, the sun shone most of the time and every match went into the fifth day. The stadiums were packed and although tensions flared at times on the pitch - perhaps inevitable given the immense pressure - it was a series that featured all the best things that make test cricket such compulsive viewing. With more and more one-day cricket around the world, it was a timely boost for the longest format of the sport which many people believe is fighting for its existence. Pacer Mohammed Siraj was star in India's stunning win in the fifth Test against England that which helped them square the intensely-fought five-match series. Mohammed Siraj (5/104) was the standout performer, delivering one of his finest performances under pressure. He finished the series with 23 wickets — the highest across both teams. Set a record target of 374, England were well-placed at 339 for six at stumps on the penultimate day, before bad light and rain halted play. However, India picked up the remaining four wickets quickly on the final morning to bowl England out for 367.
