No new trials for Michigan school shooter's parents despite violation by prosecutors, judge rules
Setting aside the involuntary manslaughter convictions of James and Jennifer Crumbley and starting over would be too severe, Oakland County Judge Cheryl Matthews said.
'The court would effectively be ignoring the impact of dozens of hours of testimony, postulating a basis for the jury verdict, dismissing a plethora of other evidence suggesting guilt, and impermissibly speculating about what 'might have happened,' ' Matthews said.
The Crumbleys are serving 10-year prison sentences. They didn't know their son had planned to commit a mass shooting at Oxford High School in 2021. But they were accused of failing to lock a gun at home and ignoring Ethan Crumbley's mental health needs. Four students were killed.
The parents didn't take Ethan home on the day of the shooting when they were confronted with his macabre drawing of a gun, blood and dark messages.
School administrator Nick Ejak and counselor Shawn Hopkins testified about that meeting. But unknown to jurors and defense lawyers: The men earlier had given interviews to investigators with the promise that their words would not be used against them. They were never charged.
Lawyers for the Crumbleys argued that producing those agreements was a fundamental obligation of prosecutors. They said trial attorneys would have further tried to cast doubt on the credibility of Ejak and Hopkins during cross-examination.
'The lack of disclosure ... is in itself disturbing,' the judge acknowledged.
Prosecutor Karen McDonald's team had argued that the deals weren't immunity agreements and didn't need to be shared.
Jennifer Crumbley's appellate lawyer said the fight will continue in higher courts.
'So the prosecution intentionally cheated and violated the court rules, but they didn't cheat hard enough for the court to do anything about it,' Michael Dezsi said.
Ethan Crumbley is serving a life prison sentence.
Crumbley, now 19, is serving a life prison sentence. His parents, James and Jennifer Crumbley, are each serving 10-year sentences for involuntary manslaughter. Prosecutors said they had ignored his mental health needs, bought him a gun as a gift and then failed to safely secure it.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Thousands of mourners gather for funeral of NYPD Officer Didarul Islam, killed in NYC shooting
NEW YORK — NYPD Officer Didarul Islam, the cop gunned down in a Midtown Manhattan mass shooting inside a Park Ave. office building, was posthumously promoted to detective first grade during his funeral on Thursday as a sea of mourners, mostly police, gathered outside to pay their respects. An estimated 15,000 people were on hand. Islam was one of the four people killed on Monday by rampaging gunman Shane Tamura in what police Commissioner Jessica Tisch called a 'self-centered, senseless crusade of violence,' as she announced Islam's promotion. '(Tamura) tore a father from his children, a husband from his wife, a son from his family, and, in that moment, he ripped the world away from everyone who knew and loved NYPD Police Officer Didarul Islam,' Tisch said. 'His journey was cut too short. But the way he lived this job — with steadiness, with heart and conviction — he reflected everything this title represents.' Islam's father, Abdur Rob, suffered a minor heart attack after rushing to New York-Presbyterian Hospital Weill Cornell and being told that his son had not survived the 6:30 p.m. bloodbath. On Wednesday night, Mayor Eric Adams visited with Islam's family and spoke with Rob and other family members. 'There is nothing more tragic than having a parent bury their child,' Adams said at the funeral Wednesday. 'The pain is so immense. It is so intense, and we (are) thinking about it over and over again.' The mayor said that talking to Rob made him think about his own son: 'I want to say sorry as one parent to another parent. We must live in the spirit of Officer Islam and what he stood for.' Adams and Tisch also went to the 47th Precinct stationhouse where Islam worked on Wednesday to attend morning roll call and talk to cops mourning their colleague's death. Islam had been a cop since 2021. He was in uniform working a paid security detail in the building at E. 51st St., which had been authorized by the NYPD, when Tamura stormed inside with an assault rifle and started firing, hitting him repeatedly in the torso. Tamura, a resident of Las Vegas, also killed building security guard Aland Etienne, 46, and Blackstone executive Wesley LePatner, 43, in the lobby. He then took an elevator to the 33rd floor where he killed Julia Hyman, 27, and shot at but narrowly missed hitting a fleeing cleaning woman, before taking his own life. In all, he fired more than 40 shots from a high-powered AR-15 assault rifle, littering the lobby and 33rd floor with bullets and blood, NYPD Chief of Department John Chell said Wednesday. 'I've been doing this 32 years,' Chell said, getting choked up at times during the interview on Fox 5's 'Good Day New York.' 'Just getting there on that scene and realizing you had casualties and there was an active shooter going on. This is not a normal event.' 'We lost four great New Yorkers,' he added. 'They didn't deserve this. This was pure evil. Senseless.' Speaking to other pressing issues of the day, the imam overseeing the service challenged police, local elected officials and mourners to rid the world of Islamophobia and end the war in Gaza. 'Do not stand with him in death, stand with his people in life,' Imam Zakir Ahmed told an overflow crowd at the Parkchester Jame Masjid mosque as he prayed for Officer Islam, a Bangladeshi immigrant, loving husband and father, and dedicated police officer. 'He lived at a time when, too often, people like him are feared. You cannot take our sacrifice but ignore our suffering.' 'We commit ourselves to not just to honor him, but to building a world worthy of his sacrifice,' he said. 'A world where freedom is for all, not for some.' ________
CNN
28 minutes ago
- CNN
Air Marshals are being pulled from commercial flights to ‘serve sandwiches and check lice' on ICE deportation flights
President Donald Trump has vowed to carry out the largest deportation operation in American history, and his administration has been tapping employees from across the government to aid his ambitions of removing a million immigrants a year. That now includes, for the first time, using Federal Air Marshals to guard some of the thousands of deportation flights operated by Immigration and Customs Enforcement this year. The Federal Air Marshal Service was created in response to a rise in airplane hijackings in the 1960s and tasked with stopping terrorists after the 9/11 attacks. But since June, some 200 Air Marshals have also been redeployed to provide security on flights filled with detainees in ICE custody, who are being shuffled from detention centers around the US, or deported to a growing number of ICE Air destination countries, according to sources and documents seen by CNN. The unprecedented arrangement has sparked concerns that marshals are being diverted from guarding against potential national security threats onboard commercial passenger planes. Instead, according to two sources familiar with the matter and documents seen by CNN, these highly trained agents are taking ICE assignments — some, willingly, others, under intense pressure from supervisors — where they are serving sandwiches and acting as flight security guards. The Air Marshal National Council, a group that lobbies for Air Marshals' interests, this month sent a cease-and-desist letter to the Department of Homeland Security and the Transportation Security Administration, which oversees the Federal Air Marshals, accusing the Trump administration of undermining security on commercial aircraft by redeploying Air Marshals onto ICE Air flights. The group says they've also filed a complaint with the Department of Homeland Security's inspector general. The ICE redeployments 'undermine aviation and national security and expose federal officers to unsafe and improper working conditions,' the Air Marshal National Council said, citing concerns that marshals on these flights were unarmed while transporting passengers. The council also pointed out that the federal government has hired a private contractor, GEO Group subsidiary GEO Transport, to provide security onboard ICE deportation flights. Sonya LaBosco, the executive director of the group, says marshals are being deployed to essentially work as security guards for the private contractor, and to perform duties including checking for lice and cleaning aircraft. The council contends that GEO Group is using unarmed government agents to provide onboard security for ICE flights—a job the company was contracted and being paid to do. LaBosco was concerned that this highly unusual arrangement could constitute 'contract fraud,' with public employees doing the work covered by the company's contract. 'We are supplementing a billion-dollar company's security staff for these deportation flights,' she said. Asked to comment on these concerns, Russel Read, a spokesman for TSA told CNN in a statement: 'TSA's Federal Air Marshals are proud to support our ICE colleagues by providing in-flight security functions for select [ICE] flights. This new initiative is part of the interagency effort to support the President's mandate and DHS's mission to secure the homeland.' The GEO Group referred CNN's questions to ICE, an agency overseen by DHS. The company announced last year that it had secured a five-year contract deal with ICE worth $25 million a year 'to provide air operations support services,' though it was unclear whether this was the contract the AMNC's complaint was referring to. In a letter responding to the Council reviewed by CNN, TSA said the redeployments were in line with Trump's immigration goals. The agency had assessed risks, TSA said, and found that it 'has not impacted Federal Air Marshals' deployment on domestic and international flights to assess, address, and mitigate varying potential risks and threats to transportation and travelers.' For decades, the US government has used flights for deportations, dating back to the 1940s and 1950s. Flights have taken place under recent Democratic as well as Republican administrations, but in Trump's second term, they have been turbocharged. Not only has there been an uptick in removal flights, but also domestic flights within the US to transport deportees between local airports in towns and cities across the country, including some that had previously never hosted ICE flights. According to Witness at the Border, an advocacy group that tracks immigration activity, since Trump took office in January to June, flights have increased 34% — to 4,748 flights — when compared to the same time period in 2024. The group has used publicly available flight tracking information to monitor ICE flights since 2020. This number includes moving detainees domestically between ICE facilities as ICE agents ramp up immigration raids in cities nationwide. In June alone, Witness at the Border says there were 209 deportation flights to 41 foreign countries, and nearly 700 domestic 'shuffle flights' of ICE detainees being moved around within the country. To supplement the huge undertaking, ICE has relied on several other parts of the federal government, including the US Marshals Service, FBI and, now, the TSA's Federal Air Marshals division. According to the sources who spoke to CNN, Federal Air Marshals assigned to ICE flights are now sometimes collecting thousands of dollars in overtime pay. Though marshals have been used to aid with immigration operations at the border in the past, they have not previously been used on deportation flights. 'They're just walking the aisles and handing out ham sandwiches. They get overtime, it's an easy gig with little responsibility,' according to one source familiar with the deployments. The source quipped that the marshals are essentially 'serving as highly paid guards' aboard the flights. According to an internal DHS memorandum seen by CNN, TSA agreed to provide as many as 250 marshals to ICE for its flight operations. TSA employs between 2,000 and 3,000 Air Marshals in total. One Air Marshal who had been placed on a 5-day deployment to provide security on a deportation flight bound for West Africa gave a sense of the job as being filled with unpredictability. The person arrived for the assignment, only to find the flight delayed, and spent three days waiting by the pool for what amounted to a 'vacation' before the next flight. The Air Marshal Association, the union representing Air Marshals, said they supported the redeployments. 'The Federal Air Marshal mission has lost its focus under TSA, so assisting with criminal alien deportations allows our highly skilled agents to perform a vital security function while we wait for lawmakers to create a standalone Federal Air Marshal agency,' its president, John Casaretti, told CNN in a statement. However, redeployments have drawn serious concerns from others. 'After 9/11 the only job we [Air Marshals] have is to thwart another hijacking on a commercial passenger plane,' LaBosco, of the Air Marshal National Council, told CNN. 'We should be using federal air marshals for the job they should be doing.' GEO Group is just one company in an ecosystem of firms that allows the complex US deportation system to work. Besides a vast network of local airports, there are private and commercial charter flight companies; aviation partners for on-the-ground logistics and refueling; and even providers of passenger boarding steps and security onboard aircraft. 'Right from the early days, Immigration Naturalization Services [the precursor to ICE] were fielding offers and soliciting offers and also receiving unsolicited offers from people looking to make a buck off of the business of deportation,' says Adam Goodman, author of 'The Deportation Machine' and professor at the University of Illinois Chicago. With the passage of the president's tax and spending package, some $14 billion will be allotted to ICE flights, according to DHS. Plans are underway to bolster the federal government's fleet to carry out more deportations, according to senior Trump officials. Both established players and new companies not previously involved in ICE flights and detentions are vying for contracts. Asked about ICE's deportation flights operations plans, a DHS spokeswoman said: 'ICE's goal is to swiftly remove illegal aliens from this country. The sooner ICE removes dangerous criminal aliens from our nation, the safer our entire country will become.' Priscilla Alvarez, Holmes Lybrand and Aaron Cooper contributed to this report.
Associated Press
28 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Federal judges detail rise in threats, 'pizza doxxings,' as Trump ramps up criticism
In 2020, a disgruntled litigant posing as a deliveryman opened fire at the New Jersey home of District Judge Esther Salas, killing her 20-year-old son Daniel Anderl. Five years later, as President Donald Trump steps up hiscriticism of federal judges who have blocked some of his agenda, dozens of judges have had unsolicited pizzas delivered to their homes, often in Daniel Anderl's name. District Judge John J. McConnell, Jr. of Rhode Island, who stalled Trump's initial round of across-the-board spending cuts, is among those who received pizzas in Anderl's name. His courtroom also has been flooded by threatening calls, including one profanity-laced one that called for his assassination. McConnell, Jr. played a recording of the call during an unusual discussion Thursday where multiple federal judges discussed threats they have received — a notable conversation because judges usually only speak publicly from the bench and through their rulings, and rarely if ever, about personal threats and attacks. Salas and others said the number of attacks has escalated in recent months. Without using his name, Salas called on Trump and his allies to tone down the rhetoric and stop demonizing the judiciary, for fear of what more could happen. 'We're used to being appealed. But keep it on the merits, stop demonizing us,' Salas said. 'They're inviting people to do us harm.' Thursday's event was sponsored by Speak up for Justice, a nonpartisan group supporting an independent judiciary. District Judge John C. Coughenour of Washington recalled having a police SWAT team called to his home to respond to a false report of an attack after Coughenour in January halted Trump's executive order ending birthright citizenship for children of people in the country illegally. District Judge Robert S. Lasnik of Washington also had pizzas delivered in Anderl's name to both his home and those of his two adult children, each in different cities, after an article in which he was quoted as being critical of attacks on judges was picked up by a television station in the Pacific Northwest, where he hears cases. 'The message to me was 'we know where you live, we know where your kids live, and they could end up dead like Daniel Anderl did,'' Lasnik said in an interview. Salas says U.S. Marshals have told her of more than 100 cases of so-called 'pizza doxxings,' unwanted deliveries to the homes of federal judges and their families, since 2024, with most occurring this year. Salas added that she's heard of additional cases targeting state judges in states ranging from Colorado to Florida, incidents that wouldn't be tracked by Marshals, who protect federal judges. 'This is not some random, silly act, this is a targeted, concentrated, coordinated attack on judges,' Salas said in an interview, 'and yet we don't hear any condemnation from Washington.' Salas, nominated by Democratic President Barack Obama, in 2022 was critical of protests at the homes of Republican-nominated Supreme Court justices who revoked women's right to have an abortion, which were followed by the arrest of a man at the home of Justice Brett Kavanaugh who said he was there to assassinate the justice. Salas said both sides of the political aisle have used worrying rhetoric about judges, but it's reached a new peak since Trump took office. 'I've often referred to it as a bonfire that I believe the current administration is throwing accelerants on,' Salas said. Trump himself has led the charge against judges, often going after them by name on social media. He's said judges who've ruled against his administration are 'sick,' 'very dangerous' and 'lunatic.' Trump's allies have amplified his rhetoric and called for impeaching judges who rule against the president or simply disobeying their rulings. Earlier this year, several judges at the panel noted, Rep. Andy Ogles of Tennessee had a 'wanted' poster of judges who'd crossed the president hanging outside his congressional office. Lasnik said many judges appointed by presidents of both parties have told him of concerns but are nervous about discussing the issue openly. 'A lot of them don't know how to speak up and are afraid of crossing a line somewhere where they would get a judicial complaint like judge Boasberg did,' Lasnik said, referring to District Judge James E. Boasberg of D.C., who infuriated the Trump administration by finding they likely committed criminal contempt by disobeying his order to turn around a deportation flight to El Salvador. Though Chief Justice John Roberts has come to Boasberg's defense, Trump's Department of Justice this week filed a complaint against Boasberg over comments he made at a judicial conference that other judges worry the Trump administration won't obey their orders. Last month, Trump's Justice Department took the extraordinary step of suing every federal judge in Maryland over rules governing how they handle immigration cases. More than five dozen judges who've ruled against Trump are receiving enhanced online protection, including scrubbing their identifying information from websites, according to two Trump-appointed judges who wrote Congress urging more funding for judicial security. In 2022, Congress passed a law named after Daniel Anderl allowing judges to sue internet sites to take down identifying information.
