I was sure Lucy Letby was guilty… then spent weeks poring over evidence & now I'm convinced NO babies were murdered
And last week it emerged
Advertisement
8
Killer nurse Lucy Letby could face even more charges but some question her guilt
Credit: pixel8000
8
Sun man Oliver Harvey thinks Letby has been let down by the legal system
Credit: Peter Jordan
Letby, 35, is understood to have carried out two work placements at Liverpool Women's Hospital - where she trained as a student - between October and December 2012, and January and February 2015.
The
Crown Prosecution Service
(CPS) said it had received "a full file of evidence from
Cheshire
Constabulary asking us to consider further allegations in relation to deaths and non-fatal collapses of
babies
at the Countess of Chester Hospital and
Liverpool
Women's Hospital".
It comes after
three people - who were in senior leadership roles at the Countess of Chester Hospital -
as part of an investigation into the
.
Advertisement
But while evidence continues to stack up against her, there are also a growing number of people - including some prominent politicians - who have publicly expressed doubts over her guilt.
Yesterday we told how journalist Nigel Bunyan, who attended Lucy Letby's main trial and the retrial that followed it, is convinced justice was served because Letby is "
a nailed-on
serial killer
of tiny, defenceless babies
".
But The Sun's Chief Features Writer Oliver Harvey is in the opposite camp, concerned "an innocent young woman has been jailed in one of the greatest miscarriages of justice in British legal history".
Here he puts forward his argument for why he's convinced Lucy Letby is not guilty of her harrowing crimes, and why a fresh appeal is needed immediately.
STARING at Lucy Letby's washed out mugshot on the day of her conviction, I believed she was a wicked baby killer.
Advertisement
Justice was done, I assumed, so let this monster rot in hell. Hadn't the 'Angel of Death' even admitted her own guilt in scrawled notes?
Months later, after being commissioned to write an
Top doc whose work was used to nail Letby reveals why he KNOWS she's innocent
Much of it involves complex medical and statistical information. It required strong coffee, a string of late nights and expert advice.
Now, I believe an innocent young woman has been jailed in one of the greatest
And, in my view, no babies were murdered or harmed at the Countess of Chester Hospital.
Advertisement
Last week prosecutors revealed they were
Cheshire Police have been investigating further 'deaths and non-fatal collapses of babies'.
8
Staring at Lucy Letby's washed out mugshot on the day of her conviction, Oliver believed she was a wicked baby killer
Credit: PA
8
The writer has since changed his mind after being commissioned to write an article about Letby 'truthers'
Credit: PA
So why do I believe Letby - already caged for murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others - has been wrongfully convicted?
Advertisement
And could two jury trials and two Appeal Court hearings really have misread things so badly?
A solemn truth is that English justice - long admired across the world - sometimes gets it wrong.
After nearly 30 years working in Fleet Street, including reporting for a news agency at the
I saw the
After nearly 30 years working in Fleet Street, including reporting for a news agency at the Old Bailey and the High Court, I've witnessed my share of wrongful convictions firsthand
Oliver Harvey
Wrongly convicted for murdering 13-year-old paperboy Carl Bridgewater, James spoke of the 'long, lonely years that we've cried and wept' as 'people have looked at us with hate' and 'called us child-killers'.
Advertisement
Words delivered with such raw emotion stay with you.
Then there was
During her 18-months incarceration I got to know her salt-of-the-earth husband Terry.
Visiting him at home in Salisbury,
"After she was jailed I just sobbed and sobbed on my sofa.'
Advertisement
Angela's conviction was overturned by the Appeal Court in 2003 after it emerged medical evidence against her was flawed and that her babies had actually perished from
8
Angela Cannings was wrongly convicted of killing her children and freed by the court of appeal
Credit: Reuters
8
The Bridgewater Three were wrong convicted of murder
Credit: PA:Press Association
It's a pertinent example of how police, prosecutors and juries can get it wrong when dealing with complex medical issues.
I believe evidence used to convict Letby was also catastrophically flawed and doesn't stand up to scrutiny.
Advertisement
A central plank of the prosecution case - placed before the jury at the beginning of Letby's first 10-month trial - was an apparently damning shift rota.
The chart showed a cluster of 25 suspicious baby deaths and collapses matched against the shift rota of the 38 nurses who worked on the unit.
Only Letby was at the scene for every death and collapse.
Yet the jury wasn't told about six other baby deaths in the period for which she faced no charges.
Statisticians also say the chart covers far too narrow a period of time.
Advertisement
Professor Richard Gill, whose expertise is medical statistics, told me the spreadsheet was 'ludicrous' and that he believes Letby is innocent.
Fatal flaws
8
MP David Davis has come out in support of Letby as has retired medic Dr Shoo Lee
Credit: Ben Whitley/PA Wire
8
Dr Dewi testified that Letby had injected insulian or air into bloodstreams or feeding tubes
Credit: PA
When a case has been built around what the professor says are flawed statistics, then I believe the whole evidential edifice starts to crumble.
So what about the science?
Advertisement
Expert witness
A string of respected neonatologists called Dr Evans's theory that Letby injected air into babies via their nasal feeding tubes as 'implausible' and 'ridiculous'.
Dr Evans had cited a 1989 academic paper which said skin discolourations occur with air bubbles in blood vessels, and he believed this was evident in several of the babies.
But the paper's co-author, Dr Shoo Lee says none of the descriptions of the babies' skin blemishes given by witnesses matched those that he had noted.
In February, Dr Lee chaired a panel of 14 leading international experts who had examined 17 cases at the heart of Letby's prosecution.
Advertisement
Their conclusion?
"We did not find any murders. In all cases, death or injury were due to natural causes or just bad medical care," he revealed.
Remember Letby - who has always pleaded her innocence - was never seen injecting a baby or harming them in any way.
That Letby's case is likely to rumble on for years is heartbreaking for the bereaved families
Oliver Harvey
Police found no internet searches for her alleged murder techniques while no motive or psychological profile of a serial killer was ever presented to the court.
And Letby's
Advertisement
The ramblings also included: 'WHY ME? I haven't done anything wrong.'
They were written as part of her therapy after she was removed from her nursing duties following a cluster of baby deaths.
Used as a 'gotcha' moment at her first trial, the 'I'm evil I did this' sentiment may simply have been her insecurity at so many babies dying on her ward.
Letby also kept 257 confidential shift handover sheets from the ward under her bed. Twenty-one of the documents related to 13 children prosecutors said she had harmed.
Campaigner and former Cabinet Minister David Davis told me: 'If you didn't know that she was accused of murder, you'd just think she was being excessively conscientious.'
Advertisement
Revelations that she searched bereaved families on Facebook perhaps shows she was concerned for those grieving.
It certainly doesn't amount to evidence she was a baby killer.
UK's most prolific child killer Lucy Letby
The
All about Lucy Letby's
Inside her interview with
Lucy Letby's
How Lucy Letby went
Killer nurse
The Countess of Chester - which treated critically ill and very premature babies clinging to life - was plagued by staff shortages and a superbug, while a leading medic described its neonatal unit as 'out of its depth'.
With so many clustered baby deaths, I believe blame was subconsciously shifted to a convenient scapegoat - the young, female, guileless nurse Lucy Letby.
The prospect of fresh charges and a trial may actually work in her favour. A better marshalled defence could call on a wealth of expert witnesses deployed to debunk bad science and iffy statistics.
Advertisement
That Letby's case is likely to rumble on for years is heartbreaking for the bereaved families.
A fresh appeal is needed immediately. The threshold for criminal conviction - being beyond reasonable doubt - hasn't, in my opinion, been close to being reached.
Justice may be blind, but it is not infallible.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Fury as number of foreign sex offenders & violent criminals jailed in England and Wales hits record high
THE NUMBER of foreign sex and violent offenders locked up in England and Wales has soared to record highs, damning new data reveals. Official figures show 1,731 foreign-national sex offenders were in prison in June - up nearly 10 per cent in a year and almost three times the rate of British offenders. 2 'They need to be kicked out of the country immediately. Starmer must suspend visas and aid until countries take back their nationals', says Robert Jenrick Credit: PA Violent Shadow Justice Secretary "They need to be kicked out of the country immediately. Albanians remain the largest foreign nationality in UK prisons, with 1,193 behind bars - many for drug offences. READ MORE ON PRISONS Poles, Romanians and Irish make up the next biggest groups, followed by Lithuanians and Foreign nationals now account for more than one in 10 sex offenders and violent criminals in custody, and one in five drug offenders. The new figures, published by the Ministry of Justice, follow months of pressure for greater transparency on the nationality of offenders. Some of the Most read in The Sun The Sun also recently revealed that four in ten people charged over sex attacks in London in the last seven years were foreign nationals. Police figures showed these migrants were behind 2,809 of the 7,798 alleged crimes recorded in the capital since 2018 - despite making up less than a quarter of the city's population. Manchester Police Raids smash down doors in early morning raids on postal drug dealers 2 The number of foreign sex and violent offenders locked up in England and Wales has soared to record highs Credit: Getty
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Hammer gang raid Harry Redknapp's £5m mansion and steal wife Sandra's jewellery as cops probe theory on how they got in
MASKED robbers smashed their way into Harry Redknapp's mansion with hammers and stole wife Sandra's jewellery. The ex-Prem boss and Sandra were out when the gang broke down the front door of their 4 A gang broke into Harry Redknapp's mansion with hammers and stole his wife Sandra's jewellery Credit: Getty 4 The mansion is near Dorset beach resort Sandbanks, where property is among the most expensive in the world per square foot Credit: PA A source said: 'It was clearly organised. 'The raiders must have known the house was empty." The gang may have checked the layout on a property website ad, it was feared. And the raiders helped themselves to jewellery belonging to the ex-Premier League manager's wife Sandra and other luxury items, it is understood. Read more on Harry Redknapp Former Spurs, West Ham and Portsmouth boss Harry and Sandra, both 78, were away from the £5million house when the crooks broke in last Friday night. The pile is for sale and one theory is the gang noted details on the Rightmove listing for the property near Dorset beach resort Sandbanks — where property is among the most expensive in the world per square foot. In May this year, burglars attempted to break into the A source said: 'The criminals would only have to keep watch on the property and break in once the coast was clear, knowing the full layout of the house in advance.' Most read in Football The masked gang used heavy hammers to break down the front door of cockney Harry's home. The mob were caught on CCTV rifling through the detached gated property in the mega-rich area. A source said: 'The raiders were all masked up. Legend Harry Redknapp's wife of 57 years has been taken into hospital, it was claimed last night 'They used lump hammers and a sledgehammer to smash the front door open. 'They were caught on CCTV cameras breaking in and trying to ransack the property looking for valuables. 'It was clearly organised and they must have known the house was empty at the time.' One family friend said 2018 I'm a Celeb winner Harry — who we have revealed is set to A spokesman for Harry told The Sun: 'Harry doesn't want to make a fuss. 'There was no one in the house at the time and we don't want to comment on what was taken. 'It's a matter for the police.' Officers last night confirmed they were still hunting the thieves who broke into the property close to Branksome Dene Beach in Poole. It is on sale while the couple's new waterside villa at Sandbanks is completed. They moved into their current home in 2021, after a lack of privacy while living in a modern mansion with large windows overlooking Sandbanks beach. In 2020, they starred in ITV reality show Harry Redknapp's Sandbanks Summer. 4 Ex-Prem boss Harry is said to have attended a function on the night of the robbery Credit: CameraSport - Getty 4 The property is on sale while Harry and Sandra's new waterside villa at Sandbanks is completed Credit: Instagram
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Evil terrorist confesses he masterminded 7/7 bombings – but could be freed in DAYS despite ‘grave concerns from cops'
FURY erupted last night over the imminent release on to British streets of a terrorist who has admitted being a mastermind behind 9/11 and the 7/7 London bombings. Despite his confession while in US custody Haroon Aswat, 50, could still be freed from a secure unit onto UK streets without a full risk assessment within days. 4 Haroon Aswat, 50, could be freed from a secure unit onto UK streets without a full risk assessment within days Credit: John Cobb 4 In 1999 Aswat helped Finsbury Park mosque hate preacher Abu Hamza set up a US terror camp According to US court documents obtained by The Sun, the al-Qaeda fiend confessed he was a 'mastermind behind the 9/11 attacks and a 2005 terrorist attack in the UK'. But he could be released from a secure psychiatric unit within days thanks to a legal loophole blocking him from being subjected to stringent risk checks. Shadow Justice Secretary In April, we told how worried counter-terror chiefs — who believe Aswat, 50, is a continuing threat to national security — had to apply for permission to keep tabs on him. But he will be subject only to a notification order requiring him to register his address and tell police of his future travel plans. We put in legal requests for the disclosure of statements made to the High Court during the application for the notification order. Aswat was arrested but never put on trial for the Most read in The Sun But it can now be revealed that he confessed to his role while in a US jail in 2017 following his extradition on other terror charges. The US District Court document states: 'The defendant's crimes are incredibly serious. He is a terrorist and foot soldier of al-Qaeda trained to commit acts of violence. 'His comments while in prison and his numerous disciplinary violations indicate he still supports al-Qaeda and remains dangerous. Al Qaeda 'mastermind' linked to 7/7 attack set to be freed to walk UK streets despite fears he is 'still a risk' 'In 2017 he told staff he was associated with al-Qaeda, Osama bin Laden was his 'commander' and that he would 'behead all of you'. 'In March 2017 the defendant stated, 'if you think I am a terrorist, I don't shy away from my responsibility', and also stated he was a mastermind behind the 9/11 attacks and a 2005 terrorist attack in the UK.' In his witness statement Det Chief Supt Gareth Rees, head of operations for the Met's SO15 Counter Terrorism Command, said of Aswat: 'He has spoken positively of his time with al-Qaeda in Afghanistan and expressed aspirations to reconnect with them. 'Based on my experience, this is conduct which gives me grave concerns about the risk which the defendant poses to the UK's national security and to the public. 4 Aswat has admitted being a mastermind behind the 7/7 London bombings Credit: EPA 'The assessment of medical practitioners is that he currently has capacity to make complex decisions and understand complex restrictions when mentally stable. 'However, he may temporarily lose capacity if he were to relapse into a psychotic state.' Aswat trained in al-Qaeda camps in Afghanistan months before the 2001 terror attacks which claimed more than 3,000 lives. Documents also revealed his name on a ledger recovered from a house in Pakistan where the 9/11 'architect' Khalid Sheikh Mohammed stayed. In 1999 Aswat helped Finsbury Park mosque hate preacher Abu Hamza set up a US terror camp. In 2002 he stayed at an al-Qaeda safe house in Pakistan where he met two 7/7 bombers. In 2005 police traced 20 calls to a phone linked to Aswat made by the 7/7 bombers before their attack. That year Aswat was arrested in He was deported to the UK and held under a US arrest warrant. Aswat fought extradition on mental health grounds but after a nine-year battle was sent to the US in 2014. A year later he pleaded guilty to terror charges. His 20-year jail term was cut to seven years because of time detained here at Broadmoor Hospital. Aswat, of Batley, West Yorks, was deported back to the UK in December 2022 and is held under the Mental Health Act at Bethlem Royal Hospital in South London. Doctors say he is well enough to be released 'in the relatively near future' but UK law means he cannot be formally risk-assessed while detained. 4 Aswat as also confessed to involvement in 9/11 Credit: Getty A report compiled in 2022 by psychiatrist Dr Richard Taylor concluded he still posed a serious risk. It highlighted Aswat has 'continued to express violent extremist Islamic ideology' even when in a relatively stable mental state. Other police officers who gave statements to the High Court in April also expressed concerns. Det Sgt David Taylor said: 'I assess the defendant has a significant involvement within Islamist extremism, involvement in terrorism and a long-standing association with others holding radical beliefs. 'I believe the defendant's US conviction, historic involvement with Islamist extremist groups and previously reported mindset alongside his vulnerable and fragile mental health do pose a potential risk to the security of the UK.' Det Insp Karen Bradley warned of danger if Aswat was excluded from normal risk checks applied to terrorists after release. No formal terrorist risk assessment has been carried out since the defendant's return here Mr Justice Jay She said: 'In my professional judgment, I believe that Mr Aswat still poses a potential terrorist risk.' The High Court was told that, owing to his detention, Aswat was not allowed to be assessed under Extremism Risk Guidance protocols. Under the notification order, he will not be under surveillance or wear a tag and can travel abroad if he tells cops in advance. Granting the order, Mr Justice Jay noted: 'No formal terrorist risk assessment has been carried out since the defendant's return here. 'The circumstances of his detention have precluded that. 'However, on the basis of the material which is available the defendant has been assessed by various police officers that he remains a risk to national security.' Protecting our national security is the very first priority of this government and if any individual poses a threat to that security A Government spokesman We had to formally notify Aswat of our request for more details before the Met Police agreed to release them and also agreed to notify medics caring for him prior to publication. Papers also revealed police and courts were obliged to consider his human rights when applying for the notification order. Read more on the Irish Sun A Government spokesman said: 'Protecting our national security is the very first priority of this government and if any individual poses a threat to that security, the police and intelligence services have a range of powers they can apply to deal with that threat. 'We will always do whatever is necessary inside the law to protect the public from any risk posed by former terrorist offenders or people of terrorist concern.'
