Keelings fails in bid to have alleged whistleblower penalisation claim heard in private
The Keelings fruit and vegetable group has failed in an attempt to have allegations of whistleblower penalisation and multiple employment rights breaches by a former employee heard entirely behind closed doors.
At the Workplace Relations Commission today, an adjudicator told the firm's representatives that the prospect of "certain people being named" in connection with the case was not reason enough to justify hearing the matter out of the public eye.
Keelings Logistics Solutions had sought a private hearing into claims by the worker, former warehouseman Rudolph Csikos, which were called on today at the employment tribunal.
He has alleged breaches of the Minimum Notice and Terms of Employment Act 1973, the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977, the Organisation of Working Time Act 1997 and the Protected Disclosures Act 2014 against the company.
At the hearing, adjudicator Brian Dalton noted the application by the company's representative, Emily Maverley of the Irish Business and Employers' Confederation (Ibec), for a hearing "in private".
"That's quite unusual, because this case is about the administration of justice," he said. "I do have the power to have a hearing in private, but I have to have very good reasons for it," he said.
"Certain wrongs, certain people being named - that in itself is not a reason," he added.
"In the administration of justice, the whole process is tested, and ultimately I will make a ruling. You can't make an allegation of defamation in the administration of justice. It's up to me to decide," he said.
He added that the law required "exceptional" circumstances for a private hearing.
Mr Dalton said he was only aware of the basis for the application for a private hearing at a "high level" and said there was "no point" discussing the detail any further with a member of the press in the room.
"I'm going to ask the press to leave temporarily," he said.
The matter proceeded for around 25 minutes behind closed doors before Mr Dalton reopened the hearing to the public.
"An application was made for the hearing to be heard in private, and it was turned down," he said.
After a short adjournment, Mr Dalton quoted a section of the Workplace Relations Act, as amended, to the parties.
He said the legislation required a hearing "in public, unless the adjudicating officer… determines that due to the existence of special circumstances, the proceedings or part thereof should be conducted otherwise than in public".
"In other words, most of this case will be heard in public," Mr Dalton said.
The adjudicator gave 27 May as the date for a further hearing and adjourned the matter shortly after that.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
9 hours ago
- Sunday World
Catering supervisor sacked over racial abuse loses WRC case: ‘How can I be racist?'
FAIR FIRING | 'I think the most serious part for me was that it made me out to be racist. One person said that when we were up in the A&E that I said: 'You're not Irish, you're black'. Workplace Relations Commission. Annette Ryan was dismissed from her part-time job as shift supervisor on an evening catering team at Waterford Hospital in September 2023 following bullying, harassment and racial abuse complaints from four of her subordinates. She wholly denied all of the allegations made against her, including complaints that she decided to change one worker's name to 'Tom' because she 'didn't speak his 'lingo',' and that she insulted another worker with references to their 'fat ass'. In a decision published today, a Workplace Relations Commission adjudicator concluded Ms Ryan's ex-employer, Campbell Catering Ltd, trading as Aramark, came to 'credible and reasonable conclusions' in a disciplinary process, and found that her sacking was 'fair in the circumstances'. At an online WRC hearing in March this year, Brian Joyce of the Irish Business and Employers' Confederation (IBEC), appearing for Aramark, said Ms Ryan's manager, Marcin Skrzypczak was approached by a worker in July 2023 who complained of 'bullying and discrimination'. Three more workers also came forward with complaints, and Ms Ryan was suspended pending an investigation, the tribunal was told. Workplace Relations Commission. News in 90 Seconds - June 11th Questioning Ms Ryan at an online hearing in March this year, WRC adjudicator Gaye Cunningham said: 'There were a number of serious allegations made against you. Is it your case that you just said this didn't happen? Did you think they all made it up, or what?' 'I think the most serious part for me was that it made me out to be racist. One person said that when we were up in the A&E that I said: 'You're not Irish, you're black', or something like that. That wasn't the case at all, I'm not a bit like that, that's what I said to them,' Ms Ryan said. 'You think he made that up, is it?' Ms Cunningham asked. 'The person who said it, made it up? Of course he did,' Ms Ryan said. These were addressed with the complainant at an investigation meeting in August 2023, the WRC decision recorded. Ms Ryan was dismissed the following month. "How can I be racist? I've worked with these people for 13 years," she told the WRC earlier this year. Her evidence was that she had worked with 'people from Nigeria, China, everywhere' at Waterford Hospital and was 'not a bit like that'. Her manager, Mr Skrzypczak, told the tribunal: 'I didn't feed anyone [anything] to go forward. People started coming to me, and as a site manager, I am responsible to act,' he added. Company disciplinary officer, Vladislava Tsapova, told the hearing she considered the workers' complaints against Ms Ryan 'genuine'. 'They were people who were genuinely afraid of a person who was in a supervisory position,' she said, adding that Ms Ryan offered neither any explanation for her behaviour nor any mitigating factors. Read more Brian Joyce of IBEC, who appeared for Aramark, submitted: 'The complainant was afforded a fair and impartial determination of the issues. Any allegation the process was flawed is denied.' Ms Cunningham noted Ms Ryan's 'denial of the allegations at all stages' and her stated belief that she was 'set up' -- but concluded the employer had come to 'credible and reasonable conclusions in the disciplinary process'. 'Had [Ms Ryan] accepted or shown some acknowledgement or remorse… the penalty may have been less harsh,' she wrote. 'The dismissal of the complainant indicates that racial abuse and bullying in the workplace will not be tolerated by any reasonable employer,' she added. The adjudicator dismissed Ms Ryan's complaint and ruled her sacking 'fair in the circumstances'. In evidence to the WRC in March, Aramark regional manager, Stephen Power, said he decided Ms Ryan had a case to answer when he met her on August 17 for an investigation meeting, he said. Ms Ryan offered no explanations when he presented her with the statements and responded with denials, he added. Ms Tsapova said she chaired the disciplinary meeting with Ms Ryan on August 30, 2023. She said Ms Ryan offered neither any mitigating factors nor any explanations when the investigation findings were put to her. She decided on the balance of probabilities that Ms Ryan had committed gross misconduct, with immediate dismissal given as a sanction on September 15, 2023, the WRC heard. The tribunal was told the sanction was upheld on appeal by a senior manager.
Irish Independent
21 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Tara Mines workers in Meath call for meeting with management on long-term future
The Tara Mines Group of Unions, including representatives from SIPTU, has formally requested a meeting with management to discuss delays in implementing a key component of the 2024 Sustainability Agreement, which was brokered by the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC). The agreement was pivotal in ending an 18-month layoff period for workers and restarting operations at Ireland's largest zinc mine. Tara Mines, operated by Swedish firm Boliden, is Europe's largest zinc mine and a major economic engine for Meath. SIPTU Sector Organiser, John Regan, said: 'As part of the Sustainability Agreement reached under the auspices of the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) in April 2024, which began the process of ending what would be 18 months of layoff for workers, it was agreed that 'further underground exploration drilling' would begin before 2027.' 'This refers to the Tara Deep, a project to develop a new ore body which has the potential to provide a further 40 years of mining in County Meath. Our members are not only focused on their employment but also the long-term viability of the mine, that is why this commitment by management was crucial to the 2024 WRC deal. In order to action this, Union representatives tabled a compromise proposal, to commence underground exploration drilling with immediate effect, at a Sustainability Agreement review meeting on May 12, 2025.' Mr Regan added that If management does not agree to commence work in line with the agreement, the unions will refer it back to the WRC. Andrew McGuinness, SIPTU Organiser, backed those concerns, pointing out that the company had already invested four years into developing Tara Deep before operations were halted in July 2023. He said: 'The company had invested in the development of Tara Deep for four years prior to the mine going into care and maintenance, with the lay-off of its workforce, in July 2023. At the time of commencement of this development plan, the timeframe was for Tara Deep to come into production in 2029. This timeframe is now ever increasing with Tara Deep development mining having not recommenced following the resumption of other activities at the Mine last year.' 'A failure to commence this development will leave the northeast region without one of its biggest employers in the near future. This will remove a key economic lifeline for the surrounding communities,' Mr McGuinness added. Funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme.
Irish Times
4 days ago
- Irish Times
Design & Crafts Council Ireland lost half of its workforce in 2024
About half of the staff working at Design & Crafts Council Ireland left the organisation last year. A total of 24 employees have resigned between the period 2021 to 2024. The figures were released under the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act and seen by The Irish Times. Design & Crafts Council Ireland (DCCI) is the national agency for craft and design and, according to its website, it aims to 'support designers and makers to develop their businesses in a sustainable way, and advocate for the societal benefits of craft and design'. Its activities are funded by the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment via Enterprise Ireland. The data released shows that one employee retired in 2020 while there was also a redundancy. There were eight resignations in 2021 as well as one redundancy. READ MORE There were seven resignations in 2022, alongside three redundancies and one retirement. In 2023, one employee resigned while another had their job terminated. Last year, there were eight resignations and three redundancies. DCCI said the average number of employees last year was 22. Overall staff numbers have averaged between 23 and 30 since 2020. During the period 2020 to 2024, three members of staff were part-time while all others were full-time. Four employees have brought cases to the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC). 'DCCI is unable to comment on the nature of any of the cases, but all have been concluded,' it stated. Jim Sheridan of Fórsa trade union, which represents a number of DCCI employees, said WRC cases it was involved in related to 'various employment issues'. The council said that staff have left the organisation over recent years for 'a number of varied reasons'. 'They left in the main to pursue other interests, or to retire, while a small number availed of voluntary severance. Significant restructuring and change programmes in mature organisations often result in staff turnover of this nature,' it said. In relation to 2025, two new staff members did not successfully complete their probationary period and were not retained while a third employee 'left the organisation to take a role located closer to where they live'. The organisation also said there has been a 'very significant restructuring of its functions and its team' over the past four years in line with its new strategic focus. In 2021, DCCI worked with KPMG to develop a new five-year strategy for the organisation. The strategy was launched following 'extensive consultation with the sector and key stakeholders, and DCCI's board formally adopted this new strategic plan'. DCCI threatened legal action against glass artist Róisín de Buitléar over a critical feedback report she sent on behalf of up to 20 other members earlier this year. The report was in relation to their experience of participating in the Collect 24 exhibition in London. In 2022, nine former DCCI employees wrote to the Department of Enterprise and then tánaiste Leo Varadkar, as well as to the board, to flag their concern at the high turnover of staff and request a review of the organisation's HR and workplace procedures. Rosemary Steen stepped down as chief executive of the council last summer after more than four years in the role to become director of the Residential Tenancies Board (RTB). The Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment (DETE) said DCCI is an independent organisation that receives funding through Enterprise Ireland (EI), while a service level agreement is in place. 'This provides the framework for agreement of service levels and performance management in respect of the funding provided by EI on behalf of DETE to the Design and Crafts Council Ireland,' it said.
