Diddy's sex trafficking trial faces setback as key victim may refuse to testify, prosecutors admit

Time of India

08-05-2025

Diddy trial drama: Victim-3's absence could weaken prosecution's strategy
The federal trial of Sean 'Diddy' Combs has taken an unexpected turn as prosecutors admitted that one of their key witnesses—identified in court documents as Victim-3—may not show up in court despite receiving a subpoena.
#Operation Sindoor
Live Updates| From Sindoor to showdown? Track Indo-Pak conflict as it unfolds
India hits Lahore's Air Defence Radars in proportionate response
Pakistan tried to hit military targets in these 15 Indian cities, New Delhi thwarts strikes
During Monday's trial proceedings, including jury selection, prosecutors voiced concerns that Victim-3, who resides outside of New York City where the case is being tried, has gone cold. They told the court that both the woman and her attorney have been difficult to reach, and there's a strong possibility she 'may not show up.'
Also read:
Sean Diddy Combs's trial begins; these are the A-list celebrities who may be called as witnesses
Continue to video
5
5
Next
Stay
Playback speed
1x Normal
Back
0.25x
0.5x
1x Normal
1.5x
2x
5
5
/
Skip
Ads by
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Dog licks arent kisses. Heres what your dog really means when it licks you.
Novelodge
Undo
This revelation could undermine part of the prosecution's case against Diddy, who is facing serious charges including sex trafficking, racketeering conspiracy, and transportation to engage in prostitution.
While Victim-3 had previously agreed to testify—reportedly waiving her right to use a pseudonym—her sudden change in stance could jeopardize the depth of the government's argument, especially during the second phase of the trial where her testimony was expected to play a more significant role.
Live Events
Opening arguments to proceed without Victim-3's storyline
Prosecutors clarified that Victim-3's testimony won't be mentioned in detail during opening statements scheduled for May 12. They plan to refer to her only in general terms as one of several alleged victims connected to Diddy's criminal indictment.
Diddy's legal team pushed for clarity, requesting prosecutors provide a final decision regarding her appearance by the end of the week. Judge Arun Subramanian backed the request, pressing prosecutors to exhaust all avenues to ensure her presence.
Also read:
Sean 'Diddy' Combs' says he's 'a little nervous' as sex trafficking trial gets underway
This situation adds another layer of tension to an already explosive case involving one of the biggest hip-hop moguls in the U.S. legal spotlight.
Cassie expected to testify despite defense pushback
Meanwhile, Cassie Ventura, long identified as Victim-1 in the indictment, is expected to testify in person. Cassie, who previously filed and settled a civil suit against Diddy in 2023, is anticipated to speak openly without concealing her identity.
Her lawsuit marked the beginning of a wave of additional civil allegations against Combs, though he denied all claims. Despite her prior settlement, her testimony remains central to the prosecution's narrative.
Earlier, Cassie's lawyer attempted to quash a subpoena from Diddy's defense team, which sought access to her private writings, financial records, and manuscripts. The court ruled she could retain her financial documents but must surrender her personal writings.
Cassie surveillance footage cleared for use in court
The trial has also been shaped by the controversial surveillance video that emerged after the civil suit. The video, reportedly showing Diddy assaulting Cassie in a hotel hallway, was released by CNN after the lawsuit settlement.
Also read:
From mogul to defendant: Sean 'Diddy' Combs trial to begin today, faces life in prison
While Diddy issued a vague statement taking 'responsibility' at the time of its release, his attorneys now argue that the footage was 'altered, manipulated, sped-up, and edited to be out of sequence.' CNN firmly denies any tampering.
Despite the defense's attempt to suppress the video, Judge Subramanian ruled it admissible. The footage will be shown to the jury, potentially bolstering the credibility of Cassie's account when she takes the stand.
Diddy maintains innocence amid growing legal pressure
Sean Combs has pleaded not guilty to all federal charges and denies all allegations brought in civil or criminal court. His attorneys have reiterated his innocence, claiming that the mounting accusations are part of a broader attempt to tarnish his legacy.
As the trial continues, the absence of Victim-3 may present a hurdle for the prosecution. However, testimonies from other key witnesses—including Cassie—and admissible video evidence could still pose significant legal risks for the music mogul.