Pakistan-India: Viewers Slam Piers Morgan's India-Pakistan Special as Chaotic and Lacking Substance
Piers Morgan host of Piers Morgan Uncensored has once again garnered attention on social media over his handling of a high-stakes debate between Indian and Pakistani guests on the ongoing military standoff and ceasefire between the two nuclear-armed neighbours.
The episode, which featured Pakistan's former Foreign Minister Hina Rabbani Khar, Pakistani podcaster Shehzad Ghias Shaikh, Indian journalist Barkha Dutt, and Indian influencer Ranveer Allahbadia (aka BeerBiceps), was billed as a balanced discussion on regional tensions.
However, critics across platforms accused the show of poor moderation, nationalist bias, and devolving into theatrics.
Talk show-turned-shouting Match?
Commenters on YouTube, X (formerly Twitter), and Reddit were quick to criticise the episode's chaotic format.
Indeed quite poorly moderated and missing struture. More sort of chitchat like desi talk shows. Didn't understand what this @BeerBicepsGuy was doing here! Has nothing to do with this sort of discussion and in presence of serious and sober ppl.
— Sheroff Shafi (@Sheroff_Shafi) May 13, 2025
That debate was a mess
Ranveer sounded drunk, Barkha acted like a soap star, and Piers thought he was Churchill.
Pakistan didn't even need to try. 😂 — Stealth Falconer (@Stealthfalconer) May 13, 2025
Morgan, known for combative hosting, was criticised for failing to challenge inflammatory claims made by the Indian guests. Allahbadia accused Pakistan of exporting terrorism and used visual props during his remarks, drawing online criticism for lacking evidence or diplomatic nuance.
Dutt, previously viewed as a critic of India's ruling establishment, also adopted a confrontational tone. Pakistani guests Khar and Shaikh attempted to focus on international law and the risks of escalation, but were repeatedly interrupted or sidelined.
The episode's chaotic structure drew comparisons to regional talk shows, with many viewers describing it as a missed opportunity for constructive dialogue.
Social media reactions also noted the absence of meaningful moderation or accountability for unsubstantiated claims.
Despite the panel's intention to analyse the ceasefire and diplomatic fallout, the conversation quickly descended into a loud exchange of accusations and political messaging.
Analysts said the format reinforced nationalist narratives and failed to provide clarity on the conflict's core issues.
The segment has prompted renewed scrutiny of Western media's approach to South Asian conflicts and the risks of platforming divisive voices without adequate editorial control.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Bilawal urges India to end ‘excuses', resume dialogue with Pakistan
Former foreign minister Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari on Saturday urged India to move beyond what he termed 'repetitive excuses' and engage in meaningful dialogue with Pakistan to address long-standing bilateral issues. Speaking at a press conference in Washington following a series of meetings with US lawmakers, policy experts and think tanks, the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) chairman criticized New Delhi's reluctance to resume talks, saying it was counterproductive to regional peace. 'India continues to evade efforts for dialogue and investigations. The excuses vary, be it civil-military dynamics, geopolitics, or blanket narratives linking Muslims with terrorism, but they all serve the same purpose: avoidance,' Bilawal said. Bilawal Bhutto warns of escalating water disputes with India, calls for diplomatic engagement 'It's not sustainable for two nuclear-armed neighbours with such low conflict thresholds to lack any structured dispute resolution mechanism.' The former foreign minister is part of a high-level Pakistani delegation currently visiting key Western capitals as part of a diplomatic outreach initiative aimed at presenting Islamabad's stance on recent tensions with India. The delegation, which includes senior political figures and former diplomats, will also visit London and Brussels in the coming days. Alongside Bilawal, the group includes former foreign ministers Hina Rabbani Khar and Khurram Dastgir Khan, Senators Sherry Rehman, Musadik Malik, Faisal Sabzwari and Bushra Anjum Butt, as well as seasoned diplomats Jalil Abbas Jilani and Tehmina Janjua. Bilawal emphasized that Pakistan's civil and military leadership are united in their stance against terrorism, and that dialogue with India is essential for regional stability. He reiterated Islamabad's openness to talks at both political and military levels. 'If India truly seeks peace, it must be willing to engage, whether through direct talks or through mediation by international stakeholders,' he said. 'Unfortunately, New Delhi has rejected all options, be it engagement through the UN, third-party mediation, or bilateral diplomacy.' He further stressed that reversing decisions that have escalated tensions would be a constructive step forward. 'It is in everyone's interest, including India's, to revisit policies that have only led to a diplomatic freeze and increased hostility.' The Pakistani delegation's engagement in Washington is seen as part of a broader attempt to counter India's expanding diplomatic footprint and narrative, particularly in Western capitals.
Express Tribune
4 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Ceasefire but no peace: Bilawal warns of ‘less safe' South Asia despite Trump-led de-escalation
Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, former Foreign Minister of Pakistan and current head of the Pakistan People's Party, leads a delegation to Washington, which played a key mediatory role in a ceasefire after Pakistan's conflict with India in May. Photo: AFP Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari has warned that South Asia remains at risk of a full-scale war despite a US-brokered ceasefire between India and Pakistan, calling for sustained diplomatic efforts and international engagement to avoid further escalation. Speaking to US news network Newsmax, Bilawal said a ceasefire between the two nuclear-armed neighbours had been achieved in May with the help of former US president Donald Trump and his team, but cautioned that peace remained fragile. 'At the moment we have achieved ceasefire between India and Pakistan, thanks to the role played by President Trump, his team, Secretary Rubio, and that's a big achievement. The US deserves credit for that,' he said. 'But... we have achieved ceasefire, we haven't achieved peace and we are actually in a situation in South Asia right now where we [are] less safe than we were before this conflict.' Bilawal, who also chairs Pakistan's Parliamentary Diplomatic Committee, warned that the threshold for war between the two rivals had dangerously decreased, particularly in the event of a cross-border terrorist attack. 'If there [is] any terrorist attack in India or anywhere in Indian Illegally Occupied Jammu and Kashmir (IIOJK), it means war between India and Pakistan and that's not sustainable,' he said. Tensions between the two countries escalated last month following a deadly attack in Pahalgam, IIOJK, in which 26 Indian tourists were killed. On May 7, India launched airstrikes on Pakistani soil, prompting Islamabad to respond with Operation Bunyanum Marsoos. A US-brokered ceasefire was reached on May 10, halting further military action. Bilawal said Pakistan's agreement to the ceasefire had come after consultations with Washington and should be seen as the beginning of a broader peace process. 'We did so while communicating with the United States and we will communicate that this would just be the start,' he said, calling for dialogue at a neutral venue.'We work towards permanent peace through dialogue and diplomacy... we should discuss all friction points with India.' While expressing confidence in the current US leadership's willingness to support regional stability, Bilawal also voiced concern that the Indian government could sabotage mediation efforts. 'I also suspect that Indian government will try and sabotage the President's efforts,' he said. 'Just like President Trump played a role in achieving this ceasefire, we will be looking to the US to encourage their friend and ally India to have a dialogue with Pakistan.' Praising Trump's influence, Bilawal said the former president had the trust of both countries and could help bring them back to the negotiating table. 'I think President Trump is the one man at the moment who can bring about peace between India and Pakistan,' he said. 'I think his stature, his leadership qualities and his vision supports peace... he is friends with Pakistan, he is friends with India so he can talk to both of us as friends and try and convince [us] to get along.' He reiterated that Kashmir remained a core issue in any future dialogue. 'We have to discuss Kashmir as a root issue... because if [we] keep ignoring Kashmir, they will keep producing the cannon forger for terrorists to use in such events.' He said Pakistan was willing to engage on counterterrorism and recalled previous US-Pakistan cooperation in that domain. 'We had done a great job while working with them. The one country that US President thank[ed]... after he was elected President was Pakistan for our cooperation.' Bilawal also accused India of 'weaponising water' by threatening to cut off water supplies to Pakistan — an action he said violated international norms. 'We are really looking to the international community to add their voice to ours in condemning India's decision to cut off our water,' he said. On trade, Bilawal said talks with US officials had shifted from traditional security concerns to economic cooperation. 'We are actually sitting with Americans talking about trade rather than terrorism, war and other things,' he said, noting particular interest in agriculture and mineral investment. However, he cautioned that peace was a prerequisite for foreign investment. 'If we have peace in the region then business is gonna progress,' he said. 'If the aggression [is] gonna continue, if they [are] gonna continue [to] support terrorist proxies in Balochistan... then it's not gonna create an environment that's conducive even if our trade talks go well,' he added.
Express Tribune
6 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Bakhtawar Bhutto shares Eidul Azha family photos with sacrificial lambs
Listen to article Bakhtawar Bhutto-Zardari, the eldest daughter of Benazir Bhutto and President Asif Ali Zardari, marked Eidul Azha by sharing family photographs that quickly went viral on social media. Posting on Instagram, Bakhtawar shared a series of festive images alongside her husband, Mahmood Chaudhry, their three sons, and two sacrificial lambs, extending Eid greetings to her followers. In the photos, she is seen wearing a light brown outfit, while her husband and sons twinned in traditional white shalwar kameez paired with black waistcoats. The pictures also featured two prominently displayed lambs, indicating that the family performed Eidul Azha's traditional animal sacrifice. Bakhtawar married Mahmood Chaudhry, a Dubai-based businessman of Pakistani origin, on January 29, 2021. The couple now has three sons: Mir Hakim, Mir Sujawal, and the youngest, Mir Zulfiqar.
