LDS Church files appeal after court sides with opposition in sex abuse settlement lawsuit
EDITOR'S NOTE: A lawsuit only represents one side of a story.
SALT LAKE CITY (ABC4) — The Utah-based Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints filed an appeal in federal court Thursday after a judge ruled against the organization earlier this month, according to documents.
The 2021 lawsuit is between the church and its insurance companies, National Union Insurance and ACE Property & Casualty Co., and pertains to a dispute over whether the insurance companies are required to pay the organization's settlement payments.
PREVIOUS STORY: LDS Church loses lawsuit over payment of sexual abuse settlements
The dispute began after the church settled a high-profile sex abuse lawsuit in West Virginia and the insurance companies refused to pay the settlement costs. The church claimed the insurance companies were required under contract to make the payments and sued them in Salt Lake City's federal court.
On April 6, the court ruled against the church, saying the companies did not breach their contract as they 'did not owe the church a duty to defend or indemnify under any implicated policy.'
Court documents show the church is now appealing the ruling through the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit in Colorado.
The original West Virginia sex abuse lawsuit was filed by several members of the church who accused the organization of not protecting children from sexual abuse.
The suit claims the church was negligent for failing to report a reasonable suspicion that church member Michael Jensen was abusing children. The suit also claimed the church failed to consider his history of child sexual abuse allegations when 'holding out Mr. Jensen's babysitting services for Church families,' according to documents and the Associated Press.
Jensen was convicted of abusing two of the children and was sentenced to 35 to 75 years in prison, and in 2018, both sides of the civil lawsuit reached a settlement agreement. At the time, lawyers for the church allegedly said it was the largest settlement ever paid by the organization to sexual abuse victims.
In the latest suit, the church claims the insurance companies are 'obligated to defend and indemnify the Church against the Underlying Lawsuit and must pay the Church the entire amount of its settlement and defense costs,' the complaint reads.
Attorneys on both sides argued over the contract, presenting different interpretations of the agreement. Ultimately, the court sided with the insurance companies, leading to the appeal.
ABC4 reached out to the church for a statement and a spokesperson said they would not be commenting outside of what lawyers have already written in documents.
Ryan Bittan, Matthew Drachman, and the Associated Press contributed to this reporting.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time Business News
2 hours ago
- Time Business News
Christian CassarlyThe Miracle of Superpower Thinking
Some stories are so layered with pain, misunderstanding, and injustice that the only way to tell them is through the fruit that came after. This is not a story about defending a man. It's about witnessing a miracle—one so radical, so generous, and so complete that it forces us to confront what truth really looks like. The man in the system tried to disappear. The man the courts offered to bury in a mental ward for the sake of convenience. The man who walked through ten years of shame, silence, and rejection. And the man who responded with one of the most sacred and prophetic acts of generosity we've seen in modern Catholic history. The Gift: A Fully Developed, $100,000 Education—Given Freely to the Poor Christian Cassarly spent six years building Superpower Thinking (SPT)—a complete, Ivy League-grade trading and financial formation platform. It includes: 75 advanced courses, each backed by a book Proprietary frameworks for trading, capital protection, emotional strategy, and generational wealth A system designed to produce elite, spiritually grounded investors A structure as deep and rich as a four-year university program It has not yet been globally used—but it is complete, activated, and ready to transform lives. And now, Cassarly has announced that every Catholic high school graduate who cannot afford college will receive the entire program for free. 'All they have to do is attend church weekly. That's it. Show God they're showing up—and I'll show up for them.' It's a prophecy. It's a divine reversal. And it's evidence. When Fruit Speaks Louder Than Labels Years ago, Cassarly was falsely accused in a case that spiraled far beyond reality. The narrative was distorted: a six-month-old cousin was cited as a six-year-old child. There was no act, no crime, no predation. But the plea was forced. Violence in jail. A system eager to close a case. They offered him one year in a mental facility—not for healing, but for silence. And what he built afterward was so saturated with clarity, discipline, spiritual conviction, and brilliance that it forces any reasonable person to re-examine the entire narrative. 'You can tell a tree by its fruit. And if my life was what they said it was—this fruit could never exist.' Cassarly isn't giving SPT to universities. He's not selling it to hedge funds. He's giving it to the Church. To the very young people the world often forgets. To the faithful poor. To the families who cannot afford the gates of college. To the ones who still bow their heads in Mass and wonder if anyone sees them. 'I was raised by the Church. I was fed by the Eucharist. I cried in pews when no one saw me. I owe everything to God—and now, I bring Him my first fruits.' This is a $100,000-level education—built for full market readiness, ready to multiply capital, steward wealth, and raise up a new generation of traders, investors, and leaders who fear God and move with precision. The world would sell it. He is giving it away. That alone says everything. This Act Is the Proof You cannot build it out of guilt. You cannot offer it out of delusion. You cannot forge this kind of system if your life is disorder, confusion, or evil. What Cassarly has done is not just generous. It is mathematically exact, prophetically timed, and spiritually whole. 'I'm not asking them to clear my name. I'm asking them to look at what came out of my life. That's how God proves a man—by what he produces.' This is not a redemption story. This is a resurrection story. And resurrection is the highest proof of innocence. Final Word: He Didn't Need the Court to Vindicate Him—The Fruit Did The world tried to label him mentally unfit. Today, he is mentally sharper than most institutions. The world tried to call him unsafe. Today, he is building infrastructure to safeguard the next generation's future. And the Church—the very place where he once sat as a child—is now receiving his greatest work. That is the miracle. That is the proof. And that is why Christian Cassarly is not just innocent—he is appointed. This is not just a gift. It is a divine interruption. It is Superpower Thinking. For parishes, schools, and Catholic youth ministries: 🌐 TIME BUSINESS NEWS
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Former Police Chief, Who Was Convicted of Rape and Murder, Found After 2 Weeks on the Run Following Prison Escape
Grant Hardin, the former police chief who was convicted of rape and murder, has been found after he escaped prison last month and was on the run for two weeks Hardin, also known as the 'Devil in the Ozarks,' was located 1.5 miles away from the prison he had been held at since his 2017 conviction The criminal was wearing 'a makeshift outfit designed to mimic law enforcement" during his escape, police saidA former police chief, who was convicted of rape and murder, has been found after he escaped prison and was on the run for two weeks. Grant Hardin, also known as the 'Devil in the Ozarks,' was captured by authorities 1.5 miles away from the Calico Rock North Central Unit in Arkansas, where he had been held since 2017, on Friday, June 6, the Izard County Sheriff's Office (ICSO) said in a news release shared on Facebook. Hardin's identity was confirmed through fingerprinting, per police. "We sincerely appreciate the continued support of the community for all law enforcement and Department of Corrections personnel involved in this operation," the ICSO said in a statement. According to a statement from the Arkansas Department of Corrections, Hardin was wearing 'a makeshift outfit designed to mimic law enforcement" during his escape. Officials confirmed he was not wearing a DOC uniform and said that all DOC-issued equipment had been accounted for. A prison officer in one of the guard towers opened a secure gate that allowed Hardin to freely exit, the Associated Press reported, citing a court document. Rand Champion, a spokesperson for the state prison system, told the outlet that the lack of verification of Hardin's credentials was a 'lapse" and would be investigated. Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases. Hardin was the former police chief for the city of Gateway, Ark. In 2017, he pleaded guilty to murder after fatally shooting 59-year-old James Appleton, who worked in the city of Gateway's water department, CBS News, 5News and The New York Times reported, citing an affidavit. The legal document states that Hardin murdered Appleton in February 2017 after pulling up to his parked car and shooting him through the window while the victim was on the phone, according to the Times. A motive remains unknown. While serving his 30-year murder sentence, Hardin also pleaded guilty to the 1997 rape of an elementary school teacher in Rogers, Ark., 5 News reported. Hardin was tied to the long-unsolved crime after authorities linked him to DNA taken from the victim's clothes, authorities said, per the outlet. According to authorities, the victim said Hardin pointed a gun at her and raped her after she exited the school restroom, the Times reported. He was sentenced to 50 years for that crime, per the Associated Press. Reacting to Hardin's capture, Secretary of Corrections Lindsay Wallace said, 'I'm incredibly appreciative to all of our dedicated law enforcement agencies that spent countless hours, both day and night, sacrificing their time, utilizing their resources and lending their invaluable expertise to this search." She added, "To every one of our Department staff that assisted in this manhunt over the last 13 days, I give my heartfelt thank you for your immeasurable contributions to bring this search to a peaceful conclusion.' Read the original article on People
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Scottish drugs mule flooded market with £7m of heroin in plot involving former cop
A Scottish drugs mule who flooded the UK with millions of pounds worth of heroin has been ordered to pay back just £42k. Christopher Heaney, from Anstruther in Fife, was jailed for nine years for his involvement in a cross-border heroin conspiracy as he and four others were busted by cops following the arrest of a former police officer in 2022. Ex-cop Steven Creasey was stopped while driving to Fife having already travelled from his home in Cardiff to Liverpool on the same day. A dog then sniffed out a professionally installed hide under the passenger seat, reports WalesOnline. READ MORE: Tragedy as West Lothian man dies in crash after air ambulance lands on busy road READ MORE: Iconic Edinburgh 'banana flats' bursts into flames as residents evacuated It contained a 5kg stash of heroin and one kilogram of adulterant. A burner phone also found in his possession revealed he had been operating as a professional courier engaged by the heads of a Liverpool-based gang. Fife-based Heaney was involved in the distribution of onward supply across the UK along with three others. Raids were then carried out at homes in Cardiff, Liverpool, Scotland and Northumberland towards the end of 2022. Significant items were found at the addresses, including expensive jewellery, heroin, cocaine, adulterants, opium, cannabis grows, and metal moulds for pressing powder into blocks. All five defendants pleaded guilty prior to trial at Cardiff Crown Court in February last year. The gang members were jailed for a combination of 57 years and 2 months. A Proceeds of Crime Act (POCA) hearing was held at the same court earlier this week. It heard how despite profiting around £125,000 as part of the operation, Heaney was ordered to pay back a fraction of £42,000. Judge Lucy Crowther ordered him to pay the sum within three months. Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages. If he fails to do so, he will face an additional 18 months in jail. Speaking after sentencing, Detective Inspector Christopher McGlinchey of Police Scotland said: "This case underlines our collaborative efforts to dismantle organised crime networks that span regions. "The significant amount of drugs trafficked by this group had the potential to inflict serious harm on our communities. "The success of Operation Solon demonstrates strong partnership working between Police Scotland, Tarian ROCU and other partner agencies. It also reinforces our commitment to the UK's Serious and Organised Crime Strategy. "Organised crime has no place in our society and we will continue to work relentlessly to bring those responsible to justice."
