Supermarket own-brand ketchup crowned better than Heinz in taste test – plus it's a third cheaper too
Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
HEINZ Ketchup is a classic for BBQs, picnics and summer parties - and it's rare to find anything just as good.
But consumer site Which? has conducted a new taste test comparing the classic brand with supermarket own brand ketchups - and it's found a bargain alternative.
Sign up for Scottish Sun
newsletter
Sign up
1
Which? tested eight supermarket own-brand ketchups versus Heinz and Hellmann's
Asda's Classic Tomato Ketchup matched Heinz in the blind taste test, with both achieving an impressive score of 77%.
At £1 for a 550g pack, it's a budget-friendly option. This works out at 18p per 100g.
Meanwhile Heinz Tomato Ketchup comes with a higher price tag of £3 for a 460g pack (or 65p per 100g).
By choosing Asda's version, you'll enjoy a ketchup rated just as delicious, but at less than a third of the cost.
The majority of testers said the Asda ketchup had well-balanced tanginess, sweetness and strength of flavour.
It also contains less salt and sugar than Heinz ketchup.
However, testers praised Heinz for being one of the most visually appealing ketchups, while also scoring highly for its texture and flavour.
As the priciest ketchup in the test, it's worth keeping an eye out for supermarket deals if you're a fan, making it a good idea to stock up when it's on offer.
The panel of 72 testers also sampled seven other supermarket own-label ketchups, along with Hellmann's.
Other supermarket versions that scored highly were Waitrose's Essential Tomato Ketchup and Aldi's Branwells Tomato Ketchup.
My kid's obsessed with Heinz ketchup but can't tell difference with £1 version
The Waitrose condiment scored 75% and testers said they loved its flavour and thickness.
It's 95p for a 470g bottle, or 20p per 100g.
Aldi's version is one of the cheapest options and scored a very reasonable 73%.
A bottle will cost you 85p for 550g, which works out at 16p per 100g.
The testers thought it had great texture and thickness, but not everyone liked the taste - only around half of people were satisfied with its sweetness and strength of flavour.
The full list of scores
HERE'S how each ketchup scored: Asda Classic Tomato Ketchup (£1 for a 550g pack) and Heinz Tomato Ketchup (£3 for a 460g pack) - 77% Waitrose Essential Tomato Ketchup (95p for a 470g bottle) - 75% Aldi Branwells Tomato Ketchup (85p for 550g) - 73% Co-op Tomato Ketchup – (£1.25 for 550g) - 72% Sainsbury's Tomato Ketchup (90p for 460g) – 71% Tesco Tomato Ketchup (£1 for 555g)) – 71% Hellmann's Tomato Ketchup (£2.15 for 473g) – 70% Lidl Batts Tomato Ketchup (89p for 560g) – 68% M&S Tomato Ketchup (£1 for 495g) – 61%
Most of the other supermarket ketchups scored similarly - but the M&S one fell behind.
Hellmann's ketchup came out as fairly average despite being one of the most expensive at £2.15 for a 473g bottle.
Jessica Carson, Which? food and health editor, said: "The perfect tangy flavour boost on chips, burgers, bacon sandwiches and so much more, it isn't hard to see why tomato ketchup is one of the nation's favourite condiments.
"The good news is that rather than forking out for the big brand version, you can get a tasty supermarket alternative for a third of the price."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
19 hours ago
- BBC News
Shopper from Cornwall told to return items to China for refund
A shopper has described her "shocking experience" with an online clothing company after she said she was told she would need to post return items to Griffiths, from Newquay, Cornwall, ordered what was listed as a "stylish khaki jumpsuit" from Mova London but instead a cream two piece requested a full refund but she said she was told by the firm she had to send the items to China, which would have cost more than she paid for them. Despite its name, she questioned whether the firm was based in the London said it "understands there has been some concern regarding the order" but it did not respond to questions about its return policy or whether it was UK-based. Ms Griffiths, who believed she was ordering from a firm based in the UK, said she was told her items were being shipped from China when they failed to arrive within five the items arrived three weeks later, she said the items were "not khaki but cream", while the material was "flimsy" and the "fit was wrong".She said she asked to return the items, but was told she could keep them and have anything from between 10%-40% experience left her feeling "conned", she said. Kat Cereda, from Which?, said more shoppers were being misled by websites that appear to be UK-based."They sell items that generally disappoint and are extremely hard to get a refund from," she Griffiths used charge back through her bank and received a full London said it considered the case to be closed "as the matter has already been addressed through the appropriate channels and resolved via the customer's bank".
The Guardian
3 days ago
- The Guardian
US workers say Trump's immigration crackdown is causing labor shortages: ‘A strain on everybody'
Donald Trump's crackdown on immigration is piling pressure on US factories, according to employees and union leaders, as veteran workers from overseas are forced to leave their jobs. As economists warn the administration's full-scale deportation ambitions could ultimately cost millions of jobs, workers at two sites – in Michigan and Kentucky – told the Guardian that industrial giants are grappling with labor shortages. The US president has moved to strip more than a million immigrants of their legal status in the US, including by shutting down the Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans, Venezuelans (CHNV) Parole Program, which allowed hundreds of thousands to work legally in the country. It has meanwhile ramped up immigration arrest operations with prospective daily quotas of 3,000 arrests per day. Such moves have piled pressure on industries across the US economy – including the food, hospitality, construction, transportation and care sectors – which rely on large numbers of migrants to do essential work. At a GE Appliances plant in Louisville, Kentucky, more than 125 workers were abruptly forced out of their jobs in the spring due to programs cancelled as part of Trump's immigration crackdown, according to an employee. GE Appliances makes home appliances including refrigerators, microwaves and dishwashers. 'In three different buildings, on a couple of different shifts, stewards reported that they lost production so they weren't able to make all the products they were supposed to make,' said Jess Reese, a replacement operator at the plant and organizer for IUE-CWA Local 83761. 'It was hard to cover certain job tasks on the assembly line, and so that created chaos, and it was just hard to get things done.' Reese expressed concern about the threat of more workers being forced out. Trump's efforts to revoke protected status could impact an additional 200 union members next February, she said. 'Hundreds of workers kind of disappearing at the drop of a hat is no joke, as we've seen with the last wave of mass terminations.' A spokesperson for GE Appliances said: 'We added additional staffing where needed and continue to follow the law.' At a Kraft-Heinz plant in Holland, Michigan, meanwhile, workers are said to have been mandated to work overtime. The firm is one of the largest food and beverage companies in the world, behind brands including Philadelphia cream cheese and Jell-O deserts. 'We had people there for 20 years, and all of a sudden they get notification their immigration authorization is revoked,' Tomas Torres, a maintenance mechanic of 13 years, and president of RWDSU Local 705. 'And they can't be there anymore, and that just puts a strain on everybody,. 'The lack of people on the lines. There are employees running two machines; it should be one person per machine. Manager and supervisors are all stressed out, and cancelling vacations for people because they don't have enough to run the machines.' Torres has been working 12- to 14-hour days, he said: part of a first shift, all of a second shift, and part of a third shift. 'I'm tired. And you catch people falling asleep on the line, and it's a big safety issue,' he added. 'All of this that has happened has affected everybody at the plant. It's crazy, because I hear people complain every single day.' Kraft Heinz refuted the plant is experiencing labor shortages due to immigration policy changes, but did not say how many workers were lost at the plant due to the changes. 'Kraft Heinz has strict work authorization verification processes that comply with all applicable laws and regulations,' said the firm in a statement. 'Overtime is driven by the needs of the business, and we are currently in one of our busiest seasons of the year.' As Trump's officials press ahead, economists have warned that deporting millions of immigrants from the US could have drastic consequences. The Economic Policy Institute estimated this month that 4 million deportations would result in the loss of 3.3 million jobs held by immigrants in the US and 2.6 million US-born employees, hitting industries including construction and childcare. The American Enterprise Institute, a conservative thinktank, meanwhile found that Trump's immigration policies would likely lead to a negative net migration into the US for the first time in decades and result in a decrease in US gross domestic product of between 0.3% and 0.4%, or $70.5bn to $94bn in economic output, annually. 'One day they are there,' said Maria Jose Padmore, a human services assistant for Fairfax County in Virginia. 'And the next day, I'm looking for my coworker, and he's gone because their Temporary Protected Status expired. 'Forget about the fact that I now have to share my coworkers' job. Let's think about my coworkers' family: how are they going to put food on their table?' Padmore was speaking at a panel on how Trump's immigration polices are affecting workers, organized by the AFL-CIO in Washington DC this month. Gwen Mills, President of Unite Here, the largest hospitality union in the US, said they were 'wreaking havoc across the families of our coworkers and in our communities'. 'Oftentimes within the labor movement, we find ourselves divided by industries,' said Jimmy Williams, president of the International Union of Painters and Allied Trades, which represents construction workers. 'When it comes to immigration, it's gotta be the one single thing that puts a thread between a hotel worker, a construction worker, a service worker, a public employee, a teacher. This is something that affects every single working person in this country.' The Trump administration alleges that CHNV and other temporary protected status programs were abused, a claim challenged by groups such as Refugees International. 'There is no shortage of American minds and hands to grow our labor force, and President Trump's agenda to create jobs for American workers represents this Administration's commitment to capitalizing on that untapped potential while delivering on our mandate to enforce our immigration laws,' said Abigail Jackson, White House spokesperson. But its policies are already causing apprehension on the factory floor. 'This has a real impact on immigrant workers, obviously, but it also has a real impact on non immigrant workers,' Reese, at the GE Appliances plant in Louisville, said. 'It's really important that we stick together, because we all want the same things. 'We want safe workplaces. We want good wages. We all want to go home to our family in one piece. We want to live in a safe place. We want to be free. These are things we all share, and we're only going to get that stuff if we stick together.'
Daily Mail
6 days ago
- Daily Mail
You're doing your supermarket shop wrong! Experts reveal why you should NEVER buy items at eye-level
It's a weekly chore that many people dread. And now it turns out you've probably been doing your supermarket shop wrong. Experts from Which? have revealed why you should never buy items at eye-level. While these items might look tempting, they're probably a lot more expensive than products stored at less accessible heights. If you really want to bag a bargain, it's best to cast your eyes downwards, according to Which?. 'The most expensive brands are often at eye level, while cheaper products tend to be on the bottom shelves,' the consumer champion explained. 'For example, PG Tips (£2.98 for an 80-pack) commandeered the top three shelves in Asda's tea aisle, while its own-label tea bags sat on the bottom shelves (£2 for an 80-pack). 'And branded doesn't necessarily mean better – Asda's Everyday Tea Bags beat the big-name brands' tea bags in our blind taste test.' Supermarkets use a range of sneaky tactics to try to force shoppers to part with their cash. One of the most manipulative measures is the strategic arrangement of items on supermarket shelves - also known as the 'planogram'. 'A planogram is defined as a 'diagram or model that indicates the placement of retail products on shelves in order to maximise sales',' explained Professor Graham Kendall, Professor of Operations Research at the University of Nottingham in an article for The Conversation. One phrase commonly used within planograms is 'eye level is buy level', according to Professor Kendall. 'Products positioned at eye level are likely to sell better,' he explained. 'You may find that the more expensive options are at eye level or just below, while the store's own brands are placed higher or lower on the shelves. 'Next time you are in a supermarket, just keep note of how many times you need to bend down, or stretch, to reach something you need. You might be surprised.' Beyond the planogram, the location of items in an aisle is also important. 'There is a school of thought that goods placed at the start of an aisle do not sell as well,' Professor Kendall added. 'A customer needs time to adjust to being in the aisle, so it takes a little time before they can decide what to buy.' If you want to avoid getting suckered in by these tactics, the best thing to do is write a shopping list and stick to it, according to Which?. 'Supermarkets use other tactics to encourage us to spend more, too, such as stocking essential items such as milk and eggs at the back of the store and far away from each other,' the consumer champion added. 'Then they stop us in our tracks with brightly coloured signs, end-of-aisle displays and eye-catching special and seasonal offers. 'Avoid being sucked in by writing a shopping list and sticking to it.'
