Two firms found guilty of Rs1.13bn anti-competitive pact in pharmaceutical sector
The CCP imposed a total penalty of Rs42 million on UDPL and IBL for entering into and giving effect to the non-compete agreement that the commission said had violated Section 4 of the Competition Act, 2010.
'In a detailed order, the commission found both companies guilty of entering into a restrictive agreement that prevented UDPL from entering the distribution market of human pharmaceutical products in Pakistan for three years.
CCP clears 40.63% share acquisition of Mitchell's Fruit Farms by CCL Holding
In return, IBL paid Rs1.131 billion to UDPL as compensation—an arrangement disclosed by UDPL to the Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) without prior regulatory approval,' the CCP statement read.
The CCP said the agreement had constituted an illegal market-sharing arrangement that foreclosed competition and had been executed in clear contravention of the law.
'The intention was to establish a protective barrier around IBL's operations, secured through a compensation of Rs1.131 billion, in exchange for UDPL to abstain from market participation,' the order noted, adding that such conduct undermined competitive dynamics and harms consumers.
While the agreement included a clause stating that regulatory exemption would be sought from CCP, the parties 'failed to do so until after the show-cause notices were issued in June 2024'.
'The commission found this post-facto action insufficient to cure the violation.'
As a result, the CCP imposed a penalty of Rs20 million each on UDPL and IBL for violating Section 4(1) and 4(2)(b) of the Act. An additional penalty of Rs1 million was levied on UDPL under Section 38 for making disclosures to PSX without regulatory clearance.
CCP grants exemptions to logistics and transport sector
The order also directed the companies to submit a compliance report within 30 days and warns of additional daily penalties for continued non-compliance.
Furthermore, the CCP referred the matter to the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) and the PSX for any further action deemed necessary under their respective legal frameworks.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
CCP imposes Rs1 billion in penalties on cartels, deceptive advertisers during FY2024-25
The Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) issued 12 major orders during FY 2024-25, imposing penalties worth Rs1.007 billion on businesses involved in anti-competitive practices across key sectors including fertilisers, poultry, automobiles, pharmaceuticals, real estate, food, hygiene products, paints, and education, a CCP statement said on Monday. 'The commission has strengthened its enforcement arm and streamlined hearings by curbing unnecessary delays. This fast-track approach is helping CCP resolve cases swiftly and enforce the law more effectively,' the statement read. Out of the 12 orders issued, eight were related to deceptive marketing, it added. As per the details, three orders involved cartelisation and price fixing. One order was issued on the direction of the Lahore High Court to address the issue of CCP's jurisdiction in a case involving the deceptive and fraudulent use of a trademark under Section 10(2) of the Competition Act. Notices issued to sugar mills for rehearing in cartelisation case Moreover, CCP fined six urea manufacturers and their trade group—Fertilizer Manufacturers of Pakistan Advisory Council (FMPAC)—a total of Rs375 million for price-fixing. Each company was fined Rs50 million; the association was fined Rs75 million. Another major penalty of Rs155 million was slapped on eight poultry hatcheries for fixing prices of day-old broiler chicks. In deceptive marketing cases, Kingdom Valley was fined Rs150 million for false claims about its housing project. Unilever and Friesland Campina Engro were fined Rs75 million each for marketing frozen desserts as ice cream. Unilever also faced an additional Rs60 million penalty for deceptive ads for Lifebuoy products, CCP said. Al-Ghazi Tractors was fined Rs40 million for false fuel efficiency claims. Hyundai Nishat Motors received a Rs25 million fine for misleading ads about the Hyundai Tucson SUV. Deceptive marketing practices: CAT upholds CCP findings against marketers of PREMA Milk 3N Lifemed Pharmaceuticals was fined Rs20 million for using fake certification for dialysis machines. The fine was later reduced to Rs2 million by the Competition Appellate Tribunal (CAT). British Lyceum and Diamond Paints were fined Rs5 million each for publishing misleading advertisements. 'Cartelisation is a serious offence and will not be tolerated,' warned CCP Chairman Dr Kabir Sidhu. 'Cartels harm economic growth, violate consumer rights, and deter new investment,' he was quoted as saying in the CCP statement. He further emphasised that association platforms must not be used for 'price collusion or to facilitate market abuse', which leads to the exploitation of the entire nation.
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
PM paints bright picture of ‘economic rescue'
ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Saturday credited his government's effective measures for stabilising the economy, citing a sharp fall in inflation and interest rates, as well as a crucial agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) that helped Pakistan avert default. Speaking to students of the Uraan Pakistan Summer Scholars Internship Programme, Sharif painted a picture of economic rescue under his leadership, claiming the country had dodged financial collapse through team work and tough reforms. 'When we took over, inflation was exploding at 38% and the policy rate had hit a punishing 22%. Today, it's down to 11%. We did not just make policies, we worked day and night and left the rest to Allah,' he added. Pakistan's tax-to-GDP ratio lags due to narrow tax net, informal economy: ADB The prime minister said 2023 had brought Pakistan to the brink of default, but his administration pushed through reforms and sealed IMF agreements that stabilised the economy. 'Most thought we'd go bankrupt. I knew we wouldn't,' he said, adding that 'Pakistan has come out of the risk of default.' Sharif did not hold back from criticising what he called a deeply entrenched culture of favouritism and influence-peddling. 'Recommendations start pouring in even before real reform begins,' he said. 'But we were ready. Officers from grades 20 to 22 were shown the door despite pressure from all over the country.' Taking a shot at corrupt practices, he warned, 'Those who lie by swearing on Allah and the Prophet should repent.' He pointed to major reforms at the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) as proof of his administration's commitment to clean governance. 'Sharp bureaucrats used to game the system. We changed that. Now digitisation and faceless tech are in place and the FBR has collected Rs500 billion through enforcement.' While touting his government's work, Sharif struck a moral tone. 'Allah will ask me what I did in this world and I'll say I worked on merit,' he said, vowing to continue what he called a 'journey full of obstacles.' He praised Pakistan's youth as the backbone of the country's future and said the laptop distribution scheme in Punjab – worth Rs20 billion – was entirely merit-based. 'The future lies with this galaxy of young superstars,' he said. Sharif also took aim at India, referencing the Pahalgam incident and cross-border hostilities. 'Pakistan had no role in that incident, but India used it as an excuse for aggression, killing 55 innocent civilians. We defended ourselves and shot down six enemy aircraft. On May 10, we hit back and it was a strong, united response.' Sharif said Pakistan had offered to support an impartial international investigation, but insisted Islamabad would never shy away from defending its sovereignty. Despite the defiant tone, Sharif said he was not seeking personal accolades. 'I have never taken credit – it has always been about teamwork. We must achieve our goals, or we will face the consequences.' Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
4 days ago
- Business Recorder
Household appliances sector: Tribunal upholds CCP's order against price fixing
ISLAMABAD: The Competition Appellate Tribunal has upheld the order of the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) against leading electronic home appliances brands for engaging in Resale Price Maintenance (RPM), a prohibited form of price fixing under the Competition Act, 2010. While maintaining the findings of contravention, the Tribunal reduced the monetary penalty imposed by the CCP to the tune of 90 million, directing the companies to deposit the amount within 30 days. The CCP had earlier imposed penalties on the companies after concluding that both the companies in the home appliances sector had engaged in anti-competitive conduct by restricting their dealers from selling products below specific prices, offering discounts, or providing package deals. In their defense before the Tribunal, the companies did not challenge the finding of contravention but argued that the penalty imposed was high. The Tribunal noted that the appellants demonstrated remedial actions by reimbursing to the dealers the amounts which were imposed by the companies under their price fixing policy. They also assured strict future compliance with the Competition Act. Taking the mitigating factors into account – particularly cooperative stance and restitution to affected parties – the Tribunal reduced the penalties imposed on both companies. The Tribunal also noted the companies' commitment to lawful business practices going forward. The CCP urges all undertakings to refrain from all forms of price fixing, including the setting of minimum or maximum resale prices and imposing restrictions on discounts or promotional offers, as such practices constitute serious violations of competition law. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
