Norfolk woman refuses to hand over 16th-century Italian painting identified as stolen
A 16th-century Madonna and Child painting disappeared without a trace after it was stolen from a museum in northern Italy more than half a century ago.
Now, having surfaced in Britain, it is in the possession of a woman in Norfolk, who is refusing to return it – even though it is listed on police stolen art databases.
It was painted by Antonio Solario, an Italian who is represented in the National Gallery in London and whose patrons included a Bristol cloth merchant who traded with Italy.
The painting was acquired in 1872 by the Civic Museum of Belluno, where it remained until 1973, when it was among several pictures targeted by thieves.
Some were recovered soon afterwards in Austria. The Madonna and Child ended up in the possession of Barbara de Dozsa, who now believes that it belongs to her, partly because her deceased former husband, Baron de Dozsa, bought it in good faith in 1973. Until their divorce, they kept it at their 16th-century Norfolk home, East Barsham Manor in Fakenham, which Henry VIII is said to have described as his 'small country palace'.
In 2017, De Dosza tried to sell the painting through a regional auction house, but it was spotted by someone linked to the Belluno museum, who confirmed that it is on the 'most wanted' lists of police forces, including Interpol and the Italian Carabinieri.
Due to delays caused by the Covid lockdown, the Italian authorities were unable to supply relevant documents requested by the British police, and so the painting was simply handed back to De Dozsa in 2020.
Christopher Marinello, a specialist art lawyer, has tried repeatedly to persuade her to return it to its rightful owner. 'It's the right thing to do,' he said.
But she has cited the Limitation Act 1980, which states that someone who buys stolen goods can be recognised as the legal owner if the purchase was 'unconnected to the theft' after more than six years.
Marinello said: 'Her first argument was that when the British police gave her the painting back, they gave her good title. So I wrote to the police, and they sent her a formal letter saying 'by no means do we convey title to the painting'.'
Asked why the police did not just hand it back to Italy if it was stolen, he said: 'It's a good question. It just shows the failure of law enforcement to help the Italians out. The UK police said that this woman didn't commit a crime, so we're not going to treat it as a criminal matter. It's a civil case.'
Sign up to First Edition
Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
Carlo Cavalli of the museum wrote to her: 'The fact that the painting has been given back to you doesn't mean you have the title.'
Marinello is the founder of Art Recovery International, which focuses on stolen or looted art and is based in London, Venice and New York. His previous recoveries include a Matisse painting that was stolen in 1987 from Stockholm's Museum of Modern Art and whose whereabouts had been shrouded in mystery for 25 years until it surfaced in London.
He believes there is a moral argument for De Dozsa to return the painting – particularly as he has understood from her that she does not even like it enough to hang it on her walls. He is not working for a fee and is driven only by a belief that it belongs to the people of Belluno, from where his own family originated.
De Dozsa had argued that, as well as the cost of storage and insurance, she had to pay £6,000 in legal fees to resolve this problem.
Marinello claimed he understood from her that if he could reimburse those fees she would return the painting.
After securing permission from the Italian police, he found an insurance company that would donate the £6,000 – only for her to allegedly change her mind.
He said: 'Her husband could not have paid more than a couple of hundred back in 1973. It's only worth maybe £60,000 to £80,000 now. She refuses to cooperate unless she gets paid the full value, but she can never sell the painting. No legitimate auction house will ever touch it … the Carabinieri have it on their database and will never take it off. As soon as that painting goes to Italy, it's going to be seized.'
Norfolk constabulary said: 'Norfolk police have been advised by the UKCA [UK Central Authority] to release the painting to Mrs De Dozsa given several years have passed and there has been no response from Italian authorities in relation to the investigation. We have returned the painting but would not, as the police, return this in a judicial capacity in terms of awarding legal title to the painting.'
De Dozsa declined to comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Metro
42 minutes ago
- Metro
Major update in Liam Payne death investigation with trial date set
Two men accused of supplying drugs to former One Direction singer Liam Payne just hours before his fatal fall from a hotel balcony will face trial, Argentinian prosecutors have confirmed. Braian Nahuel Paiz, 25, a restaurant waiter, and Ezequiel David Pereyra, 24, a former hotel employee, have been in custody since early January. They stand accused of selling cocaine to the British musician, who died on October 16, 2024, after falling from the third floor of the Casa Sur Hotel in Buenos Aires. The Little Things hitmaker was a beloved UK musician after rising to fame alongside his former bandmates Louis Tomlinson, Zayn Malik, Niall Horan, and Harry Styles on The X Factor in 2010. In a statement released by Argentina's public prosecution service, Prosecutor Andrés Esteban Madrea confirmed the pair would go to trial, facing potential prison sentences of up to 15 years if convicted of drug trafficking offenses. 'Braian Nahuel Paiz, who met Payne while working as a waiter in Puerto Madero, and Ezequiel David Pereyra, a former employee at the hotel where the incident occurred, are charged with the crime of selling drugs,' the statement read. Forensic investigations revealed Payne had consumed cocaine through both snorting and smoking shortly before his death. An autopsy showed he died from severe polytrauma and internal and external bleeding, and toxicology reports detected a combination of substances in his system, including cocaine, alcohol (at 2.7 grams per litre), methylecgonine, benzoylecgonine, cocaethylene, and the antidepressant sertraline. 'The toxicological analysis confirmed Liam Payne had ingested cocaine at least 72 hours before his death and possibly as recently as a few minutes before falling from the hotel balcony,' authorities said. Three other individuals initially charged in connection with Payne's death – his close friend Rogelio Nores, hotel receptionist Esteban Grassi, and head of hotel security Gilda Martin – were cleared of wrongdoing after an appeal overturned a lower court's manslaughter accusations. No date has been set for the trial of Paiz and Pereyra, but proceedings are expected to begin soon. More Trending Speaking from his Buenos Aires jail cell in an interview with local outlet Infobae, Paiz denied selling cocaine to Payne, though he admitted to having shared drugs with the pop star. 'I don't know what I'm doing here, I'm a good person,' he said. 'I shared drugs with Liam but I didn't sell them.' The young waiter described himself as a longtime marijuana user and expressed regret over the connection he formed with Payne. 'I regret giving Liam my Instagram because everything spiralled from there,' he said. 'If I hadn't, I'd probably be working or studying today. I miss my freedom, my family, my mom, and my sisters.' Got a story? If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@ calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you. MORE: Rita Ora reveals empowering way LGBTQ+ fans have 'inspired' her new music MORE: Liam Payne's girlfriend Kate Cassidy shares unseen picture of One Direction star
Wales Online
7 hours ago
- Wales Online
Company boss pocketed £150,000 in fraudulent Covid business loans
Company boss pocketed £150,000 in fraudulent Covid business loans A judge told Zahid Afzal that at a time of national emergency the government had set up a system to help businesses which he had abused A company boss fraudulently obtained £150,000 in loans designed to help businesses hit by the Covid pandemic, a court has heard. Zahid Afzal made two legitimate applications for "Bounce Bank" loans but then used his knowledge of the application process to acquire three more loans he was not entitled to. A judge at Swansea Crown Court told the defendant that at a time of national emergency the government had set up a system to help businesses which he had abused to obtain loans he was not entitled to. Harry Dickens, prosecuting, told the court that the UK government established "Bounce Back" loans to help small and medium businesses during the coronavirus pandemic, and that the scheme allowed companies to borrow between £2,000 and £50,000 at a low interest rate. He said the defendant made two legitimate applications for his companies Phones Onn and Phone Bits Ltd to HSBC and NatWest respectively, and the applications were successful. However, he said Afzal subsequently made three more applications to Lloyds, Starling, and Metro Bank during 2020 for the same phone companies and in each case falsely declared there had been no previous applications for those firms. The court heard the defendant also inflated the turnover figures of the firms in order to access the maximum £50,000 loan amounts. Article continues below The prosecutor said the three loan applications were successful and a total of £150,000 was paid into the companies' accounts, much of which was subsequently transferred out into personal accounts. Zahid Afzal, aged 37, of Albert Street, Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire, had previously pleaded guilty to three counts of fraud by false representation when he appeared in the dock for sentencing. He has no previous convictions. Jon Tarrant, for Afzal, said the defendant employed eight people, and said six of those needed the employment to maintain their UK visas. He said the father-of-three was a successful businessman who had established himself in a positive light to many people but that position "has now been reversed". He said the defendant's remorse for his "unwise decisions" had been "palpable" during their conferences. For the latest court reports sign up to our crime newsletter Judge Catherine Richards said at a time of nation emergency the UK government had established a system to help businesses that was paid for by society and which "relied on the trust and confidence that each gives the other as a member of this society". She told Afzal he had deliberately abused that by applying for loans he knew he was not entitled to and which, ultimately, were not for business use. The judge said while she had no doubt the offending justified immediate custody she was concerned that "the public finances are not further prejudiced" by Afzal's actions. She also said she was mindful of the impact of immediate custody on others. With one-quarter discounts for his guilty pleas Afzal was sentenced to two years in prison suspended for two years and was ordered to complete 300 hours of unpaid work. A proceeds of crime investigation will now be launched into the defendant's finances. Article continues below The prosecution barrister said he wanted to out the court on notice that a written application would be made for a restraint order to be made in respect of the defendant's personal Santander bank account which currently contains some £74,000.
Daily Mail
9 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Huge twist as footy star Payne Haas's dad fights to avoid death by firing squad after allegedly trafficking a huge amount of meth
There is renewed hope that the father of two NRL stars may be allowed to return to Australia and avoid the death penalty in Indonesia, more than a year after he was arrested on serious drug trafficking charges. Gregor Haas, father of NSW State of Origin star Payne Haas and Gold Coast Titans forward Klese Haas, was detained in Cebu City, Philippines, in May 2024 following a red notice issued by Interpol at the request of Indonesian authorities. That red notice has now been lifted after a successful appeal by Haas' Australian legal team, which could pave the way for a return home. Investigators allege that in December 2023, Haas attempted to smuggle five kilograms of methamphetamine from Mexico to Jakarta, allegedly hiding the drugs inside ceramic tiles. The case allegedly links him to the powerful Mexican Sinaloa cartel, though Haas has consistently denied any involvement. He says he has never visited Mexico and believes the allegations stem from a business dispute related to a resort deal in Indonesia. Following his arrest, Haas was held at Camp Bagong Diwa, a notoriously harsh immigration detention centre in Manila. Over the past year, his health has deteriorated significantly. According to his lawyer, he has lost 30 kilograms and is receiving inadequate medical care. The red notice issued by Interpol is sent to law enforcement bodies globally and enabled Indonesia to request provisional arrest while pursuing extradition. If extradited and convicted, Haas could face execution by firing squad under Indonesian law. While Indonesia initially offered assurances that the death penalty would not be imposed, those promises were made under former president Joko Widodo. His successor, Prabowo Subianto, has yet to confirm whether that stance will hold. In December 2024, a Philippine court found that Haas was also a Filipino citizen by birth through his mother. However, the Bureau of Immigration appealed the decision, and the ruling was later overturned, keeping him in detention. Then, in a major legal breakthrough on June 2, 2025, Interpol revoked the red notice against Haas. His legal team argued that the notice was based on inaccurate and unfounded information and violated international human rights conventions. Interpol accepted those arguments, agreeing that enforcing the notice could lead to torture or death, and deleted the associated data. Australian lawyer Abdul Reslan, representing Haas, called on the Philippines to act swiftly to release and deport him to Australia. 'We now urge the Philippines to ensure the expeditious release and repatriation of Haas to Australia,' he said. He told SMH that if the Philippines does not comply with international norms, the Australian government must step in and formally demand Haas' repatriation. He emphasised that Haas holds an Australian passport and should not be detained by a foreign government now that the red notice has been removed. It is rare for Interpol to revoke a red notice, particularly one issued by a democratic nation such as Indonesia. Phillip Gibson, a defence lawyer specialising in international crime, said the decision was significant and raised expectations that the Philippines would follow suit. The case has become a diplomatic flashpoint, putting strain on Australia's relationships with both Indonesia and the Philippines. Australia strongly opposes capital punishment and has laws preventing the extradition of citizens to face execution abroad. Indonesia has also proposed a prisoner exchange involving Haas and Alice Guo, a former Philippine mayor arrested in Indonesia and accused of links to Chinese organised crime. No deal has been finalised. The situation unfolds amid wider negotiations between Australia and Indonesia, including a separate agreement last year in which Prime Minister Anthony Albanese secured the release of five remaining Bali Nine inmates still serving life sentences. Australia's Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade confirmed it is providing consular assistance to Haas but declined to comment further due to privacy rules. Meanwhile, the personal toll on Haas' family continues to grow. Payne and Klese's mother, Uiatu 'Joan' Taufua, remains in custody in Queensland over a 2022 car crash in Bonogin that killed three people. She has been charged with three counts of manslaughter and is yet to enter a plea. Payne Haas has not commented publicly on his father's legal battle. The NSW Blues forward is expected to take the field for State of Origin II in Perth on Wednesday night.
