
Who's safeguarding the Middle East's cultural treasures? – DW – 06/30/2025
The Paris-based International Council of Museums (ICOM) had issued an emphatic warning after the first bomb strikes: There was a "growing danger" for museums and their employees in Israel and Iran.
The professional association, which consists of 8,000 museum professionals worldwide including members from Israel and Iran, had demanded that both sides adhere to international conventions for the protection of cultural heritage, even in the event of conflict. "However, we can do no more than admonish and warn," president of the German National Committee, Felicia Sternfeld, told Deutsche Welle.
Did this appeal have an impact? The news situation on the ground is thin, with only sparse information coming out of Iran in particular, as it allows hardly any foreign journalists to enter and severely restricts press freedom. However, one thing seems certain: Contingency plans were activated in both countries at the start of the Israel-Iran conflict. As far as possible, experts worked to secure, remove and relocate cultural assets. It is currently unclear whether despite all the warnings there has been any damage.
Iran has a rich cultural heritage. This includes 28 UNESCO World Heritage Sites and around 840 museums, 300 of which are under the administration of the Ministry of Culture. "Iran has a well-organized and professional heritage authority," Judith Thomalsky, the head of the Tehran branch of the German Archaeological Institute, said in an interview with Deutschlandfunk radio.
Thomalsky's office has been operating from Berlin since 2023, when thousands of Iranians protested the mullah regime and the German Federal Foreign Office withdrew staff from German institutions as a precaution. The Institute itself continues its work on the premises of the German Embassy in Tehran with local staff, and Thomalsky maintains as much contact as possible with her Iranian network.
Barbara Helwing, director of the Museum of the Ancient Near East in Berlin and Thomalsky's predecessor from 2000 to 2014, is also an expert on Iran. She told German regional broadcaster RBB that she was in contact with her colleagues at the National Museum until recently; there has been occasional radio silence because the Iranian regime had shut down the Internet.
"We know that the museum and its two large buildings near the Foreign Ministry have been emptied," said Helwing, adding that she has seen photos showing empty display cases.
The Iranian National Museum is not only the oldest but also the most important museum in Iran. Comprising two buildings with three halls each, it houses more than 300,000 archaeological finds from pre-Islamic [before 7th century CE: Eds.] and Islamic times, including many objects made of stone, ceramics, glass and metals.
"In Iran, the relationship with cultural heritage is very close," Helwing said. The country's cultural identity is based on a long history and the awareness that the first real-world empire in history, the ancient Persian Empire (around 550 to 330 BCE), originated in Iran. According to Helwing, all portable museum objects were hastily transported into the cellars.
The non-movable artifacts, mainly stone objects, were covered with sandbags to protect them from strikes and flying debris. Unlike in Israel, there are no bunkers in Iran — neither for people nor for valuable art treasures.
Protecting archaeological sites that are often located in open areas has proven to be far more difficult: "You can't really protect them," Helwing said, "You can only hope that they are far enough away from potential targets."
According to the English-language , Taq-e Bostan, an archeological complex from the era of the Sasanian dynasty (224-651 CE) that includes a one-of-a-kind monumental rock relief, faces particular danger. The newspaper reported that the Israeli Air Force bombed a weapons depot just two kilometers away from the complex. The resulting shock waves and vibrations may have damaged the site, Helwing fears, though she lacked more precise information.
"Iran's Department of Antiquities knows what it needs to do," says Judith Thomalsky, a historian who focuses on prehistoric times and who has spent over 20 years working in Iran. She also believes it isn't possible to protect open archeological sites like the Persepolis complex, the Bisotun inscriptions and Takht-e Soleyman, or "Throne of Solomon," an archeological site. She told the Berlin daily that while she doesn't believe cultural assets face an acute threat, it is impossible to know how things may develop.
Institutions in Israel, for their part, activated emergency plans following the first Iranian counterattacks. For instance, the Tel Aviv Museum of Art secured its collection of Israeli and international art in underground storage, the French Magazine reported. It is planning to reopen its doors on July 3. It is already possible to visit Jerusalem's Israel Museum again, which with its 500,000 objects is one of the largest in the Middle East. The museum website informs visitors that it is equipped with safe rooms that are located in the museum in case of emergency.
Israel is currently home to nine UNESCO World Heritage Sites, including the White City of Tel Aviv, a neighborhood with numerous buildings in the Bauhaus architectural style, the Masada mountaintop fortress and the Old City of Acre.
"To our knowledge there has been no damage to archeological artifacts under the management of Israel Antiquities Authority, nor to objects in museums," the authority has stated, as reported by both and .
World heritage sites are under formal protection of the international community. The 1954 Hague convention regulates the protection of cultural material in armed conflict, while the 1972 UNESCO World Heritage Convention governs conservation of cultural assets among nations.
From July 6-16, the UNESCO World Heritage Committee will be holding its 47th session in Paris. Among other things, experts will discuss potential future UNESCO cultural heritage sites. The session will be live-streamed. The Israel-Iran conflict was not on the agenda as at June 30.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


DW
30 minutes ago
- DW
Germany updates: Interior minister downplays coalition spat – DW – 07/12/2025
Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt described the postponement of judicial appointments as normal, saying he cannot understand accusations of damage being done to Germany's top court. German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt on Saturday described a postponed Bundestag vote on judicial appointments as normal. Critics within the ruling coalition have accused the CDU/CSU of "dismantling democratic institutions." A vote was abruptly cancelled Friday after the CDU/CSU withdrew support for an SPD candidate. from Bonn Following the pause, DW resumes its coverage of news and analysis from Germany. On Saturday, Germany awaits news from Paris, where the World Heritage Committee of UNESCO is expected to decide whether to grant World Heritage status to the castles of Neuschwanstein, Herrenchiemsee, and Linderhof, as well as the royal residence on Schachen Mountain in Upper Bavaria. Stay tuned for more, and we hope you enjoy reading! It's just past midnight here in Germany, so we're pausing our coverage for now and will resume early in the morning. Thousands of Bosnians gather at a cemetery near Srebrenica to mark the 30th anniversary of a massacre in which more than 8,000 Muslim Bosniak men and boys were executed by Bosnian Serb forces during a 1992-5 war. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video German comedian Sebastian Hotz will have to go to court in relation to social media posts he made about the attempted assassination of Donald Trump. The Berlin public prosecutor's office charges that Hotz, who is also known as "El Hotzo," condoned and rewarded criminal offences. His trial is scheduled to begin on July 23 at the Tiergarten district court in Berlin. Hotz deleted the posts on X, but screenshots soon began to circulate. In one comment, he suggested a similarity between a "last bus" and then presidential candidate Trump, writing that "unfortunately" both had been "just missed." In another, Hotz said: "I think it's absolutely fantastic when fascists die." In the wake of the scandal, regional public broadcaster RBB ended its collaboration with Hotz on a youth program. Soon after, national public broadcaster ARD Kultur canceled a literary event with him. Christina Block, heiress to Germany's Block House steakhouse chain, went on trial in Hamburg on Friday accused of ordering the violent kidnapping of her two youngest children. Block is standing trial alongside her partner, former television sports presenter Gerhard Delling, and several other alleged accomplices accused of snatching the children from their father in Denmark. Find out more about the high-profile case. Hasan Hasanovic lost his twin brother and father in the Srebrenica genocide in 1995. Now, he has made it his life's work to document the deadliest massacre in Europe since World War II. Today, one of Hasanovic most important projects has to do with building an archive with video footage of survivors of the genocide telling their stories. It is unique and the most important record of what happened 30 years ago. Read more about his life and work here. Vivian Spohr, the wife of Lufthansa CEO Carsten Spohr, said she was "at the complete disposal" of Italian judicial authorities following the death of a 24-year-old woman who was struck by a vehicle in the Italian island of Sardinia. Local media reported that the 24-year-old died from serious head injuries after she was struck by a vehicle at a crosswalk on Tuesday, with Spohr reportedly at the wheel. Gaia Costa, the victim, was from from Tempio Pausania, in the Gallura region of northern Sardinia. She died at the scene of accident in in Porto Cervo in northern Sardinia. In a statement issued by her Italian lawyer on Friday, the 51-year-old German businesswoman expressed "dismay and deep sorrow for this grave accident, which has devastated a family, the town of Tempio, and the entire community of Gallura." The statement added that Spohr places herself "at the complete disposal of the Italian judicial authorities for the necessary investigations and, while aware that such a great personal loss cannot be repaired, will take steps to mitigate its consequences." Spohr had been staying at her family's vacation home when the accident occurred, local media reported. She returned to Germany shortly after the accident. Germany does not plan to procure more F-35 fighter jets beyond the 35 already ordered, the defense ministry has said, rejecting a report that claimed Berlin aimed to expand its fleet to 50. Germany has so far ordered 35 US-made jets to replace a total of 85 ageing Tornado aircraft. "The defense ministry currently has no plans to procure additional F-35s beyond the 35 F-35s already contractually agreed," a ministry spokesperson said at a regular news conference. A military source told the Reuters news agency that the 15 additional jets had been part of earlier considerations. However, NATO's new targets for weapons and troop numbers mean that the number may need adjusting. The source did not confirm if more jets will ultimately be ordered. The report by comes amid tensions between Germany and France over their joint FCAS fighter jet project. An industry source told Reuters that France now wants an 80% workshare, which could scrap the agreed split and block the project's next phase. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz will make his first official visit to London on Thursday, with a German-British treaty of friendship expected to be signed. Government spokesman Steffen Meyer said in Berlin on Friday that the visit aims to deepen close ties between the two countries. Merz will be received by British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, who has sought to repair relations with the EU after Brexit. The draft treaty is set to be approved by the German Cabinet on Wednesday. It will focus on cooperation in foreign and defense policy, economic growth, and more direct contact between citizens. Once signed, the agreement will go to the Bundestag for approval. An action plan with specific joint projects will also be presented to strengthen bilateral ties. Independent justices preside over Germany's Federal Constitutional Court. How are they chosen? DW looks at the process of picking judges in Germany. A joint car plant in the Chinese city of Nanjing, run by German car company Volkswagen and its local partner SAIC, will be closed in the coming months. "Volkswagen Group and its joint venture partners are accelerating the transformation towards electric, intelligent, connected vehicles," a spokesperson for Volkswagen told AFP news agency. "Many SAIC Volkswagen sites are currently being converted or have already been converted for electric vehicle production," the spokesperson said. The spokesman also confirmed the news first reported by German newspaper, , about production having already come to a halt there. One reason for the closure of the plant, which is set to be closed over the second half of the year, was because of its urban location, making the expansion of electric vehicle production difficult. The plant, which has a capacity to produce 360,000 vehicles per year, first opened in 2008. It made models like Volkswagen Passat and Skoda Superb. The number of companies that went bankrupt in Germany significantly rose again in April, according to finalized data from the German Federal Statistical Office (Destatis). The number of 2,125 companies going bust in April 2025 marks a rise of 11.5% more than in the same month last year. Volker Treier, the head analyst of the German Industry and Commerce Chamber, warned that "Whoever wants to ensure competitiveness, cannot further postpone relief." According to preliminary data from Destatis, the number of businesses filing for bankruptcy in June 2025 is expected to rise by 2.4% in comparison to June 2024. A Bundestag debate marking the 30th anniversary of the Srebrenica genocide on Friday ended with recriminations and outrage when members of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party suggested that what happened in Bosnia in 1995 was not in fact genocide. AfD politician Alexander Wolf caused uproar by questioning whether the events in Srebrenica were worthy of the label of "genocide," arguing that Bosnian Serbs had only shot men, and had spared women and children. The statement does not square with the fact that, beyond the killings of about 8,000 men and boys during the massacre, there have been thousands of reported cases of sexual abuse against Bosniak women and girls. Verdicts by both the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY) and the International Court of Justice (ICJ) have already determined the genocidal character of the massacre. Politicians from the coalition SPD and CDU/CSU accused Wolf of spouting revisionist history that denies genocide and sides the perpetrators of war crimes. Still, the AfD was not done, with Martin Sichert calling Srebrenica a glaring example of the threat posed by multiculturalism, claiming that Germany was running headlong into a similar fate. It was then that parliamentarians demonstratively turned their backs, with Klöckner reprimanding Sichert and Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul unexpectedly taking to the speaker's pulpit to apologize to Bosnia-Herzegovina's Ambassador to Germany Damir Arnaut for having to listen to Sichert's words. On Friday, the German parliament held a special session in memory of the Srebrenica massacre, which took place 30 years ago. About 8,000 Muslims were murdered by Bosnian Serbs in an act, recognized by several international courts as a genocide, that started on July 11, 1995. Julia Klöckner, president of the Bundestag, said that "Srebrenica was the worst war crime on European soil since World War II." She said that the massacre was the result of UN peacekeeping forces doing nothing to protect those seeking refuge. "With brutal violence, the attackers separated families and deported women, children and the elderly," she stated. "They kept men and boys behind in order to systematically murder them in the days that followed." To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video A German backpacker who went missing in western Australia almost two weeks ago has been found alive, Australian media reported on Friday. Australian police must first confirm the 26-year-old Carolina Wilga's identity, Australia's reported. A passerby ran into Wilga on a path in the bush, Australian media reported. Her reappearance follows a large-scale search that dragged on for days. Read more on when Wilga went missing and how she was found here.


DW
5 hours ago
- DW
Germany debates quota for immigrant students – DW – 07/12/2025
Education Minister Karin Prien has proposed limiting the number of immigrant children in Germany's schools. This has been met with both approval and criticism. When Sabine Schwarz* first heard about German Education Minister Karin Prien's idea via a friend, she thought it was just a bad joke. A quota limiting the number of immigrants at German schools was a "conceivable model," the center-right Christian Democratic Union (CDU) politician had suggested, adding that Germany should check what other countries do to determine "whether that ends up being 30 or 40%". Schwarz is the head of an elementary school in Germany's most populous state of North Rhine-Westphalia. More than 80% of her 350 pupils are from immigrant families. She says Prien's proposal would be impossible to implement in reality: "We don't even have the quota of people here who would qualify as German-speaking or German," Schwarz told DW. The Germans who live in the detached houses next to the school prefer to send their children elsewhere, says Schwarz. She finds this sad. Almost 20 years ago, North Rhine-Westphalia abolished the obligation to send one's child to a primary school in the neighborhood. As a result, many parents avoid schools like Schwarz's — for fear that learning among a high proportion of immigrants could have a negative impact on their own children's academic success. "What you always hear is that migration is equated with a lower level of education and that the children learn more slowly. But that's not true at all," Schwarz says. "For example, we benefited from the wave of refugees in 2015 because we received many children who were very interested in getting a good education." Schwarz criticizes the fact that all children are lumped together. There are "traumatized children with refugee experience who can't even think about education at first, and children who are very interested in education and children who have fled poverty." Her school's motto is: Every child is welcome, no matter where they come from. And no child is abandoned. In Germany, around 30% of the population of over 80 million have some immigrant background. But this percentage is much higher among young people, especially in urban areas. According to Berlin's statistics office, for example, children make up 17% of the population, and 55% of all children and teenagers living in the city have an immigrant background. In individual districts of the capital, such as Neukölln, that number rises to over 70%. Stefan Düll, president of the German Teachers' Association, has welcomed the debate that Prien has initiated, although he suspects that her proposal will fail to be implemented. He agrees with critics who say that the problem is not an immigrant background, but rather a lack of German language skills. "The German Teachers' Association has been pointing out for years that it makes teaching considerably more difficult if many pupils do not have sufficient knowledge of German," he told DW in a written statement. "In our view, however, there is little point in redistributing pupils just to achieve a certain quota in individual classes. This is hardly feasible from an organizational point of view and does not promote social cohesion within a school community." To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Instead, Düll praised the federal and state government's program making €20 billion ($23.4 bn) available over the next few years for 4,000 schools with a particularly high number of immigrant students. German education researcher Klaus Hurrelmann believes in the positive effect of diverse school classes: "The minister's proposal is understandable, because a well-mixed composition of school classes and learning groups according to origin clearly leads to better work." However, he warns that implementing Prien's proposal would lead to discrimination and be counterproductive. "The resulting misunderstandings and perceived discrimination do not outweigh any potential benefits. Approaches that support schools with a very high proportion of children and young people with language problems would be better." The federal students' body (Bundesschülerkonferenz) sharply criticized Prien's idea of introducing an immigrant quota at German schools. In a statement, it said it sends out the dangerous signal that not all children are equally welcome. The students argue that such quotas do not promote a fairer education system, but stigmatize children. An individual's ethnic origin should never become a criterion for educational opportunities. Also, schools should be places of participation, not exclusion, they wrote. However, the students' representative body does agree with one of the minister's proposals: "We are in favor of the German aptitude tests for four-year-old children suggested by Karin Prien. However, these must be introduced across the board and be compulsory for all children in Germany, not just students with an immigrant background. If the results are inadequate, targeted, comprehensive support measures must be introduced — early, binding and effective. This is the only way to ensure that every child starts their educational career with the same opportunities." To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Performance problems among students in Germany are by no means exclusive to those with an immigrant background. When it comes to education in Germany, one thing is certain: Teachers, parents, pupils and experts all agree that the system urgently needs to be reformed. Germany performs too poorly in many categories: In the last PISA study in 2022, Germany only came in mid-table in an international comparison. The competence of 15-year-olds in reading, mathematics and science fell to the lowest levels ever measured. According to the International Primary School Reading Survey (IGLU) from 2023, one in four fourth-graders in Germany has difficulties reading. And 56,000 pupils left school in Germany in the same year without obtaining even a low-level degree. That's over 7%, and the trend is rising. Many argue that issues of integration and language learning must be tackled in pre-school education. But statistics show that Germany lacks around 125,000 nursery teachers in childcare facilities across the country. Sabine Schwarz can confirm this from her own experience: "We work very closely with the kindergartens, but we can't make up for the lack of staff there. They need trained specialists and the appropriate resources to promote language learning. Unfortunately, this is not happening at the moment, so we have a gap between kindergarten and elementary school." The principal emphasizes: "The work in the kindergartens is key to educational success in elementary school." While you're here: Every Tuesday, DW editors round up what is happening in German politics and society. You can sign up here for the weekly email newsletter, Berlin Briefing.


DW
17 hours ago
- DW
Families of Israeli hostages in Gaza rally support in Berlin – DW – 07/11/2025
Hamas continues to hold 59 hostages in Gaza, including seven German-Israeli nationals — five of whom are believed to be alive. Their relatives visited Berlin to call for their release. It has been 642 days since October 7, 2023, when Shachar Ohel's 24-year-old nephew, Alon Ohel, was gravely injured at the Supernova music festival in southern Israel by Hamas-aligned militants and taken to Gaza. Since then, the family's thoughts and emotions have revolved around whether Alon is still alive and how he can be freed from captivity. "We still have hope," Shachar Ohel told DW. Hostages held with Alon were released by Hamas five months ago and have told him about his nephew's condition. "They have been together with him for the whole period of time," Shachar Ohel said. "We know that he is in a very bad condition. He lost his sight in the right eye. There is a real danger for the other eye. He does not get any food. He is starving. He is in a critical condition… We hope he is surviving, because they [Hamas] want him to be alive. Because (otherwise) they have nothing to deal with Israel." Alon Ohel is one of the hostages kidnapped by Hamas — a Palestinian Islamist group based in the Gaza strip — during its October 7 attack on Israel. After several rounds of negotiations, 146 hostages were released in exchange for Palestinian prisoners. 83 Hamas hostages have died in captivity, yet Hamas still has not handed over the remains of 35 individuals. 24 hostages are believed to still be alive — with the Bring them Home hostages and missing families forum demanding their immediate release. Relatives and friends of hostages holding joint Israeli and German citizenship have come to Berlin, calling for greater German involvement. Five of the captives are believed to still be alive, two are reported dead. In Berlin, the group is appealing to German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul and President Frank-Walter Steinmeier and others to provide more support. "We have received a lot of sympathy and hugs," says Liran Berman who has two brothers being held captive by Hamas. "But now it's time to act and apply more pressure." Liran Berman and the other relatives are pinning all their hopes on the ongoing ceasefire negotiations between Israel, the US, and Hamas. "We are in the middle of a crisis that we have never had in history. It is on governments, and I believe in diplomacy, to get to a deal," Efrat Machikawa told DW. Five of her relatives were held captive by Hamas at various stages, with four eventually released. A fifth relative was murdered. Efrat is working with other relatives who have come to Berlin to secure the release of the German-Israeli hostages. This does not only involve those sitting at the negotiating table, she said, but also other countries, including Germany, "that have a relationship with those around the table, this is why international community involvement in so important." All Germans should be concerned about this, she said, adding that freeing the hostages is the first step toward improving the terrible situation in the Middle East. Alon Ohel's parents placed a yellow piano in central Tel Aviv in memory of their son, a pianist and jazz lover. Anyone can play it in tribute to Alon. The yellow piano was even brought to Berlin for a solidarity concert. On October 7, 2023, Hamas attacked several Israeli villages and the Supernova music festival near the Gaza Strip, killing around 1,200 people and taking 251 hostages. In response, the Israeli army began fighting Hamas in the Gaza Strip. According to various unverifiable reports, between 50,000 and 80,000 people have been killed in Gaza since then. Large parts of the Gaza Strip have been destroyed. The humanitarian situation in the territory is catastrophic, according to the UN. Hamas is a militant, Palestinian Islamist group based in Gaza. The European Union, US, Germany, and other countries classify it as a terrorist organization.