Young people do not belong in nursing homes
Another is trapped in a care home among residents twice his age, paying €3,000 a month while his savings and spirit drain away. He can't even go for a walk out of the grounds without permission.
I've met these men — both under 65 and both with lives worth living. The man living in a nursing home is not merely another wasted life, he is a person too.
Prime Time Investigates exposed what we've known for years: the shameful institutionalisation of people under 65, leading to rapid physical and mental decline. Today, 1,227 remain in nursing homes.
In 2025, the HSE asked for €8.5 million to relocate 40 people — sounds like progress, right? Until you realise only €4.8 million was allocated, enough to move just 24 people.
Over four years, 104 people have been moved out of nursing homes, while 32 more are added every month (Wasted Lives Update, 2024). The maths doesn't add up — and neither does the morality.
I've lived with early onset Parkinson's for a decade — a condition affecting 10–20% of people with Parkinson's, with members of our organisation symptomatic as young as 20 years old.
With 18,000 living with Parkinson's in Ireland, as many as 3,600 people aged 18 to 55 are at risk of being sent to a nursing home should they experience rapid progression, or symptoms become unmanageable alone. This is not to mention the countless others living with neurodegenerative conditions.
I've met people living this nightmare — like a man in his 30s with Cerebral Palsy, placed in a nursing home alongside residents his parents' age. With both parents in long-term dementia care and no community supports available, he was sent there.
His fear? That he might never get out.
And what about the families? Under the Fair Deal scheme, 80% of a person's assessable income and 7.5% of their assets per annum, are paid towards nursing home care.
In the case of early onset conditions what happens to the mortgage, the family left behind, the children still in school? The financial devastation affects everyone.
I'm lucky to have a supportive husband, four amazing children, family and friends. I'm doing my best to live well. But many I've met aren't so fortunate.
They're institutionalised, cut off from vital therapies like physio, exercise, and neurology that could slow disease progression. Their savings vanish, they're isolated from peers, and their mental and physical health decline as their independence slips away, day by day.
This practice is not new. Nor is it an accident. The Wasted Lives report in 2021, laid bare the systemic failings, and since this, the Government repeated promises to end the institutionalisation of young people in nursing homes.
What do these promises mean to the young man in his 30s with Cerebral Palsy? Nothing. His life hasn't changed. The government has, but his reality has not.
Slow erosion of dignity
Having just retired from my role as a dementia adviser in Clare, I have seen how the system fails people. I've seen the heartbreak, the isolation, and the slow erosion of dignity.
I've also seen community workers and healthcare staff stretch every resource and contact to find funding and support often forcing them to act first and ask forgiveness later in the hopes of a better outcome.
It appears that the €4.8 million allocation is a one-off fund, as there is no indication that funding has been committed for the many years that would be required to solve this crisis. That is not a strategy. It is an insult. Especially when the Government claims its commitment to ending this practice.
What happens next year? What happens to the hundreds still living in no man's land.
Fiona Staunton: 'Having just retired from my role as a dementia adviser in Clare, I have seen how the system fails people. I've seen the heartbreak, the isolation, and the slow erosion of dignity.'
We need real, long-term investment in community supports, as promised in Sláintecare. Clear exit pathways must be created for those already institutionalised and we need transparent, updated data on how many of these people are wrongly placed in nursing homes — including those stuck in hospital beds waiting for nursing home spots.
We need full, informed consent — because I can tell you now, no young person willingly chooses this as a long-term path.
This shameful practice must end. Being diagnosed with a neurodegenerative disease should not mean your human rights are stripped away. We are not statistics. We are people with hopes, with families, friends, and with futures.
One of the myriad symptoms of Parkinson's is a softening — and even loss — of one's voice. However, on this issue, we will continue to shout until our voices are heard, until there are no more wasted lives.
Fiona Staunton is a Board Member, EOPD Ireland Dementia Adviser (retired), The Alzheimer Society of Ireland Person living with Early Onset Parkinson's Disease Parkinson's Advocate
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
10 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Irish Examiner view: Health staff recruitment crisis underlined by HSE's inability to hire temporary agency workers
Our hard-pressed health service is not short of challenges, with new issues materialising on a regular basis. Now a whole new problem in staffing has emerged. As revealed here this week by Health Correspondent Niamh Griffin, worker shortages are now so acute that the HSE has warned that it is sometimes unable to fill vacancies even with agency staff, because agencies are themselves struggling to recruit health workers. A familiar problem is contributing to these shortages — agencies are reporting that while there are general shortages of workers on a global scale, one specific issue in Ireland is the shortage of accommodation. The housing crisis has affected almost every part of Irish life, and now it appears that a general lack of accommodation for health workers is having a direct impact on the supply line of staff. This impact can be clearly seen in the numbers involved. As reported here, in 2021, disability services spent €40m on agency staff, but last year that figure reached €77.9m, and by May this year, €37.2m had already been spent. Similar increases can be seen in other areas of the health service — the mental health division spent €71.5m on temporary workers four years ago, and in 2024, that figure was €106.3m. The net result is that some of the most vulnerable people in our society are being cared for by agency staff, which is far from ideal. The British Medical Journal, for instance, reported some years ago on the link between heavy use of agency staff and worse experiences for patients and staff alike. The Government must address this issue by revisiting its recruitment strategy, one which has been much criticised by health unions. It must also rein in expenditure in this area, described accurately by an opposition TD as 'runaway agency spending'. This is particularly necessary in the context of the unfinished Children's Hospital and its associated costs. Irish passports in demand in the US A surge in the number of US applicants for Irish passports earlier this year was linked to the return of Donald Trump to the White House. This yielded a new entry for the dictionary — Trumpugees — as well as a couple of celebrity applicants such as Rosie O'Donnell. Mayor TD Paul Lawless caused a stir when he called for a 'hierarchy' of passport processing, with Irish residents given preference over American citizens. Those new applicants benefited from improved efficiency in the Passport Office's operation, which has reduced the turnaround time for most adult online renewal applications to two working days. This is a standard of service which other State organisations and bodies would do well to emulate. However, Aontú TD Paul Lawless has called for a 'hierarchy' of passport processing, telling this newspaper: 'I'm aware of some cases where American citizens are applying for passports because they just want to frame it, or to be able to say that they have an Irish passport. These individuals should be put to the bottom of the waiting list, especially at times where Irish families are struggling to get passports. This is a delicate point: Passports cannot be issued on the proviso that they are used in a certain way or at particular times. It is difficult to see how the holder of an Irish passport in America could be compelled to use it, or whether such conditions could be attached to its issuance. However, we are right to focus on any action, or inaction, which might have the potential to lower the standing of our passport, which has an international currency many nations envy. An Irish passport is an expression of our specific sovereignty, which is important, but it also identifies the bearer as a citizen of a country which is independent in its outlook, non-colonial in its international relations, and supportive of those in need. Many of those seeking Irish passports want to be seen as sharing those values, which makes it all the more important to protect our passport's reputation. What's your view on this issue? You can tell us here Taylor Swift album ...Ready for it? Music fans all over Ireland are counting down the hours to the Oasis concerts this weekend, pulling old parkas and bucket hats from the wardrobe, and preparing themselves for the warm glow of nostalgia which will start when the Manchester band recreate the '90s in Croke Park. It seems like only yesterday we were dealing with the angst of Ticketmaster interactions and soaring hotel prices for an entirely different musical act — when Taylor Swift sold out the Aviva Stadium last summer. Taylor Swift on stage during her three sold-out dates at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin on the Eras Tour in June of last year. Liam McBurney/PA The US star shifted approximately 150,000 tickets for those three concerts in Dublin as part of her Eras Tour, which ran for almost two full years and generated approximately $1bn (€856.7m) in revenue. Yesterday, we learned that Swift is to release a new album. The news came following some mysterious online hints which her fans quickly seized upon, and frenzied speculation hardened into confirmation when the singer announced the news in one of the most 21st-century publicity strategies imaginable — she displayed a blurred copy of the album cover in a social media clip promoting her boyfriend Travis Kelce's podcast, New Heights. The new release will be Swift's 12th studio album and is entitled The Life of a Showgirl, and eagerly-anticipated is an understatement. Last year, her 11th album, The Tortured Poets Department, broke the Spotify record for being the most-streamed album in a day. The new album may challenge for that title. Further details will emerge tomorrow, and expect speculation about a new tour to begin at the same time. Hotel room prices are sure to spike accordingly.
Irish Independent
21 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Consultant backs initiative between HSE and Parkrun on participation for those living with Dementia
Parkrun in Sligo and Leitrim are welcoming people living with Dementia, their families and carers to take part in their local runs. The HSE and Parkrun Ireland have recently launched a Dementia Friendly Parkrun Manual. The manual reflects Parkrun's ongoing commitment to removing barriers to participation and promoting physical, social, and mental wellbeing for all. Speaking about the initiative, Professor Paula Hickey, Consultant Geriatrician Sligo University Hospital said: 'I am delighted to support the Dementia Friendly Parkrun Manual. 'This is a valuable initiative to create a welcoming space for people living with dementia, their family, friends and carers. 'Maintaining an active life with social engagement is such a fundamental part of living well with dementia, this practical action can make a big difference and helps promote inclusive friendly communities.' Parkrun Ireland have been working with HSE Health and Wellbeing for many years supporting and driving engagement in physical activity. The new initiative is designed to make parkrun's across the country more welcoming and inclusive for people living with dementia. People with dementia or family members who are caring for a person with dementia may consider taking part or volunteering in their local parkrun as a good physical or social activity. Doing things with others and taking part in worthwhile activities can improve the quality of life of people living with dementia. It may also slow the development of dementia. Parkrun is a safe and friendly way to get regular activity. Whether walking, jogging or running - anyone can join in. Parkrun is a free weekly run, jog or walk for all, taking place on Saturday mornings at 9.30am. Its locations in Sligo and Leitrim are: Sligo Parkrun - Doorly Park, Cleveragh, Sligo Tubbercurry Trail Parkrun- Tubbercurry Trail, Ballina Rd, Rathscanlon, Tubbercurry, Co. Sligo Glenfarne Wood Parkrun- Glenfarne Wood, Moneyduff, Co. Leitrim. Ballinamore Greenway Parkrun- Ballinamore Greenway, Ballinamore, Co Leitrim. The manual is available to order free of charge from (direct link:
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
2,500 Carlow customers hit with boil water notice due to presence of E.coli
Uisce Éireann has issued a boil water notice for customers supplied by the Bagenalstown public water supply. The notice is being issued to protect the health of approximately 2,500 customers due to the presence of in a regulatory sample. can cause a variety of health issues such as diarrhea, stomach cramping, pain or tenderness and nausea and vomiting in some people. Customers impacted include those in Parc Muire, Bagenalstown town centre, Borris Road, Saint Bridget's Crescent, Father Cummins Park, Conway Park, The Long Range, Eastwood and surrounding areas. All customers on this supply are advised to boil water before use until further notice. Drinking water experts from Uisce Éireann are working to rectify the issues and lift the notice as quickly and as safely as possible, in consultation with the Health Service Executive (HSE). 'Public health is Uisce Éireann's number one priority and we would like to assure customers that the notice has been put in place to protect public health,' said Shane Aylward, spokesperson for Uisce Éireann. 'We acknowledge the inconvenience caused to homes and businesses and would like to assure customers that we are working to resolve the issue and lift the notice as quickly and as safely possible.' Water must be boiled for: Drinking Drinks made with water Preparation of salads and similar foods, which are not cooked prior to eating Brushing of teeth Making of ice. Discard ice cubes in fridges and freezers and filtered water in fridges. Make ice from cooled boiled water. What actions should be taken: Use water prepared for drinking when preparing foods that will not be cooked (e.g. washing salads) Water can be used for personal hygiene, bathing and flushing of toilets but not for brushing teeth or gargling Boil water by bringing to a vigorous, rolling boil (e.g. with an automatic kettle) and allow to cool. Cover and store in a refrigerator or cold place. Water from the hot tap is not safe to drink. Domestic water filters will not render water safe to drink Caution should be taken when bathing children to ensure that they do not swallow the bathing water Preparing Infant Formula: Where a Boil Water Notice is in place, you can prepare infant formula from tap water that has been boiled once (rolling boil for 1 minute) and cooled beforehand. Bottled water can also be used to make up infant formula. All bottled water, with the exception of natural mineral water, is regulated to the same standard as drinking water. It is best not to use bottled water labelled as 'Natural Mineral Water' as it can have high levels of sodium (salt) and other minerals, although it rarely does. 'Natural Mineral Water' can be used if no other water is available, for as short a time as possible, as it is important to keep babies hydrated. If bottled water is used to make up infant formula it should be boiled once (rolling boil for 1 minute and cooled in the normal way). Ready-to-use formula that does not need added water can also be used. Customers can check if their property is included by visiting the 'water quality section' of and entering the property's Eircode or by calling the Uisce Éireann's customer care helpline, open 24/7, on 1800 278 278.
