Monash IVF: Human error blamed for two embryo mix-ups but details kept secret

18 hours ago

A review into embryo mix-ups at Monash IVF clinics in two states has found that both incidents were the result of human error.
An independent review commissioned by the IVF giant into two cases of patients being implanted with the wrong embryos has found that although there were stark differences in the circumstances of the bungles at its Brisbane and Clayton clinics, human error was at the heart of both incidents.
The Clayton clinic in Melbourne where Monash IVF's second embryo bungle occurred. Credit: The Age
In an announcement to the Australian stock exchange on Wednesday, Monash IVF confirmed Fiona McLeod, SC, had completed her look at the incidents and made a range of recommendations that would be implemented.
The company initially commissioned McLeod to conduct an independent investigation on March 4, after revelations emerged in April that an embryo transfer error at its Brisbane facility resulted in a Queensland woman giving birth to a stranger's baby.

Hashtags

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

New $2 billion plan to shift kids with autism or development delays off NDIS could be ‘generational reform'

7NEWS

4 hours ago

7NEWS

New $2 billion plan to shift kids with autism or development delays off NDIS could be ‘generational reform'

Children with autism who rely on the NDIS for support will be diverted to a new program, touted by disability groups as a 'once-in-a-generation' reform. Disability Minister Mark Butler used a speech at the National Press Club on Wednesday to say the NDIS was not the right fit for the growing number of children on the autism spectrum or with developmental delays. WATCH THE VIDEO ABOVE: Government plans to shake up disability support for children. A separate program called Thriving Kids will be set up to focus on those children previously covered by the NDIS. It will begin rolling out from July 2026 and be fully implemented by July 2027. Children with autism on the NDIS would not be steered from the scheme until supports were fully rolled out, the minister said. 'I know this will be hard for some parents to hear and I don't say it lightly,' Butler said in the speech. 'We need as a matter of some urgency to create a better system that will enable our children to thrive. 'Diverting this group of kids over time from the NDIS is an important element of making the scheme sustainable and returning it to its original intent.' 'Once-in-a-generation change' Medicare items for occupational therapy, speech pathology and psychosocial therapy would be considered for the program, including a bulk-billed check-up for three-year-olds, Butler said. The federal government would start by making a $2 billion contribution, matched by states and territories. Early intervention strategies were key for ensuring children received the right support, Autism Awareness chief executive Nicole Rogerson said. '(Thriving Kids) potentially has the opportunity to be a once-in-a-generation change in how we look at developmental pediatrics,' she said. She said what Butler was doing was 'pretty rare for a politician' because he was 'owning what the problem is'. Rogerson told 7NEWS: 'The structural problem has become so big that children with any kind of developmental delay are now getting a label of autism, in order to get assistance from the NDIS and that's inflated the numbers.' Ensuring the program was in place before children were moved from the scheme was reassuring, People with Disability acting chief executive Megan Spindler-Smith said. 'That terrifies me' Since the announcement, many families have shared their concern. Australian mum Kaili Metani's daughters live with autism and she said the NDIS saved their lives. 'My youngest daughter was told when she was diagnosed that she would never walk or talk and it's only because of therapy that she is able to,' she told 7NEWS. She feared the new program, if not implemented correctly, would lead to a 'generation who are unsupported, and that terrifies me'. The minister said while one in 50 people had a significant disability which would be covered by the NDIS, one in five young children were on the autism spectrum or had a developmental delay. Parents had little choice but to put their children with autism on a scheme designed for permanent disability, Butler said. 'Families who were looking for additional supports in mainstream services can't find them because they largely don't exist anymore and in that, all governments have failed them,' he said. Butler said the changes would help to bring down the cost of the NDIS, with taxpayers set to fork out more than $52 billion for the scheme in 2025/26. Laws passed in 2024 put in place a cap on spending growth of eight per cent per year. 'Even under that scenario, the NDIS is still forecast to cost $105 billion and will increase its share of GDP by 0.5 per cent over the coming decade,' Butler said. 'That's the equivalent of growth in Medicare, defence and aged care spending combined — measured as a share of GDP.' The minister said the existing level of growth was unsustainable and a cap of between five and six per cent would be more effective. 'After we achieve our current target, a further wave of reform will be needed to get growth down to a more sustainable position,' he said. 'There's no significant change in disability prevalence in the community and the scheme is now fully rolled out. So growth should really reflect unit price inflation plus growth in Australia's population.' Autism peak body Aspect said families needed the right level of support. 'Given the number of autistic children we support through our schools and therapy programs, families must have confidence there will be continuity of supports, real choice and control, and no gaps during the transition,' chief executive Jacqui Borland said