State told to pay ₹1.25 lakh compensation to patients administered expired Hepatitis-B vaccines
The Commission, in its order dated July 4, also called for strict action against hospital authorities and a complete overhaul of medicine procurement and verification protocols in government hospitals.
The incident, which came to light through complaints filed in 2014 and 2015, involved 16 individuals who suffered adverse effects after being given expired vaccines at the hospital's Anti-Retroviral Therapy (ART) Centre of Excellence.
The complainants alleged that Dr. V. Tara Devi, a Research Fellow at the centre, administered the vaccines despite their expiry, leading to dizziness, stomach pain, drowsiness, and significant mental distress.
The THRC also took suo motu cognisance of a newspaper report published in 2015, which revealed irregularities in the hospital's medicine supply system. Its investigation found that the vaccines were indeed expired, and that the packaging displayed two conflicting expiry dates, one for the vaccine and another for the syringe. While hospital authorities claimed the administration was unintentional and blamed the manufacturer for the unclear labelling, the Commission rejected the explanation, holding the hospital accountable for failing in its basic and non-negotiable duty to verify expiry dates before drug administration.
The Commission found the hospital superintendent's report defending the act to be motivated by a desire to shield the hospital staff. It also dismissed the claim that the expired vaccines had low potency and were therefore harmless, calling it medically unfounded.
Justice Shameem Akther, Chairperson of the THRC, held that the victims' fundamental rights to health, dignity, and bodily integrity were violated. He noted that although Dr. Tara Devi had been suspended, disciplinary action alone was not sufficient to address the seriousness of the breach.
The Commission directed the Chief Secretary of Telangana to initiate proceedings against all responsible officials, including the hospital's Superintendent and supervising staff. It further asked the government to ensure that expired or nearly expired drugs are not accepted at any government-run healthcare facility. Suppliers must be made to print clear and prominent expiry dates on both the outer wrapper and internal containers of all medical supplies. The State government has been given two months from the date of the order to implement the recommendations in full.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
11 hours ago
- The Hindu
All patients to register with ABHA ID, says NMC to all medical colleges and institutes
To ensure that authentic patient records are maintained by medical colleges, the National Medical Commission (NMC) has written to them directing that Ayushman Bharat Health Account (ABHA) ID should be recorded along with patient registration in the hospital. The ABHA card contains a unique 14-digit identification number called ABHA ID. The entire medical history, consultation details, and prescriptions are included in the ABHA ID. However, NMC maintained that no patient should be denied treatment without the ABHA lD. For authentic records In its letter to the dean/principals of all medical colleges and institutes under NMC, the body noted that the intent is to ensure availability of authentic records of patients and the clinical material in the associated hospital of the medical college. However, it has been noticed that this requirement is not being followed by all medical colleges and for all patients. As per the latest directive, colleges shall maintain the records of all patients. 'All in-patient records should have the entry of the unit faculty and senior residents with their name and signature authenticating that they have admitted and seen the patient. All investigative reports should be signed by a faculty in the corresponding department. Verification of the authenticity may be conducted by the NMC as part of the assessments. If at any point of time, the patient records are found to be fake; action shall be taken against the concerned faculty and the college/institute,' NMC said, adding that the move was decided in the Commission (NMC) 14th meeting held recently. All medical colleges are now required to ensure that ABHA lD be mentioned as a prerequisite for registration of patients visiting for the OPD/ IPD/ emergency services in hospitals attached to them. Additionally, all patients must have registration done with the ABHA lD in addition to the hospital's registration number, the letter noted. 'The Commission has endorsed a strong need to have authentication of patients and other clinical material in the hospital for decision on the prospects of a college (increased seats in UG or PG, new college, annual renewal of permission/recognition to admit students). The creation of ABHA lD is a very simple process and can be facilitated conveniently with the possession of Aadhaar card that has already been extended to people on a large scale,' the letters stated.
India Today
19 hours ago
- India Today
Liver cancer cases to double by 2050: Mega study reveals how to lower the burden
Liver cancer is one of the world's most common and deadly forms of cancer. It is currently the sixth most common cancer and the third leading cause of cancer-related deaths have now predicted that the number of new liver cancer cases could almost double by 2050, if nothing is done to control it, according to a latest study published in The 2022, around 8.7 lakh new cases of liver cancer were recorded worldwide. If current trends continue, that number may reach 1.52 crore (15.2 million) by 2050. The most common type of liver cancer is hepatocellular carcinoma, which makes up about 80% of all liver cancer tackle this growing health crisis, a group of doctors, public health experts, and researchers came together to find ways to reduce the number of new expert group looked at past data, conducted detailed studies, and even created models to understand how the disease might spread in the of the most important findings from their work is that to stop liver cancer cases from rising, the world needs to reduce new cases by at least 2% every areas where progress has already started, the researchers say we should aim even higher — at a 5% yearly this 2–5% annual drop is achieved and maintained over the next 25 years, the benefits could be study estimates that between 88 lakh to 1.73 crore (8.8 to 17.3 million) new cases of liver cancer could be avoided. More importantly, between 77 lakh to 1.51 crore (7.7 to 15.1 million) lives could be to the researchers, the study helps nations understand that major risk factors such as viral hepatitis, alcohol consumption and obesity need to be dealt with if they want to see lower cases of liver authors said that an increased public, medical and political awareness on the rising risk of fatty liver conditions, with a focus on people having diabetes and obesity, especially in the US, Europe and Asia, is hope that there are intensified efforts to increase vaccination drives against hepatitis B and C along with policies to restrict the consumption of alcohol."We estimated that at least 60% of liver cancers are preventable via control of modifiable risk factors, including (hepatitis B virus), (hepatitis C virus), metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease, and alcohol," the report expert group hopes this new information will push countries to take liver cancer more seriously and act quickly to prevent it from becoming an even bigger global health problem.- EndsMust Watch
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
HC takes stock of Mahaprayan scheme at SCB
Cuttack: Orissa high court took stock of the ailing Mahaprayan scheme at SCB Medical College and Hospital (SCBMCH), Cuttack, following media reports that both designated vehicles for transporting bodies had become non-functional forcing grieving families to depend on costly private options. Launched by the Odisha govt to provide free and dignified transportation of the dead from govt hospitals, the Mahaprayan scheme was aimed at helping economically weaker sections. However, the scheme's execution at SCBMCH has drawn criticism for its poor upkeep and delayed response. A division bench of Justice S K Sahoo and Justice V Narasingh reviewed the matter on July 25, following reports that the two Mahaprayan vehicles operated by the Red Cross were allegedly lying defunct — one damaged in an accident and the other abandoned. The report highlighted that, in the absence of these vehicles, families were forced to transport bodies on trolley rickshaws or hire private ambulances at high rates. Prof. Dr. Goutam Satapathy, superintendent of SCBMCH, appeared in the virtual mode in the court and submitted a status report. According to the report, one vehicle was damaged in an accident on Nov 29, 2024. The repair estimate was received on Dec 30, 2024, and subsequently certified by the Motor Vehicle Inspector (MVI). by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo The hospital requested funds from the emergency officer, Cuttack, on Jan 17, 2025, and the general administration & public grievance (GA & PG) department sanctioned the amount from the Chief Minister's Relief Fund (CMRF). The vehicle is currently under repair and expected to be operational soon. The second vehicle remained in service until July 16, 2025, before requiring replacement of four tyres and the battery after logging over 1.1 lakh km. On July 11, 2025, the emergency officer was requested to replace the necessary parts in consultation with the regional transport office (RTO), Cuttack. The replacements have since been made, and the vehicle is now back in operation. Taking the developments on record, the bench closed the hearing but not before underlining the need for regular maintenance and timely intervention to ensure uninterrupted services under the Mahaprayan scheme.
