Call for CNMI leaders to fight back on high airfares
Photo:
Supplied / United Airlines
Former Northern Mariana Islands lawmaker Edwin K. Propst taken to social media to urge leaders to "go to war" with United Airlines over what he claims are exorbitant airfares between Saipan and Guam.
The call to action comes amid renewed efforts to reinstate the Essential Air Service program in the CNMI and push for a cabotage exemption.
"Attention all leaders of the Marianas in the public and private sector, it is time to go to war with this airline," Propst wrote.
The former representative, who now works at the CNMI broadband policy and development office, shared his frustration after attempting to book a four-day roundtrip ticket from Guam to Saipan in June - to find the lowest available fare was US$767.
"For a 25-minute flight?!
"They have just made record-breaking profits and instead of rewarding their customers, they increase their prices."
Propst called the airfares "devastating" to the local economy and tourism.
The CNMI is currently seeking exemption from federal cabotage restrictions, which bar foreign airlines from operating domestic routes between US territories such as Guam and the CNMI.
Governor Arnold Palacios mentioned this effort during his State of the Commonwealth Address, saying he had "actively advocated for potential cabotage waiver [and] essential air services" in recent talks with federal agencies and congressional leaders.
Palacios emphasized the importance of improved regional connectivity to support the CNMI's tourism-dependent economy.
Senate public utilities, transportation and communications committee chair, Senator Jude Hofschneider called Propst's complaints a "sad reality of economic times," adding that United's pricing is "likely a business decision by the air carrier".
Still, Hofschneider said the moment calls for greater support of Congresswoman Kimberlyn King-Hinds' bill introduced in April to requalify CNMI airports for the Essential Air Service (EAS) program. If passed, the measure would allow federal subsidies to fund daily round-trip flights even if commercial carriers withdraw service.
A quote from CWM Travel International showed a Saipan-Guam roundtrip departing 8 June 8 and returning 12 June costing $420 - significantly cheaper than Propst's booking but still high for an inter-island flight.
The EAS program, created in 1978 and stripped from CNMI eligibility in 2012, was intended to preserve air access for small US communities.
King-Hinds' bill seeks to restore eligibility to Saipan, Tinian, and Rota by placing CNMI alongside Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico in exemption status.
United Airlines has not responded to requests for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
CNMI Senate president proposes amendment to allow cash dividends for indigenous voters
Saipan in the Northern Marianas. Photo: Supplied Senate president Dennis James Mendiola has introduced a legislative initiative that could result in direct cash payouts to registered voters of Northern Marianas descent. He proposes what he described as a long-overdue return on investment from public land revenues. Senate Legislative Initiative No. 24-01 seeks to amend the CNMI Constitution to authorize the distribution of monetary dividends to registered Northern Marianas descent (NMD) voters, from earnings generated by the Marianas Public Land Trust (MLPT), which manages funds derived from the lease of public lands. "This is just the start of the conversation," Mendiola said in an interview. "For years, we've said public lands belong to NMDs. But outside of constitutional protections, there's been no direct economic return. This initiative changes that." To be eligible, recipients must be both of Northern Marianas descent and registered voters - a dual requirement Mendiola said was intentional to encourage civic participation and ensure a fair and transparent process. "We want the beneficiaries themselves to vote on it," he said. The initiative proposes the creation of a Northern Marianas descent dividend program, beginning with a one-time distribution of US$30 million to $50 million from the land trust's investment corpus. Future distributions would occur every ten years and be subject to legislative appropriation, in coordination with the land trust and the Commonwealth Election Commission. Mendiola emphasized that the payout mechanism is designed to be sustainable. MPLT currently generates roughly US$3 million to $3.5 million annually in investment income, and the proposed 10-year cycle would allow time to replenish the fund before the next disbursement. "This is not a one-and-done deal," he said. "We've built in the timeline so the trust remains solvent and continues to grow." Because the proposal seeks to amend the CNMI Constitution, the measure must go through a multi-step process. First, it will be referred to the appropriate Senate committee, which will schedule public hearings on Saipan, Tinian, and Rota. If cleared by the committee, it returns to the Senate floor for a vote. To move forward, the initiative must be approved by three-fourths of the members in both the Senate and the House of Representatives. Commonwealth Election Commission. Photo: RNZ Pacific / Mark Rabago If it garners that level of legislative support, the proposed amendment is then forwarded to the Commonwealth Election Commission, which will place it on the ballot for a public vote during the next general election or a special election. Only if a majority of voters approve the measure will it become part of the CNMI Constitution and carry the force of law. While many residents welcomed the news on social media, some expressed skepticism. Critics questioned the long-term sustainability of the plan and raised concerns that the initiative may draw legal challenges over discrimination. "I refuse to sit back and keep worrying about theoretical lawsuits," Mendiola responded. "The Constitution is clear - MPLT funds exist for NMDs. If challenged, maybe this will finally bring clarity on the scope of protections under our covenant." He added that estimates of how much an individual could receive under the proposal vary depending on the final list of eligible recipients. Preliminary figures suggest dividends could range from $1,000 to $2,000 per person in the first round. "This isn't about politics - it's about economic justice," Mendiola said. "Our people are struggling. This puts money back into homes and boosts the local economy." The Senate President urged the NMD community to take part in the public input process as the proposal moves through the legislative pipeline. "Whether you support it or not, I encourage everyone to come out, ask questions, and help shape what could be a historic shift in how we recognize and reward our indigenous landowners," he said.
RNZ News
13 hours ago
- RNZ News
Govt injects a further $13 million into tourism
money economy 26 minutes ago The government's making another pitch to get tourists to come here, with a $13 million investment. Mackenzie District Council acting mayor Karen Morgan spoke to Corin Dann.
RNZ News
14 hours ago
- RNZ News
Nature, not geopolitics, remains region's biggest threat
Photo: supplied The top military affairs official in the CNMI said that while geopolitical tensions continue to make headlines, the region's most immediate and consistent threat remains environmental. "Mother Nature is still our biggest threat out here," said Edward Camacho, special assistant to the CNMI governor for military affairs. "We deal with typhoons, tsunamis, earthquakes, volcanic eruptions - you name it." Camacho made the remarks during an extended interview last week, highlighting how military activity - despite being framed as a response to rising tensions in the Indo-Pacific - is also about readiness in the face of natural disasters and operational necessity. He said the Commonwealth Bureau of Military Affairs, which he leads, plays a key coordinating role in all US Department of Defense-related activity in the Northern Marianas, ranging from military exercises to the divert airfield project on Tinian and upgrades at airports and seaports throughout the islands. "There is no plan for permanent basing here. What we're seeing is a focus on rotational training," Camacho said. "The US military needs places to train - land, air, and sea. And the CNMI provides strategic value on all fronts." While military activity is seen as a potential lifeline for the CNMI's struggling economy, Camacho was candid about the limited economic benefits trickling down to local businesses. "We're talking about close to US$500 million in activity in one year alone," he said. "But the reality is most of those contracts are awarded to off-island companies. So, much of that money leaves the Commonwealth." Camacho called it a form of "capital flight" that undermines the long-term economic promise of military investment. "We see the impacts at the surface level - hotels, restaurants, car rentals, and catering companies do get a boost - but those are peanuts compared to what's leaving." Read more: He urged better enforcement of CNMI tax laws to ensure that companies doing business in the territory pay their fair share. "If you're building airfields or infrastructure here, you should be registered here, paying BGRT here, and following our laws," he said. "That's what makes us different - we're not just a US state, but we're not foreign either. We have our own Constitution." Camacho added that his office has been working closely with the Department of Defense to flag concerns over compliance and keep military partners informed of local requirements. Asked whether military activity could realistically replace tourism as the CNMI's primary economic driver, Camacho said it could serve as a significant supplement - but not a guaranteed substitute. "We've seen economic anchors come and go . Garments left. Casinos collapsed. Tourism is still uncertain. So even military activity, as consistent as it seems now, isn't permanent," he said. However, Camacho acknowledged that the CNMI's renewed strategic value - especially with the US Indo-Pacific Strategy gaining momentum - puts the islands in a stronger position than in previous decades. "During the Cold War, we were needed. Then we were forgotten. Now we're needed again. My hope is that even when things cool down, the military doesn't forget us this time." The Northern Marianas leaders announced a slight increase in revenue collections in the 2024 financial year. Photo: supplied Camacho also previewed an upcoming public forum tied to the release of the new draft environmental impact statement (EIS) for proposed military training activities in the CNMI. The draft EIS covers activities particularly focused on Tinian and also includes use of the former Voice of America site on Saipan. The latter may serve as an alternate range control station to prevent conflicts between military and commercial air traffic. "We want transparency. The public will have a chance to review the draft and submit comments," Camacho said. In response to a newly announced Pentagon policy limiting frequent duty station changes for military personnel, Camacho said the move could benefit the CNMI by fostering institutional knowledge. "If you keep changing out commanders every two years, you spend a lot of time retraining them. If you have someone who stays longer, they get to understand the community, the environment, and how we do things," he said. While acknowledging concerns that longer assignments could lead to entrenched influence, Camacho emphasized that stability is key for continuity and trust in places like the CNMI. "We're not trying to teach a new admiral how things work every two years," he said. "We need people who understand the dynamics of this region."
