Ryan Murphy's JFK Jr., Carolyn Bessette first look slammed by critics
Ryan Murphy has his work cut out for him.
The 'American Horror Story' creator, 59, took to Instagram over the weekend to share a first look at the actors portraying John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy in his upcoming 'American Love Story' anthology series.
'Here are some stills from our LOVE STORY camera test,' Murphy wrote on Saturday, June 14. 'We started shooting this week in New York City and can't wait until you see the romantic and tragic love story between America's prince, JFK Jr., and fashion icon Carolyn Bessette.'
Advertisement
10 Ryan Murphy took to Instagram to share a first look at the actors portraying John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy in his upcoming 'American Love Story' series.
Instagram/@ryanmurphyproductions
10 But not everybody was impressed by the first look at Murphy's 'American Love Story.'
Getty Images
He then introduced fans to Paul Kelly (JFK Jr.) and Sarah Pidgeon (CBK).
Advertisement
'I am thrilled to introduce you to Sarah Pidgeon as Carolyn and Paul Kelly as John F. Kennedy Jr,' Murphy continued. 'Over a thousand actors auditioned for each of these roles, and we absolutely found the perfect choices.'
However, not everybody was impressed by the first look at 'American Love Story,' and some fans slammed the 'Glee' producer for his surprising casting and costume design choices.
10 Paul Kelly has been cast as JFK Jr. and Sarah Pidgeon will portray CBK.
Instagram/@ryanmurphyproductions
10 'There was nobody else who could play Carolyn?!' one disappointed person wrote.
Getty Images
Advertisement
'There was nobody else who could play Carolyn?!' one disappointed commenter wrote alongside the eight stills of Kelly as JFK Jr. and Pidgeon as CBK.
'She would never wear this,' another responded after seeing Pideon dressed in a leather overcoat, a black sweater, trousers and pointed-toe heels.
'Her blonde hair is all wrong,' wrote a third fan. 'She was famous for the varying blonde tones, the highlights and lowlights. It should be warmer. Not platinum. Please try again.'
10 Paul Kelly as JFK Jr. in 'American Love Story.'
Instagram/@ryanmurphyproductions
Advertisement
10 'JFK Jr was gorgeous, this guy is average,' a critic wrote.
Getty Images
Other fans were equally disappointed to see how Murphy had Kelly portray JFK Jr. in the first look at 'American Love Story.'
'Her yes, him no,' one critic wrote. 'JFK Jr was gorgeous, this guy is average.'
'Usually the actors are better looking than the real people,' another JFK Jr. and CBK fan tweeted. 'The opposite is true here. Both are not good looking enough as the real people. How sad!'
'I think maybe Ryan Murphy should be stopped,' added a third, while a fourth commented, 'Ryan needs to take a break, seriously.'
10 Sarah Pidgeon as Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy in 'American Love Story.'
Instagram/@ryanmurphyproductions
10 Other fans praised Kelly as JFK Jr. and Pidgeon as CBK.
Getty Images
However, some fans praised Kelly as the political prince and Pidgeon as the '90s fashion icon.
Advertisement
'Casting looks great,' someone wrote on Murphy's post. 'In terms of look-alikes, Elizabeth Debicki would've also been a great choice.'
'Wow, I knew who they were before even reading the caption,' added another impressed viewer.
While 'American Love Story' was first announced in 2021, it wasn't until September 2024 that Murphy revealed the first installment would chronicle JFK Jr. and CBK's whirlwind romance.
10 Paul Kelly as JFK Jr. in 'American Love Story.'
Instagram/@ryanmurphyproductions
Advertisement
10 'American Love Story' will chronicle the rise and tragic fall of JFK Jr. and CBK's whirlwind romance.
Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images
JFK Jr., who was the only son of President John F. Kennedy and former First Lady Jackie Kennedy, first met Bessette in 1992. Bessette was working for Calvin Klein at the time and was tasked with giving the political scion a tour and fitting.
The pair married in September 1996.
Advertisement
Three years later, JFK Jr. and CBK both died when their private plane crashed off the coast of Massachusetts during a flight from New Jersey to Martha's Vineyard in July 1999.
Besides Kelly and Pidgeon, 'American Love Story' will also star Naomi Watts (Jackie Kennedy), Grace Gummer (Caroline Kennedy), Sydney Lemmon (Lauren Bessette) and Alessandro Nivola (Calvin Klein).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
24 minutes ago
- USA Today
Michael Weatherly's 'NCIS: Tony & Ziva' spinoff finally gets premiere date
Michael Weatherly's 'NCIS: Tony & Ziva' spinoff finally gets premiere date Show Caption Hide Caption 'Tony and Ziva' trailer has Michael Weatherly, Cote de Pable on 'NCIS' The first "NCIS: Tony & Ziva" teaser drops with views of reunited Michael Weatherly and Cote de Pablo running for their lives in style and in Europe. There are official corporate announcements of TV show premieres, and then there's Michael Weatherly's way. Weatherly, 56, seems to have forgotten his shirt when posting a video to his Instagram account on June 17, to declare when "NCIS: Tony & Ziva" will premiere on Paramount+, co-starring Cote de Pablo. "There it is, I see it, it's coming Sept. 4," the unshaven Weatherly says to the camera with a cheeky smile during the informative yet nonsensical video. Weatherly added in the comments, "It's like the fine wine people think must be appropriate, and timing, the decanting and ultimately the perfect setting." To be fair, a fully and nattily dressed Weatherly, along with de Pablo, posted a video on the Paramount+ Instagram account announcing the premiere date earlier on June 17. It was a Save the Date message that showed the actors back in full-banter form. "That's my line, you always take my line," De Pablo lamented at one point. When does 'NCIS: Tony and Ziva' return? To quote Weatherly, "NCIS: Tony & Ziva" comes to Paramount+ on Sept. 4. The first trailer shows Tony DiNozzo (Weatherly) and Ziva David (de Pablo) still have that perfect sizzle in the "NCIS" reunion series. The couple briefly lives the dream in Paris, running their security firm while caring for their 12-year-old daughter, Tali (Isla Gie). But their happily ever after is blown apart, sending the family on the run throughout Europe in the action series.
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Anne Burrell was ‘keeping an eye out' for the Green Lady of Brooklyn in sad final photo before death
Celebrity chef Anne Burrell lived her life to the fullest up until the very end. Just five days before the Food Network star passed away on Tuesday, June 17, at the age of 55, Burrell took to Instagram to share what would be her final post – and it included a familiar face. 'I ran into [the Green Lady of Brooklyn] in my neighborhood today!' she wrote on June 12 alongside a photo of her and NYC fixture Elizabeth Eaton Rosenthal. 'I'm not going to lie – I have been keeping an eye out for her.' 6 Anne Burrell's last Instagram post before her shocking death on Tuesday included the celebrity chef with NYC fixture the Green Lady of Brooklyn. chefanneburrell/Instagram 6 'I'm not going to lie – I have been keeping an eye out for her,' Burrell wrote alongside the picture of her and her 'lovely' new friend. Getty Images for PFLAG 'I may or may not have followed her down the street for a minute,' Burrell added. 'She is just lovely!!!' Rosenthal, 84, earned the nickname Green Lady of Brooklyn because she has been devoted to only wearing the color green for over 20 years. Rosenthal responded to Burrell's Instagram post one day later to say that it 'was so much fun meeting' the celebrity chef. 6 The Food Network star sadly passed away on Tuesday, June 17, at the age of 55. Bloomberg via Getty Images She also invited the 'Worst Cooks in America' co-host over to her garden to pick figs. 'Hi Anne, it was so much fun meeting you, see you again soon in the neighborhood, the only thing I make is coffee and fig preserves from my fig tree, love and hugs,' the Green Lady of Brooklyn wrote with several green heart emojis. 'Hi Anne,' Rosenthal added on Sunday, 'I would like to invite you to my garden and pick figs when they are ready, usually beginning to ripen beginning September, and come and visit the garden on a sunny day anyway.' 6 Burrell's loved ones confirmed the news in a statement. Brian Zak/Page Six Rosenthal, who is also known as Elizabeth Sweetheart, returned to Burrell's Instagram page once more on Tuesday following the devastating news of the celeb chef's sudden passing. 'Hi Anne,' she wrote, 'you are such a lovely person just to meet and not knowing you, I just love you and so sorry but come to my garden and visit with all your beauty and love and I will be waiting for you.' Burrell sadly passed away at her home in Brooklyn on Tuesday morning. Her family confirmed the shocking news in a statement to People, but the cause of death was not immediately revealed. 6 The beloved 'Worst Cooks in America' co-host's cause of death was not immediately revealed. Getty Images for NYCWFF 'Anne was a beloved wife, sister, daughter, stepmother, and friend — her smile lit up every room she entered,' Burrell's loved ones shared. 'Anne's light radiated far beyond those she knew, touching millions across the world,' they added. 'Though she is no longer with us, her warmth, spirit, and boundless love remain eternal.' The Food Network also remembered Burrell in a touching statement to The Post. 'Anne was a remarkable person and culinary talent – teaching, competing and always sharing the importance of food in her life and the joy that a delicious meal can bring,' a representative for the network said. 6 The Food Network remembered Burrell as a 'remarkable person and culinary talent' in a statement to The Post. NBCU Photo Bank/NBCUniversal via Getty Images 'Our thoughts are with Anne's family, friends and fans during this time of tremendous loss,' they added. Burrell is survived by her husband, Stuart Claxton, his son, Javier, her mother, Marlena, her sister, Jane, and her brother, Ben.
Cosmopolitan
an hour ago
- Cosmopolitan
Pamela Anderson debuts a textured French bob haircut – and it's the trend of summer 2025
Looking for a new summer hairstyle? Look no further than the French bob à la Pamela Anderson. It's chic, it's airy and above all, it's super low-maintenance. Thanks, Pam! The actor's brand new haircut in question dropped via Harper's Bazaar UK's most recent July/August issue. Pam dons the magazine cover wearing a crisp white shirt, sparkling jewels and most importantly, the jaw-length hairstyle. Beauty-wise, it also appears that Pam is staying true to her diversion from makeup – a decision she made at the beginning of 2023. "I think that with AI technology and filters, people are becoming kind of boring-looking. I want to challenge beauty norms," she says in the Harper's Bazaar interview. "I've always been a rebel. I never see somebody and think, 'I want to look like that.' I just want to see who I am. A some point, you have to say, 'This is all I've got.' Surrender to it. And it's real happiness. It's freedom to know you can walk on a red carpet without a stitch of make-up on. I mean, why can't I? Men do it all the time." Hear, hear! Now, if, like Pamela, you're looking to challenge beauty norms with a shorter, more rebellious hairstyle, we've got the details on how you can achieve it. As its name suggests, the French bob draws inspiration from the Parisian chic look; "It's that effortlessly cool, jaw-skimming cut that just screams Parisian chic," Samantha Cusick, Contributing Cosmopolitan expert and professional hairstylist, previously told Cosmopolitan UK. "It's short, sharp and always looks like you've made zero effort (in the best way)." But what differentiates it from its bob counterparts? Well, the length! "It's all about that blunt jaw-length chop," Sam says. "Sometimes you'll see a bit of subtle layering to give it some movement, but the shape is what really makes it." Think: sharp and thick yet still loose and airy. And we predict the French bob is going to be *big* this summer. Humidity hair? Embrace the frizz bby! Wavy hair types work great with bobs that are designed to be worn with movement. Anything flipped over or where flicks or texture is desired is ideal for achieving the French bob look. So, what are you waiting for? Make like Pam Anderson with a French bob for S/S25! Follow Lia on Instagram. Lia Mappoura (she/her) is the Beauty Writer at Cosmopolitan UK. Covering everything from viral celebrity hair and makeup news to the latest trend predictions, she's an expert in recognising the season's next big beauty look (before it ends up all over your social media feeds). You'll usually find her putting TikTok's recent beauty hacks to the Hype Test, challenging the gender-makeup binary and social stereotypes, or fangirling over the time Kourtney Kardashian viewed her Instagram Story (yes, it's true). Find her also on LinkedIn.
