Smartphone bans have little to no impact on education or bullying, study finds
Smartphone bans have little or no impact on education, online bullying and wellbeing among students, according to a study by Dublin City University (DCU).
Last week, new national guidance was issued to schools on restricting mobile phone use.
Primary schools now require a policy to ban the use of and access to mobile phones during the school day, while secondary schools require a policy to restrict mobile phone use during the school day.
€9 million in funding has been allocated for schools to look at a range of storage storage solutions including lockable boxes, cubby holes or drop-off and collection at the school office.
It followed opposition criticism of a plan to fund "phone pouches" across secondary schools.
Researchers from DCU's Anti-Bullying Centre found that the stricter the phone ban, the more students look for ways to subvert it.
A report published on Wednesday looked at existing international research as well as a new Irish study on the experiences of students.
In the DCU report, researchers examined existing international research on smartphone bans and related research on smartphones among children and adolescents.
It finds that that international research is "clearly mixed and somewhat conflicting", with most studies showing that smartphone ban policies can have "little or no impact on education and wellbeing among students" in different countries.
The study finds that no current research can be said to definitively demonstrate that smartphone bans completely protect children and adolescents from online bullying or harmful content.
The Anti-Bullying Centre is also recommending that online safety and digital citizenship education should be a compulsory topic in schools.
Researchers also conducted focus groups in six schools in the east of the country.
Students reported that they were not taught enough in school about online safety and digital citizenship, leading them instead to rely on their peers for guidance and skills.
Some pupils also reported that teachers cause distractions to the learning environment with their phone use.
Others were concerned that smartphone bans may inhibit students from learning resilience and skills for life beyond school.
The report also found that students' voices have not been included in decision-making on smartphone restrictions within schools.
Lead author of the report, Dr Megan Reynolds, said: "Our research shows that we need to listen to students on issues that directly impact them and ensure that they are included in the decision-making process regarding policies on smartphone bans and related issues.
"My hope is that this research will allow adolescents to finally have their voices heard and it will provide an opportunity for more nuanced conversations on smartphones."
Director of DCU Anti-Bullying Centre and Unesco chair on Bullying and Cyberbullying, Professor James O'Higgins Norman, added: "Students have also indicated that there are more pressing issues for students than smartphones in schools that they believe require action, including vaping."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Ireland's universities among most improved in the world as Trinity retains top place in country's rankings
Trinity College Dublin (TCD) retained its place as Ireland's top institution in the QS World University Rankings for 2026, improving its overall ranking from 87th last year to 75th. University College Dublin (UCD) was ranked 118th, up from 126th a year ago, followed by University College Cork (UCC), up to 246th from 273rd, and the University of Galway, which fell to 284th from 273rd. The University of Limerick, Dublin City University (DCU), the University of Maynooth and the Technological University of Dublin (TUD) made up the rest of the eight Irish universities included in the rankings. Seven of the eight improved on their ranking from a year ago, making Ireland the most-improved country in Europe and the second-most improved in the world, trailing Azerbaijan. This edition of the QS rankings also marks the first time every ranked Irish university has been included in the world's top 800. Further and Higher Education Minister James Lawless said third-level institutions 'play a vital role in delivering education and research' in Ireland. 'This work has been and continues to be pivotal to the success of our country as a knowledge-driven economy,' he said. Their achievements reflect the strength of our higher education system 'I congratulate the institutions that have improved their standing in this year's QS university rankings. 'Their achievements reflect the strength of our higher education system and reinforce Ireland's global reputation for academic excellence and cutting-edge research. 'This progress also reflects the significant investment this Government has made in higher education in recent years, supporting our ambition to build a world-class, innovative and inclusive system that delivers for all.' TCD ranked in the top 100 globally in three indicators: academic reputation, international faculty and graduate outcomes. UCD landed in the top 100 for graduate outcomes and in the top 50 for sustainability, where it was ranked 49th. After rising into the global top 250, UCC also improved in academic reputation, employer reputation and citations per faculty. The University of Oxford was in fourth place, down from third At the top of the rankings, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) retained the number one spot it has held since 2012. In second place was Imperial College London, the same spot it earned last year. The University of Oxford was in fourth place, down from third, and Harvard University was in fifth, down from fourth. QS senior vice-president Ben Sowter said: 'Ireland's outstanding results in the 2026 QS World University Rankings are testament to the dedication of academics, administrators and students across the eight universities from the country included in the ranking. 'The Government has been clear in its ambitions to make Ireland a first-choice destination for international learners in its Global Citizens 2030 Talent and Innovation Strategy and, with every university improving in the international student indicator, the country's campuses are increasingly open and diverse.'
Irish Independent
11 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Man diagnosed with Mpox in Ireland despite being vaccinated, scientists reveal
A middle-aged man was diagnosed with the Mpox virus even though he was fully vaccinated, research published today by Irish scientists shows.
The Irish Sun
19 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
UK waters could see surge in shark numbers scientists say, as they seek out new habitats
BRITISH waters could soon see a surge in shark species as they seek out new habitats, scientists say. These include increasing numbers of basking and spurdog sharks - which can grow up to 1.6 metres - and thornbacks, a type of stingray with spines. Advertisement 2 Basking sharks are expected to thrive further in British waters Credit: Getty 2 The sharks, pictured here close to a Scottish Highland coast, can grow to 32ft Credit: Graham Campbell Scientists have mapped out how those at threat of extinction will migrate for a better chance of survival as sea temperatures rise. The research - undertaken by the Centre for Environment, Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (Cefas) - showed native oysters will be amongst the biggest winners. Experts say mobile species will cope best, but static creatures could struggle to adapt - with fears the sea pen could lose as much as 40 percent of their habitat by the end of the century. The ocean quahog, a type of clam that can live more than 500 years, is also predicted to find it harder to adapt. Advertisement Read more news Bryony Townhill, marine scientist at Cefas, told "Any changes that we see in our seas are particularly impactful." She added that movement of the 19 species could result in bigger catches for fishermen in coastal communities. I went to see basking sharks off Irish coast and I can't believe how lucky I was Professor John Pinnegar, director of the Cefas Marine Climate Change Centre, said the biggest surprise from the findings was the possibility of native oysters thriving. Advertisement Most read in The Sun "They've been declining and disappearing for 100 years - and yet the climate model suggests they should be doing fine and perhaps even thriving," he explained. Prof Pinnegar said although there is potential for new habitats, the vulnerable species still need protecting from the likes of fishing equipment, disease and pollution. Basking sharks are the second-largest living shark after the whale shark, and can grow up to 10 metres, or 32ft. They are not, however, a threat to humans, and live on plankton. Advertisement
