Fine witnesses who mislead select committees, MP urges
Mark Pritchard warned that witnesses 'get away with it' if they provide inaccurate evidence and statements.
According Parliament's rulebook Erskine May, the Commons has not imposed a fine in 359 years, since 1666, the year the Great Fire of London broke out.
'Of course, there is the ministerial code, there are the Nolan Principles, and there is the contempt of Parliament procedures, but there hasn't been a fine since that time,' Mr Pritchard told the Commons.
'And for members and non-members alike, what is the deterrent? What is the incentive, even, for telling the truth to this place?
'Ministers of course can be brought back to the House, correct the record, but people giving evidence to select committees? There really is a gap at the moment.
'Isn't it time we put fines on a statutory basis for members and non-members alike so that we can always be assured that people are incentivised to tell the truth, and have a deterrent should they be tempted not to tell the truth?'
Commons Leader Lucy Powell said Mr Pritchard had raised a 'very, very serious issue'.
She added that there are 'many, many ways for members to hold ministers account', including by raising points of order, asking questions, and making complaints through a standards procedure.
Conservative MP Mr Pritchard later told the PA news agency: 'The current sanctions for ministers and MPs work quite well, but for non-member witnesses giving evidence to Parliament, the sanctions are weak to non-existent.
'Fines for contempt before a select committee, for example, need to be put on a statutory footing.
'This will act as both a deterrent and incentive for all public officials and external witnesses who might be tempted, on the rarest of occasions, to mislead Parliament whilst giving evidence before any of Parliament's committees.'
The Wrekin MP added: 'Currently, anyone apart from members and ministers can lie to Parliament, if they were so tempted, and get away with it.
'That is a significant gap in Parliament's powers to scrutinise.
'Other Parliaments have considerably more powers than Westminster to sanction anyone who lies to the legislature.'
New Zealand's House of Representatives is one such Parliament, where its members can agree to fine people up to 1,000 US dollars for contempt.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
Trump gets down to business with trade talks after round of golf at Scotland resort
Donald Trump commenced a five-day private visit to Scotland, starting with a round of golf at his Turnberry resort. He is set to meet European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen on Sunday for discussions on the trading relationship between Europe and the US. Further talks are scheduled with Sir Keir Starmer on Monday, expected to focus on trade issues, including potential tariff reductions for British steel. Trump will also meet Scottish First Minister John Swinney, who plans to address global and humanitarian concerns, notably the suffering in Gaza. The visit has seen significant security operations, and while no protesters were present during his golf game, demonstrations occurred in Edinburgh and Aberdeen.
Telegraph
29 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Stablecoins: the next big financial crisis waiting to happen
Financial deregulation is once again all the rage. In the search for that ever more elusive commodity, economic growth, even Rachel Reeves, the Chancellor, has caught the bug. Excessive regulation is 'a boot on the neck of business, choking off the enterprise and innovation that is the lifeblood of economic growth', she declared in her recent Mansion House speech. The pendulum has swung too far in favour of stamping out risk. You could almost see the annoyance on the face of Andrew Bailey, the Governor of the Bank of England, seated beside her. In remarks last week to MPs, he confirmed that beyond a few tweaks of little significance, he was dead set against tearing up the regulatory reforms that came out of the global financial crisis. He is right to be concerned. Almost all major financial crises are strongly associated with deregulation and the 'financial innovation' that inevitably follows in its wake. Take the Depression-era Glass-Steagall restrictions in the US, which enforced separation of investment from retail banking. There was no banking crisis of systemic importance as long as they remained in force. But at the turn of the century, Glass-Steagall was repealed, and within a decade finance had once again blown up the world economy. It is admittedly debatable whether lifting Glass-Steagall of itself had much to do with it. Nonetheless, it was symbolic of a much wider pattern of financial deregulation that was to fuel such stars of the following credit bubble as the 'collateralised debt obligation'. These things are cyclical, and though history never repeats itself exactly, the US is once more tearing down the structures that keep finance in check. We might call it 'light touch' regulation 2.0. Should the UK be following suit? As I say, Bailey is right to be concerned, but the reality is that we do indeed need to replicate at least some of what the Trump administration is doing in the US if the City is to remain a force to be reckoned with as a global financial centre. Already, the signs of decline are all too visible, with the City failing to find a new raison d'etre after losing its position as Europe's de facto financial centre after Brexit. As with so much else, the big game changer is technology. The danger is that we get stuck in the same rut as the European Union, with an approach to regulating financial services that looks backwards to a bygone era of eviscerating catastrophe rather than forward to the transformative power of the new technologies. An analogue solution to a digital age is just what we don't need. As is its wont, the EU was first out of the traps in attempting to regulate the cutting edges of fintech, with its so-called 'Markets in Crypto Assets' directive. This is essentially just another attempt to predict what risks might materialise before they actually happen, and therefore acts as a significant barrier to innovation.
Daily Mail
29 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Britain's 'MAGA summer': Donald Trump and JD Vance lead red-cap brigade enjoying time in the UK this summer... to the horror of Ellen DeGeneres
The UK is seeing a 'MAGA British summer' as Donald Trump and JD Vance lead the red-cap brigade in enjoying time in the UK. While the US President touched down in Scotland this week for the opening of a new 18-hole golf course at his estate in Aberdeenshire, vice president Vance is expected to rent a holiday cottage in the Cotswolds next month. His upcoming trip comes much to the dismay of talk show host Ellen DeGeneres, who abandoned her Californian lifestyle to enjoy a quieter life in the Cotswolds with wife Portia de Rossi in November 2024. DeGeneres revealed their move to the English countryside was prompted by last year's US election, specifically the re-election of Trump. The former talk show host is reportedly planning a two-week break from her adopted home when Vance visits with his family in August. And with Trump back on British soil again in September for an unprecedented second state visit, one Republican told The Times that the UK is facing'a Maga British summer'. Ms DeGeneres said last week that Trump's victory influenced her move to the UK. 'We got here the day before the election and woke up to lots of texts from our friends with crying emojis and I was like, ''He got in'',' she said. 'And we're like, ''We're staying here then''.' Last week it was revealed she is selling one of her two Cotswolds properties for a cool £22.5million - £7.5million more than she paid for it. The Cotswolds is a popular British holiday hotspot, and home to political powers like former Prime Minister David Cameron and celebrities such as the Beckhams. The Vances were also in London before the 2024 US election, when they were given a personal tour of the British Museum by George Osborne, its chairman. In 2011 Barack Obama took time out to visit his ancestral home in Moneygall, Ireland. And in 2023 former US President Joe Biden embarked on a tour of Ireland, with the UK hardly getting a look-in. Rishi Sunak had to treck to Northern Ireland to meet him at the airport. Trump is not only visiting the UK to play golf, as he also has important trade talks set up with EU chief Ursula von der Leyen and Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer. As he touched down at Glasgow Prestwick Airport in Ayrshire on Friday, Trump told Europe to 'get your act together' over illegal immigration - branding it a 'horrible invasion' that is 'killing Europe'. Trump is set to meet Sir Keir and Scotland's First Minister John Swinney on Monday. He will also enter trade talks with the EU chief this afternoon after officials from both sides said they were nearing an agreement. But an EU diplomat claimed 'everyone is quite tense' - after Trump threatened 'you're not going to have Europe anymore' if illegal immigration continues.
