Musk claims ‘OpenAI betrayed its mission and the public' in scathing court filing
Elon Musk fired back at OpenAI's accusation that he's been waging a 'relentless' campaign for more than a year to damage the startup.
In a court filing late Wednesday, an attorney for the world's richest person asked a judge to brush aside allegations that he has weaponized legal claims, social media posts and attacks in the press to try to sabotage OpenAI's success — all to gain advantage for his own generative artificial intelligence startup, xAI.
Musk's latest filing comes just days after OpenAI retreated from its plan to restructure as a for-profit business — which Musk, as well as some former employees and academics, have alleged would be an improper pivot from the startup's roots as a nonprofit charity.
ALSO READ| Elon Musk changes his X name to 'Gorklon Rust': What does it mean?
Instead, the ChatGPT maker said Monday it would move forward with an effort to overhaul its for-profit division as a public benefit corporation, but the overall business will remain under the control of its nonprofit.
Even though the new plan would effectively maintain the contours of how OpenAI is currently set up, Musk's lawyer, Marc Toberoff, said the proposal 'changes nothing,' a sign the billionaire may continue with his legal crusade against the startup led by Sam Altman.
'OpenAI's counterclaims not only fail as a matter of law, they confirm OpenAI's betrayal of its charitable mission, and the public at large,' Toberoff wrote in the filing. 'The nonprofit is nothing more than an inconvenience standing in the way of Altman's profit-driven ambitions.'
The legal wrangling between Musk and Altman, who worked together to launch OpenAI a decade ago, is playing out as the startup is in talks with officials in Delaware and California over its restructuring plans.
In the court fight Musk launched last year, he accused OpenAI of walking back on its founding purpose as a charity when it accepted billions of dollars in funding from Microsoft Corp. starting in 2019, the year after he left OpenAI's board. Musk launched rival xAI in 2023.
ALSO READ| Trump takes shocking jibe at Elon Musk, stunned netizens say 'This guy has no decency'
Altman and OpenAI filed a countersuit in early April, claiming Musk is trying to hurt the ChatGPT maker and damage its relationships with investors and customers. 'Musk has tried every tool available to harm OpenAI,' the startup's lawyers said in the countersuit.
A federal judge in Oakland, California, has set a March trial in Musk's challenge to Altman's restructuring plans, setting the stage for a high-stakes courtroom clash between the two billionaires.
The case is Musk v. Altman, 24-cv-04722, US District Court, Northern District of California (Oakland).
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
an hour ago
- News18
Energy And Electrons: Could They Become Currency In A Decade? What Nikhil Kamath Says
Last Updated: Zerodha co-founder Nikhil Kamath predicts energy and electrons could become trade currency in a decade due to rising data center and AI energy consumption. Zerodha co-founder Nikhil Kamath has shared a thought-provoking idea based on research with a lingering assumption that energy and electrons might be the currency of trade in a decade. In a series of tweets, he shared the infographics explaining the research, highlighting the growing financial footprint of data centers and artificial intelligence. The electricity consumption in data centers is insane, with one new Data center consuming more electricity than 4 lakh electric vehicles in a year. Thus, the research says, electricity alone eats up 65 per cent of a data center's costs – primarily for computing and cooling. Data centers are large facilities that store, process, and manage digital data. They are the backbone of the internet and digital services—every time you use a website, stream a video, store files in the cloud, or make a bank transaction, chances are it passes through a data center. US is the leader with the most number of data centers (3680), followed by Germany (424) and UK (418). India ranks seventh in the number of 262 data centers. The more servers the data center has, the more energy it requires. Earlier, OpenAI founder Sam Altman explained how the words like please and thank you cost the company tens of millions of dollars. The research adds that one ChatGPT query uses 10x the electricity of a regular Google search. Data Centers To Consume 10% Of Global Energy By 2030 The research shows that data centers' consumption of energy is expected to grow to 10 per cent by 2030, which is 1.5 per cent of global energy. 'Just 5% of global internet searches using AI could consume enough energy to power over 1 million Indian homes for a year." Energy To Become Asset Kamath's idea is rooted in an emerging economic paradigm: as the demand for electricity grows, energy becomes a critical and tradable asset—much like money. If energy is as essential as cash in powering AI, streaming services, financial systems, and cloud operations, pricing and trading electricity akin to currency could be the next step. This concept isn't just futuristic—it carries real-world relevance. Companies might begin to hedge not only currency risk but also energy risk. Imagine supermarkets trading kilowatt-hours or data centers using energy derivatives in a similar fashion to forex trading. Over time, energy tokens or blockchain-based credits for electrons could emerge, giving rise to a sophisticated energy-backed financial ecosystem. If this shift happens, economies would have to rethink everything from inflation metrics to banking, as 'energy currency" could fundamentally alter how value is transferred and stored—making energy both a means and a measure of wealth. About the Author Varun Yadav First Published: June 08, 2025, 15:03 IST News business Energy And Electrons: Could They Become Currency In A Decade? What Nikhil Kamath Says
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Physics changed AI in the 20th century. Is AI returning the favour now?
Artificial intelligence (AI) is booming. Various AI algorithms are used in many scientific domains, such as to predict the structure of proteins, search for materials with particular properties, and interpret medical data to provide a diagnosis. People use tools like ChatGPT, Claude, NotebookLM, DALL-E, Gemini, and Midjourney to generate images and videos from text prompts, write text, and search the web. The question arises in the same vein: can they prove useful in studies of the fundamental properties of nature or is there a gap between human and artificial scientists that needs to be bridged first? There is certainly some gap. Many of the current applications of AI in scientific research often use AI models as a black box: when the models are trained on some data and they produce an output, but the relationship between the inputs and the output is not clear. This is considered unacceptable by the scientific community. Last year, for example, DeepMind faced pressure from the life sciences community to release an inspectable version of its AlphaFold model that predicts protein structures. The black-box nature presents a similar concern in the physical sciences, where the steps leading up to a solution are as important as the solution itself. Yet this hasn't dissuaded scientists from trying. In fact, they started early: since the mid-1980s, they have integrated AI-based tools in the study of complex systems. In 1990, high-energy physics joined the fold. Astro- and high-energy physics In astronomy and astrophysics, scientists study the structure and dynamics of celestial objects. Big-Data analytics and image enhancement are two major tasks for researchers in this field. AI-based algorithms help with the first by looking for patterns, anomalies, and correlations. Indeed, AI has revolutionised astrophysical observations by automating tasks like capturing images and tracking distant stars and galaxies. AI algorithms are able to compensate for the earth's rotation and atmospheric disturbances, producing better observations in a shorter span. They are also able to 'automate' telescopes that are looking for very short-lived events in the sky and record important information in real time. Experimental high-energy physicists often deal with large datasets. For example, the Large Hadron Collider experiment in Europe generates more than 30 petabytes of data every year. A detector on the collider called the Compact Muon Solenoid alone captures 40 million 3D images of particle collisions every second. It is very difficult for physicists to analyse such data volumes rapidly enough to track subatomic events of interest. So in one measure, researchers at the collider started using an AI model able to accurately identify a particle of interest in very noisy data. Such a model helped discover the Higgs boson particle over a decade ago. AI in statistical physics Statistical mechanics is the study of how a group of particles behaves together, rather than individually. It is used to understand macroscopic properties like temperature, and pressure. For example, Ising developed a statistical model for magnetism in the 1920s, focusing on the collective behavior of atomic spins interacting with their neighbors. In this model, there are higher and lower energy states for the system, and the material is more likely to exist in the lowest energy state. The Boltzmann distribution is an important concept in statistical mechanics, used to predict, say, the precise conditions in which ice will turn to water. Using this distribution, in the 1920s, Ernst Ising and Wilhelm Lenz predicted the temperature at which a material changed to non-magnetic from magnetic. Last year's physics Nobel laureates John Hopefield and Geoffrey Hinton developed a theory of neural networks in the same way, based on the idea of statistical mechanics. An NN is a type of model where nodes that can receive data to perform computations on them are linked to each other in different ways. Overall, NNs process information the way animal brains do. For example, imagine an image made up of pixels, where some are visible and the rest are hidden. To determine what the image is, physicists have to consider all possible ways the hidden pixels could fit together with the visible pieces. The idea of most likely states of statistical mechanics could help them in this scenario. Hopefield and Hinton developed a theory for NNs that considered the collective interactions of pixels as neurons, just like Lenz and Ising before them. A Hopfield network calculates the energy of an image by determining the least-energy arrangement of hidden pixels, similar to statistical physics. AI tools apparently returned the favour by helping make advances in the study of Bose-Einstein condensates (BEC). A BEC is a peculiar state of matter that a collection of certain subatomic or atomic particles have been known to enter at very low temperatures. Scientists have been creating it in the lab since the early 1990s. In 2016, scientists at Australian National University tried to do so using AI's help with creating the right conditions for a BEC to form. They found that it did so with flying colours. The tool was even able to help keep the conditions stable, allowing the BEC to last longer. 'I didn't expect the machine could learn to do the experiment itself, from scratch, in under an hour,' the paper's coauthor Paul Wigley said in a statement. 'A simple computer program would have taken longer than the age of the universe to run through all the combinations and work this out.' Bringing AI to the quantum In a 2022 paper, scientists from Australia, Canada, and Germany reported a simpler method to entangle two subatomic particles using AI. Quantum computing and quantum technologies are of great research and practical interest today, with governments — including India's — investing millions of dollars in developing these futuristic technologies. A big part of their revolutionary power comes from achieving quantum entanglement. For example, quantum computers have a process called entanglement swapping: where two particles that have never interacted become entangled using intermediate entangled particles. In the 2022 paper, the scientists reported a tool called PyTheus, 'a highly-efficient, open-source digital discovery framework … which can employ a wide range of experimental devices from modern quantum labs' to better achieve entanglement in quantum-optic experiments. Among other results, scientists have used PyTheus to make a breakthrough with implications for quantum networks used to securely transmit messages, making these technologies more feasible. More work, including research, remains to be done but tools like PyTheus have demonstrated a potential to make it more efficient. From this vantage point in time, it seems like every subfield of physics will soon use AI and ML to help solve their toughest problems. The end goal is to make it easier to come up with the more appropriate questions, test hypotheses faster, and understand results more gainfully. The next groundbreaking discovery may well come from collaborations between human creativity and machine power. Shamim Haque Mondal is a researcher in the Physics Division, State Forensic Science Laboratory, Kolkata.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Who will replace Elon Musk as Donald Trump's Silicon Valley bestie: Four tech CEOs analyst are betting on
The high-profile alignment between Elon Musk and US President Donald Trump appears to be dissolving. Following the Tesla CEO's departure from a prominent advisory role, questions are now emerging regarding which, IF ANY, tech executive might next enter the President's inner circle. His second inauguration in January was a red carpet for Silicon Valley elites — with execs from Apple, Meta, Google and even OpenAI making an appearance, essentially pointing out a way that there's no shortage of names lining up to be the next tech mogul to the Oval Office. Here's a list of potential contenders — executives and entrepreneurs who can be the next in line (via Business Insider). Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook co-founder and Meta Platforms CEO Mark Zuckerberg was among the first tech CEOs who demonstrated support for Trump. Meta contributed $1 million to Trump's inauguration, and Zuckerberg co-hosted a black-tie event to honour the president. Moreover, it was Zuckerberg's Meta that quickly brought changes to how the company worked. For example, launching X-like Community Notes service for fact checking, and making significant changes to its Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programmes. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Many Are Watching Tariffs - Few Are Watching What Nvidia Just Launched Seeking Alpha Read Now Undo In early 2025, the company announced that it would be terminating major DEI initiatives, including those related to hiring, training, and supplier diversity. Reportedly, Zuckerberg also made multiple trips to Trump's Mar-a-lago residence. Zuckerberg is reportedly establishing a stronger presence in Washington D.C., having acquired a $23 million, 15,000-square-foot mansion in the capital. Sam Altman, OpenAI CEO OpenAI co-founder and CEO Sam Altman has also engaged with the Trump administration. His involvement includes the Stargate project, a $100 billion AI infrastructure plan announced the day after Trump's inauguration, involving OpenAI, Oracle and SoftBank. Altman's inclusion in the project came as a surprise because of infamous Musk-Altman feud when the Tesla CEO was standing beside the President. In May, Altman joined Trump on a trip to Saudi Arabia while working on a major deal to construct one of the world's largest AI data centers in Abu Dhabi. The Wall Street Journal reported this trip prompted Musk to join at the last minute, and that Musk allegedly attempted to derail the deal, for which OpenAI was ultimately selected. Trump has expressed enthusiasm for the AI arms race, aligning with Altman's focus. Jensen Huang, Nvidia CEO Nvidia co-founder and CEO Jensen Huang did not attend Trump's second inauguration in January but was present on the Middle East trip in May. Nvidia is involved in the OpenAI data center plans in the UAE, partnering with Oracle, SoftBank and G42. Huang has also praised Trump on several occasions for reversal of Biden administration's chip export rules, calling the previous rules "fundamentally flawed". However, Nvidia has faced challenges from the Trump administration, specifically in April when Trump banned the chip maker from selling its most advanced chips, the H20, to China. Nvidia stated this decision cost the company $5.5 billion. Jeff Bezos, Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos , founder of Amazon and Blue Origin, has transitioned from public opposition towards Trump to a more cooperative stance. Bezos said in December that he expects a more friendly regulatory environment in the upcoming administration and in January, Amazon donated $1 million for Trump's inauguration. 'I'm actually very optimistic this time around. He seems to have a lot of energy around reducing regulation. If I can help do that, I'm going to help him," Bezos said at that time. However, the Bezos-Trump relationship has seen strained periods. In 2015, Bezos famously suggested he would use his space company, Blue Origin, to "#sendDonaldtospace" after Trump criticised the Washington Post, which Bezos owns. A brief point of tension emerged in April when Amazon reportedly considered displaying Trump's tariffs next to product prices, a plan White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt called "hostile and political." The idea was not implemented.
