South Korean top court rules 'Baby Shark' not plagiarised
With its catchy lyrics, the "Baby Shark Dance" video is the most viewed on YouTube, with more than 16 billion views, roughly double those of the runner-up, 'Despacito', and third-place 'Wheels on the Bus'.
In 2019, New York composer Johnny Only, whose legal name is Jonathan Wright, filed a lawsuit in Seoul, alleging that the 2015 hit 'Baby Shark' by South Korean education startup SmartStudy copied a song he had released in 2011.
Mr Only demanded 30 million won (€18,544) in compensation, accusing the firm of copying elements of his work, including its bassline and rhythm.
SmartStudy, now known as The Pinkfong Company, argued that its version was an adaptation of a classic North American children's tune that is not protected by copyright.
A South Korean lower court initially cleared the company of the charges at a trial in 2021, finding that there was insufficient evidence of copyright infringement.
That ruling was upheld by an appeal court in 2023.
Mr Only then challenged the 2023 decision, but South Korea's Supreme Court this morning affirmed the lower court rulings.
"All appeals were dismissed and the lower court's rulings were upheld," according to court documents seen by AFP.
The Pinkfong Company said in a statement that the Supreme Court's decision confirmed 'Baby Shark' was "based on a traditional singalong chant that has entered the public domain".
The company said it had given "a fresh twist to the chant by adding an upbeat rhythm and catchy melody, turning it into the pop culture icon it is today".
Mr Only did not immediately reply to an AFP request for comment.
He told Canadian public broadcaster CBC in 2019 that he had created a toddler-friendly version of 'Baby Shark' in 2011, revising the original song, which was about a gory shark attack.
"I was the first one that did that (rewriting the song), you know? And basically Pinkfong's version does the same thing," he said in the interview.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
an hour ago
- Extra.ie
Leonardo DiCaprio,50, states he's 'emotionally' 35
Leonardo DiCaprio has revealed he feels 'emotionally' 35 despite having turned 50 last November. Speaking to director Paul Thomas Anderson for Esquire's Mavericks of Hollywood issue this week, the Hollywood star opened up about his outlook on ageing after reaching a monumental landmark. The Titanic actor has a long-standing reputation of dating partners who are notably younger than him, garnering a lot of media attention over the years. Leonardo DiCaprio has revealed he feels 'emotionally' 35 despite having turned 50 last November. Pic: VALERY HACHE/AFP via Getty Images His most recent relationship with model Vittoria Ceretti has seen the couple going strong after two years together, despite her being two years over the age of 25, his usual dating age. In the interview, Anderson asked DiCaprio: 'If you didn't know how old you are, how old are you right now?' To which he responded '32.' The Titanic actor has a long-standing reputation of dating partners who are notably younger than him, garnering a lot of media attention over the years. Pic:He also said that when he turned 50, he actually felt as though he turned 'emotionally 35.' The director then asked if the landmark birthday had made the star reflect on his life at all, to which he added: 'Well, it creates a feeling like you have a desire to just be more honest and not waste your time. 'I can only imagine how the next few decades are going to progress.' He also credited his mum, Irmelin Indenbirken, for teaching him to be more sincere as he ages, stating: 'I look at my mother, for example, and she just says exactly what she thinks and wastes no time. She spends no time trying to fake it.'
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Oasis tickets bought with dynamic pricing are on 'ethical' resale websites abroad for over €560
OASIS TICKETS FOR this weekend's much-awaited gigs at Croke Park are being sold for over €500 on 'ethical' and 'fair' resale platforms that cap prices relative to the face value cost. The Journal has previously reported that tickets for the sold out shows have been resold on Ticketmaster for close to €600, but new searches ahead of the weekend gigs have shown they are also being sold on resale platforms based in the UK and Australia. UK-based Twickets is the official resale platform for the 41-concert Oasis '25 tour, with the website only allowing tickets to be resold at the face value paid 'plus a standard booking fee between 10-15%'. The website states: Twickets is an ethical ticket resale marketplace, enabling users to sell spare tickets at the price they paid, or less. We have partnered with Oasis as their official ticket resale platform to protect fans from being ripped off by profiteering resale sites that encourage ticket touting. A search of Twickets for the Dublin gigs showed tickets available listed at between €357 and €515. Several of these tickets are described as being originally sold by Ticketmaster as 'In Demand' tickets, which was the description used for the dynamic pricing model that was controversially used for some tickets when they went on sale last year. Dynamic pricing essentially describes a fluctuating price which rises with increased demand and, in the case of Oasis tickets, led to fans paying hundreds of euros for tickets. Advertisement It is unclear exactly how many of the tickets sold for the Croke Park gigs were bought via fixed pricing or via dynamic pricing, but much of what is available through resale websites are clearly dynamically priced tickets being resold. Twickets states this explicitly in listings, saying: 'These are standard tickets sold at varying prices by the original retailer, which may be much greater than other similar tickets.' In the case of two tickets being resold which The Journal saw this week, one was a dynamically priced ticket for the Lower Cusack Stand which originally sold for €490 but which was now available for €515 . The other was an Upper David Stand ticket which sold via dynamic pricing for €332 and was now available for €357 . In these cases, the resale prices are 5% and 7% above the original face value prices, respectively. Twickets Twickets The resale of tickets above face value has been banned in Ireland since 2021 and, as a result, Oasis tickets being sold at inflated prices has largely not been prevalent on online marketplaces such as whose owner has common shareholders with Journal Media, states on its website that all ticket sales must be 'at face value (plus booking fee and additional costs) or less' and that 'moderators reserve the right to remove any ad that is deemed excessive'. In one case, The Journal viewed an ad listed by a seller on which said that they were selling a ticket on another website, Tixel, before the post was removed. Australian-headquartered Tixel operates across a number of territories and allows sellers to list tickets for resale at a prices that are capped at 20% above face value. Related Reads Liam Gallagher slams Scottish council for its description of Oasis fans Consumer watchdog launches investigation into Ticketmaster's handling of Oasis ticket sales The Oasis ticket scramble has put 'dynamic pricing' back in the news: What exactly is it? 'This allows sellers to cover the fees associated with listing a ticket on Tixel as well as regain the face value they paid for the ticket,' the website states. Tixel takes a cut of 5.9% of the purchase price and the company says it has a 'mission' to be 'fair, accessible, and transparent'. 'We've built an event marketplace that helps fans get to their favourite shows without paying through the nose to be there,' the website adds. Tixel Tixel A search of Tixel did show a number of tickets for Oasis in Croke Park, with one listed as being a Standing ticket bought via dynamic pricing for €437 which was now available for €481 . Another Platinum ticket for the Lower Hogan Stand was listed as having been purchased for €516 which was now being sold for €567 . Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
RTÉ News
2 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Premier League soap opera gears up for new campaign
The back-to-school signs are up in supermarkets and the leaves are turning yellow and red as we enter the final days of summer. With evenings drawing in, it's time to put away the snorkels and swimming togs for another year, wave goodbye to the outside and settle in for some comfort television. That's where the Premier League has you covered. While the drama and nonsense of the summer transfer window is becoming a bigger and bigger sporting circus with each passing year, it's still just about playing second fiddle to the soap opera of the Premier League. And what a series there is in store. With storylines aplenty, season 34 of the show formerly known at The Barclays promises more betrayal, heartbreak, and dramatic stare-downs than the last four decades of Eastenders. We're got new faces on the scene, returning heart-throbs, old favourites looking to reclaim faded glory and a couple of nasty villains out for retribution. From an Irish perspective, Keith Andrews stepping onto the Square raises the biggest questions. On the surface, he's bounding into the managerial limelight with a swagger and a glint in his eye but he's also a man with some skeletons in his closet and some powerful enemies lurking in the background. Andrews has been handed an unexpected opportunity to take the reins of Brentford as his first managerial job. Having swapped the pundit chair for the hot seat, there's some murky figures from his past just waiting for him to slip up and let them twist the knife. Roy Keane, who famously said Andrews was up there with the 'biggest bullsh***ers' he'd ever met, will be box office when the Bees first come under the Sky Sports microscope, with Martin O'Neill ready to get his digs in too, albeit from the less glamourous platform of TalkSport YouTube clips. Andrews has a tricky task in replacing a genuinely transformative manager in Thomas Frank. With big performing players like Brian Mbeumo, Christian Norgaard and Mark Flekken all departing, he has a huge task on his hands, which is why the bookies have him down as the favourite for the sack race If Andrews is the man likely to feel the early heat, Liverpool boss Arne Slot is riding on a crest of a wave heading into the new campaign. Cantering to a surprise Premier League title win with Jurgen Klopp's creaking squad, Slot has spent hundreds of millions of pounds bringing in new big name players. With the chase for Alexander Isak still trundling along, Slot's Liverpool could eclipse Chelsea for the highest ever transfer window spend. Darwin Nunez, Luis Diaz and tragically Diego Jota all had to be replaced, but could it be a case of too much, too soon? Florian Wirtz, Hugo Ekitiké, Milos Kerkez and Jeremie Frimpong are already through the door and with the possibility of Isak, Marc Guehi and Giovanni Leoni following, that's a lot of first-team players to integrate in a short time. Home and Away fans of a certain age will still speak of the generational trauma that was inflicted on them when Pippa's actress was recast overnight without any on-screen reference to the change. Sudden breakneck upheaval like Pippa's switch and Liverpool's summer transfer window can take time to settle and a questionable second-half performance in the Community Shield already has rival teams wondering if they could be vulnerable in the early stages. Manchester United, meanwhile can only look on at Liverpool's summer turnover in envy. As the Sky Sports News deadline day counter ominously ticks down, the Old Trafford club are still no closer to getting their high-earning deadwood off the books. Marcus Rashford still remains a United player, albeit one out on loan for the season at Barcelona, while the club have been unable to attract any meaningful interest in the rest of their bomb squad. With Antony, Jadon Sancho, Alejandro Garnacho and Tyrrell Malacia still training separately and no closer to leaving than they were at the start of the summer, Jim Ratcliffe is looking more and more like a frustrated Peggy Mitchell trying to sling the drunks out at the end of the night screeching "get outta my club!" to little effect. United have at least been able to bring in some new faces, albeit they're now shopping among the second tier of available players following several disastrous seasons and a 15th place Premier League finish. Benjamin Sesko, Bryan Mbeumo and Matheus Cunha are the headline signings and they're eager to add Brighton's Carlos Baleba to their ranks. Decent players all with plenty of potential, but United have a habit of draining players of their promise and Ruben Amorim still has much to prove. Meanwhile, having already spent £214million, after pleading poverty at Christmas time, you have to wonder just how much those tea ladies given the elbow by Ratcliffe were earning. Across the city in Manchester, Pep Guardiola is hoping he can write his own redemption story arc after the wheels came off for the Sky Blues in spectacular fashion last season. With old stars like Kevin De Bruyne and Kyle Walker being written out, City have undergone the kind of TV seasonal reset that you can only really have when you set fire to the pub or crash a plane into the village in the Christmas special. Perhaps the biggest surprise is that Guardiola has stuck around for another go. Between the winter transfer window and the current one, City have undergone a huge overhaul and while the signs were promising towards the end of last season, a poor start could see more questions being asked of Guardiola. He should have enough credit in the bank with the club's owners to weather out any early storms but his increasingly tetchy press conferences and head-scratching antics last term hinted towards a man who could jump before he's pushed if things don't go to plan. Jack Grealish knows just how changeable Guardiola can be when it comes to things not going his way as the most expensive player signed by the club has decided to cut his losses at the Etihad and high-tailed it to Everton. Grealish's move to the Toffees looks guaranteed to be entertaining, no matter how things go on the pitch and like all good soap opera pretty boys, Jack knows how to party. The midfielder's recent career trajectory saw him win the treble with City and then never quite find his way back from the celebrations. Now he's made the move to Everton and with his first move, has taken the number 18 jersey in honour or Paul Gascoigne and Wayne Rooney. In fairness, both Gascoigne and Rooney were exciting, creative players, but both knew how to enjoy themselves off the pitch. Hopefully Grealish takes more inspiration from the sporting side, rather than emerging in a couple of years like a bedraggled and bearded Ian Beale. Should he find himself in a moral quandary or too tempted towards the call of the party lifestyle, in fine soap opera tradition, he can have a sit down in a laundry and a heart-to-heart with a wise old head who's seen it all before. James Milner, the Dot Cotton of the Premier League is now gearing up for his 23rd season as a Premier League player and looking back wistfully on all that's gone before him. Speaking ahead of Brighton's season opening at home to Fulham, it's clear that Milner is starting to feel the weight of the years on his shoulders. "There are lads I played with at the start of my career whose sons I'm now playing with or against: Justin Kluivert, I played with his dad at Newcastle; I played with Bobby Clark at Liverpool and played with his dad at Newcastle; Tommy Watson's girlfriend is Ian Harte's daughter." So as the new season kicks off, with Milner slowly morphing into a sentient Shoot Magazine archive, Grealish trying to remember if he left his Gucci washbag in the Grafton, and Andrews eyeing Keane like a man checking for sharks in a pool, the Premier League remains the greatest soap opera we've ever seen.
