US lawyer uses ChatGPT to cite fake legal cases: Judge imposes fine; warns ChatGPT can write a story, but…
fake legal cases
in court. According to a PCGamer report, Thomas Nield, an attorney from Semrad Law Firm, was found to have submitted four
fabricated case citations
while representing a client in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy case. As per the report, the matter came to light when Judge Michael Slade reviewed Nield's filings and spotted multiple inconsistencies. 'In sum, what happened here is that Mr Nield cited four cases for a proposition of law, but none of them exist as alleged in his brief,' the judge said.
Lawyer admits using AI
The report says that Thomas Nield admitted to using AI to assist with the legal brief. He told the publication: ''I think the citation element of these cases, I guess, was—I ran it through AI to some extent, but I didn't think that the citation was wrong.'
Nield told the court he had never used AI before for legal research and did not verify the output because he trusted the program's accuracy. 'He assumed that an AI program would not fabricate quotes entirely,' the court noted.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Mini House for 60 sqm for Seniors with Toilet and Bath (Price May Surprise You)
Pre Fabricated Homes | Search Ads
Search Now
Undo
Judge Slade raised concerns over use of AI in the legal environment, saying this practice was "unacceptable". He said 'At this point, to be blunt, any lawyer unaware that using generative AI platforms to do legal research is playing with fire is living in a cloud.'
He said: 'The bottom line is this: at this point, no lawyer should be using ChatGPT or any other generative AI product to perform research without verifying the results. Period.'
He added that tools like ChatGPT 'can write a story that reads like it was written by Stephen King (but wasn't) or pen a song that sounds like it was written by Taylor Swift (but wasn't). But they can't do your legal research for you. ChatGPT does not access legal databases like Westlaw or Lexis, draft and input a query, review and analyze each of the results, determine which results are on point, and then compose an accurate, Bluebook-conforming citation to the right cases.'
Four fake cases flagged by the court
The PC Gamer report lists four fake citations that the bankruptcy lawyer used in the legal case. These include:
In re Montoya: The quote did not appear in the actual case, and the case did not discuss the issue cited.
In re Coleman: The case was cited with the wrong jurisdiction and included a quote not found in the opinion.
In re Russell: Wrong court location and no relevance to the legal argument.
In re Jager: This case simply 'does not exist.'
According to Judge Slade, none of the quotations matched actual court opinions.
None of the quotes matched actual court opinions, and some of the cited cases were entirely fictional. 'None of the quotations relied upon in the Semrad brief are actual statements written by any court,' said Judge Slade.
Judge fines law firm
Lawyer Thomas Nield and Semrad Law Firm admitted to the mistake, promised not to repeat it, withdrew their request for legal fees, and completed a legal education course. However, Judge Slade ruled that 'there must be consequences.'
He ordered the firm to pay a $5,500 fine and required Nield and a senior attorney from the firm to attend a mandatory AI ethics session at the National Conference of Bankruptcy Judges.
Calling the $5,500 fine a 'modest sanction,' the judge warned future offenders: 'The next lawyer who does the same thing is warned that he or she will likely see a more significant penalty.'
Sony WF-C710N Review: Solid Sound and Long Battery
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
23 minutes ago
- Time of India
NMRDA for 15-meter wide approach roads for develoment of properties in region
Nashik: Nashik Metropolitan Regional Development Authority (NMRDA) has now decided to permit approach roads with a width of not less than 15 metres for development of properties in the region. "Developers construct properties and move on, and then the people who live in those properties face problems due to narrow roads. In order to ensure proper development, we have decided on 15-metre norm," said NMRDA commissioner Manikrao Gursal. As per the Unified Development Control and Promotion Regulations 2020, properties are developed only on the basis of available width of road that helps dwellers access the nearest public way. The region is likely to see huge development during the forthcoming Simhastha Kumbhmela as well as overall development of places just outside Nashik Municipal Corporation limits. "We will have development of roads and properties considering the forthcoming Simhastha, besides handling movement of traffic from Ozar and even Shirdi international airports to and from Nashik city, all of which will be happen in NMRDA region spread across 275 villages in six talukas. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Could This NEW Collagen Blend Finally Reduce Your Cellulite? Vitauthority Learn More Undo Hence, NMRDA has previously announced the decision of widening the roads passing through the region. The current decision about the access roads is another step further," he said. Gursal said huge plots have been developed in neighbouring talukas of Nashik but their approach roads are very small, leading to problems for the residents as well as visitors. "Given the climatic conditions in Igatpuri, Nashik, and surrounding areas, there is demand for second homes, and so a large number of people — even the aged — visit these places. Traffic jams have now become regular issues on roads leading to chaotic conditions," said the officer. NMRDA has already announced widening of village roads from 15 to 18 metres, the other district roads (ODR) from 18 to 24 metres, and major district roads (MDR) from 24 to 30 metres. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Time of India
23 minutes ago
- Time of India
Nexus with contractors? GDA set to transfer 76 supervisors
Ghaziabad: Ghaziabad Development Authority (GDA) is set to transfer 76 supervisors following persistent complaints of collusion with contractors in facilitating illegal construction. Residents also allege that supervisors, working in tandem with private builders, demand hefty sums to overlook unauthorised floors. GDA has around 200 supervisors in the seven zones under it, but its manual does not specify a maximum tenure for postings before an employee can be shifted. Many of the supervisors on the list have been posted in the same zone for more than five years. Officials admitted that supervisors posted in the same zones for years had formed "unholy alliances" with local realtors, and said the reshuffle aimed to curb the spread of illegal colonies, which have risen from 321 in 2021 to 351, occupying around 3,000 acres. You Can Also Check: Noida AQI | Weather in Noida | Bank Holidays in Noida | Public Holidays in Noida | Gold Rates Today in Noida | Silver Rates Today in Noida While the GDA work manual states that a supervisor's role includes reporting any illegal construction to the zone's junior engineer and senior officials but for all practical purposes, they are considered to be GDA's eyes and ears and their foot soldiers. Supervisors are also tasked with checking the quality of construction materials and ensuring that all work is carried out in line with the approved plan. However, their nexus with contractors runs deep. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like A Teaspoon Before Bed Burns Body Fat - Fit Into Your Clothes Again! Health & Family Click Here Undo A Vaishali resident told TOI, a contractor allegedly sought Rs 40,000 on behalf of a GDA official to allow his family to construct an additional floor in their two-storey flat. "We hired a private contractor, prepared a cost estimate, and even had construction material delivered," he said. But that evening, a GDA supervisor reached their house and warned the family that the work violated regulations. Unsure how to proceed, the family considered abandoning the plan. "But the contractor assured me it could be 'managed' for Rs 40,000. Construction went ahead without further interference. Only later did I realise the nexus between contractors and supervisors," he added. According to a GDA official, despite checks and balances, illegal construction has been unabated in the city. "We deduced that many of the supervisors are working in the same zone for years and have developed a nexus with contractors, allowing illegal construction. This nexus needs to be broken, for which GDA has prepared a list of 76 supervisors who will be transferred to other zones." Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Time of India
23 minutes ago
- Time of India
DDA allocates land at Nehru Place for 5-star hotel for 55-yr period
New Delhi: Delhi Development Authority's first attempt to offer land for a five-star hotel on an annually incremental licence fee fetched Rs 27.2 crore per annum against the reserve fee of Rs 18 crore. The bid, won by one of the biggest hotel chains in the country, will generate revenues of Rs 10,000 crore for DDA over the licence period of 55 years. The initiative will provide a much-needed boost to the hospitality sector while contributing to DDA's coffers. "It was on the directions of lieutenant governor VK Saxena that DDA decided to move away from the existing freehold and perpetual lease models and chose a 'special licence property' mode to offer lands for prominent projects on annual incremental licence fee," an official said. The official explained that the experience of the last two decades showed that the freehold and perpetual lease models were not achieving desired results due to the high cost of land. "In contrast, the special licence property initiative is a key step towards leveraging DDA's land assets for sustainable, high-value development, contributing to Delhi's emergence as a global destination for business, hospitality, and medical treatment. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like New German Hearing Device Sweeping Canada (And Under $100) Top Trending News Today Learn More Undo It will also ensure that DDA continues to be the owner of the land," the official said. You Can Also Check: Delhi AQI | Weather in Delhi | Bank Holidays in Delhi | Public Holidays in Delhi | Gold Rates Today in Delhi | Silver Rates Today in Delhi The initiative included making suitable and viable land parcels available to different sectors such as hospitality, warehousing, health, iconic retail and other large-scale developments. As a part of this initiative, the first land parcel offered was of around two acres at Nehru Place for a five-star hotel, announced through a request for proposal issued on May 2. The auction was conducted on Aug 13, in which Fleur Hotels Pvt Ltd, a subsidiary of Lemon Tree Hotels Limited, emerged as the winning bidder. SBI Capital Markets Ltd assisted DDA as the transaction advisor for the auction process. "The company secured this project for an annual licence fee of Rs 27.19 crore. The yearly licence fee will escalate annually and is expected to generate around Rs 10,000 crore as revenues for DDA over the 55-year licence period," said a DDA official. The hotel to be named Aurika Nehru Place is set to become one of the city's biggest with over 500 rooms. It claimed it would offer elegant rooms, suites, signat-ure dining, expansive banqueting and best-in-class leisure facilities. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
