Karnataka HC rejects plea against Siddaramaiah's election from Varuna
BENGALURU: Stating that there is no averment in the petition as to how the 'five guarantees' have materially affected the result of the election, the Karnataka High Court on Tuesday rejected the petition filed by a voter of Varuna assembly constituency, questioning Chief Minister Siddaramaiah's election as MLA in 2023.
'If the assertion of 'guarantees' was grounds to set aside the election, the question of invoking the same to declare an election to be void would require an act by the returned candidate.
Admittedly, the 'guarantees' flow from a promise made in the manifesto of the party, and cannot be attributed to the candidate, and accordingly, the question of invoking Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of the RP Act in the present case does not arise, to declare the candidate is not qualified to be chosen from Varuna assembly constituency,' said Justice S Sunil Dutt Yadav, rejecting the election petition.
'The plaint is liable to be rejected both on the ground of 'want of cause of action' as well as being barred by law,' the court said, allowing an interlocutory application filed by Siddaramaiah against the petition.
The petitioner, K Shankara from Koodanahalli in Mysuru district, questioned the election of Siddaramaiah as MLA, mainly on the grounds that the five guarantees are construed as corrupt practices amounting to bribery and undue influence in terms of Section 123(2) of the Representation of the People (RP) Act.
The court noted that the 'guarantees', which are promises of freebies, cannot be considered to constitute a corrupt practice under Section 123 of the RP Act in the light of the law laid down by the apex court in the S Subramaniam Balaji case.
Even the petitioner's contention that Siddaramaiah had affixed his signature to the handout and thus adopted the manifesto as his own, is required to be rejected as the handout is an appeal by the party to vote for its candidate. The affixing of signature on the handout is 'only in the capacity of a CLP (Congress Legislative Party) leader and not more', the court said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
31 minutes ago
- India Today
Will be met with big force: Trump warns protesters ahead of Army parade
President Donald Trump on Tuesday issued a stern warning to anyone planning to protest during the upcoming military parade on June 14, which marks the US Army's 250th anniversary in Washington. The large-scale event, scheduled to take place on the National Mall and through the streets of Washington, also coincides with Trump's 79th birthday. It will feature a military parade, an Army birthday festival, and a special enlistment and re-enlistment ceremony overseen by the president those people that want to protest, they're going to be met with very big force," Trump told reporters during unscheduled remarks in the Oval Office. The president emphasized that Saturday's parade is intended to be a patriotic celebration and suggested that dissenters would be treated as hostile IN: President Trump sends a STRONG message those planning to disrupt the Army Parade in DC this weekend'YOU WILL BE MET WITH VERY HEAVY FORCE!' Nick Sortor (@nicksortor) June 10, 2025Law enforcement officials are preparing for what could be a massive turnout. According to US Secret Service Special Agent in Charge Matt McCool, 'thousands of agents, officers and specialists' from federal, state, and local agencies will be deployed. McCool added that 'at least nine permits have been issued for protests' on that day, although the FBI and Metropolitan Police have found no credible threats so One group organizing nationwide protests is called No Kings, which has openly criticized the administration's policies. "They've defied our courts, deported Americans, disappeared people off the streets, attacked our civil rights and slashed our services," the group states on its website. "The corruption has gone too far. No thrones. No crowns. No kings."Trump, meanwhile, reiterated his support for a strong military presence in response to public unrest, including his controversial decision to send 4,000 National Guard troops and 700 Marines to Los Angeles. The deployment followed protests triggered by immigration raids targeting workplaces."We're going to celebrate big on Saturday," Trump declared, before doubling down on his warning to demonstrators. "If any protesters want to come out, they will be met with very big force.""This is people that hate our country," he continued. "They will be met with heavy force."TRUMP SAYS OPEN TO INVOKING INSURRECTION ACTDuring an Oval Office exchange with reporters, Trump signaled he may consider invoking the Insurrection Act: one of the most extreme emergency powers available to a president, in response to ongoing immigration protests in Los Angeles. The Act allows the deployment of military forces within the United States to suppress rebellion, domestic unrest, or enforce federal law in specific the scale of Saturday's planned celebration, Trump added, "It's going to be a parade, the likes of which I don't know if we've ever had a parade like that. It's going to be incredible." He also touted the spectacle of military equipment, old and new, on display: "We have many tanks. We have all sorts of new ones and very old ones old from World War I and World War II,' Trump was quoted as saying by ABC News."We have a lot of those army airplanes flying over the top, and we have tanks all over the place," the president said, suggesting the event would rival global military parades in grandeur and patriotic spirit.(With inputs from Reuters)Tune InMust Watch
Time of India
35 minutes ago
- Time of India
SEP: Recommendation to regulate deemed varsities sparks debate
Chennai: In its recommendations for State Education Policy (SEP), the high-level committee headed by Justice D Murugesan has recommended that deemed universities in the state be regulated. This recommendation has, however, stirred up a debate as academicians said deemed universities were established under Section 3 of the University Grants Commission Act, 1956, and state govts cannot regulate them. As per the All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE), there are 35 deemed universities functioning in the state. These institutions have an approximate intake of more than 60,000 students in undergraduate courses. There were complaints that a few of them are providing substandard education while some are enrolling students who could not clear engineering exams in affiliated colleges and awarding them degrees. "A regulatory body with the powers to regulate 'deemed to be universities' should be put in place," the Justice Murugesan committee said in its 550-page report to the govt. "The regulatory body should have the power to regulate the admission procedure, including admission of a fixed percentage of the total intake of students from Tamil Nadu in each course, fee structure that may be determined by the fee committee, emolument structures for teaching and non-teaching staff as decided by the state, adopting the reservation policy of the state and the allied issues," it said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Trade Bitcoin & Ethereum – No Wallet Needed! IC Markets Start Now Undo "It is to provide education for the downtrodden, marginalised, and suppressed sections of the society from the state," the panel said in the report. It also suggested bringing a separate act by the name 'Tamil Nadu Higher Education Institutions (Private) Registrations Act' and conditions for the grant of a no-objection certificate to deemed universities. "Deemed universities are functioning like uncontrolled entities. Except for academic autonomy, the state govt should have a say in admissions, fees, and other issues," a source in the high-level committee said. Academicians say the state govt cannot regulate deemed universities that were established by UGC Act. Representatives from the deemed universities said only UGC can prescribe guidelines to the institutions. "State govt can interfere only with law and order issues. For any academic and regulatory issues, they cannot interfere with the deemed universities," Anna University former vice-chancellor E Balagurusamy said. "NBA and NAAC accreditations by deemed universities show they follow certain regulations. State govt has no power to control them," he added. Madras University former vice-chancellor S P Thyagarajan concurred with this view. "State govt cannot control the deemed universities as far as academic and administrative functions," he said.
India Gazette
36 minutes ago
- India Gazette
"Agreement that caste enumeration should be conducted": Karnataka CM Siddaramaiah after meeting Congress leadership
New Delhi [India], June 10 (ANI): Karantaka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah and Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar met with the Congress high command in Delhi on Tuesday to discuss key issues, where they discussed two to three crucial issues, including the caste census and the recent stampede in Bengaluru. Speaking to the media after the meeting, CM Siddaramaiah said that they have accepted the leadership's suggestion to re-enumerate the case census data. 'Discussions were held regarding the caste census as concerns were raised by some organisations, religious heads, and even a few ministers. The report submitted on the caste census has been accepted in principle. There is an agreement that a caste enumeration should be conducted. We have also agreed to this,' he said. He further mentioned that the discussion emphasised that the fresh survey should be completed within 90 days. 'We will conduct a fresh survey. Since the last enumeration was done in 2015-16, there is an opinion that a new enumeration is necessary. Just as we are conducting surveys for Scheduled Castes, we will carry out another enumeration. It was discussed that this survey should be completed within 90 days,' Siddaramaiah said. Congress General Secretary KC Venugopal had earlier confirmed that the party leadership has suggested that the Karnataka government re-enumerate the caste census data. Speaking on the Bengaluru stampede near the Chinnaswamy Stadium on June 4 that killed 11 people and left over 50 injured, CM Siddaramaiah briefed the Congress leadership about the action taken by the government. 'We discussed the recent tragic incident and explained the measures we have taken. A magisterial inquiry is underway, and a judicial commission has been appointed, led by retired Justice Michael Cunha. Five police officers have been suspended, intelligence officers have been transferred, and the political secretary has been relieved. We explained these actions, and there is a consensus that the measures taken are appropriate.' Siddaramaiah said. Referring to the stampede at Maha Kumbh Mela earlier this year in which more than 30 people lost their lives, Siddaramaiah said that the stampede should not be politicised. 'The Kumbh Mela incident should be discussed first before addressing this issue. I am not using the Kumbh Mela deaths to defend this incident. When people die, it is human to feel sorrow. This incident should not be politicised.' Siddaramaiah said. (ANI)
