NHS Fife reveals £220,000 legal bill for Sandie Peggie trans row tribunal
Under the Clinical Negligence and Other Risks Indemnity Scheme, the Scottish government's health and social care directorate is initially responsible for costs above the £25,000 threshold.This money is then recouped from member bodies in their annual contributions to the scheme which aims to ensure frontline clinical services are not affected.
Details of the spend were revealed after an order from the Information Commissioner following FOI requests from the Herald newspaper and other publications.The newspaper said the health board "repeatedly refused" to release the information due to concerns around assisting Ms Peggie's legal team, informing other legal firms on NHS billing expectations, and possible endangerment of staff.But the health board said it did not have access to the information about the costs when the FOI requests were initially received.NHS Fife confirmed that, as of 31 May, a total of £220,465.93 has been spent so far on legal costs relating to the tribunal.It said the figure included counsel fees and services provided by NHS Scotland's central legal office.The health board said it was not possible to estimate the full cost of proceedings while the tribunal was still ongoing.A spokesperson said: "NHS Fife notes the report from the Scottish Information Commissioner published on 9 July and will comply fully with the decision notice."NHS Fife sought a Rule 50 order to protect the confidentiality of sensitive personal information of staff involved in the tribunal process ."As a public sector organisation NHS Fife has a duty of care to all its staff with consideration given to protecting their privacy, safety, security and wellbeing."The decision to apply for the order was made following legal advice and in line with the reasons outlined above."The Information Commissioner's Office has been asked for comment.
Harassment claims
Sandie Peggie took NHS Fife and Dr Beth Upton to tribunal after she was suspended over an incident in the female changing room in Victoria Hospital in December 2023.Ms Peggie objected to having to share the changing room with Dr Upton - a trans woman - and claims her treatment amounted to unlawful harassment under the Equality Act.Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment against the nurse.The incidents alleged by the medic happened before the UK Supreme Court unanimously ruled that a woman is defined by biological sex under equalities law.At the time, NHS guidance said that trans men and women were allowed to use the changing rooms that aligned with their gender identity.The Equality and Human Rights Commissioner has since written to NHS Fife and the Scottish government to remind them about workplace legislation around single-sex spaces.The tribunal was initially scheduled to conclude in February after 10 days but has been adjourned until Wednesday 16 July.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
12 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Tributes to doctor known for work on rheumatic diseases
Died: June 25, 2025 Hilary Murdoch, who was died aged 75, was one of Scotland's most distinguished rheumatologists. She worked for many years as a consultant rheumatologist at the Centre for Rheumatic Diseases at Glasgow Royal Infirmary and was best known to her colleagues and patients as Hilary Capell. She was born in South Africa, a second daughter for Aubrey and Gladys, and grew up in Johannesburg with her older sister Janice. On leaving school, Hilary went on to study medicine at the University of the Witwatersrand (Wits). She first came to Britain in 1970 to undertake a student elective at St Mary's Hospital in London. As this was such a positive experience, she returned later to tour more of the country and visited a friend working in Glasgow. Afterwards, back home in South Africa, she decided to return to Scotland to obtain the MRCP, a postgraduate medical qualification. Her first post was as a senior house officer in medicine at Stobhill Hospital. During this time Hilary not only passed her exams but met her future husband Robert Murdoch, a mathematician. They married in 1976. She quickly became an honorary Glaswegian although the finer points of the patter sometimes eluded her. An amused Robert received a call one morning with a question. She had seen three patients who all told her they had the dry boak – did he know what this was? Later as a consultant, she was at a loss when referred to as the heid bummer! Attracted by the work of Professor Watson Buchanan who had not long before established the Centre for Rheumatic Diseases in Baird Street, Hilary was appointed as a registrar in his unit and began her career in rheumatology. She thrived there and became a consultant at the early age of 29 at a time when there were very few senior medical women. Read more Tributes to leading figure in Glasgow's Hares and Hounds club | The Herald Film-maker who played pivotal role in the Scottish industry dies | The Herald Tributes to Dundonian who became eminent director of the stars | The Herald Hilary enjoyed her clinical work and the care of patients with rheumatic diseases, especially rheumatoid arthritis, also drove her research. Her main research interest lay in the use of disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs (DMARDs). The aim was to reduce disease activity in inflammatory arthritis and thereby improve the lives of affected individuals. When her work began there were very few good therapeutic options. She initially studied the use of gold, penicillamine and sulfasalazine and later the pros and cons of corticosteroids in rheumatoid arthritis. She also considered other interventions such as the effects of a Mediterranean-type diet. Research findings were regularly presented with her team at many national and international meetings and published in both medical and rheumatology journals. She led the working group for the SIGN Guideline on the Management of Early Rheumatoid Arthritis (2001). Over the years, Hilary inspired a number of young doctors to enter her speciality and she mentored many trainees, some of whom went on to become consultants themselves. She asked searching questions and had high standards but was, at the same time, supportive and encouraging, quick to look for a silver lining rather than dwell on a setback. She was also formidably well organised but her superpower was undoubtably her ability to get people to do things – people who sometimes afterwards wondered what on earth had induced them to take the task on. Hilary contributed to medicine more widely and became a Fellow of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow, served on its council and examined in its postgraduate exams. She was made an honorary professor by Glasgow University. After she retired in 2008 she continued to support Pharmacy NHS Education for Scotland for several years. In retirement, her interest in fostering the potential of young people continued. She and Robert answered an advert for the Intergenerational Mentoring Network in the Centre for Lifelong Learning at Strathclyde University. This led to them providing additional support to young people at Springburn Academy who wished to go on to university. Hilary was particularly interested in trying to help those keen to pursue careers in healthcare. More recently, she and Robert were providing support to young people studying at the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland. Foremost among Hilary's interests was her passion for travel and not many places in the world were left unexplored. Difficult conditions didn't put her off and she remained unruffled by technical hitches such as being stranded on a sandbank in a small boat in the middle of an Indian river when the boatman became disorientated in thick early morning fog. She was never happier than when on safari in Africa or India observing wildlife in their natural surroundings. Back home in Glasgow she enjoyed long, chatty lunches often tucked away in a corner of the Buttery. On one such occasion the group knew that they had definitely overstayed their welcome when a staff member very politely asked if they would like him to call them a taxi. She did of course have a few foibles. High on the list of these was her favourite drink which was unusually, indeed unnaturally, weak tea. The brew consisted of sugary (very) hot water over which tea leaves were transiently wafted. Virtually no-one other than herself could ever make this to her specifications. Although Hilary lived in Scotland for over 50 years, she never forgot her South African roots. She kept in close touch with her family and visited every year with Robert, sometimes taking Scottish friends with them. Hilary and Robert were a devoted and highly sociable couple with many friends. They were the organisers of many get-togethers, away days and theatre visits. A tremendous double act who marked their 49th wedding anniversary earlier this year. By any standard, Hilary's was a life well lived and enjoyed to the full on her own terms. Who among us could ask for more. ELAINE MORRISON AND ROBERT MURDOCH At The Herald, we carry obituaries of notable people from the worlds of business, politics, arts and sport but sometimes we miss people who have led extraordinary lives. That's where you come in. If you know someone who deserves an obituary, please consider telling us about their lives. Contact
Daily Record
15 hours ago
- Daily Record
NHS boards splurge £53m on private advisers as frontline services suffer
Included in the spending was £200k for conflict resolution experts and £23k for media advisors. Scottish NHS boards have spent a shocking £53million on private management consultants in the last five years the Sunday Mail can reveal. Labour has accused the SNP government of allowing the health service to 'haemorrage' money on external firms, while cash strapped frontline services struggle to cope. The spending includes more than £200,000 paid by NHS Highland for 'conflict management resolution' experts, and £23,000 by the State Hospital Board for 'media strategy advice'. Public Health Scotland, the national health improvement and protection body, spent £97,000 on change management and business service consultants from auditing firm KPMG. It comes as soaring long waits at A&E departments are estimated to have contributed to more than 1,000 needless deaths. Jackie Baillie, Scottish Labour deputy leader, said the SNP had to 'get a grip' on the spending. She said: 'While outside expertise will always be needed, these figures show that at a time when our hospitals and surgeries are under pressure, health boards are still haemorrhaging cash. 'The SNP must get a grip on health boards' spending and ensure that where money does go to external consultants it can be clearly justified.' NHS Highland was at the centre of a bullying scandal after whistleblowers exposed a culture of fear at the health board in 2018. Two years later bosses paid Conflict Management Plus, a firm based near Cambridge, £189,000 for help to deal with problematic workplace relationships. Another £15,000 was handed to the firm in 2023. The State Hospital Board, which is responsible for running Scotland's only high-security psychiatric hospital at Carstairs - paid £23,000 to a firm for help in developing proactive media strategies over three years between 2020 and 2022. In 2023 Carstairs bosses also spent £720 on a 'courageous conversation workshop' from Scottish firm Class 1 Consultants. The Scottish Ambulance Service spent £373,000 for a private consultant to plan rosters between 2019 and 2023. Last year NHS Education Scotland paid a private firm £210,000 to complete a business case for the government's new health and social care app which is supposed to be launched by the end of the year. In total between 2019/20 and 2024/25 health boards have spent £53 million on private consultants. This also includes private consultants for infrastructure projects. The details come amid concern about the state of Scotland's NHS. A report by the Institute for Fiscal Studies in December last year found that while the NHS in England is steadily improving since the pandemic, in Scotland things are getting worse. Their study found that compared to before Covid, the percentage of people waiting for tests, cancer care, emergency care and elective care for longer than the NHS target time has all increased. It has also increased compared to last year in all areas except the percentage of people waiting six weeks or less for diagnostic testing. The IFS stated: 'There remains the ongoing challenge of ensuring that money is spent well, staff are deployed effectively, and productivity in the NHS is enhanced – all essential if waiting times are to be reduced.' Baillie said: 'It's the Scottish Government which should show leadership when it comes to reforming our health service yet after nearly two decades the SNP is out of ideas. 'The reality is that John Swinney and the SNP have no meaningful plan, no strategy and no ideas to save our NHS. 'A Scottish Labour government will make sure our NHS is free and available at the point of need, declare a national waiting times emergency, end the 8am rush for a GP appointment and do whatever it takes to fix the NHS.' Last month the Scottish Government pledged to 'target funding at frontline services' including the NHS as part of its five year financial plan and promised an increase in value for money, investment in preventative measuress to reduce demand on services and to reform public services. Trade unions have raised concerns about severe staffing shortages in some areas of the health service, including 'chronic understaffing' in the nursing sector, Unison Scotland warned in April there were not enough nurses on duty to 'ensure patients are protected from harm like falls, medication errors or other risks'. Its members warned there were not enoguh staff on duty in two thirds of shifts to deliver safe care. A Scottish Government spokesman said: 'Spending on external consultants is a tiny fraction of the NHS budget. 'NHS Boards make decisions on their spending, including the use of external consultants, where this is necessary to provide the most effective services. 'This information is published to ensure transparency and discussions are held on a regular basis with each NHS Board on how it is utilising its resources to ensure value for money.' Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
The Herald Scotland
a day ago
- The Herald Scotland
A vision for social security, designed by and for disabled people
From the outset, the review was a model of inclusivity, rooted in the voices of disabled people and the organisations that represent them. As the largest provider of support to ADP applicants (outside of friends and family), our network was perfectly placed to channel these insights into people's real-life experiences of accessing the system. Exploring the entirety of how ADP operates, the review recognised the achievements associated with ADP as a payment based upon the values of dignity, fairness and respect, while seeking to understand how to build on those achievements. It includes several important recommendations, such as establishing a group of people who have direct experience of accessing ADP from Social Security Scotland – placing real-world perspectives at the heart of Scotland's social security agency. This would be augmented by agency-wide training for staff in how to support people who have experienced trauma, embedding a flexible approach which is crucial to preventing further harm. Other simple, transformative suggestions include improvements to the ADP application form and giving people the option from the outset to discuss their circumstances with specialist staff either in person or remotely. Evidence from our network shows that many people struggle with the nature of their circumstances, often unable to articulate or even perceive them clearly. Giving people the opportunity to interact directly with agency staff can be the most effective way of conveying a complete and accurate picture of their situation. Empowering people in this way would help to avoid inaccurate decisions, resulting in fewer disputes that cause psychological and financial harm. The review is clear. Ambition is needed if ADP is to become a truly world-leading payment. For example, facilitating seamless connections between social security to other agencies and services that a person might need, such as a local authority team, would facilitate consistency in decision-making and better anchor services to the needs of individuals. Achieving this means revising the ADP eligibility criteria to focus on the impact of health on wellbeing and everyday outcomes, such as being able to prepare a nutritious meal. It means accounting for the way health conditions interact and explicitly recognising health related risks and potential harms. The review has drawn a map towards a process that sensitively explores the multiple dimensions of a person's life and health, including medical information; the ability to perform tasks; personal circumstances; and social and environmental realities. Such an approach would radically improve the experience of, and trust in, social security and its ability to identify and fulfil the needs of disabled people. The Scottish Government will now consider whether to accept the review's recommendations. Our view is that doing so would take Scotland forward toward a genuinely world-leading, participative and fair social security payment; surely a promising future worth investing in. Erica Young is senior policy officer in the social justice team at Citizens Advice Scotland
