NEPRA approves Rs50b write-off for KE
The National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA) approved on Thursday a write-off amount of Rs50.013 billion for K-Electric (KE) under the Multi-Year Tariff (MYT) period of FY2017 to FY2023. While still an acknowledgment, it is much less than what KE had asked for despite meeting NEPRA's strict guidelines on what constitutes prudent cost recovery.
The approved amount is part of the broader claim of Rs76 billion submitted by KE, for which NEPRA hearings were held in December 2024 and April 2025. Ensuring the write-off amount pertaining to unrecovered dues comprised an extensive process of meeting stringent conditions, including verification of essential documents, multiple recovery efforts, disconnections, and KE's Board certifying that all reasonable and best possible recovery efforts were undertaken.
The approved write-offs are strictly based on criteria laid out in KE's NEPRA-approved write-off policy and have undergone rigorous internal and external audits, including physical surveys and consumer-level documentation checks.
During the hearings, KE officials had stressed that these unrecovered amounts were not a result of inefficiency but a reflection of ground realities, such as the presence of unplanned settlementsslumsleading to operational challenges in areas where recoveries are no longer possible due to demolition, migration, or theft. Hearing discussions also included matters like the circular debt, which KE highlighted it had no contribution to.
Interveners and commenters shared their statements and opinions regarding KE's write-off claims. Sheikh M Tehseen, President of the Federal B Area Association of Trade & Industry (FBATI), mentioned that KE's financial sustainability and investment plans were dependent on write-off claims, while emphasising that under the current tariff framework, any such claims should be resolved fairly, recognising that 100% recovery in a city like Karachi is unrealistic.
Similarly, the President of the SITE Association of Industry, in his letter, had expressed support for a timely resolution of KE's write-off claims, emphasising the need to maintain KE's operational stability while protecting industrial stakeholders from additional financial burden, and urging NEPRA to ensure a balanced decision that supported uninterrupted industrial operations and served the greater public interest.
The Secretary General of the Overseas Investors Chamber of Commerce & Industry (OICCI) highlighted KE's investments since privatisation and wrote about its performance as a benchmark for future investors, mentioning that NEPRA's decision would set the mood for the privatisation of DISCOs. He stated that a fair evaluation and subsequent decision would support foreign direct investment (FDI) and restore investor confidence in the energy sector.
The last few days have witnessed approvals and decisions by NEPRA for KE's critical matters, including the determination of its transmission, distribution, and supply tariffs, with the write-off decision being the latest in this series.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
a day ago
- Express Tribune
SHC suspends Moonis Alvi's removal in harassment case
Listen to article The Sindh High Court (SHC) on Friday suspended the decision of the Provincial Ombudsperson that had ordered the removal of K-Electric Chief Executive Officer Moonis Alvi over allegations of workplace harassment. The interim relief came during a hearing before a two-member bench headed by Justice Faisal Kamal Alam and comprising Justice Hassan Akbar. The court was hearing a petition filed by Alvi, challenging the ombudsperson's verdict delivered a day earlier. Barrister Abid Zuberi, counsel for the petitioner, submitted that the provincial ombudsperson lacked jurisdiction in the matter, arguing that KE is an interprovincial entity and, therefore, falls under the purview of federal legislation. Also Read: Senior lawyer Khawaja Shamsul Islam shot dead in Karachi The court inquired about the legal flaws in the ombudsperson's ruling. Zuberi contended that the order to remove Alvi and impose a penalty of Rs2.5 million was issued without jurisdiction and in contravention of the relevant laws. 'The ombudsperson's office is not authorised to adjudicate such matters. In similar cases, jurisdiction has been found with the National Industrial Relations Commission (NIRC) or labour courts,' he argued. He further pointed out that KE supplies electricity to areas beyond Sindh, including Lasbela and Hub, which categorises it as an interprovincial company. Therefore, the case should be dealt with by the Federal Ombudsperson. The court, after hearing the arguments, suspended the removal order until the next hearing, scheduled for August 8. It directed Alvi to deposit the Rs2.5 million fine with the Nazir of the SHC. A request by the petitioner's counsel to reduce the amount was declined by the bench. Read: Pakistan hit with 19pc tariff as Trump targets dozens of countries with new duties Mahreen Aziz Khan, a former consultant at KE and the company's first female CxO, had filed a complaint under the Protection Against Harassment of Women at the Workplace Act, 2010, accusing CEO Moonis Alvi of harassment and creating a hostile work environment. In his verdict, Sindh Ombudsman Justice (retd) Shahnawaz Tariq stated that Alvi had committed harassment, created a hostile environment, and caused mental agony at the workplace to the complainant and her team. The ombudsman had ordered Alvi's removal from service under Section 4(ii)(d) of the Act and directed him to pay a fine of Rs2.5 million within one month.
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
SHC suspends ombudsman's order to remove KE CEO Moonis Alvi
The Sindh High Court (SHC) has suspended provincial ombudsman's decision to remove K-Electric Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Moonis Alvi from his office. The KE through a disclosure form apprised the Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) in this regard, saying that the KE CEO has filed a petition in the SHC 'which has suspended the operation of Provincial Ombudsman's Order dated July 31, 2025'. A day ago, the Sindh ombudsman had ordered to remove Alvi from his position of K-Electric's CEO, over his alleged involvement in a case pertaining to 'workplace harassment'. Sindh Ombudsman for the Protection against Harassment of Women at the Workplace Justice (retired) Shah Nawaz Tariq also imposed a fine of Rs2.5 million on Alvi in the same case. 'Moonis Abdullah Alvi is penalised under section 4(4)(ii)(c) of the Act, 2010, and is removed from his service instantly,' read the order issued by the ombudsperson. Sindh ombudsman orders to remove KE CEO Moonis Alvi for 'workplace harassment' Justice (retired) Tariq said in his decision that the KE CEO Alvi harassed and mentally tortured the complainant. 'If Moonis Alvi fails to pay the fine, his movable and immovable property should be confiscated and his CNIC and passport should also be blocked,' he ordered. Meanwhile, Alvi has termed the ombudsman's decision 'deeply distressing' for him, saying the findings did not reflect the truth of the situation as he experienced it. The KE chief executive said he always upheld the values of integrity and dignity in professional interactions, and he deeply believed in fostering safe and inclusive workplaces for all. In its disclosure form submitted to the PSX today, KE said the employee had lodged the complaint against the CEO and three other officials in November 2020 before the ombudsman, after she was terminated from services by the company 'on October 14, 2020, on performance reasons'. Following the complaint, the provincial ombudsman issued a show cause notice on November 24, 2020, to the accused persons. The show cause notice was challenged by the accused persons before the SHC for being without jurisdiction inter alia on the grounds that (i) an ex-employee could not file a complaint under the Act of 2010 after termination from employment (ii) the nature of allegations do not fall within the confines of the Act of 2010 and (iii) KE being a trans-provincial organisation, the complaint was not maintainable before the provincial ombudsman. The KE said the SHC on December 1, 2020, directed that no final order shall be passed by the provincial ombudsman, however, the court later observed that the ombudsman can continue the proceedings of the complaint. Being aggrieved by the observation of the SHC, the accused persons challenged the same before the Supreme Court, which is currently pending adjudication, it added. An appeal was also filed in the relevant office of the Sindh governor, the KE maintained.
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Order issued by Sindh ombudsman: KE CEO denies charges
KARACHI: K-Electric (KE) CEO Moonis Alvi vehemently denies charges of harassment in the 22-page order by the Sindh ombudsman on Thursday, categorically stating that he is set to appeal the decision that his lawyer termed an 'unreasoned order'. In a series of tweets on X, Alvi – the longest-serving CEO of KE – said that he was going to fight back. 'The recent verdict is deeply distressing to me,' he said on X. 'While I respect the legal process and the institutions that uphold it, I must, in good conscience, state that the findings do not reflect the truth of the situation as I experienced it. 'I am currently reviewing the decision with my legal counsel and will be exercising my right to appeal… I remain committed to ensuring that the truth is fully brought to light, through all lawful means available.' On behalf of Alvi, Senior Counsels Barrister Abid S Zuberi and Barrister Ayan Memon announced the intention to appeal. 'We respect the honourable court and all its decisions. However, in light of serious procedural and legal inconsistencies, we are moving to appeal this decision before the appropriate forum and are confident that justice will prevail. 'The distorted framing of performance feedback as harassment, imposition of severest penalty without reasoned rationale and anchoring of baseless allegations are massively concerning. 'Mr Alvi gave full disclosure of work performance-related issues of the complainant and retaliatory complaints after her termination. These facts have been totally ignored. 'A substantial portion of the order has been dedicated to frivolous allegations, not backed by hard evidence.' In his message on X, KE Spokesperson said that today's decision by the Ombudsman has been a challenging moment for the KE family, for our stakeholders and well-wishers alike. On behalf of KE, want to state unequivocally: KE stands by the principles of truth, due process, and the values of a professional and respectful workplace. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
