Mental Health Commission finds 'concerning' attitude towards rules in HSE inpatient centres
It comes against the backdrop of the standards of compliances improving overall in centres across the country that offer mental health services.
The MHC has also said in its annual report for 2024 that there has been a 'sustained decline' in the use of restrictive practices in centres.
Just six centres nationwide achieved 100% compliance with the regulations.
31 Enforcement actions had to be taken over incidents, events and serious concerns that arose in 20 centres which failed to meet regulations in response to the inspector's report.
The findings found the worst failings in a small number of HSE operated facilities.
Inspector of Mental Health Services Jim Lucey said that these enforcement actions show that the MHC has strengthened its commitment to 'regulatory vigilance' but that they also highlight issues that need to be addressed by HSE leadership.
'Closer attention by the HSE to underperforming approved centres would transform the national picture,' he said.
Individual care planning, staffing levels, and the state of mental health facility buildings were identified as areas where the most centres were failing to meet the regulations.
Advertisement
A HSE spokesperson said that it welcomes the MHC report, and acknowledged that a number of HSE centres have 'recurring or increasing levels of non-compliance' that are 'disproportionately' impacting the health service's 'overall rating'.
They added that the HSE will continue to invest in mental health services.
There were also positive findings noted in the MHC report, including a reduction in the admission of children to adult mental health centres.
Just five of these admissions occurred in 2024, which is the lowest annual number recorded to date.
Lucey praised the decline in the use of coercive and restrictive practices and said that the finding indicates 'one of the most notable human rights advances in mental health care in Ireland in recent times'.
Restrictive and coercive practices refers to patients being physically restricted and secluded for challenging behaviour, which mental health professionals are now trying to avoid in favour of other methods.
The report notes similar levels of compliance with the rules across approved centres to 2023, but it notes that 'there was a marked difference in levels of compliance achieved across the HSE's Community Healthcare Organisations.
'Overall average compliance across all adult centres within a HSE CHO was just under 81% in 2024,' it states.
CHO 6 (Wicklow, Dun Laoghaire, Dublin South East) had the worst average rate of compliance at 64.65%.
Eight of the non-compliances found in the Acute Mental Health Unit in Cork University Hospital were deemed to be of a critical risk level, compared with six of the non -compliances in the centre in Tallaght Hospital, and four in the Midland Regional Hospital in Portlaoise.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Anti-sunscreen ‘lies' sweeping social media are dangerous, dermatologist warns
Influencers on platforms such as TikTok are claiming in posts that chemicals in sunscreen are dangerous. Some viral clips have gone so far as to claim 'the sun does not cause skin cancer'. Reality TV star Sam Faiers from The Only Way Is Essex was criticised when she recently posted that none of her family used sunscreen as she believed it was 'full of toxic ingredients'. Professor Anne Marie Tobin, the HSE's national clinical lead for dermatology, said there is 'absolutely no truth' to the claims and warned that misinformation is particularly dangerous for the Irish population. She said 75pc of Irish people have skin that is at risk of burning on exposure to the sun, 'and never tan or tan only after a long time, so they're at particular risk of skin cancer'. It makes no sense to me. It's anti-science, anti-evidence — it's just untrue The consultant dermatologist at Tallaght University Hospital said there is no evidence to suggest the chemicals in sunscreen are harmful. 'It makes no sense to me. It's anti-science, anti-evidence — it's just untrue. By not using sunscreen, people are increasing their risk of cancer. Apart from the risk of skin cancer, exposure to the sun really damages your collagen, that's incredibly ageing.' Prof Tobin said sunscreen has decades of scientific backing, and added: 'It originated in Western Australia, where they have a very high skin cancer rate. There's good evidence to show that it works. Skin cancer is entirely preventable. Unlike certain cancers, like colon cancer, you can completely avoid it.' She said the rates continue to be 'very high' in Ireland, despite the availability of sunscreen for several decades. One blistering sunburn in childhood or adolescence more than doubles your chances of developing melanoma in later life,' she added.
Irish Times
14 hours ago
- Irish Times
HSE accused of ‘abandoning rural mothers' at protest over Portiuncula maternity services
The HSE was accused of abandoning mothers in rural areas during a protest prompted by concerns over the future of maternity services at Portiuncula University Hospital in Co Galway . About 2,000 people from western and midland counties marched through Ballinasloe on Saturday to chants of 'Care Can't Wait – Reinstate". The demonstration was organised by the Portiuncula Maternity Alliance (PMA), which was established after the HSE decided that expectant mothers with high-risk pregnancies would have their antenatal care moved from Portiuncula to other locations. The decision was taken on foot of a report published last month that summarised five reviews of care provided to women and their babies at Portiuncula and found there were 'significant clinical risks' at the maternity unit. READ MORE The HSE has said it was committed to implementing the 34 recommendations contained in the reviews and had established an implementation team to do this. Protesters carried county flags and placards, one of which read 'No births on the M6!'. Among those participating were nuns from the Franciscan Missionaries of the Divine Motherhood, the order that established the hospital in 1943. Cllr Evelyn Francis Parsons, a GP and Independent member of Galway County Council , told protesters it was wonderful to see such a turnout and that 'together we will not let [the hospital] be downgraded'. 'This hospital and especially its maternity unit is not just bricks and mortar, it has been part of our families, our community for many, many years,' she said. 'Behind every statistic, behind every policy decision, there are real people, mothers, babies, families and staff.' She said mothers' voices have not been heard much in the debate about Portiuncula and she shared some experiences of women cared for there in the past. Ms Parsons cited the case of Mary O'Malley, whose child experienced hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, a brain injury caused by a lack of oxygen and blood flow to babies. 'Her care was reviewed. These are her words: 'Forcing a high-risk pregnant woman to travel is not a safety plan. It's a terrifying gamble with our lives, with our babies lives, on the road. We were promised a safe modern service. Instead of delivering that promise, the HSE is abandoning rural mothers, and forcing us to bear the risk of its own strategic failures'.' Kevin Connolly, a retired paediatrician who worked at Portiuncula from 1978 to 2010, said he was very proud to have worked at the hospital. 'I am very concerned that the right thing is not being done, the wrong thing has been imposed on us,' he said. 'What has been imposed on us is not safe, is reducing capacity and taking away resources. It is patently the wrong thing to do and it must stop. We have to win.' Ms Parsons said that 'when services are downgraded they rarely come back', noting the experiences of Nenagh and Roscommon, where accident and emergency departments were closed years ago. 'But I also want you to look at Portlaoise, they fought and they saved their maternity unit. And so can we,' she added. 'We demand proper staffing, proper resourcing and proper respect for our healthcare workers, our nurses, midwives, doctors and all the other staff. 'This is about mothers, the guardians of our future, it's about our babies, our families. It's about equality, about rural families. They deserve the same level of care as families in Dublin, Galway or anywhere else in Ireland.'
Irish Examiner
2 days ago
- Irish Examiner
'I fear the HSE won't step up': Pregnant women scrambling for options following closure of private midwife service
Expectant women as far along as 38 weeks pregnant have been left scrambling for options after the sudden closure of a private midwifery service offering homebirths, a midwife working for them said. Private Midwives Ireland (PMI) closed abruptly on Wednesday, citing financial pressures as did their UK parent company. Community midwife Sarah McCann had one client at 38 weeks and three days pregnant that day. 'These women are just so upset,' she said. 'They feel comfortable and safe with us because they know us and trust us now. 'I'm devastated for her and for the women of Ireland I'm devastated because they are now even more curtailed in their choices.' The Coombe hospital has stepped in for this woman with Ms McCann welcome in as a support person, not a midwife. She had eight PMI clients making up about 1/3 of her work, the remainder are under the HSE's national homebirth service. The two services applied different criteria with the HSE for example excluding women who had a caesarean section previously. Ms McCann said this means none of her PMI clients can transfer over. 'I fear that the HSE won't step up,' she said. I feel that PMI being here and offering this alternative was good. "I do not think the HSE will step in and meet these women's needs.' She warned that 'free birth is going to happen more often I think. That's what I am hearing.' The former PMI midwives are in talks with an English insurance broker as a group to try and re-arrange insurance to continue working. Meanwhile 'tens' of affected pregnant women contacted the Association for Improvements in Maternity Services (AIMS) Ireland for advice, according to chairwoman Kyrsia Lynch. "Women found out about this online on Wednesday, on Instagram and Facebook. It was shocking." She acknowledged it was a private service, but said: 'they did provide a service which the HSE failed to provide' until now. PMI took on clients in geographic areas where the HSE doesn't provide a service. She shares Ms McCann's concerns around choice. 'You might not be able to get past the first post if something in your medical history falls foul of the HSE's blanket criteria,' she warned. She is also aware of women considering free births, saying making that decision under pressure due to lack of options is ' a coerced decision' compared to planning it from the start. 'It's very different because often those decisions are a lot less informed then,' she said. The HSE indicated it is aware of talk around free birthing. 'While the HSE is aware that a small number of women choose to give birth without medical assistance, this is not recommended,' a spokesman said. 'Unassisted births carry increased risks and are not covered by State Claims Agency insurance. 'The HSE strongly advises that all births are attended by a trained midwife and/or obstetrician.'
