Mental Health Commission finds 'concerning' attitude towards rules in HSE inpatient centres
THE MENTAL HEALTH Commission (MHC) has said that it has identified 'concerning attitudes towards compliance' in a number of HSE-run mental health centres which are persistently out of step with the rules of safe care.
It comes against the backdrop of the standards of compliances improving overall in centres across the country that offer mental health services.
The MHC has also said in its annual report for 2024 that there has been a 'sustained decline' in the use of restrictive practices in centres.
Just six centres nationwide achieved 100% compliance with the regulations.
31 Enforcement actions had to be taken over incidents, events and serious concerns that arose in 20 centres which failed to meet regulations in response to the inspector's report.
The findings found the worst failings in a small number of HSE operated facilities.
Inspector of Mental Health Services Jim Lucey said that these enforcement actions show that the MHC has strengthened its commitment to 'regulatory vigilance' but that they also highlight issues that need to be addressed by HSE leadership.
'Closer attention by the HSE to underperforming approved centres would transform the national picture,' he said.
Individual care planning, staffing levels, and the state of mental health facility buildings were identified as areas where the most centres were failing to meet the regulations.
Advertisement
A HSE spokesperson said that it welcomes the MHC report, and acknowledged that a number of HSE centres have 'recurring or increasing levels of non-compliance' that are 'disproportionately' impacting the health service's 'overall rating'.
They added that the HSE will continue to invest in mental health services.
There were also positive findings noted in the MHC report, including a reduction in the admission of children to adult mental health centres.
Just five of these admissions occurred in 2024, which is the lowest annual number recorded to date.
Lucey praised the decline in the use of coercive and restrictive practices and said that the finding indicates 'one of the most notable human rights advances in mental health care in Ireland in recent times'.
Restrictive and coercive practices refers to patients being physically restricted and secluded for challenging behaviour, which mental health professionals are now trying to avoid in favour of other methods.
The report notes similar levels of compliance with the rules across approved centres to 2023, but it notes that 'there was a marked difference in levels of compliance achieved across the HSE's Community Healthcare Organisations.
'Overall average compliance across all adult centres within a HSE CHO was just under 81% in 2024,' it states.
CHO 6 (Wicklow, Dun Laoghaire, Dublin South East) had the worst average rate of compliance at 64.65%.
Eight of the non-compliances found in the Acute Mental Health Unit in Cork University Hospital were deemed to be of a critical risk level, compared with six of the non -compliances in the centre in Tallaght Hospital, and four in the Midland Regional Hospital in Portlaoise.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Vaping has led a surge of young people using nicotine/tobacco products
The number of young people vaping and/or using other tobacco products has surged from less than 20% in 2015 to 30% almost a decade later., new Irish analysis shows. Experts have also warned that the decrease in tobacco cigarette use has slowed in parallel with a rise in e-cigarette use. Ireland has seen an experiment in 'unrestricted access' to vapes with worrying consequences, warned Paul Kavanagh, chair of the Royal College of Physicians clinical advisory group on smoking and e-cigarettes. It follows a finding this week from the Irish National Cancer Registry that up-take of e-cigarettes has been 'particularly marked among young people and adolescent non-smokers'. Dr Kavanagh was co-author on new Irish analysis published in The Lancet Regional Health – Europe. He said: It may well be another 10, 15, 20 years before we have a definitive and clear picture in relation to the health effects of e-cigarettes particularly when it comes to some disease categories like cancer. 'Nicotine is a poison, it's a psychoactive drug, and it's addictive. These e-cigarette products contain nicotine and in fact they can contain it in uncertain and unpredictable doses.' Dr Kavanagh added: 'Of course there is then that concern also that using an e-cigarette may lead young people to go on and start smoking.' Surge in uptake of vaping The analysis showed that vape use increased from 3.1% to 8.4% across all ages, and dual use increased from 1.3% to 3.1%. Among those aged 15–24 use of vapes and/or tobacco increased from 19·6% in 2015 to 30% in 2023. They also found that while in 2015 the use of vapes and tobacco cigarettes together was 'strongly associated' with higher odds of wanting to quit smoking, that is no longer the case. This is against a backdrop of the ban on sales of vapes and tobacco products to under-18s since December 2023. Despite that ban, teenagers speaking to the Irish Examiner described how vapes remain very popular. HSE data on prosecutions New HSE figures show that 51 retailers were prosecuted for selling tobacco products to children last year including — for the first time — eight prosecutions for sale of vapes to children. Disposable vapes in breach of regulations that were purchased in Waterford City. Picture: Joe Evans HSE assistant national director for environmental health Ann Marie Part said: 'While the majority of retailers take active measures to confirm the age of someone buying tobacco or vape products, it is disappointing to see some retailers still selling to children.' She added: 'All it takes is a request for ID at the counter to ensure you are selling to someone over the legal age.' Also last year the HSE National Environmental Health Service prosecuted two shops for selling e-cigarettes with nicotine levels higher than legally allowed. In 2023, working in conjunction with Customs and Revenue, they seized 37.8 tonnes and last year 26.6 tonnes of vapes or refill products with illegal nicotine levels. Links between sales of vapes and the tobacco industry were discussed during the World Conference on Tobacco Control in Dublin this week.
Irish Independent
12 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Not economically viable to re-open hydrotherapy pool at Cregg, meeting is told
He said senior HSE management recently met with respect to the hydrotherapy pool at the former Cregg Campus and following consideration a decision has been made not to progress/pursue a business case pertaining to the re-opening of the pool. 'A number of factors were considered in reaching this decision.' he said. 'Substantial financial resources would be required in order to bring the pool to a standard which both adheres to safety regulations and also comprehensively meets the needs of people potentially requiring the service. 'Furthermore, the HSE is mandated in utilising available resources in the most beneficial, effective and efficient manner. The re-opening of the hydrotherapy pool is not economically viable. Ultimately, the HSE is closing out all its arrangements within the former Cregg Campus. 'This decision is in line with current national HSE policy, such as the New Directions Policy for Adult Disability Day Services, which focuses on shifting from traditional, disability specific and centre based models of care to more individualised, outcome focused supports including community inclusion and active citizenship i.e. a community based social model of care. 'Furthermore, the decision was made following cross care group consultation within the HSE, the future and anticipated demand for hydrotherapy and with the needs of service users to the fore. 'Finally, any service user, who is clinically identified as requiring the use of a hydrotherapy pool, may be facilitated in Our Lady's Hospital, Manorhamilton.' he said. Cllr Declan Bree, said he was disappointed with the response, particularly given the fact that the hydrotherapy pool in Cregg had been part funded by the public 'Many disabled people, people with Multiple Sclerosis, with Cerebral Palsy, with Parkinsons Disease, require the use of a hydrotherapy pool. 'I note from the reply I have received today that any service user, who is clinically identified as requiring the use of a hydrotherapy pool, can be facilitated in Our Lady's Hospital, in Manorhamilton. 'I welcome this because it has been my view, for quite some time, that the hydrotherapy pool in Manorhamilton was not being used to its full potential,' he said.
RTÉ News
12 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Warning issued after strain of avian influenza detected in wild sea birds
The Department of Agriculture has issued a warning after a strain of avian influenza - or bird flu - was detected in a number of wild sea birds off the west coast of Ireland in recent weeks. Minister for Agriculture Martin Heyden said that "in the past three weeks, there have been a number of reports of groups of dead wild sea birds washing up on shorelines in counties Kerry, Clare and Galway. "In two instances, a wild sea bird which washed up on a beach tested positive for H5N1 avian influenza virus, with one case in Kerry and one in Galway." Members of the public are advised not to touch or pick up dead wild birds and to keep pet dogs on a leash in areas where there are sick or dead wild birds. Meanwhile, poultry farmers in coastal areas of Kerry, Clare and Galway have been advised to implement stringent biosecurity measures to mitigate the risk of the disease spreading to their flocks. Farmers are also asked to report any suspicions of avian influenza to their local Regional Veterinary Office. The department also said the public can continue to report incidents of dead wild birds via its Avian Check app. The HSE and Health Protection Surveillance Centre have advised that the risk to public health from the strain of avian influenza currently circulating (Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza subtype H5N1) is considered low for the general public, and low to medium for occupationally exposed people. Special biosecurity regulations for poultry were in place due to the increased risk of bird flu from last December to the end of May. No outbreaks of the high pathogenic HPAI strain were detected in commercial poultry flocks in Ireland last year or so far in 2025.
