Orders status quo amid concerns over demolition
The Bombay High Court on Friday sought to know from the Urban Development Department (UDD) of Maharashtra government by when the heritage status will be granted to the residence of Hindutva ideologue VD Savarkar, Savarkar Sadan, situated at Shivaji Park area of Central Mumbai.
The court passed an order while hearing a PIL by a public charitable trust called Abhinav Bharat Congress, seeking heritage status for the premises and a directive to declare the building 'monument of national importance' and formulate special compensation policy for its inhabitants.
The court issued notices to respondent authorities seeking their response to the PIL during next hearing on June 13 and ordered that till the said date the status of the property shall not be changed.
A division bench of Justices Atul S Chandurkar and Neela K Gokhale was hearing the PIL by the Trust filed through its co-founder and authorised representative, Professor Pankaj Phadnis, who resides in the building, seeking directive to the state UDD to issue a notification so as to include the 'Savarkar Sadan' property in the heritage list in terms of final recommendation of the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) to Principal Secretary UDD through letter dated August 30, 2010.
The petitioner contended that the Municipal Architect (Development Plan) of the BMC on January 20, 2012, too, had written to the UDD to make such a recommendation for heritage status to the said property.
The petitioner claimed that after an inaction of more than ten years, the Chief Minister's Office on February 1, 2025 forwarded to UDD an email sent by the petitioner raising grievances, requiring the steps to be taken and enquiries to be made in the matter.
The PIL alleged 'apathy' by the state government of 'sitting on recommendation to give the site a heritage status for fifteen years' and apprehended that the same has left the building vulnerable to demolition or redevelopment. It said that while Jinnah House is granted heritage status, Savarkar Sadan has remained unnotified despite having historical relevance.
Phadnis, citing a news report of earlier this month, apprehended that prior to such heritage status being bestowed to the said property, it is likely to be demolished.
After hearing the petitioner, the bench issued notices to respondents UDD, BMC, Mumbai Police and Union Ministry of Culture seeking their responses during the next hearing.
'Instructions be obtained from the first respondent (UDD) as regards the time within which the grant of heritage status to the aforesaid premises would be undertaken. Till the returnable date, the status of the said property shall not be changed and the position as prevailing today shall be maintained,' the bench noted in the order.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Wire
4 hours ago
- The Wire
Modi 3.0: No Longer the Intransigent Prime Minister We Knew
The last one year has showed that the prime minister, in his third term, has found his once-potent political cocktail of Hindutva and muscular nationalism insufficient to remain in control. He has been forced to publicly acknowledge the significance of caste politics and add it to his strategic mix officially.
The Print
9 hours ago
- The Print
Hindutva grouse returns to haunt an MF Husain auction in Mumbai. Latest row & past controversies
The Hindutva outfit has also submitted a memorandum to this effect to Home Minister Amit Shah, Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, and Mumbai Commissioner of Police Deven Bharti, warning of a public agitation if they refused to meet its demands. There are neither any new grouses nor any fresh grounds for the outfit to call for the scrapping of the auction. The HJS has claimed that Husain previously hurt Hindu sentiments, and the auction would be akin to a 'glorification of his criminal deeds'. Mumbai: The late Indian modernist painter, M.F. Husain, has once again riled up Hindutva activists ahead of a rare auction of his 25 paintings Thursday at Hamilton House, Mumbai. The Hindu Janajagruti Samiti (HJS) has called for the scrapping of the auction. ThePrint reached out to Hindu Janajagruti Samiti over a call, but the member who picked up the call refused to comment. Hamilton House, or Pundole Art Gallery was also contacted via calls and email for its comments. Once a response comes, the report will be updated. The HJS threats are nothing new. The illustrious art career of Husain, who died in 2011 in London at 95 years of age after a self-imposed exile, was marked with protests, police complaints, and legal tussles with Hindutva outfits back home. Controversies over Husain's paintings Maqbool Fida Husain, known as Picasso of India, was a revered artist who, at the same time, was a child of controversies. He produced nearly 60,000 works of art in his 95 years of life, covering subjects ranging from the Ramayana and Mahabharata to the British colonisation and motifs of urban and rural India. However, some of his works, especially in the 90s, landed him in the crosshairs of the saffron brigade and political outfits. In 1996, he drew the goddess of knowledge, Saraswati, nude. Hindutva outfits, such as Vishwa Hindu Parishad and Hindu Janajagruti Samiti, strongly criticised it. In the late 1990s, Bajrang Dal activists attacked his exhibition in Ahmedabad, destroying some of his paintings. Enraged again in 1998 by a painting depicting a nude Sita, sitting on the tail of Hanuman, Bajrang Dal activists attacked his home in South Mumbai. At the time, Husain had to apologise for things to calm down. 'We should find a way once and for all to establish what is art and what is obscenity. It is not an attack on me but on culture and the freedom of expression,' M.F. Husain told the media back then. His representations of Hindu gods and goddesses such as Shiva and Durga—allegedly controversial—led to legal actions and threats in the early 2000s. After years, nearly a decade later, he again landed in a controversy for painting 'Bharat Mata' nude. He had drawn a nude woman in red, in the shape of India. At the time, the backlash was severe, with multiple cases filed against him in several states under sections 153A, 295A, and 292 of the Indian Penal Code, which pertain to promoting enmity between communities, insulting religious sentiments, and participating in or promoting businesses selling obscene objects, respectively. The Bal Thackeray-led Shiv Sena attacked his exhibition titled India in the Era of Mughals in Delhi in 2007, vandalising two of his paintings. Though Husain then apologised for the portrayal, he left the country in 2006 and sought asylum in Doha. He spent his last years between Doha, Dubai, and London. In 2008, the Delhi High Court dismissed the criminal cases against him. In 2011, the Supreme Court consolidated all the cases in the lower courts. Then, it passed a judgment, extending protection to his art under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution, guaranteeing freedom of speech and expression. Also Read: Mumbra train tragedy: Call for automated doors, more trains after at least 4 dead due to overcrowding The auction Back in 2004, Swarup Shrivastava, a Mumbai-based art collector and chairman of Swarup Group of Industries, bought 25 paintings from Husain for a deal. Each painting cost Rs one crore each. The deal was to commission 100 paintings for Rs 100 crore. However, in 2006, the Central Bureau of Investigation initiated a probe against the Swarup Group and Srivastava for allegedly misappropriating Rs 150 crore from Rs 236 crore taken in loans from the National Agricultural Cooperative Marketing Federation of India (NAFED). A tribunal in December 2008 permitted NAFED to secure the Husain paintings among assets of Rs 100 crore. Finally, the case reached the Bombay High Court, which asked for a valuation of the paintings from the Pundole Art Gallery. Last year, in May, Pundole submitted that the valuation was Rs 25 crore for 25 paintings. Subsequently, the Bombay HC, in a February 2025 order, allowed the sheriff of Mumbai to auction 25 paintings to recover the dues from Shrivastava. The auction, titled 'M.F. Husain: An artist's vision of the XX century', includes 25 canvases painted as a part of the OPCE, Our Planet Called Earth, series by Husain. The Hindu Janajagruti Samiti has submitted a memorandum to the government officials to raise objections. The memorandum stated, 'M.F. Husain, during the 26/11 Mumbai attacks, painted a nude and disrespectful image of Bharat Mata titled 'Rape of Mother India', which is a severe act of sedition. In other paintings, he portrayed Bharat Mata nude with names of Indian cities written on her body.' 'Holding an auction of these 25 paintings is tantamount to indirectly supporting his previous anti-national and anti-social acts. Glorifying such individuals under the guise of 'artistic freedom' is unacceptable. The Patiala House Court in Delhi has recently ordered the seizure of Husain's controversial paintings, and an investigation is underway,' the HJS added in its memorandum. In the past, there had been cancellations of his exhibitions in India and revocations of awards in his name, the memorandum further stated. (Edited by Madhurita Goswami) Also Read: Solo or together? The big question for Maharashtra alliances this BMC poll season
Hindustan Times
10 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
State issues order to BMC to prepare draft on ward formation
MUMBAI: The state government on Tuesday ordered BMC to prepare the draft on ward formation for BMC polls and made it clear that BMC will go for polls with 227 seats. Along with the BMC, the state government also issued orders to all other civic bodies to start the work on draft ward formation and also made it clear that not the current population figures but the figures from the last census - 2011 census - should be used in ward formation and reservation. Except for Mumbai, there will be four elected members in each ward. In BMC and class A, B, C municipal corporations, municipal commissioners will prepare draft ward formation, while in class D municipal corporations, district collectors will have this authority. Recently, after the Supreme Court decision on conducting the local body elections in Maharashtra in mid-May, the state election commission had written to the state government, asking it to start the formation of wards for all local bodies going for elections. Accordingly, on Tuesday, the state government issued separate orders regarding the preparation of draft ward formation to all civic bodies. As per the estimates, it would be completed in around two months and submitted to the state election commission. The commission wants to complete the process of ward formation before September 16 - the date on which the Supreme Court will hear ongoing petitions on local body elections. Commissioner and district collectors of respective civic bodies will prepare draft ward formation and submit it to the state election commission. After the state election commission approves it, the commissioner will publicise it and complete the process of inviting objections and suggestions, and then submit it again to the commission. The commission will approve the final ward formation and the respective commissioner and district collector will then declare it in their area. Regarding the formation of wards, the order states: 'Use 'Google Earth' map, decide boundaries by using river-road-bridge-flyover-railway track. No building, chawl or home should be divided into two wards. Open spaces in the ward cannot be kept out of it. No scheduled caste or tribal habitat should be divided into separate wards, they should be in one ward only. No locality should be divided into separate wards.' The government also directed the authorities not to disclose any information about draft ward formation to political parties and media, and warned that if anyone is found compromising the secrecy, action would be taken on him.
