Ross Lyon joins chorus of coaches openly criticising AFL over fines and penalties
The tally for fines in 2025 alone is closing in on $500,000 through 17 rounds, with 37 players fined $49,250 in round 16.
In the wake of an AFL crackdown on umpire contact this week, which could lead to increased fines or even suspensions, Essendon coach Brad Scott labelled the fine situation as 'outrageous' and Gold Coast coach Damien Hardwick questioned how a change could be made mid-season.
The AFL Players Association also called for a 'forum' to review the entire match review and tribunal system.
'The AFLPA wrote to the AFL weeks ago to request a forum where the players can sit down and genuinely discuss these issues holistically with the AFL,' AFLPA chief executive Ben Smith said.
'These fines aren't proportionate to the acts committed.
'It's evident to the AFLPA and players that the current MRO and tribunal system is not working and needs to be reviewed and revised, and we look forward to being a part of that process.'
St Kilda great and assistant coach, Robert Harvey, met with the umpires last week to help his club navigate the increasingly dicey waters, but Lyon declared just increasing fines was not a way to curb player behaviour.
'I don't think fines are the solution on anything,' he said on Thursday,
'I don't think I've ever fined a player in my life to get a decision or an action. Ultimately, it's all about education and setting a framework.
'Most of (umpire contact) occurs in the centre bounce. The debate from players and midfield coaches with the umpiring fraternity is what's the right exit and protected area. If the principle is, and we know it is, umpire health and safety, it's the right thing to be doing.
'But it's just finding the right solution.'
AFL boss Andrew Dillon defended the crackdown and said it was merely reinforcing existing rules.
'There hasn't been a change in policy,' he said.
'This was something that's part of the tribunal guidelines that if there's multiple financial sanctions we can refer it to the tribunal.
'We wrote to the clubs at the start of the year and in again in April advising them we may do that, just to put the players on notice.
'We haven't seen a change in player behaviour, so I advised the club CEOs at a meeting on Tuesday. All the CEOs completely understood the situation.
'What we want to do is avoid the contact where its avoidable. We know it can be done.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Halls Creek left without football oval for second season as works delayed
One of outback Australia's most talent-laden footballing communities has been left without a safe football ground for a second consecutive season. Halls Creek, 3,000 kilometres north-east of Perth, is home to 3,600 people and has produced more than 10 AFL and AFLW footballers over the past decade. Scouts have flocked to the town's rough-and-tumble oval, where players like Shane McAdam (Melbourne), Jy Farrar (Gold Coast), Ash Johnson (Collingwood) and Sam Petrevski-Seton (Carlton/West Coast) got their first taste of football. But after months of delays to planned works, the oval remains unsafe for football. In a statement posted to the Shire of Halls Creek's Facebook page, chief executive Sue Leonard acknowledged the news was disappointing. "Due to the unfinished nature of the work, the oval cannot be used safely in any capacity," she said. "We acknowledge the delay is a significant setback for local footy teams, junior sports and many community members who rely on the oval as a central gathering and recreation space. "We want to reassure the public that the project has not been abandoned. "We are actively exploring all options to move the works forward." The local competition split from the wider East Kimberley Football League in 2023 due to the staggering travel distances local clubs faced. But the delays have made it hard for the fledgling South East Kimberley Football League to get up and running. The local competition remains a source of pride, fun and community connection in a region facing immense social challenges. Dennis Chungulla coaches the Yardgee Dockers, one of two teams based in Halls Creek, and said the prospect of another year with limited footy was very disappointing. Despite past violent incidents during matches, he said the games were important "family events". "The footballers are upset," he said. Halls Creek Hawks president Trish Mackay said the delay had seen players drift away from the community. "Some might have gone to Fitzroy [Crossing], some have definitely gone to teams in Kununurra," she said. Sport also provides an important outlet for local youths, with Mr Chungulla often bringing in young players considered "at risk" in the wider community. He said he was increasingly concerned about the impact another year without regular organised football would have. "Without activities like these, you have kids roaming around the streets," Mr Chungulla said. Ms Mackay said those who remained were desperate for footy to return. "I've always got to answer: 'Look at the oval, you can't play on that, so we've got no football,'" she said. "Football is a big part of their lives." Mr Chungulla would like to be on the sidelines cheering the players on with their families as soon as possible, but he is not sure when the oval will be ready to host Australian Rules games again. "We'd like to see something moving forward." Mr Chungulla said the delay meant Halls Creek, Yardgee and other community teams would need help getting the competition up and running again. In a social media statement, the Halls Creek Shire said it was engaging with the contractor — the second one since the works started — and could not provide any further details.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Police appeal for information over suspected link in torture and murder cases
NSW Police officers are investigating a connection between the killing of a 32-year-old man in Sydney to two cases of kidnapping and torture. Strike Force Hallet is investigating whether a "contract crew" is behind the three cases, which are believed to have occurred within a period of six days last year. The state's police force believes the three incidents may be linked to a Victorian crime syndicate. The first case in this suspected timeline involves the kidnapping of a 31-year-old from Canley Vale in Sydney's south-west, which police believe occurred on July 19. It is alleged the man was tortured by his kidnappers, with part of his ear being severed before he was released that day. NSW Police said the kidnapping and torture was not reported to authorities, but detectives did execute a crime scene warrant on October 10 at a Canley Vale property, where the man was believed to have been held during the incident. Police seized a box cutter for further forensic analysis. Two days after the alleged kidnapping, police say an attempted murder took place in south-east Queensland. During the early hours of July 21, a 23-year-old man, covered in dirt and suffering a facial gunshot wound with a bullet lodged in his brain, was taken to hospital after collapsing in a Jimboomba service station. Police believe there was an attempt to murder and bury the man. The 23-year-old was allegedly seen in CCTV footage of a white Hyundai Getz driving through the Mid North Coast carrying four passengers the day before the alleged incident. Four days after this alleged attempted murder, NSW Police believe Rich "Dylan" Choup — a 32-year-old whose remains were found on August 31 last year in bushland at Lucas Heights — was kidnapped before being fatally shot and having the top of his right ear severed. According to NSW Police, Mr Choup was captured shortly after 6pm on CCTV on July 25 meeting and being slapped by a man in Cabramatta, before they both walked towards a grey Audi SQ2. Mr Choup was later reported to police as missing on 29 July. Anyone with information about the vehicles or the men in the CCTV are urged to contact Crime Stoppers on 1800 333 000.
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
‘It's a disgrace': Ricky Stuart blows up over Kyle Flanagan situation
Raiders coach Ricky Stuart has launched a passionate defence of Dragons playmaker Kyle Flanagan after he was booed by the Canberra faithful during his side's 28-24 win. FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer > Raiders fans booed Flanagan as he lined up a conversion in the first half, but dad Shane was caught off-guard when questioned about it post match. 'Never heard it. What would the crowd be booing Kyle for?' Flanagan asked. 'Just kicking the conversion early in the game, they were quite passionate,' the journalist replied. 'I think they do that, so good on them, it's going to happen everywhere,' Flanagan said. However, Stuart was fuming at the journalist over the question. 'Probably a poor question too when you ask Shane about his son,' Stuart said. 'I think it is a disgrace how you guys in the media are just absolutely bashing the kid publicly. 'And that question there about the booing, like honestly, I have got a son playing and that's my biggest fear, you people. 'Not him, but the media. The way he is being portrayed in the media at the moment that poor kid. 'I went up to him after the game and took him aside and spoke to him. I've known him since he has been a little boy. 'He was the leader tonight. He led the charge in terms of them getting back into that game. 'I think it is a disgrace that his so-called Dragons supporters, the social media and the bulls*** that he has to listen to and cop. 'It is something I just don't like. He is a better football player than he is being given credit for. 'The way that boy has handled that from a mental point of view to be able to turn up every week and he said, I'm tough enough I'll handle it. 'I know he is, but it's awful. He led the charge for them tonight and they nearly came back on the back of him to winning that game.' Stuart accused the media of playing games with Flanagan. 'It becomes a game with the media reporting what social media says,' Stuart said. 'You have got to actually look at some of these people involved. It would be torture for his mother. 'I know his old man will handle it, but it would be torture for his mother. Can you imagine if it was one of yours. That's when it becomes real.' Stuart echoed Flanagan's sentiments on the fans booing. 'Were they all Raiders fans were they?' Stuart said. 'They always boo goal kickers. How many games do you go to? I want them to boo their goal kicker. They can throw cans at him for all I care. I want them to boo a bloody goal kicker. That's their job.' Braith Anasta blasted the question as an attempt from a reporter to get a reaction. 'Whoever asked that question, it is one of the stupidest questions I have ever heard,' Anasta said. 'They either know nothing about rugby league or they are just trying to incite a reaction. 'To ask a question about him being booed kicking a goal. Every player gets booed kicking a goal and this reporter has just singled Kyle out because he is in the media at the moment and has pressure on him and there is speculation about his position. 'It is really unprofessional from the reporter who asked that.' Cooper Cronk agreed with Stuart that social media trolls don't deserve airtime. 'I agree with what Ricky said, about giving air time to people whose opinion don't really matter a hell of a lot,' Cronk said. 'You don't listen to people you don't talk to. I agree with what Ricky said. It was the right thing. 'But at the end of the day, people who love our game the fans, like I have been booed at every stadium I have gone to.' Adam Reynolds believes it is harder for people close to players than the players sometimes. 'It is tougher on the external people around you,' Reynolds said. 'Like they said, his mother and sisters, they are the ones that have to deal with it on a daily basis as well. 'It is not just Kyle and the players who are getting targeted. It is the families. 'Social media is so out there these days that it is so easy to get access to players. It can come across a bit offensive at times, but if you read it and listen to it then you are in the wrong sport.' Mal Meninga called for government action against social media abuse. 'I am not on social media for that very reason,' Meninga said. 'The question was stupid and good on Shane and Ricky for protecting young Kyle. 'I get frustrated because I am in the twilight of my life and players have to put up with that sort of crap and then it is the ripple effect. 'It is not just the individual it is everybody that knows him. The family and its stupid. 'They get away with anonymity of it all and not actually disclosing their names. I don't understand how they can do that. How they can come out and criticise people when their name is not to it. 'It is getting to a stage where the government has to do something about it.'
