Italy Cleared Over Libya's Deadly 2017 Migrant Boat Sinking
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has dismissed a case against Italy over its alleged responsibility in a deadly migrant boat sinking off the Libyan coast in 2017. The court ruled that Italy was not liable for the actions of the Libyan Coast Guard, rejecting claims made by 14 survivors of the incident.
The Strasbourg-based court declared the case inadmissible, stating that Italy did not have 'effective control' over the maritime area off Tripoli where the vessel carrying about 150 migrants sank. The tragedy resulted in the deaths of at least 20 people.
According to survivor accounts, those rescued by the Libyan Coast Guard were returned to Libya and detained at the Tajura Detention Centre, where they reportedly faced beatings and abuse. However, the ECHR judges concluded that the Libyan crew aboard the rescue vessel Ras Jadir acted independently, without direct control or instruction from Italian authorities.
While Italy has supported Libya's coast guard with vessels, training, and funding to stem the flow of migrants across the Mediterranean, the court found that such support did not amount to Italy exercising governmental authority over Libya.
Some of the migrants were later rescued by the humanitarian group Sea-Watch and brought to Italy. The 14 complainants were among them.
A ruling in favour of the migrants could have challenged EU-backed migration control agreements with Libya, Turkey, and other nations aimed at limiting migrant arrivals to Europe.
The ECHR clarified that it has no jurisdiction over Libya, which is not a member of the Council of Europe. The court's mandate is limited to the 46 member states of the Council, an entity separate from the European Union, created after World War II to uphold democracy and human rights. Tags: ECHRImmigrationItalylibyamigrants
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Libya Review
4 hours ago
- Libya Review
Libya's State Council Urges Parliament to Restart Political Dialogue
Head of Libya's High Council of State (HCS) Khaled Al-Mishri has formally called on the Speaker of the House of Representatives, Ageela Saleh, to begin urgent consultations to form a new unified Libyan government, amid renewed legal affirmation of Al-Mishri's position. This move follows a ruling by the Administrative Circuit of the Supreme Court (Ruling No. 72/165Q, dated 28 May 2025), which nullified a previous decision from the South Tripoli Court that had contested Al-Mishri's leadership. The Supreme Court's decision confirmed the legitimacy of the electoral process that brought him to office. Al-Mishri emphasised that the court ruling has definitively settled the legal dispute over his leadership, describing the decision as 'final and conclusive.' He warned that the ongoing division of executive and oversight bodies continues to obstruct national reconciliation efforts and delays Libya's critical political deadlines. In his letter, Al-Mishri stressed the urgent need to reactivate the agreed roadmap for unifying sovereign institutions, rebuilding trust in the political process, and paving the way for national elections. He reiterated that ending Libya's transitional phases and delivering stability and sovereignty are essential goals aligned with the aspirations of the Libyan people. Libya has been in chaos since a NATO-backed uprising toppled longtime leader Muammar Gaddafi in 2011. The county has for years been split between rival administrations. Libya's economy, heavily reliant on oil, has suffered due to the ongoing conflict. The instability has led to fluctuations in oil production and prices, impacting the global oil market and Libya's economy. The conflict has led to a significant humanitarian crisis in Libya, with thousands of people killed, and many more displaced. Migrants and refugees using Libya as a transit point to Europe have also faced dire conditions. The planned elections for December 2021 were delayed due to disagreements over election laws and the eligibility of certain candidates. This delay has raised concerns about the feasibility of a peaceful political transition. Despite the ceasefire, security remains a significant concern with sporadic fighting and the presence of mercenaries and foreign fighters. The unification of the military and the removal of foreign forces are crucial challenges. Tags: Ageela SalehHCSKhaled Al-MishrlibyaLibyan parliament
Libya Review
6 hours ago
- Libya Review
Libya's Human Rights Body Blames Dbaiba's Interior Ministry for Militia Abuses
The National Institution for Human Rights in Libya (NIHRL) has strongly condemned disturbing footage showing a young woman being interrogated in chains by a known militia leader, and placed full legal and moral responsibility on the country's Ministry of Interior, headed by the outgoing Prime Minister Abdel-Hamid Dbaiba. In an official statement, the NIHRL expressed 'deep concern' over widely circulated images and videos showing the woman handcuffed and subjected to an inhumane interrogation. The man seen questioning her was identified as Ahmed Al-Dabbashi, also known as Al-Amo, a notorious militia leader operating in Libya's western coastal region. The NIHRL emphasized that Al-Dabbashi has been implicated in numerous serious human rights violations, including the abuse of migrants and Libyan citizens in trafficking hubs under his control in Sabratha. He is also accused of human trafficking, migrant smuggling, and other grave offenses. The statement described the footage as 'a blatant assault on human dignity' and a violation of national laws, constitutional norms, and international human rights principles. The NIHRL further warned that such acts undermine the rule of law and violate the constitutional principle of separation of powers. The institution called on the Attorney General, the judiciary, and relevant security authorities to launch a full, transparent investigation into the abuses allegedly committed by Al-Dabbashi. It demanded swift legal action and the imposition of the harshest penalties available under Libyan law. Crucially, the NIHRL held Libya's Acting Interior Minister and Prime Minister Abdel-Hamid Dbaiba personally responsible for failing to stop these violations and for enabling a security environment in which militia crimes continue with impunity. This case has reignited calls for disarming militias, re-establishing state authority in western Libya, and prosecuting warlords who continue to operate outside the legal system. Tags: Abdel-Hamid DbaibaHuman Rightshuman traffickinglibya
Libya Review
20 hours ago
- Libya Review
Saddam Haftar & Italian Defense Minister Discuss Migration & Border Security in Rome
On Thursday, the Commander of Libya's Ground Forces under the General Command, Saddam Haftar, held official talks in Rome with Italian Defense Minister Guido Crosetto to discuss joint efforts in curbing irregular migration and tackling human trafficking networks. The visit took place in Saddam Haftar's capacity as the envoy of Field Marshal Khalifa Haftar, head of Libya's eastern-based armed forces. According to a statement issued by the War Information Division of the Libyan General Command, the meeting focused on the growing challenges related to migration across the central Mediterranean and the need for greater cooperation to enhance regional security. Both sides exchanged views on recent developments in the Mediterranean region and stressed the importance of a unified approach to managing migration flows, organized crime, and border security. Saddam Haftar reaffirmed the General Command's interest in building a strong, long-term strategic partnership with Italy that serves the shared interests of both countries. Minister Crosetto expressed appreciation for the role of Libyan armed forces in securing the country's borders and maintaining internal order. He acknowledged Libya's efforts in reducing irregular migration and disrupting smuggling routes, particularly in the southern regions, which serve as a key point of departure for migrants heading toward Europe. The meeting followed another session between Saddam Haftar and Italian Interior Minister Matteo Piantedosi, where discussions centered on enhancing security coordination and reducing illegal crossings from North Africa to Italy. Tags: Italian MinisterItalylibyamigrationSaddam Haftarsecurity
