Italy Cleared Over Libya's Deadly 2017 Migrant Boat Sinking
The Strasbourg-based court declared the case inadmissible, stating that Italy did not have 'effective control' over the maritime area off Tripoli where the vessel carrying about 150 migrants sank. The tragedy resulted in the deaths of at least 20 people.
According to survivor accounts, those rescued by the Libyan Coast Guard were returned to Libya and detained at the Tajura Detention Centre, where they reportedly faced beatings and abuse. However, the ECHR judges concluded that the Libyan crew aboard the rescue vessel Ras Jadir acted independently, without direct control or instruction from Italian authorities.
While Italy has supported Libya's coast guard with vessels, training, and funding to stem the flow of migrants across the Mediterranean, the court found that such support did not amount to Italy exercising governmental authority over Libya.
Some of the migrants were later rescued by the humanitarian group Sea-Watch and brought to Italy. The 14 complainants were among them.
A ruling in favour of the migrants could have challenged EU-backed migration control agreements with Libya, Turkey, and other nations aimed at limiting migrant arrivals to Europe.
The ECHR clarified that it has no jurisdiction over Libya, which is not a member of the Council of Europe. The court's mandate is limited to the 46 member states of the Council, an entity separate from the European Union, created after World War II to uphold democracy and human rights. Tags: ECHRImmigrationItalylibyamigrants
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Libya Review
5 hours ago
- Libya Review
Did Libya's Tripoli Government Hold Secret Talks with Israel on Displacing Palestinians?
A report by the Middle East Eye (MEE) has revealed that a senior figure in Libya's UN-recognised Government of National Unity (GNU) has been engaged in secret talks with Israeli officials regarding the potential resettlement of Palestinians expelled from Gaza. According to Middle East Eye (MEE) , the discussions were led by Ibrahim Dbaiba, the national security adviser for his cousin, Prime Minister Abdul Hamid Dbaiba. Multiple Libyan, Arab and European sources told the outlet that the talks were being conducted quietly, without parliamentary knowledge, due to Libya's strongly pro-Palestinian public opinion. According to MEE, a source said 'practical talks' had already taken place, though no clear implementation mechanism had been agreed. Reports suggest that the United States offered Libya economic incentives, including the release of $30bn in frozen state assets, if it accepted displaced Palestinians. The revelations come as Israel continues to float ideas of relocating Gaza's population, with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu recently saying that his government was in contact with 'several countries' over the issue. Israel's Agriculture Minister Avi Dichter even singled out Libya as an 'ideal destination' for Gazans. The proposal has sparked alarm. Analysts warn that transferring Palestinians to Libya – a country fractured by civil war, rival governments and militia rule – could be catastrophic, pushing desperate families into further instability or risky migration routes across the Mediterranean. GNU officials have strongly denied involvement. Prime Minister Abdul Hamid Dbaiba recently said his government 'categorically rejects' any role in what he called the 'crime' of displacing Palestinians, stressing Libya's refusal to normalise ties with Israel. Middle East Eye also claimed that Libya's rival eastern strongman Khalifa Haftar was approached with similar proposals, though he too denied involvement. With Libya already deeply divided, observers say any complicity in Israel's controversial relocation plans could trigger widespread public anger. Tags: Abdel-Hamid DbaibaDisplacementGazaIsraellibyaPalestine
Libya Review
8 hours ago
- Libya Review
25 Libyan Officers Complete Maritime Course in Greece
Greece has completed the first round of training for 25 officers of the Libyan Coast Guard, as part of a broader initiative to curb irregular migration across the Mediterranean. The month-long program, held at the Hellenic Navy's Maritime Training Center in Marathi, Crete, provided practical exercises in patrolling, search and rescue operations, and vessel inspections. The training initiative follows a July meeting in Benghazi between Greek Foreign Minister George Gerapetritis and Libyan National Army (LNA) Commander Field Marshal Khalifa Haftar, during which Haftar requested Greek support in maintaining patrol boats, vehicles, and border surveillance equipment along Libya's frontiers with Egypt and Sudan. A second training course is scheduled for September in either Athens or Thessaloniki, with a specific focus on maritime vessel maintenance—a critical need for Libya's coastal security operations. This cooperation underscores Greece's growing role in supporting Libya's security infrastructure, particularly in tackling migration challenges and enhancing stability in the Eastern Mediterranean. Libya has been in chaos since a NATO-backed uprising toppled longtime leader Muammar Gaddafi in 2011. The county has for years been split between rival administrations. Libya's economy, heavily reliant on oil, has suffered due to the ongoing conflict. The instability has led to fluctuations in oil production and prices, impacting the global oil market and Libya's economy. The conflict has led to a significant humanitarian crisis in Libya, with thousands of people killed, and many more displaced. Migrants and refugees using Libya as a transit point to Europe have also faced dire conditions. The planned elections for December 2021 were delayed due to disagreements over election laws and the eligibility of certain candidates. This delay has raised concerns about the feasibility of a peaceful political transition. Despite the ceasefire, security remains a significant concern with sporadic fighting and the presence of mercenaries and foreign fighters. The unification of the military and the removal of foreign forces are crucial challenges. Tags: Coast guardCreteGreeceGreek Navylibya
Libya Review
9 hours ago
- Libya Review
Libya Explores Major Green Hydrogen Investment with H2-Global
Libya's eastern-based government is stepping up its push into renewable energy with talks underway for a landmark green hydrogen project. The Ministry of Electricity and Renewable Energy, under the Libyan Government-designate, met on Tuesday with global firm H2-Global to discuss a $billion-scale initiative to produce one million tons of green hydrogen annually for export to international markets. The high-level meeting took place at the ministry's headquarters in Benghazi and included Minister of Electricity and Renewable Energy Awad Al-Badri, the Chairman of the National Electricity Holding Company, and the National Program Committee for Solar Energy Localization. Representing H2-Global, Ahmed Al-Azzam, Chairman of the Global Consultancy and Technical Support Company for Infrastructure Projects, presented the project's economic feasibility and development benefits. According to projections, the project could contribute significantly to Libya's public budget and generate over 10,000 jobs for Libyan youth—highlighting both economic and strategic value. At the close of the meeting, both parties agreed to proceed with signing a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU), paving the way for practical implementation. The move signals Libya's increasing seriousness about investing in clean energy and securing its position as a future green energy hub. Green hydrogen is a clean fuel generated from renewable sources and emits no carbon dioxide, unlike traditional fossil fuels. As climate change accelerates and energy prices surge globally, green hydrogen has become a focal point for nations seeking sustainable energy alternatives. The International Energy Agency (IEA) previously identified Libya as one of the most promising countries for low-cost green hydrogen production, stressing the urgent need for African nations to adopt clean energy strategies amid rising global energy prices. Libya has been in chaos since a NATO-backed uprising toppled longtime leader Muammar Gaddafi in 2011. The county has for years been split between rival administrations. Libya's economy, heavily reliant on oil, has suffered due to the ongoing conflict. The instability has led to fluctuations in oil production and prices, impacting the global oil market and Libya's economy. The conflict has led to a significant humanitarian crisis in Libya, with thousands of people killed, and many more displaced. Migrants and refugees using Libya as a transit point to Europe have also faced dire conditions. The planned elections for December 2021 were delayed due to disagreements over election laws and the eligibility of certain candidates. This delay has raised concerns about the feasibility of a peaceful political transition. Despite the ceasefire, security remains a significant concern with sporadic fighting and the presence of mercenaries and foreign fighters. The unification of the military and the removal of foreign forces are crucial challenges. Tags: benghaziGreen HydrogenH2-GlobalIEAlibya
