Morocco Slams Algeria's ‘Selective' Stance on Western Sahara at UN Council
'It reflects a masterclass in selective political manipulation,' Majda Moutchou charged, responding to the Algerian ambassador's intervention regarding human rights monitoring in MINURSO's mandate.
She accused Algeria of 'suddenly discovering a new passion for human rights and international law.'
'The mandate has been clearly defined by the Security Council, and any attempt by the Algerian delegation to distort its role is either misinformed or deliberately misleading,' Moutchou asserted, emphasizing MINURSO's clear mandate to supervise the ceasefire.
Moutchou dismantled the Algerian position by pointing out that seven out of eleven UN peacekeeping operations lack human rights monitoring mandates.
'We wonder why the Algerian delegation, demonstrating obvious double standards, focuses solely on MINURSO while turning a blind eye to other peacekeeping operations,' she declared.
The Moroccan diplomat revealed that the Security Council had 'categorically rejected' proposals to include a human rights monitoring mechanism in MINURSO's mandate in October 2024.
'This rejection wasn't accidental: it reaffirmed that the human rights situation in the Moroccan Sahara doesn't require such a mechanism,' she stated.
Turning the tables on Algeria, Moutchou demanded answers about 'a far more pressing issue: the Tindouf camps on Algerian territory, where the population lives under daily oppression, deprived of fundamental rights and subjected to severe movement restrictions and flagrant violations of international law.'
'The UN must pay attention to all these aspirations, without exception or selectivity, including on the territory of states that advocate self-determination for others while systematically denying it to oppressed peoples on their own territory,' she charged.
The diplomat exposed what she termed a 'troubling contradiction' in Algeria's stance on self-determination, arguing that Algeria wielded it 'as a political weapon against Morocco's territorial integrity' while ignoring 'legitimate aspirations of other peoples still living under foreign occupation and oppression.'
'The Sahara has always been an integral part of Morocco,' Moutchou concluded, describing this as a reflection of 'centuries of historical, cultural and geographical links' rather than a recent claim.
The heated exchange occurred during a public debate on strengthening UN peacekeeping operations' adaptability, where Morocco's representative systematically countered Algeria's attempts to modify MINURSO's established mandate.
This diplomatic clash comes as Morocco continues to gather international support for its position.
In a meeting yesterday with UN Envoy Staffan de Mistura in Rabat, Foreign Minister Nasser Bourita reiterated Morocco's commitment to a political solution based exclusively on the Autonomy Plan, while respecting the country's sovereignty and territorial integrity.
Meanwhile, the American Enterprise Institute has criticized MINURSO's ongoing mission, with scholar Michael Rubin pointing out in a recent commentary that 'Thirty-four years and billions of dollars later, MINURSO has not even conducted a census.'
Rubin further charged that the separatist Polisario Front 'holds wives and children as hostages to prevent refugee resettlement' in the Tindouf camps.
Read also: Mali Slams Algeria for 'Persistent' Interference in its Internal Affairs Tags: AlgeriaMoroccoUN councilWestern sahara
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Morocco World
33 minutes ago
- Morocco World
Geneva Talks Reignite Hope for Global Treaty on Plastic Pollution
Brussels – Delegates from across the globe convened in Geneva this week for a fresh round of United Nations-led negotiations aimed at securing a legally binding treaty to combat plastic pollution, a crisis with mounting environmental and human health consequences. The talks, hosted by the UN Environment Programme (UNEP), mark a pivotal moment in the global push for a 'plastic-free future' after last year's negotiations in Busan, South Korea, collapsed. Those talks broke down due to deep divisions between oil-producing countries and those advocating for stronger regulations. Despite the setbacks, momentum has been building behind the scenes. 'There's been extensive diplomacy from Busan till now,' UNEP Executive Director Inger Andersen said, emphasizing that most countries she has spoken with are arriving in Geneva 'to strike the deal.' Over the next 10 days, negotiators are expected to tackle contentious issues, including whether to cap plastic production, ban hazardous chemicals, and establish financial support for countries transitioning away from fossil fuel-based plastics. The stakes are high, as over 400 million tons of plastic are produced globally every year, half of it for single-use, with devastating consequences for ecosystems and human health. In a symbolic gesture outside the UN venue, a replica of Rodin's 'The Thinker' sculpture is being slowly submerged in plastic waste by Canadian artist Benjamin Von Wong, highlighting the urgency of the crisis. 'To protect health, we need to think about the toxic chemicals that are entering our environment,' Von Wong stated. Ecuadorian diplomat Luis Vayas Valdivieso, who is chairing the negotiation process, acknowledged the road ahead won't be smooth but expressed optimism. 'Our paths and positions might differ; our destination is the same. We are all here because we believe in a shared cause: a world free of plastic pollution,' he said. More than 600 NGOs are present at the Geneva talks, with groups like Greenpeace calling for ambitious measures that go beyond waste management. 'We cannot let a few countries determine humanity's future,' said Greenpeace delegation head Graham Forbes. 'To solve the plastic pollution crisis, we have to stop making so much plastic.' With just months left before the UN's 2025 deadline to finalize the treaty, Geneva may prove to be a decisive battleground in the fight for environmental and public health. Read also: 'Zero Mika': Moroccans Call for Action on Plastic Pollution, Survey Finds Tags: Geneva talksplastic pollutionUNEP
Morocco World
2 hours ago
- Morocco World
Militant Primitivism or the Weaponization of Poverty: Why the Left Fears a Thriving Sahrawi Society
'To deny the benefits of modernity to African people while enjoying them in Europe is the height of hypocrisy.' — Chinua Achebe In the complex debate surrounding the future of Western Sahara, one disturbing current remains largely under-examined: the ideological posture that seeks to isolate, infantilize, and instrumentalize the region for political agendas. This approach — which I call militant primitivism — is not rooted in justice or development, but in the preservation of suffering as a form of currency. Those who cry the loudest for the 'liberation' of the Sahara are often the same voices opposing investment, tourism, cultural exchanges, and international partnerships in the region. Why? Because progress threatens the narrative of victimhood that justifies their activism and sustains their funding. Economic growth, infrastructure, job creation, and regional integration are not part of their strategy — stagnation is. They don't want investors in Dakhla or Laâyoune. They reject filmmakers and journalists who dare to show a modern, dynamic, and peaceful Sahara. They protest against foreign companies creating jobs or local governments building schools. For them, any improvement on the ground undermines their cause — because their cause is not justice, it's leverage. This is militant primitivism in action: a doctrine that demands underdevelopment in order to maintain political utility. The Sahara, in this view, must remain a space of lack, of grievance, of despair — not because it is, but because it must appear to be. It is a strategy that deliberately blocks opportunity in order to preserve ideology. These same actors invoke international law, but misread and misuse it. They quote UN resolutions out of context, ignoring the fact that the UN does not recognize any entity called the 'Sahrawi Republic' and has never called for independence, but for a political solution mutually acceptable to both parties. Meanwhile, inside Morocco, the government continues to invest heavily in its southern provinces, developing ports, renewable energy projects, universities, and hospitals. The Moroccan Sahara has some of the highest human development indicators in the kingdom. It is a space of movement and hope — a laboratory for inclusive growth. And this is what the militants fear most: that the Sahara may thrive — and in doing so, render their struggle obsolete. This form of instrumentalization is not new. It mirrors the logic of some post-colonial ideologues who believed that poverty and pain were prerequisites for purity and revolutionary legitimacy. But this logic has failed — everywhere. In the Sahara, it is not only outdated, it is dangerous. As Vladimir Lenin once warned in his critique of the Narodniks: 'To idealize the backwardness of the peasant commune is to idealize national stagnation.' Militant primitivism disguises itself in the language of solidarity, but it thrives on regression. It prefers symbolic victories over tangible ones. Its proponents elevate misery as identity, and mistake opposition for leadership. The real voice of the Sahrawis today is not heard in hotel lobbies in Algiers or cafés in Paris. It is heard in the classrooms of Laâyoune, in the solar farms of Boujdour, in the fishing ports of Dakhla, and in the voting booths during Moroccan elections. These are not the voices of victims — they are the voices of citizens. Let us be clear: those who truly care about the Sahara must care about its people. And that means saying yes to development, yes to investment, yes to dignity through opportunity. Militant primitivism offers only one thing: permanent stagnation for the sake of political showmanship. It is time to reject this vision — and replace it with one grounded in progress, justice, and real empowerment. Tags: Algeria and the Western SaharaSahrawis
Morocco World
5 hours ago
- Morocco World
Mali Announces Release of Kidnapped Moroccan Truckers
Rabat – The Malian government has announced the release of four Moroccan truck drivers who were kidnapped earlier this year in northeastern Burkina Faso near the border with Niger. Bamako announced their release on Monday, noting that the truckers, who were kidnapped in January, were freed last Sunday. All four Moroccan truckers are 'safe and sound,' the Malian government said, asserting that they were held by the terrorist Islamic State in the Sahel Province. The terrorist group is affiliated with ISIS. The statement emphasized that the release took place in coordination with Mali's National State Security Agency and Morocco's General Directorate for Studies and Documentation. The two departments jointly conducted an investigation that led to the drivers' release. Moroccan truckers have been increasingly affected by the deteriorating security situation in the Sahel. In January, a violent attack in Niooro du Sahel, a town in Mali, affected two Moroccan trucks as terrorists targeted several points in the city. The truckers were safe, but a few trucks were slightly damaged during the attack. In 2021, two Moroccan drivers died due to another violent attack. Back then, Mali condemned the attack, describing it as 'barbaric.' 'In this painful circumstance, the minister expressed, on behalf of the president of the transition and the government, all the compassion and solidarity with the government and the brotherly people of Morocco,' said the Malian Foreign Affairs Ministry.
