10 years on, Kurla hotel fire victims to get ₹50 lakh each in compensation after Bombay HC order to BMC
The Bombay High Court on Tuesday, June 10, directed the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) to pay ₹ 50 lakh each as compensation to the kin of eight victims of a hotel fire incident in Kurla or Mumbai. All eight victims died in a fire in Hotel City Kinara in 2015.
As many as eight persons were killed when a fire broke out inside the Kurla hotel on October 16, 2015. Seven of them were students aged 18-20, and the eighth victim was a 31-year-old design engineer from Virar.
The high court was hearing petitions filed by parents of the victims seeking to quash the Lokayukta's February 2017 order, which dismissed their complaint seeking a probe. The Lokayukta, while dismissing their pleas, noted that compensation of ₹ 1 lakh each was disbursed.
The families sought the enhancement of the compensation amount.
Citing its gross failure in the discharge of its duties, the high court ordered the civic body to pay ₹ 50 lakh each to the families of the victims within 12 weeks.
'Due to the failure of the BMC in taking action, the illegality in Kinara continued unabated and ultimately led to the fire and the loss of life,' a bench of Justices B P Colabawalla and Firdosh Pooniwalla said.
The court remarked it was "shocking" that the BMC took no action against the hotel, even though it was aware the establishment lacked the necessary fire department approvals. 'Had the BMC taken prompt action, then the fire incident would not have definitely not occurred,' the court noted.
'The negligence and breach of statutory duties by the BMC is a proximate cause of the fire, and the civic body can be held vicariously liable for the acts of commission and omission of its officials.'
'This violation of the fundamental rights of the petitioners and their kin under Article 21 of the Constitution of India has been caused as a direct result of the negligence and breach of statutory duties on the part of BMC,' the court said.
The court also noted a list of violations on part of the hotel, saying it operated a service area on the mezzanine floor, which was supposed to be a storage area and also did not have a no-objection certificate (NOC) from the fire department.
Kinara was granted an eating housing licence without obtaining any fire NOC from the fire department, the court said. The hotel had also stored several gas cylinders which was prohibited.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
7 hours ago
- Business Standard
Actor Dino Morea appears before ED over Mithi river desilting case
Bollywood actor Dino Morea on Thursday appeared before the Enforcement Directorate (ED) here in connection with a money laundering probe linked to an alleged Rs 65 crore Mithi river desilting scam, officials said. Morea, who had been summoned by the ED for questioning, reached the federal agency's office at Ballard Estate in south Mumbai at around 10.30 am, an official said. The ED on June 6 conducted searches at more than 15 locations in Mumbai, and Kochi in Kerala, including the premises of Dino Morea in Bandra (West) area here, those linked to his brother Santino, some Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) officials, and contractors among others, official sources earlier said. The searches were conducted in Kochi as one of the companies that provided desilting equipment to the BMC -- Matprop Technical Services Pvt Ltd -- is based in this city, they said. The investigation is being conducted under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), the sources had said. The ED case stems from a Mumbai Police Economic Offences Wing (EOW) FIR filed in May against 13 persons, including contractors and civic officials, for an alleged Rs 65.54 crore scam in tenders awarded from 2017-2023 for desilting of the Mithi river which flows through Mumbai and acts as a stormwater drainage channel for the metro city. The Uddhav Thackeray-led undivided Shiv Sena controlled the cash-rich BMC from 1997 till the party's split in 2022. After the expiry of the general body in 2022, the civic body was controlled by the state government, which was then headed by Eknath Shinde. It was alleged by the police in its complaint that BMC officials tailored the tender for the desilting contract in such a way that it benefited a particular supplier of machinery, and the contractors reportedly generated fraudulent bills for transporting the sludge out of Mumbai. The 49-year-old actor and his brother were questioned by the Mumbai Police EOW in this case last month also. The Morea brothers, it is understood, were questioned by the police about their alleged links with alleged middleman Ketan Kadam, arrested in the case along with another accused, Jai Joshi, apart from some financial transactions made in a company linked to Santino. Kadam and Joshi, according to police, were involved in the renting out of 'silt pusher' machines and multi-purpose amphibious pontoon machines to contractors who were carrying out Mithi river desilting work. In 2021, the ED had attached Morea's assets as part of a money laundering investigation linked to an alleged bank fraud case against Gujarat-based pharmaceutical company Sterling Biotech and its promoters. The plan to desilt the river was planned by the Mumbai civic authorities following the 2005 floods, which brought the city to a grinding halt.
Hans India
7 hours ago
- Hans India
SC judge recuses from hearing transfer petition of Congress MLA Rajendra Bharti
New Delhi: A Supreme Court judge on Thursday recused himself from hearing a plea filed by Madhya Pradesh Congress MLA Rajendra Bharti seeking transfer of a criminal case outside the state. After Justice Manmohan withdrew himself from hearing, the bench headed by Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra referred the transfer petition to the Chief Justice of India (CJI), who is the master of roster, for listing the matter before a different bench. In the meantime, the bench ordered extension of the interim order passed in the petition seeking transfer of the alleged cheating case outside Madhya Pradesh. In February this year, the apex court stayed the proceedings pending before the Additional Sessions Judge in Gwalior, observing that there was enough material placed on record before the trial court containing an allegation that the defence witnesses were sought to be intimidated. "The trial court should have also taken appropriate action on the basis of the material. (W)hen we made repeated queries to the learned AAG (Additional Advocate General) and the learned counsel appearing for the respondent-State (of Madhya Pradesh), they have no answer to the question of what inquiry or investigation the state has made on the basis of the allegations made by the petitioner (Rajendra Bharti)," it said. In its order, the Supreme Court had stressed the duty of the state machinery to ensure that a fair trial is conducted. "We must record that it is the duty of the State to ensure that a fair trial is conducted. Fair trial means that full opportunity is granted in accordance with law to the accused to defend himself," it had said. After the top court's observations, a committee of three police officials was constituted to inquire into the allegations of intimidation of defence witnesses. However, the Supreme Court, in an order passed in April this year, said that "proper investigation has not been made" into the allegations of putting pressure on the defence witnesses. "We expected the officers appointed by the State to look into each and every allegation made by the petitioner as well as by the witnesses and record findings. It is the duty of the State to ensure that there is a fair trial, which is an essential part of the rights guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India." Listing the matter for further hearing on May 16, the apex court told the state officials to carry out a "better investigation" and called for a report within one month. In the 2023 Madhya Pradesh Assembly polls, Rajendra Bharti won the Datia seat of Gwalior-Chambal region, defeating senior BJP leader Narottam Mishra, who held the portfolio of Home Minister in the Shivraj Singh Chouhan government.
News18
8 hours ago
- News18
Dino Morea Smiles, Looks Unfazed As He Reaches ED Office In Rs 65 Crore Scam Probe
Last Updated: Dino Morea appears before ED for questioning in ₹65 crore Mithi river scam. Actor seen smiling, unfazed. Watch video and get full details of the case. Bollywood actor Dino Morea appeared before the Enforcement Directorate (ED) on Thursday morning in connection with a multi-crore money laundering probe related to the alleged ₹65.54 crore Mithi river desilting scam. The actor, whose name surfaced during the ED's expanding investigation, looked relaxed and composed as he walked into the agency's Mumbai office, drawing attention for his seemingly unfazed demeanor despite the gravity of the allegations. Dino arrived at the ED's Ballard Estate office around 10:30 AM. Dressed in a crisp white shirt, jeans, and carrying a backpack, the actor greeted paparazzi with a confident smile. In videos now circulating online, he can be seen momentarily heading in the wrong direction before being gently redirected by photographers. The casual air stood in stark contrast to his last public appearance in May, where he had notably avoided cameras following reports of the ED's interest in his alleged financial dealings. The ED's investigation is linked to irregularities in desilting tenders issued by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) between 2017 and 2023. The Mithi river, which runs through Mumbai, plays a critical role in stormwater drainage, especially during the monsoon season. The alleged scam revolves around inflated tenders and substandard work that ultimately endangered flood management in India's financial capital. #WATCH | Mumbai: Bollywood actor Dino Morea arrives at the office of the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in MumbaiThe agency has summoned him in connection with the alleged Rs 65 crore Mithi river desilting case. — ANI (@ANI) June 12, 2025 On June 6, the federal agency conducted widespread raids across Mumbai, Kerala, and Kochi — covering more than 15 locations — including properties associated with Dino and his brother Santino Morea. Sources have also confirmed that the ED searched locations linked to BMC officials and contractors named in the FIR. These searches followed a May FIR filed by the Economic Offences Wing (EOW) of the Mumbai Police, which booked 13 individuals, including government officials and private contractors, for criminal conspiracy and fraud. Reports suggest that Dino Morea and his brother were questioned by police earlier for their alleged links with accused Jai Joshi and middleman Ketan Kadam — two names central to the scam's financial chain. Authorities are currently probing whether the Moreas had any monetary gains or roles in facilitating tenders or laundering funds tied to the civic project. This is not Dino's first encounter with financial scrutiny. In 2021, the ED had provisionally attached assets linked to the actor as part of its investigation into a separate money laundering case involving Sterling Biotech — a Gujarat-based pharmaceutical firm accused of massive bank fraud. While no direct charges were made against Dino at the time, his name surfaced due to business associations under the scanner. Despite the increasing pressure, the 48-year-old actor has chosen to remain composed in public, even as speculation around his involvement grows. Known for his early 2000s roles in films like Raaz, Gunaah, and Aksar, Dino has in recent years stayed away from mainstream cinema, instead venturing into business and production. Meanwhile, officials close to the investigation say more summons and questioning rounds are likely in the coming weeks, as financial trails are analyzed and digital records are examined. First Published: June 12, 2025, 13:55 IST
