Education freedom is on the march
First, Texas passed universal school choice, becoming the largest state to offer K-12 scholarships to families interested in private education options.
Second, purple-state New Hampshire just joined the growing list of (mostly red) states that have embraced universal K-12 scholarships. In the Granite State, these flexible scholarships are aptly called 'Education Freedom Accounts' and go to all students for all options.
Third, a new report from Florida revealed that — for the first time in history — a majority of Sunshine State students are now enrolled in something other than their neighborhood public school. The report, 'Changing Landscapes,' shows that 51 percent of Florida's 3.5 million K-12 students now attend a charter, magnet, private, home-based, or hybrid school alternative.
Taken together, these three developments signal universal education choice is here to stay. Not only is it spreading to big states like Texas and purple states like New Hampshire, but it has quietly become the 'new normal' in the Sunshine State of Florida.
In fact, education freedom has become so entrenched in Florida's culture (since then-Gov. Jeb Bush first championed the idea) that a growing number of Florida public school districts — including Miami-Dade — have begun offering fee-for-course options to scholarship students.
To their credit, these public school leaders have decided, 'If you can't beat 'em, join 'em.' So they are now wisely vying for scholarship students (including many longtime homeschoolers) who are looking to take one or more 'a la carte' courses.
Offering 'a la carte' courses not only improves public schools' bottom line, but it also helps district officials move beyond seeing some families as 'friends' and others as 'foes.' As Laurie Cox, the chair of the Leon County School Board, told me, 'I want to help every Leon County child succeed, whether or not they attend our public schools full-time.'
Lest there be any doubt, Florida students are clearly reaping the benefits of the 'cooperative competition' Cox describes. Indeed, Florida public school outcomes have shown steady improvement over the last two decades, thanks in large part to the increased competition that comes from alternative learning options.
To be sure, there's more work to be done. In fact, a recent James Madison Institute poll suggests some Florida families still regard their current schooling arrangement as 'sub-optimal' — which is to say, for example, they attend a charter school when they'd prefer to attend a private school.
Parental unhappiness with schooling arrangements is considerably higher in other states. But recent developments in Texas, New Hampshire, and Florida give parents throughout our country reason to hope for their children's future. Education freedom is on the march. School choice is coming soon to a neighborhood near you. And millions of American schoolchildren will be reaping the benefits.
William Mattox is the senior director of the Marshall Center for Education Freedom at The James Madison Institute in Tallahassee, Fla.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Miami Herald
31-07-2025
- Miami Herald
Jeb Bush is wrong about charters. They are gutting Florida's public schools
Former Gov. Jeb Bush recently praised, in a Miami Herald opinion article, Florida's expanding charter school and 'Schools of Hope' programs as bold education reform. But what he describes as courageous and innovative is, in truth, part of a coordinated, well-funded campaign to defund and depopulate traditional public schools — not to improve them, but to replace them with privately managed institutions operating with public dollars. As a Miami-Dade school teacher, I believe that behind the narrative of 'choice,' 'accountability' and 'innovation' lies a troubling reality: a strategy to dismantle public education and convert it into a profit-driven marketplace. These outcomes in Florida are not accidental — they result from deliberate policy choices designed to shift control away from democratically governed schools and into the hands of private operators. While traditional public schools follow strict transparency laws and financial reporting standards, charter schools are exempt from many of these requirements — even though they receive public funds. This double standard allows charter operators to profit from taxpayer dollars while shielding their operations from scrutiny. Bush points to 'persistently low performing' schools in Florida as justification for charter takeovers. But he ignores the fact that many traditional schools in low-income communities — despite chronic underfunding — have earned consecutive 'A' grades under Florida's punitive grading system. Rather than celebrate these successes, the Florida Legislature has withheld resources, expanded vouchers and rewritten rules to tip the scales against public schools. This is not reform — it's a campaign of forced failure, designed to create a false narrative that public schools are broken and must be handed over to private actors. It is nothing but a hostile takeover of a vital public good for private gain. Bush also cites declining public school enrollment as a reason to grant charters access to taxpayer-funded buildings. But this trend is no accident. It's the result of deliberate policies: Florida's universal voucher scheme, for-profit virtual schools and aggressive charter expansion have siphoned students and dollars out of public schools. When enrollment drops by design, schools are labeled 'underutilized' or 'surplus,' paving the way for their buildings to be handed over to private entities. It's a manufactured crisis with real consequences. Public schools also serve critical community functions that charters do not. They act as hurricane shelters, polling sites and hubs for vital services. These are not just schools — they are the backbone of community life. What's too often ignored is that many charter schools in Florida are run by for-profit Education Management Organizations (EMOs). These companies receive public tax dollars but operate with little accountability. Though labeled as public, they are privately managed, profit-driven institutions. Their goal isn't to serve every child — it's to reduce costs, maximize revenue and grow market share. Public dollars are flowing into private hands while communities lose control. Charter expansion is often marketed as 'parental choice.' But without information, there is no real choice — only manipulation. Many families are selecting schools without knowing whether they meet standards for safety, certified staff, special education or curriculum. Despite charter schools push to divert students, most Florida families still choose traditional public schools, including magnet and choice programs. That speaks volumes: families still believe in public education. It's up to policymakers to stop undermining it. This isn't just a Florida issue — it's part of a global playbook: starve public schools, declare them broken, then privatize under the banner of 'reform.' The winners are corporations, investors and real estate developers. Florida is the model. If we don't push back, the rest of the nation could follow. Here are some suggestions: Florida needs to tie public funds to public oversight, ban for-profit school operators, preserve public ownership of school buildings and protect the civic role of public schools. Crystal Etienne is a Miami-Dade school teacher and president of EDUVOTER, a nonprofit organization committed to protecting and strengthening Florida's traditional public schools.
Yahoo
30-07-2025
- Yahoo
New state commissioner nominee attracts universal, bipartisan support
In contrast to the polarizing fight over a new education commissioner eight years ago, Gov. Kelly Ayotte's pick of 15-year Department of Education executive Caitlin Davis of Concord attracted unanimous, bipartisan support during a public hearing. The 2½-hour session in the Executive Council chambers Tuesday drew a parade of supporters for a candidate that vowed to be an apolitical consensus builder, looking to create pathways for students to excel. 'Listening first, leading with humility and always keeping students at the center,' Davis said of her priorities in prepared remarks. The outpouring virtually guarantees that the council, meeting in Pittsburg on Wednesday, will confirm Davis to succeed two-term Commissioner Frank Edelblut of Wilton, whom Ayotte chose not to renominate when his current stint ran out at the end of March. Several speakers across the ideological spectrum said Davis would bring stability and more tranquility to the public-school landscape that endured many divisive debates about Edelblut's reform agenda such as universal Education Freedom Accounts, the Learn Everywhere program and a total rewrite of the state's education standards. 'We would like to see a commissioner of education who both leads and supports our local public schools strongly and feel the nominee will be in that direction,' said Deb Howes, president of the American Federation of Teachers, the second-largest union that was often at odds with Edelblut's approach. 'Cooperation and collegiality' Rep. Rick Ladd, R-Haverhill, the House Education chairman, got the task of pushing many of Edelblut's policies through the State House maze, but he too signaled it was time for a change. 'We ought to figure out a way to clone her 10 times over; she is really needed,' Ladd said. "She is not political as we have seen here in the past several years.' Former Education Board Chairman Fred Bramante worked with Edelblut on the standards and said Davis will usher in an era of 'cooperation and collegiality.' 'I am expecting there will be a different tone in education circles across the state with Caitlin as commissioner,' Bramante said. Micaela Demeter serves on the Dover School Board and the New Hampshire School Funding Fairness Project and spoke only for herself. 'I am really excited for a fresh start,' Demeter said. 'There is a lot of level of trust rebuilding that needs to happen based on (the) outgoing commissioner.' Once overlooked himself, Edelblut backed her In 2017, new Gov. Chris Sununu nominated Edelblut, whom he had narrowly beaten in the GOP gubernatorial primary four months earlier. Tom Raffio, a former state board chair, said 57 pages of opposition showed a lack of confidence in the choice. One prominent sticking point was Edelblut's lack of experience in public schooling as an educator, administrator or even as a parent, having opted to home-school his seven children. The council endorsed Edelblut, 3-2, along partisan lines with Democratic Councilors Andru Volinsky of Concord and Chris Pappas of Manchester in opposition. While stunned at not getting the chance to serve four more years, Edelblut endorsed the pick of Davis this time. 'Caitlin is a respected peer within the state's education field and a pivotal member of our leadership team. We are proud to have this nomination from within our own pool of talented professionals,' Edelblut said in June on the day she was nominated. In Edelblut's final week, the state Education Department notched a win when the Trump administration released $6 million in critical federal grants it had previously frozen, part of billions of dollars unfrozen nationwide. Prosecutors from blue states had sued the White House over the decision, but Davis said the latest development showed that wasn't necessary. 'We continue to review all the legal remedies that we might have. We did not think legal action was the best step at that time,' Davis said. Several said Davis was uniquely qualified to deal with the changing federal grant landscape under a president who has favored abolishing the U.S. Department of Education. 'She is probably the best prepared candidate to lead the Department of Education ever, perhaps the best to lead any state agency,' said Labor Commissioner Ken Merrifield, who got to know Davis when she attended Bishop Brady High School in Concord with his children. Every program to come under the microscope If confirmed, Davis said no existing program will be immune from review. 'He calls himself an innovator,' Davis said of Edelblut at one point while praising the incumbent for leaving public schools in better shape upon his departure. 'I would like to spend a lot of time looking at some of those programs, understanding some of the ones that are working, some of the ones that are not working — ensuring all of the support from the Department of Education is supporting programs that are high-quality, needed by students, and are a good use of our taxpayer dollars,' Davis said. After a private career in auditing, Davis came to the Department of Education in 2010 as an internal auditor. During her tenure, Davis has overseen the department's Bureau of Assessment and Accountability, Bureau of Education Statistics, Bureau of Educational Opportunities, Bureau of School Finance and Bureau of Federal Compliance. Michael Bessette, assistant superintendent of the Kearsarge Regional School District, said the fact Davis never taught in a classroom will be no impediment. "Caitlin Davis has an exceptional capacity to listen; that is the key," Bessette added. klandrigan@ Solve the daily Crossword
Fox News
09-07-2025
- Fox News
Trump targeted by Iranian death fatwas as watchdog group demands immediate sanctions response
FIRST ON FOX - A new report by United Against Nuclear Iran (UANI) is urging the U.S. government to impose sanctions on senior Iranian clerics and regime-controlled institutions that have issued or promoted Islamic legal rulings — known as fatwas — calling for the torture and assassination of President Donald Trump, other American citizens and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The fatwas invoke the Islamic charge of mohareb — "waging war against God" — a term in Iran's penal code that mandates brutal punishments, including crucifixion and cross-amputation, under the regime's interpretation of Sharia law. "Today UANI is exposing the individuals and entities in Iran hiding behind religion to foment terrorism abroad. Threats against the president of the United States and other Americans are a federal crime. Each of these individuals and entities should be sanctioned, indicted, and banned from travel, along with their families, to the United States and its allies," a joint statement by former Gov. Jeb Bush, UANI's chairman, and Ambassador Mark Wallace, its CEO and former U.S. ambassador to the U.N. for Management and Reform, told Fox News in a statement. "The last fatwa against another American citizen, Salman Rushdie, almost cost him his life, with him being stabbed by an Iranian regime sympathizer. It is time to ensure that those who threaten Americans face the full force of the law." UANI's new list identifies 11 individuals and two regime-aligned entities that have not been sanctioned under U.S. counterterrorism laws. The organization is calling for all of them to be designated as Specially Designated Global Terrorists under Executive Order 13224, which is reserved for those engaged in or supporting terrorism. Among the top targets is Ayatollah Naser Makarem-Shirazi, a powerful cleric known as the "Sultan of Sugar" for his domination of Iran's lucrative sugar trade. Makarem-Shirazi has called for President Trump and Prime Minister Netanyahu to be executed under mohareb, which he interprets to include torture before death. Another senior figure, Ayatollah Hossein Nouri Hamedani, a student of Ayatollah Khomeini who served as his representative in Europe from 1979 to 1980, has issued a series of threats against the Jewish community over the years. He has also issued fatwas targeting Trump and Netanyahu. UANI warns that such rulings amount to the incitement of terrorism. "These aren't abstract religious statements," Jason Brodsky, UANI's policy director, told Fox News Digital. "They're targeted threats by regime officials against the president of the United States. The U.S. should respond accordingly—with sanctions, law enforcement action, and immigration reviews." The list also includes Ayatollah Mohsen Araki, the supreme leader's former representative to the United Kingdom and head of the Islamic Center of England, which has been used as a platform to export the Islamic Revolution in Europe. Araki this month threatened President Trump and Prime Minister Netanyahu, saying "their lives and property are no longer protected. The U.S. government and president are now considered a hostile infidel government by all Muslims." Brodsky emphasized that Araki's background illustrates how Iran uses religious institutions in the West to export its revolutionary ideology. "This raises serious concerns about how the regime spreads radicalism through so-called religious charities abroad," Brodsky said. Another cleric, Alireza Panahian, is tied to the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and is described by UANI as a key architect of Iran's extremist ideology of Mahdism — which promotes the annihilation of Jews and the destruction of Israel as prerequisites for the return of the Hidden Imam. He has vocally advocated for terrorist attacks on U.S.-led forces in the Middle East and beyond. UANI is also calling for counterterrorism sanctions against the Islamic Republic of Iran Broadcasting (IRIB), the regime's state-run television network. According to the report, IRIB aired programming that promoted a $10–$20 million bounty on President Trump's head and solicited donations to fund the assassination. The IRIB TV studio in Tehran was bombed by the Israeli Air Force during the 12-day war. UANI also targeted the Qom Seminary, Iran's top religious training center, for publicly endorsing and pledging to implement the fatwa against Trump and Netanyahu. The seminary's faculty and students reportedly signed statements declaring their intent to propagate the decree. "We only have to remember what happened to Salman Rushdie to see how these fatwas can inspire real-world violence," Brodsky said, referring to the 2022 knife attack that left the author blind in one eye. "Now these same incitements are being directed at President Trump while he's in office."
