CFPB cuts can resume, divided appeals court rules
Donald Trump
FacebookTweetLink
A divided federal appeals court is allowing President Donald Trump to downsize the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau at this time, siding with the administration on its plans to reshape government agencies and its employees.
Groups that represent CFPB employees or use the agency to protect consumers from predatory banking sued months ago, after Trump replaced the agency's director shortly after he took office and the administration paused the CFPB's efforts. The administration then canceled the agency's lease for its headquarters building, and terminated or planned to cut more than 80% of the agency's workforce.
A trial level judge in Washington, Amy Berman Jackson, quickly stepped in to block the near-shuttering of the agency. But on Friday, the DC Circuit decided employees of the agency would need to challenge their loss of employment in other venues outside of the federal court district court first.
The appeals court, however, reiterated that some functions of the CFPB, like responding to consumer complaints, can't be shut down. But the ruling Friday took at face value the Trump administration's argument it hasn't decided to shut down the CFPB in full, and cited the lack of existence of a memo specifying that the CFPB would be closed.
'We agree with the government that there was no reviewable decision to shut down the CFPB,' Judge Greg Katsas wrote in the opinion. Katsas and Judge Neomi Rao, who were both appointed to the bench in Trump's first presidential term, split from Judge Nina Pillard, an Obama appointee, in making the decision.
Pillard disagreed with her colleagues on the bench over lessening the role of the courts in the case.
'The notion that courts are powerless to prevent the President from abolishing the agencies of the federal government that he was elected to lead cannot be reconciled with either the constitutional separation of powers or our nation's commitment to a government of laws,' she wrote.
Established after the 2008 financial crisis, the CFPB has long been a target of conservatives wanting to undermine financial regulations championed by Democrats in Congress.
More appeals are possible, as are additional legal decisions on the law governing the CFPB.
'It will be cold comfort to Plaintiffs if they ultimately succeed on the merits in their challenge to the CFPB's shutdown only to discover that Defendants have put the agency in a hole from which it can never fully recover,' Pillard also wrote in her dissent. 'That would be the effect of the agency's decisions to fire all or virtually all employees who once worked at the agency, terminate every contract that supported their work, purge all the data they amassed, and ghost all the experts and organizations with whom they had built up beneficial working relationships.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
6 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Jackson Hole, key retail earnings, and fresh economic data: Here's everything the stock market is watching this week
Markets are kicking off another news- and data-heavy week. Investors are watching for the July Fed minutes, fresh housing data, and a slew of retail earnings. The spotlight will be on Fed Chair Jerome Powell's comments at Jackson Hole on Friday. Get ready for another big week for the stock market. Investors are staring at a handful of catalysts on the radar this week, with a slew of fresh earnings reports and key signals from the Fed on the docket. All could be influential in determining the path ahead for Fed rate cuts — a bullish catalyst investors have been waiting for all year. Odds for a cut next month have edged down slightly since last week, but markets are still pricing in an 85% chance the Fed will cut rates by a quarter of a percentage point at the September meeting, according to the CME FedWatch Tool. Here's what investors will be reacting to this week. Fed minutes Investors will be paying close attention to the minutes from the Fed's July policy meeting on Wednesday. The meeting minutes will give markets more insight into the central bank's thoughts about inflation, the strength of the US economy, and its outlook for rate cuts going forward. It comes at a crucial time for the Fed, which is at a crossroads over the direction of monetary policy. Powell has continued to signal this year that the Fed is comfortable keeping rates steady, as officials wait to see the inflationary impact of tariffs. But inflation data has been mixed recently. Consumer prices rose in-line with economists' expectations last month, but wholesale inflation rose more than expected in the latest producer price index, a sign that more inflationary pressures could be building. Meanwhile, the job market has shown signs of cooling. The US added fewer jobs than expected in July, while job gains in May and June were revised downward by a combined 258,000. "Traders will be closely watching the minutes for more insight into the future rate-cut trajectory," Aaron Hill, an analyst at FP Markets, wrote in a note. "Still, the slowdown in the labour market data, as noted above, firmly swung the pendulum in favour of easing policy next month." "At the margin, the minutes of the July 29-30 FOMC meeting (Wed) could fill in some blanks about how dug in the doves were and how intransigent the inflation hawks might've been in late July," Ed Yardeni, the president of Yardeni Research, wrote over the weekend. Retail earnings Investors are also waiting on a slew of earnings reports from major retailers this week. Here are the companies on deck to report their second-quarter results: Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Home Depot (HD) TJX Companies (TJX) Lowe's (LOW) Target (TGT) Walmart (WMT) BJ Wholesale Club (BJ) The coming reports will give investors a glimpse into how the US consumer is faring. Weak earnings are likely to fan concerns about economic growth and raise expectations for a Fed rate cut next month. Markets are looking at the coming earnings reports as "key signposts" this week, top economist David Rosenberg said. "In terms of the mood of the US consumer, it is none too good (and as we saw in Friday's retail sale report, there is a trend in place towards dining in over dining out which is a sure sign of consumer frugality," the Rosenberg Research founder wrote in a note. Jackson Hole All eyes will be on Fed Chair Jerome Powell on Friday. The central bank chief is set to speak at the Fed's annual Jackson Hole symposium, where he's expected to set the agenda for future rate cuts. Markets are also eager to see if the Fed Chair comments on the independence of the central bank. President Donald Trump has continued to pressure Powell to lower interest rates, and is narrowing his list of potential Fed candidates. The speech could "well be a market-mover" this week, Rosenberg added. "One hawkish surprise could come from any commentary about how the weakness in the labor market of late has come largely from the supply side, and the 'break-even' for job growth to keep the unemployment rate steady is far lower than it used to be," Rosenberg wrote. "We expect the Federal Reserve to use Jackson Hole as an opportunity to prepare the markets and signal towards a 25 basis point cut in September and a potentially accommodating stance through year-end. Since this will be Powell's last Jackson Hole conference as Fed Chair, he'll likely reinforce the need for Fed independence from the Executive Branch," Richard Saperstein, the chief investment office of Treasury Partners, wrote in a note. Stocks could see some selling pressure once Powell speaks on Friday, strategists at Bank of America wrote in a note last week. "Dovish Powell at Jackson Hole = buy rumor, sell fact profit-taking," a team led by Michael Hartnett said. Read the original article on Business Insider
Yahoo
6 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Bausch + Lomb board members resign after Icahn agreement ends
(Reuters) -Bausch + Lomb said on Monday Brett Icahn and Gary Hu have resigned from its board of directors after the termination of the agreement with billionaire Carl Icahn and some of his affiliates. The agreement, dated June 21, 2022, ended after the Icahn group's net long position in Bausch Health Companies, Bausch + Lomb's parent, fell below the required threshold. On Friday, Bausch Health said Paulson Capital, along with certain affiliates and managed funds, increased their position in the company and acquired about 34.7 million common shares previously held by the Icahn Group. In April, Carl Icahn had built an economic interest covering about 34% of Bausch Health's shares. Sign in to access your portfolio
Yahoo
6 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Vulcan Elements signs rare earths supply deal with ReElement Technologies
(Reuters) -Vulcan Elements, a North Carolina-based rare earth magnet manufacturer, has agreed to buy a supply of the critical minerals from ReElement Technologies that will be sourced outside of China. The companies, both of which are privately held, declined to give precise financial terms but said that the price is "significantly below" the floor of $110 per kilogram that the U.S. Department of Defense guaranteed to MP Materials last month for the two most popular rare earths. The contract was signed in mid-July, Vulcan said. Rare earth oxides are used to make metal that can then be turned into magnets for use in fighter jets, radar and other military applications, as well as consumer electronics. "This pricing will enable Vulcan to be competitive in global markets," Vulcan CEO John Maslin told Reuters. "We wanted to make sure the unit economics made sense." Indiana-based ReElement, which licenses its technology from Purdue University, will supply Vulcan with "thousands of metric tons" of rare earth oxides annually for five years beginning in 2026 from outdated electronics or from mine sites, said CEO Mark Jensen. ReElement says it can supply the rare earths to Vulcan below $110 per kilogram because of its use of a processing technique known as chromatography, which is different than the industry-standard solvent extraction used by many of its peers. "We are laser focused on cost," Jensen told Reuters. "We will see where the market goes, but right now we're focused more on the market price versus that price floor." Reuters was first to report last month that the Trump administration is considering extending that price floor to other firms, news that was relayed in a close-door Washington meeting attended by Vulcan, ReElement and others.
