Problem-plagued convention centre subject of new legal action
And judging by the market's muted reaction to the news, there appeared to be little surprise among investors given the share prices of both companies barely reacted following the announcement.
Fletcher Building shares closed on Friday down 2.5 percent at $3.07, while SkyCity shares ended the week down 1 percent at 94c.
It's a far cry from May 2013 when SkyCity and the government announced with great fanfare that a heads of agreement had finally been reached to build the long-talked-about international convention centre at a cost of what was then estimated at $400m, with an expected completion date of 2017.
At the time, Fletcher Building shares were trading at around the $8 mark and SkyCity Entertainment at $4.50.
Economic Development Minister Steven Joyce confidently projected the convention centre would provide a $90m annual injection into the economy as well as creating an estimated 800 jobs on completion.
Fast forward to today and it is difficult to think of any building project in the nation's history that would come close to rivalling the convention centre for the litany of problems that have plagued its completion from beginning to end.
From significant cost blowouts, legal disputes, protracted delays, construction defects as well as a disastrous fire that took a week to extinguish and required almost a complete rebuild of the buildings inner core, it's difficult to consider what more could have possibly gone wrong for a building project that has seemed cursed from the outset.
With a newly revised completion date that will finally see the building open in February next year – nine years later than originally planned and with a final cost estimated at around $900m, more than twice the original estimate – Fletchers must be rueing the day it decided to bid for the contract.
Not only has it cost the company dearly in both financial and reputational terms, but it has also contributed to the resignation of former chairs Sir Ralph Norris in 2018 and Bruce Hassall last year.
And added to the above final completion cost, if you take Joyce's 2013 estimate of economic benefit at face value and deduct a couple of years for the Covid pandemic when the conference market was effectively mothballed, the earnings forgone from the delayed opening amounts to a further $500m cost to the economy, and SkyCity earnings in particular.
It's not hard to see why the company feels aggrieved by the totality of the impact all of this has had on its business which is reflected in its share price now trading at a 25-year low.
For its part Fletcher Building argued in its statement to the NZX on Friday that it had already paid significant liquidated damages to SkyCity in relation to the delays in delivering the NZICC in accordance with the building contract.
'Accordingly, Fletchers will vigorously defend itself against the SkyCity claim for further liquidated damages beyond the capped amount provided for in the building works contract.'
Though Fletchers acknowledged that the delivery of the convention centre had 'suffered from a number of challenges' it 'absolutely rejected' the claim by SkyCity that it was in breach of its contract in the manner alleged.
Attempting to put a positive spin on the matter, Fletchers concluded its statement by adding it was confident that 'once the NZICC is available to be seen and used by the public and international guests they will be delighted with the quality of the asset that will make a meaningful contribution to the NZ economy'.
For SkyCity Entertainment shareholders that will come as cold comfort for a business that has paid dearly for a project that was supposed to be open nine years ago, while for Fletcher Building shareholders the handover can't some soon enough. Though, if SkyCity proves to be successful in its legal action, it will come with a final and potentially nasty financial sting.
As always, the only winners out of all of this will be the lawyers who must surely be buoyed at the prospect of two of NZ's largest companies going head to head in the courts given the substantial billings that will result. It promises to be a closely followed case with significant implications for both sides and will no doubt expose further details of a project that, for all its supposed aesthetic value, will forever be seen as a national embarrassment of incompetence, mismanagement, and neglect.
Markets push higher as investors remain optimistic
Equity markets in the US and Australia are now within striking distance of eclipsing their all-time highs, while locally the NZX50 remains 5 percent below its December 2024 high and 8 percent below its all-time high from January 2021.
In the US, the benchmark S&P 500 index closed on Friday at exactly 6,000 needing just 147 points to take out its previous all-time high set in February. In Australia it's a similar story with the ASX200 now just 100 points below its all-time high.
Locally, listed property stocks received a small boost despite Stats NZ's March quarter data on the value of building activity revealing a mixed picture. Residential building work increased by 2.6 percent, while non-residential work decreased by 3.9 percent, resulting in a flat total building volume on a seasonally adjusted basis.
Elsewhere, Ebos Group recouped most of its earlier losses after its free float increased following a sell-down by longtime major shareholder Sybos exiting its stake and selling nearly 27m shares for $949m.
NZME shares closed out the week unchanged at $1.19 despite a significant board shake-up in which former radio entrepreneur and Cabinet minister Steven Joyce assumed the chair of the listed media company while activist shareholder Canadian billionaire Jim Grenon, now a New Zealand resident, and whose actions sparked the whole saga, was also elected as a director.
Meridian Energy shares gained almost 5 percent for the week to close at $5.86 after announcing New Zealand Aluminium Smelters' plant at Tiwai Pt in Southland will ramp up production sooner than expected, thanks to improved hydro lake storage levels. The smelter has an agreement with Meridian that enables the power generator to request Tiwai, the country's biggest power user, to reduce production when the system is stretched.
Meanwhile, the Paris-based Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) issued its latest report on the global economy saying that it expected growth to slow from 3.3 percent in 2024 to 2.9 percent in 2025 and 2026.
The slowdown is expected to be most concentrated in the United States, Canada, Mexico and China, with smaller downward adjustments in other economies.
In its report on New Zealand, the OECD acknowledged that though an economic recovery was under way, the country would need to battle increasing trade headwinds.
It expected the expansion to continue with growth projected to rise to 0.8 percent in 2025 and 1.7 percent in 2026 supported by lower interest rates.
'However, increased trade restrictions and high uncertainty about trade policy globally will temper external demand, confidence and the pace of the recovery,' it said.
It forecast inflation would ease because of lower oil prices and higher spare capacity including in the labour market with unemployment expected to peak in late 2025 at about 5.4 percent.
The OECD said the pace of fiscal consolidation was appropriate but may need to be slowed if the expansion stalls.
In the US bond yields rose after monthly jobs data for May allayed concerns of an imminent economic slowdown, while equities also gained amid hopes US-China trade tensions are easing after US President Donald Trump confirmed that much-anticipated negotiations will begin tomorrow (US time).
Though US job growth moderated in May (139,000 new jobs verses 125,000 forecast) and the prior months were revised lower, the news bolstered investor sentiment that had been primed for disappointment after data last week raised doubts about the buoyancy of American hiring.
Trump and Musk urged to repair their acrimonious break up
It all started off so well. The ambitious and unconventional US President Donald Trump and Elon Musk the world's most successful and wealthiest tech entrepreneur teaming up to Make America Great Again.
But it was always going to be a 50/50 bet that their relationship would survive with several commentators giving the 'bromance' less than six months before their respective egos got the better of them.
And so they have been proven correct after an acrimonious tweet storm erupted on Friday (NZ time) that has left the relationship in tatters and the two sides refusing to speak to one another.
At the centre of the break-up are plans by Trump to implement further tax cuts and fiscal spending that will significantly ramp up the national debt by as much as 10 percent at a time Musk has been focused on eliminating wasteful government expenditure and reducing the deficit.
Allies have urged the two sides to repair their now badly damaged relationship, seeking to limit the political and commercial fallout from last week's spectacular break-up.
The fracturing of the relationship between the powerful pair threatens to derail the White House's legislative agenda and wreck a hard-won alliance between Silicon Valley and Washington.
'It is unfortunate … I hope they will come back together,' Texas Senator Ted Cruz, who was in the Oval Office when Trump slammed Musk, the Financial Times reported over the weekend. 'A lot of conservatives are feeling like this is not good, let's hug and make up.'
The Tesla chief, who had spent last Thursday launching more explosive attacks on Trump, seemed to be open to a détente.
However, Trump on Friday claimed he was 'not even thinking about Elon', before adding on CNN: 'The poor guy's got a problem … I won't be speaking to him for a while I guess, but I wish him well.'
He repeated that line on Saturday, telling television network NBC he had no intention of mending their relationship. Further, Trump warned of 'serious consequences' if Musk funded candidates to run against Republicans after a poll of his 220 million X followers musing about forming a new political party in the US.
Tech figures who backed the administration hoping it would usher in an era of tax cuts and deregulation have been racing to contain the quarrel, with limited success.
'Elon isn't taking calls from anyone,' one Silicon Valley financier and big donor to Republican candidates told the FT. 'Not from people who have billions invested in his companies … The Valley is losing their shit.'
Attempts to get Trump to reconcile with his former 'first buddy' received a further set-back on Friday morning after news the president planned to sell or give away the Tesla he had bought in March as a show of support for Musk. The White House also dismissed reports of a conciliatory phone call between the two men.
Cracks in Silicon Valley and Washington's marriage of convenience had been appearing for weeks, particularly over Trump's tax bill which irked Musk. Deficit hawks have balked at the legislation adding trillions to the US debt pile, while more socially progressive tech figures have bridled at proposed cuts to entitlement programmes such as Medicaid.
Musk's allies aligned with Trump fear several Silicon Valley figures who followed him into government could find their roles are in peril.
The sudden deselection of Jared Isaacman, a tech founder and friend of Musk's who had been nominated to lead Nasa, was the start of an expected 'purge', said one person close to the administration.
It was also another expensive week financially for Musk with Tesla shares falling almost 15 percent in the wake of the breakup with Trump and the expected loss of valuable tax rebates for buyers of EVs. As a result, Tesla shares recorded their worst week so far this year wiping a further US$152 billion from the company's market capitalisation with the shares now down 22 percent year-to-date.
Coming up this week
Monday
Business Employment and Financial Data (Mar qtr) – Stats NZ
Tuesday
Scales Corp AGM
Wednesday
Migration & International Travel (April) – Stats NZ
NZ King Salmon AGM
Thursday
Electronic Card Transactions (May) – Stats NZ
Local Authority Stats (March qtr) – Stats NZ
Friday
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
The NZ economy is still sick, doubts are growing about the Govt prescription
Are these the right antibiotics? Are the antibiotics making me feel sick? I do feel a little better I think. But it's taking longer than I expected. Maybe I should see the doctor again. Or am I just being impatient? Ugh, so much uncertainty. Hopefully, those who've tuned in for a fresh read on the state of the economy can see where this is going. Never let a metaphor go by, I say! Anyway, here's me and the New Zealand economy, both sick in the midst of a miserable wet winter and worrying about whether our recoveries have stalled. A run of negative data has knocked the wind out of the nation's sails. The bad vibes are being pushed along by a strong political current. Both the left and right are telling us that the Government has prescribed the wrong medicine. The left blames the Government for cutting spending into a downturn. The logic is pretty simple. Any good Keynesian will tell you, when demand in the private sector falls, that's the time for the Government to come to the party. Borrow a bit more, don't slash and burn civil service, hire more teachers and nurses, build more stuff ... it won't be inflationary because it won't be crowding out private sector competition, which is in recession. The trouble is, we're still in the aftermath of the last big spend-up, which went on too long. Labour's stimulus, once we got through the initial Covid shock, did clash with a private sector boom and exacerbated inflation. That muddied the political narrative. It made it inevitable that the incoming centre-right coalition would cut back despite the extra damage that would do to economic growth. In the context of using fiscal policy to drive economic prosperity, you can make a good case that successive governments have got things completely arse about face. You'd expect this argument from the left. But Christopher Luxon and Nicola Willis are being savaged even more aggressively from their right flank. The monetarists, the supply-side guys, the neo-liberals, (whatever you want to call them) are berating the Government for not dealing with the national debt and Crown deficit by administering a Rogernomics-style reboot of the whole economy. I doubt that would make the current downturn any more pleasant, but they argue it couldn't be much worse. And the payoff would be longer-term gains as the economy found a more productive and financially secure baseline. Both arguments can be compelling and, if nothing else, add to the concern that the current strategy of subtle market-oriented tweaks risks underdelivering on all sides. But through all of this gloom, one thing we need to remember is that most economists still believe the foundations of recovery are in place. Step back a bit from the mess of ugly recent economic data – the second quarter sucked, we get it! What are we actually experiencing? The labour market is tough. Unemployment is rising, and new job creation is almost non-existent. But this is not a surprise. In fact, while economists do get things wrong, they've been forecasting unemployment to be about where it is now for more than a year. We know it's one of the last pieces of data to turn in any recovery. Unfortunately, it is now overlapping with an unwanted and unexpected spike in inflation. Like a jump scare in the final scene of a horror movie, food prices (with rates and power, and insurance) have conspired to pause Reserve Bank rate cuts and rattled our faith in the recovery. Then there are tariffs and global unrest and all of that. It's not really surprising that it all feels bleak. So it's a bit ironic to be writing an optimistic take on the economy, especially given the rough week stuck at home that I've just had. My view wouldn't have been so upbeat if I hadn't been woken from my sick bed on Friday morning by a text from investment bank HSBC's Australian head of communications. He was asking how far away I was from my scheduled meeting with their global chief economist, Janet Henry and and Australia-New Zealand chief economist Paul Bloxham. Oops ... I was a long way away. But they kindly let me Zoom in later, and I'm very glad I did. As anyone with Australian cousins will know, sometimes it's healthy to be slapped in the face with a slightly condescending, external view of the New Zealand condition. Bloxham told me his forecasts currently make him one of the gloomiest economists on Australian growth. However, he's one of the most positive on New Zealand growth. Last year, New Zealand had the single largest contraction of any economy in the developed world, Bloxham points out. That inevitably comes with a hangover. But if you believe in the fundamentals of the New Zealand economy, which he does, there is no reason to assume the cycle won't turn. 'I suspect why I'm a little bit more upbeat than others is I sit in Sydney and watch it from the outside and go: hey, you've got two big forces at work that are set to continue to lift growth and give you a recovery.' No prizes for guessing those two forces – falling interest rates and booming agricultural commodity prices. The money flowing into the rural economy must eventually flow through to the cities and lift growth, Bloxham says. It won't happen overnight, but it will happen (my words, not his). We've had a big downswing, which means we're due a pretty big upswing to get back to trend, he says. And we've got monetary policy and the terms of trade in place to drive that cyclical upswing. 'All cycles look different. We always ask the same question going through: oh, it's not quite happening as quickly as we thought. 'The question you ask yourself is: is that because it's not working? Is it that interest rates aren't going to have the same effect? That a positive-terms-of-trade shock won't have the same effect? Or are things just a bit different this time around?' Great question. And look, the sun's finally out and I think my head's clearing. Time to go for a walk and ponder it all. Liam Dann is business editor-at-large for the New Zealand Herald. He is a senior writer and columnist, and also presents and produces videos and podcasts. He joined the Herald in 2003.
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
Co-working space to combat loneliness
Wānaka has become a hot spot for remote workers looking to self-start their future success — but the freedom-driven lifestyle comes with a price tag. The Covid pandemic was a catalyst in enabling hybrid and remote work, which meant some people had the option of travelling and exploring as they worked. The Cell co-working space co-owner Arna Craig, experienced the increase of people choosing to live in Wānaka as they worked for companies throughout New Zealand. "I think it's no secret that Covid taught us all that lifestyle is really important," she said. "And I think Wānaka offers that opportunity to so many people because it's just, it's a lifestyle destination." Luke Robinson and Natalie Drayton are two visionaries who saw the opportunity to expand the region's remote working scene by starting Netwerk, their own co-working and networking space which partnered with NRG gym. Ms Drayton began as a paramedic in Nelson before starting a Pilates reform business and eventually deciding to travel with her partner while doing remote book-keeping work. At the time, Mr Robinson was a primary teacher and moved to online tutoring while the couple embarked on travels across the country. "We wanted flexibility," Ms Drayton said. "And because I had a service-facing business, it meant we had to be there, and we really wanted to do some more travel." They moved all around the country and have since found themselves in Wānaka twice and this time they intend to stay for the long haul. Their plan was to continue doing some contract work as they explored all the region had to offer, but constant remote working proved to be more difficult than expected. "It is amazing, but it definitely comes with its side effects," Ms Drayton said. "I get a lot of my energy from external sources ... I just need to be around people and see people, even if I don't even know them." Loneliness was one of the hardest prices to pay for choosing a lifestyle that had more freedom. Mr Robinson opted to take on a new and different challenge while in Wānaka by doing some glazing work. This made him realise that despite the freedom that came with remote work, it did not compare to being part of a team. "With all this flexibility, I can go for a walk during lunchtime and all these amazing things," he said. "But there's a certain feeling when you're with a crew of people that you really miss out on." Having met several others in town also facing the same challenges as they work remotely, they decided to set up their own co-working space which went a step further by hosting networking events and partnering with a gym. The space is one of the few other businesses within the NRG gym on Plantation Rd, and members who use the co-working space are entitled to a lower rate at the gym. The idea was not only to promote connectivity but provide people with movement and energy in a work lifestyle that could get isolating. "I mean for us, an ideal morning would be, getting up, going to the gym ... Going up while you're stimulated, do a few hours work," Ms Drayton said. Netwerk's opening week is set to start on August 18, with networking events running for most of the week, helping to connect local remote workers with each other.
NZ Herald
2 days ago
- NZ Herald
Whanganui's Sarjeant Gallery redevelopment comes in at just under $80m
On July 24, the gallery ticked over 100,000 visits since reopening on November 9, with surveys indicating 60% came from outside the region. 'It is estimated to be contributing about $17m of visitor spend into our local businesses, which will, over time, offset the cost to the ratepayer many times over,' Langford said. 'I would certainly like to see us, at the very least, sustain those [visitor] numbers, and potentially increase them.' He said the council was engaging with Tourism NZ to make sure Whanganui was well promoted internationally. Batty's report said in June 2020, the project had a total budget of $55.08m. 'In line with other major projects that have had to manage the combined impact of Covid-19 on programme, staff availability, material and labour cost escalations and disruptions in the supply chain, the project has significantly exceeded the original project budget,' it said. 'There was a 28.3% total cost increase in non-residential building costs over our construction period.' Gaye Batty in the gallery's heritage building in 2022. Photo / NZME In March 2022, the Chronicle reported that the forecast cost had blown out to $64.4m, with then-mayor Hamish McDouall saying restoring and earthquake-strengthening the gallery's heritage building had presented a number of challenges for the construction team. 'It's a unique and iconic building that has to be handled with great care,' he said. The $19.67m overspend since 2020 was due to several factors, including the pandemic, work on the heritage building, ground conditions, insurances and archaeology, Batty's report said. Council-approved scope changes and extras, including the fit-out of the cafe, additional AV/ICT infrastructure, and landscaping works, made up just over $4m of the overspend. In 2015, the council committed $5m to the project and then, in 2017, it voted in favour of being a guarantor of the project to secure Government funding. The redevelopment was expected to cost $34.9m at the time. Councillor Kate Joblin said the final cost was 'a whole chunk of money' and she hoped the council did better with significant projects in the future. But the gallery had tangible benefits, she said. 'I've been around long enough to remember, not in detail, but the number of bailouts the Cooks Gardens complex needed when that was built. 'Who can imagine what Whanganui would be like if we didn't have Cooks Gardens. 'I am in no doubt the Sarjeant will become the same treasure, the taonga of this community.' Councillor Rob Vinsen said he attended the first council meeting about the redevelopment in 1998. 'It is a great facility, but it's time now to move on from talking about the capex [capital expenditure]. That is spent money,' he said. 'Our attention as council should turn to operating costs of this institution, because $200 per ratepayer [a year] is too high.' The rates requirement to operate the gallery in 2025/26 is about $4.9m. Last year, Vinsen proposed a $15 entry fee for out-of-towners. During this week's meeting, he said he hoped that would still be considered. Whanganui Mayor Andrew Tripe said significant projects of international standards cost a lot of money, but the Sarjeant would benefit the community for years to come. 'We have an incredible asset, and we are not going to unbuild it for the very few and diminishing number of detractors out there,' he said. 'Let's move forward and celebrate what we've got.' Councillor Kate Joblin says, like Cooks Gardens, the Sarjeant will be a "taonga of this community". Photo / NZME Langford said a 'broad and all-encompassing' project review was under way, with the council's executive officers already holding workshops with Batty, the project management team and review facilitators. The council would spend about $1.78m a year in loan repayments for the project, he said. Joblin asked if, with the benefit of hindsight, he still thought it was a good project. Langford, who is leaving his role in October, said it had been - 'absolutely'. 'While the cost is higher, the benefits that are being delivered are proportionately higher still,' he said. 'Could the project have been set up slightly differently and run slightly more smoothly? 'Yes, but that's probably the answer to every single project that's ever done.' Councillor Jenny Duncan said ratepayers had to be recognised for their contribution, especially those who would not use the gallery and were struggling to pay their rates. 'I also want to acknowledge Nicola [Williams, former Sarjeant Trust chair] because, if it wasn't for her, it wouldn't be $26m we were putting in," Duncan said. 'Who knows, it might have fallen over at one point or another, because we didn't have that additional funding we needed to keep going.' Mike Tweed is a multimedia journalist at the Whanganui Chronicle. Since starting in March 2020, he has dabbled in everything from sport to music. At present his focus is local government, primarily the Whanganui District Council.
