Supreme Court refuses to hear appeal over Middleborough student's ‘two genders' shirt
Liam Morrison.
Alliance Defending Freedom
Advertisement
The 1st US Circuit Court of Appeals 'takes the remarkable position that a school may flood its halls with its views on a matter of public concern — here, gender identity — and encourage students to join in, then bar students from responding with different views,' the family argued.
The school district urged the court not to hear the case, saying the principal, Heather Tucker, reasonably took into account the mental health struggles of transgender and gender-nonconforming youths and her experience working with students who were bullied because of their gender identity.
Advertisement
Under past Supreme Court decisions, 'a public school must be able to restrict some student speech to protect its students and ensure a learning environment in which all students can flourish,' Middleborough argued.
The dispute took place in 2023, when L.M. was a seventh grader at Nichols Middle School. After he arrived at school wearing the shirt, Tucker pulled him from class and told him he couldn't return unless he took it off. When L.M. declined, the principal called his father, who took L.M. home.
L.M. later tried to wear the same shirt with a piece of tape over the words 'only two' and 'censored' written on top. L.M. removed that shirt after he was confronted by school officials. He wasn't disciplined for either incident.
The case is L.M. v. Middleborough, 24-410.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Brickbat: Third Time's the Charm?
Pro-life activist Isabel Vaughan-Spruce is under police investigation for a third time after silently praying outside an abortion clinic in Birmingham, England. The police investigation comes despite two previous arrests for the same thing that resulted in a settlement in her favor and a formal apology from the police. British law bans activities intended to influence or cause distress within a "buffer zone" around abortion clinics. Vaughan-Spruce, who is being supported by the legal group Alliance Defending Freedom International, argues that silently praying is not a criminal offense and that everyone has a right to freedom of thought. The police have asked prosecutors to decide if there is enough evidence to charge her. The post Brickbat: Third Time's the Charm? appeared first on Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
21 hours ago
- Yahoo
Former LA Fire Chief Files Defamation Lawsuit Against City For 'Unlawful Retaliation'
Former LA Fire Chief Files Defamation Lawsuit Against City For 'Unlawful Retaliation' originally appeared on L.A. Mag. Former LAFD Chief Kristin Crowley says that she was fired for "telling the truth" about department resources in the aftermath of deadly wildfires that tore through Los Angeles in January, and now she wants the city to pay for defaming her. In a lawsuit filed against the city Wednesday, L.A.'s first female and LGBTQ+ fire department leader said Mayor Karen Bass not only unfairly fired her, but has since undertaken a "smear campaign" to defame her. The war of words between Bass, who was traveling on a diplomatic mission to Ghana when the deadly wildfires exploded across Los Angeles County on January 7, and Crowley began after the former Chief spoke about her frustration that firefighters' efforts were hindered by tapped hydrants in the Pacific Palisades, understaffing and broken down rigs. "When Fire Chief Crowley confirmed to the public that Bass cut the LAFD's operating budget by $17.6 million, she was targeted and removed from her position. The Mayor and her office simultaneously launched a smear campaign built on falsehoods," according to Crowley's attorneys. "Integrity, truthfulness and serving others before self have guided me throughout the years," Crowley said in a statement Wednesday morning. "As the Fire Chief for nearly three years, I advocated for the proper funding, staffing and infrastructure upgrades to better support our Firefighters, and by extension, our communities." Crowley said the mayor then began to lie about, exaggerate and misrepresent the Fire Department's budget and issues. "As Firefighters, we run towards uncertainty and are willing to risk it all. Doing the right thing even when it is hard is always the right decision and that is why I am continuing to fight for the resources our Firefighters need to keep us all safe." Crowley wants the Mayor to apologize and retract all of what the lawsuit calls defamatory statements about her response to the fires. Crowley's attorneys say she was "demoted, sidelined, and denied opportunities to return to leadership roles for which she was qualified," by an angry Bass, who was heavily criticized for celebrating the swearing in of a leader in a country with a history of homophobia. Ghana's Parliament passed a 2024 Human Sexual Rights and Family Values Bill which criminalizes LGBTQ+ individuals and their supporters - an action that has received widespread international condemnation by human rights activists. "Former Fire Chief Crowley's tort claim presents her extensive advocacy efforts to obtain the funding and resources the LAFD needed to fulfill its public safety mission. It also shows Mayor Bass' repeated refusals to provide those resources," her attorney Genie Harrison said in a statement, adding that the former chief is putting herself "on the line" again to give Angelenos the truth about the sorry state of the Fire Department's resources. The lawsuit comes just hours after Bass announced that the city's after-action Report on the Palisades Fire - the cause of which remains a mystery more than seven months later - was paused after the U.S. Attorney's Office for California's Central District said the release could bungle what the mayor called an "ongoing investigation." The U.S. Attorney's office had no comment. The Mayor's office did not immediately return a request for comment on Crowley's lawsuit. This story was originally reported by L.A. Mag on Aug 20, 2025, where it first appeared. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
5 days ago
- Yahoo
Vandals lob bags of dog poop at L.A.-area LGBTQ youth center, officials say
For the past several months, volunteers and community members arriving at the Mi SELA youth center in the city of Bell have encountered a putrid smell. The source? Bags of discarded dog feces. The center is a partnership between the Los Angeles LGBT Center and the Latino Equity Alliance and provides youth clubs, community-building workshops, and cultural and legal resources to the LGBTQ+ community of South Los Angeles. But recently, the center has seen a pattern of dog feces being thrown in front of and onto the awning of the building's entrance. 'There were over 10 bags. That was the second time that we've had to do a full sweep of the awning … I just worry about, what if it does escalate in the future?' Sanva Lojero, Mi SELA's programs manager, told NBC Los Angeles. "This is a youth resource center, so we have clients coming in each day and I don't want them to feel like they're getting harassed.' It's unclear who is throwing the feces — or why. But given the center serves LGBTQ+ youth, some maintain it's deliberate, potentially hate-motivated vandalism. The Latino Equity Alliance denounced the recent incidents as 'abhorrent' and 'unacceptable' in a statement posted on Instagram. 'In 2025, it is shocking that young people and community organizations continue to face such targeted hate and intimidation. While law enforcement has emphasized that action cannot be taken without catching the perpetrators in the act, that does not diminish the urgent need for … a public stance against hate in our communities,' the statement read. L.A. County Supervisor Janice Hahn has pledged a $2,500 grant to install more security cameras around the community center in hopes of capturing the perpetrators. 'The fact that this person is going out of their way to do this says everything about them and nothing about our LGBTQ community in Southeast L.A.,' Hahn said in a statement. With security cameras now likely on their way, Mi SELA's staff say they won't be deterred from their mission. 'We're not going anywhere, we're going to still keep providing resources,' Lojero said. Anyone with information can contact the Bell Police Department at (323) 585-1245. Sign up for Essential California for news, features and recommendations from the L.A. Times and beyond in your inbox six days a week. This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
