B.C. author leads 'David against Goliath' lawsuits alleging big tech used writers' works to train AI
J.B. MacKinnon is named as the representative plaintiff in the claim, which says his books, The 100-Mile Diet and The Once and Future World, were part of a 196,640-book dataset that Nvidia used without paying a licensing fee or securing consent to acquire or use the works.
"This isn't a situation where some copyrighted material appears as a small fraction of the larger process. The models were entirely built on the mining of copyrighted work," MacKinnon told CBC.
"The most disturbing aspect of it is that those large language models and AIs can then compete with human writers, and are likely to displace human writers."
Besides Nvidia, MacKinnon is the representative plaintiff in three similar class actions filed in B.C. Supreme Court that individually name Meta/Facebook, Anthropic and Databricks Inc. as defendants. All four class actions will require court certification to move forward.
The class, or group, of plaintiffs described in each of the cases are all holders of Canadian copyright in works the companies used to build their LLMs.
Large language models are AI software designed to comprehend and generate language that mimics a knowledgeable human.
World's largest company
According to the claim, Nvidia trained its LLMs on books it obtained in a copied dataset "...because it believed doing so would improve its model and give it an advantage over its competition."
"NVIDIA monetized the NVIDIA LLMs by using them to assist in the growth and development [of the] company's position in the AI industry, which has in turn led to NVIDIA's growth into the world's largest company by market capitalization," it says.
Nvidia has a market capitalization of $4.28 trillion.
"Collectively as Canadian writers, we're certainly the David against the Goliath in this case," said MacKinnon. "These are the most powerful and richest corporations in the world that we're up against. I don't think we have any reason to think that the fight will be an easy one."
CBC contacted Nvidia but a company spokesperson declined comment.
The claims also allege the four companies took steps to conceal copyright infringement by training the LLMs to respond in a "misleading way" when asked if copyrighted material was used in the LLMs' creation.
"If that proves to be true in court, I hope that the courts will consider that cause not only for writers to be compensated, but for the companies to be punished for bad behaviour," said MacKinnon.
A judge in San Francisco hearing a similar case brought by authors against Anthropic sided last month with the AI company, ruling that training LLMs on purchased copyrighted books qualifies as "extremely transformative" under the legal definition of fair use.
However, the judge did say that Anthropic's use of millions of books it allegedly pirated was a separate issue to be considered.
A lawyer representing MacKinnon said the problem of AI companies using the original works of authors to build highly profitable products is an issue that's gaining attention worldwide.
"The goal of the companies is not to transform the world, it's to make money," said Reidar Mogerman.
"I think you can respect both the values of the copyright system and the ability of these companies to create these models.... It's just that you can't throw out one to create the other, especially when the thing you create is going to be a competitive threat to the work the authors did."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
38 minutes ago
- CBC
'What took so long?' P.E.I. senator says Ottawa's bridge toll cut came a decade too late
Social Sharing Prime Minster Mark Carney's decision to cut tolls on the Confederation Bridge satisfied a Prince Edward Island senator's long-standing quest for equality — but it didn't come without a question. "What took so long?" said Percy Downe during an interview with CBC's Island Morning. Downe, who served as chief of staff to former prime minister Jean Chrétien before his appointment to the Senate in 2003, had long called the bridge tolls unfair to Islanders. His complaints began about a decade ago, when the previous Liberal government announced it was fully funding and removing tolls on Montreal's Champlain Bridge. Both that bridge and Confederation are assets owned by the federal government. "That was grossly unfair. It was unfair to Islanders," Downe said. "It was a problem that should have been addressed by prime minister [Justin] Trudeau. It was never addressed. I'm thankful Prime Minister Carney fixed the problem." Carney's announcement Monday saw the price of tolls on the Confederation Bridge, which connects P.E.I. with New Brunswick, fall to $20 from $50.25. Prices for transport trucks fell to a flat rate of $20. And there was no change in the cost to cyclists, pedestrians, shuttles or motorcycles. Those changes kicked in Friday. Downe said he's OK with the $20 toll, saying that money can go toward the bridge's maintenance. But it took a decade for Ottawa to right a wrong, he said, and Islanders paid the price during that time. "In those 10 years... Islanders spent hundreds of millions of dollars in tolls," he said. More than 990,000 vehicles crossed the Confederation Bridge in 2024, many of them paying at least $50.25 to pass. Also in Carney's announcement, news that fares for passengers, cars and commercial traffic on ferry services in Eastern Canada that are federally supported would go down by 50 per cent. The ferry service between Nova Scotia and Newfoundland also got a boost from Ottawa. Ticket prices were cut in half, though rates for commercial freight did not see a decrease. To make it all happen, it's estimated government will spend about $100 million of public money annually to offset the reduction of the bridge toll and ferry fares. An economic and social boost Despite the spending, the prime minister said the move will pump millions back into the Canadian economy. "If we are going to build a stronger, more united economy, and we are doing that, we are going to need to make it more affordable to travel around this country, for people and for businesses," Carney said during the announcement. That need is something Downe has seen first-hand "Just prior to the pandemic, I heard from an agricultural producer who spent $66,000 in bridge tolls that year — money that his competitor in Cap-Pelé, N.B., did not have to spend," Downe said. WATCH | Islanders and tourists excited about reduced price to leave P.E.I.: Islanders and tourists excited about reduced price to leave P.E.I. 4 days ago In seven years, full ownership of the bridge will transfer back to the federal government from it's current operator, Strait Crossing Bridge Ltd. Downe said he is "not worried at all" about whether tolls will remain low after that deadline. But advocacy for equitable, reliable travel can't end, he said, especially as the ferry service between P.E.I. and Nova Scotia continues to face delays and disruptions this season. "It has to be addressed," he said. "I won't be in the Sentate for another 10 years."
CBC
42 minutes ago
- CBC
P.E.I. hits record housing starts, but experts say more needed to restore affordability
Social Sharing Housing starts on Prince Edward Island reached a record high last year, but a recent report says even more construction is needed to make homes affordable. In 2024, there were 1,684 housing starts, a 48.7 per cent increase from the previous year and the highest total since the 1970s. That brings the province close to the goal laid out in its housing strategy, released last year, which identifies the need for an average of 2,000 new homes per year between now and 2030. But the latest supply gaps estimate report from the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation says that, based on projected demand, Canada needs to essentially double its current pace of home construction to return to pre-pandemic levels of housing affordability. For P.E.I., that means increasing the projected average of about 1,300 annual housing starts between 2025 and 2035 to nearly 2,200 per year — surpassing even the province's all-time record of 2,122 starts set in 1973. That remains the only year since 1948, the earliest data from CHMC is available, when housing starts on the Island exceeded 2,000. Construction industry at capacity Sam Sanderson, executive director of the Construction Association of P.E.I., said reaching 2,200 housing starts may prove difficult. He said the province's construction sector, which employs more than 8,500 people year-round, is already operating at full capacity. "To say it's not achievable, I'd be lying," Sanderson told CBC News. "But there needs to be some changes, there needs to be some additions, and there needs to be some investment into construction to even look at those numbers." Sanderson said innovations in the industry are helping, including pre-manufactured wall systems and modular construction that allow for faster, more affordable builds. But labour remains a major constraint. The industry is facing a shortage of skilled workers across multiple trades, he said, and productivity has dropped as experienced workers retire. "We're saying right now, it takes pretty near 2.2 new people to do the same amount of work one person did... 20 years ago or 10 years ago," Sanderson said. "We need to find ways to increase productivity." The association has been trying to bring more workers into the industry through training programs and outreach. Last year alone it made more than 50 visits to schools across the Island. But Sanderson said more investment is needed — not just into housing projects, but into people. That includes recruitment, training and skilled trades support, especially as P.E.I. competes with other provinces. He pointed to Nova Scotia's commitment, announced in 2023, to invest $100 million over three years in recruiting skilled tradespeople as the type of investment P.E.I. needs to match. "We need to see some large-scale investments like that into our industry here in P.E.I. to be able to increase our capacity to build," Sanderson said. He added that governments must also prioritize targeted immigration strategies to attract skilled workers for the construction industry. 'The momentum has continued' Staff with Fusion Charlottetown — a non-profit based in P.E.I.'s capital that advocates for youth and young adults on issues such as housing affordability — the record-breaking year was a welcome development. The pace has continued. In the first two quarters of 2025, there have already been 751 housing starts — the most for that time period since 1973. "We're definitely pleased to see it over the past year," said Fusion Charlottetown's vice-president, Matt Pelletier. "What we're pleased to see is that the momentum has continued." Pelletier acknowledged that the 2,200 target is ambitious, but said it can be within reach. "With the right mechanisms, the right fiscal tools and the right alignment with land use, it's possible to do that again," he said. "It's going to require all orders of government coming together to make that happen." Incentives and policy changes needed Before the province tabled its 2025-26 operating budget, Fusion Charlottetown submitted a list of policy recommendations aimed at boosting the housing supply. These included encouraging apartment construction in urban areas and funding "housing-enabling infrastructure" such as roads and sewer systems, which are essential for making new housing developments possible. Fusion Charlottetown is also calling for the extension of rental construction sales tax rebates to affordable housing projects. In the fall of 2023, the federal government brought in legislation to remove the GST on new rental developments. Shortly after, the P.E.I. government followed suit by eliminating the provincial portion of the HST for new rental builds in hopes of spurring construction. Fusion Charlottetown wants to see those rebates expanded to include different forms of affordable housing, such as co-operative housing and affordable home ownership initiatives like Habitat for Humanity projects. "Creating a sales tax mechanism to allow for those sorts of units to be built would be favourable when it comes to creating affordable housing options," Pelletier said. Prince Edward Island is managing the housing crisis just about as well as anyone in the country. — Mike Moffatt, Missing Middle Initiative The organization is pushing for municipal policy changes too, like harmonizing building codes, and it's also advocating for Charlottetown to have a fast-track approval system for affordable housing projects. "In a lot of cases, the delays relating to those can contribute to the input costs of affordable housing projects, effectively undermining the affordability that they're trying to create," Pelletier said. Is 2,200 the right number? Housing policy expert Steve Pomeroy said it's important to look critically at the 2,200 figure and consider whether that many homes are really needed on P.E.I. Pomeroy, an industry professor at McMaster University and member of the Canadian Housing Evidence Collaborative, said the CMHC's projections are a theoretical exercise focused only on supply. But he said the real challenge is ensuring affordability — and that won't be solved by supply alone. Developers are unlikely to build units that would lower their profits, leaving many new homes still out of reach for low-income residents, Pomeroy said. "So rather than just any kind of supply, we need to think about, how do we actually create supply of more affordably priced homes? Which means invoking the role of the non-market sector, non-profits and co-operatives who respond to different signals than the market does," he said. "Those are provided with subsidies from government… and they have a mission to address affordability." Pomeroy pointed to the broader need for more social housing across the country, citing a 2023 Scotiabank report that found just 3.5 per cent of Canada's total housing stock is social housing — half the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development average of around seven per cent. P.E.I. stands out on social housing Despite Canada's lag in social housing, P.E.I. is making some progress. The province's housing strategy includes a $176-million investment over five years to establish 560 government-owned social housing units. In a statement to CBC News, the Department of Housing, Land and Communities said that by the end of the last fiscal year, 227 new social housing units were under design and/or construction. That's already 40 per cent of the five-year target. WATCH | P.E.I. government giving millions to let housing non-profits and co-ops buy and rent out 116 units P.E.I. government giving millions to let housing non-profits and co-ops buy and rent out 116 units 17 days ago The provincial government in P.E.I. is partnering with three non-profit groups to let them acquire existing affordable housing units and build new ones. So far, the project has led to 116 units in Charlottetown and Summerside moving out of the hands of private landlords, at a cost of about $7.5 million. CBC's Connor Lamont explains. The province said it made a "historic" capital investment of $63 million in the 2024-25 fiscal year to support new social housing, adding a record 149 units to the system: 37 through construction and 112 through acquisitions. That surpassed the previous record set in 2023-24, when 142 units were added. "Through these investments, the social housing registry was reduced to the smallest waitlist in well over a decade, with a low of 389 as of March 31, 2025," the statement read. A national report card, released by the Missing Middle Initiative at the University of Ottawa, recently evaluated provincial housing policies across Canada. P.E.I. received an A for construction of social housing, the highest grade in the country. "Prince Edward Island… came out with a plan to increase social housing that was particularly detailed — more detailed than we're seeing here in Ontario," said Missing Middle Initiative founding director Mike Moffatt.
Globe and Mail
an hour ago
- Globe and Mail
Undervalued and Profitable: 3 Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stocks for Buffett-Minded Investors
Key Points Although Arm Holdings doesn't physically manufacture anything, it's cashing in on the ever-growing need for efficient, high-performance AI hardware. As much as the semiconductor industry is trying to wean itself from its dependence on Taiwan Semiconductor, it just can't. Think of DigitalOcean as a key consumer staples company of the artificial intelligence industry. 10 stocks we like better than Arm Holdings › Warren Buffett's never been a big fan of technology stocks. He says they're too difficult to understand and often vulnerable to change. He'd rather own more predictable picks, which means he prefers investing in already-profitable companies with simple business models. This preference disqualifies many artificial intelligence (AI) stocks from becoming a Berkshire Hathaway holding. Not every technology stock, however, is the clichéd dot-com type of investment that Buffett has sought to avoid. A handful of AI stocks are arguably justifiable additions to Berkshire's portfolio based on their predictability, profitability, and of course, their potential upside. Here's a closer look at three such AI prospects that Buffett might actually approve of if given a closer look. They may be a good way of adding some AI exposure to your portfolio as well. Arm Holdings OK, Arm Holdings ' (NASDAQ: ARM) revenue and earnings may not be perfectly predictable from one quarter to the next. The company's top and bottom lines do reliably grow though, and it is reliably (and increasingly) profitable. ARM Revenue (Quarterly) data by YCharts. But what is it? This company is frequently categorized as a semiconductor stock, which isn't an inaccurate description. It's not a manufacturer in the same vein as Intel (NASDAQ: INTC) or Qualcomm, though. Rather, Arm only designs microchip architecture and then licenses this intellectual property to chipmakers that often outsource the production of these chips to a third-party manufacturer. For instance, Apple 's (NASDAQ: AAPL) latest iPhone processors are based on Arm's chip architecture, but this particular silicon is actually made (per Apple and Arm's specs) by a company called Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing (NYSE: TSM), also known as TSMC. Arm only collects a relatively small amount of revenue for every iPhone sold with its tech built into it. But since Arm incurs no production or distribution costs, this is high-margin revenue. Last fiscal year Arm Holdings turned $4 billion worth of sales into nearly $800 million worth of net income. Given the technological prowess of outfits like Intel, Apple, and Qualcomm, it seems strange that they should rely on -- and pay -- a company like Arm for something as relatively common as chip design. But it actually makes a lot of sense for a couple of reasons. First, all of Arm's know-how is patented, so using it would be illegal even if it is a logical and intuitive solution. And second, Arm's solutions are actually superior, particularly when it comes to power efficiency. Its cloud-computing data center processors require up to 60% less electricity than comparable processors from rivals, for example, answering one of data center operators' biggest frustrations. That's why Arm believes it could control as much as half of the data center processor market by the end of this year, up from only about 15% as of 2024. Taiwan Semiconductor Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing doesn't just make Apple's newest Arm-based iPhone processors. It manufactures high-performance chips for most of the major semiconductor names including Nvidia, Qualcomm, Advanced Micro Devices, and Broadcom -- just to name a few. Indeed, analysts' estimates put TSMC's market share of global production of high-performance processors anywhere from 80% to as high as 90%. What gives? As it turns out, manufacturing computer processors is complicated and expensive. It's often easier and cheaper to punt this work to an organization with the experience, expertise, and capacity to make these chips than it is to try and do it yourself. Over the course of the past couple of decades, TSMC has emerged as the industry's premier contract manufacturer This satisfies a couple of Buffett's most important rules for buying stocks. As he advises, look for proven, high-quality companies with a wide competitive moat. TSMC offers both. A handful of chipmakers are attempting to wean themselves from reliance on silicon made in the Pacific region particularly by TSMC. Back in 2022, for instance, Intel committed billions of dollars to establishing its own chipmaking foundries in Europe and the U.S. The fact that much of this work has been delayed due to complications and recently scaled back, however, underscores the difficulty of getting into or expanding the chipmaking business when players like TSMC are already so well established and so far ahead, technology-wise. Apple's strategy is more aligned with reality. It's partnering with TSMC to establish a manufacturing presence within the U.S. that it can enjoy some control of and that won't simultaneously require it to fend off competition while these factories are being built. More important to Buffett-minded investors, while the business may ebb and flow from time to time, the world's never not going to need new and better computer chips. DigitalOcean Finally, add DigitalOcean (NYSE: DOCN) to your list of undervalued and profitable AI stocks that Warren Buffett could appreciate. It's probably the least-known name of the three AI prospects in focus. In fact, there's a good chance you've never even heard of it. Its market cap of less than $3 billion just doesn't turn many heads, and it's seemingly not nearly as critical to the AI industry as Arm or TSMC. Don't be dissuaded by its relatively small size or lack of recognition. It's arguably the most Buffett-like of all three AI stocks highlighted here. DigitalOcean provides a range of cloud-based services to clients that simply want to outsource their data center needs. These include blockchain solutions, simple web hosting, video streaming technologies, online video games platforms, and yes, a whole bunch of AI solutions like AI training, virtual customer service agents, and automated coding. Although DigitalOcean doesn't strictly serve the AI industry, AI is an increasingly bigger profit center. But that's not what makes this outfit such a Buffett-esque pick. Rather, Warren Buffett would very likely fall in love with this stock due to the nature of its business model and the fact that it's reliably profitable. DigitalOcean's clients pay for access to its technological solutions on a predictable, monthly basis. As of Q1 of this year, its annualized recurring revenue run rate stands at $843 million (up 14% from the year-earlier comparison) versus 2024's total top line of $781 million, of which $84 million was turned into net income. As long as the world needs the cloud -- and needs cloud-based AI solutions in particular -- this company's revenue and earnings are apt to grow in step with both industries. Should you invest $1,000 in Arm Holdings right now? Before you buy stock in Arm Holdings, consider this: The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy now… and Arm Holdings wasn't one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years. Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $625,254!* Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $1,090,257!* Now, it's worth noting Stock Advisor's total average return is 1,036% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 181% for the S&P 500. Don't miss out on the latest top 10 list, available when you join Stock Advisor. See the 10 stocks » *Stock Advisor returns as of July 29, 2025 James Brumley has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Advanced Micro Devices, Apple, Berkshire Hathaway, DigitalOcean, Intel, Nvidia, Qualcomm, and Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing. The Motley Fool recommends Broadcom and recommends the following options: short August 2025 $24 calls on Intel. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
