Budget 3.0: Godongwana under pressure to make up for downgraded growth

The Citizen

19-05-2025

With little room to manoeuvre, the minister of finance will have to cut government spending to balance the books in Budget 3.0.
The global and local economic environment where Minister of Finance Enoch Godongwana delivers his budget speech on Wednesday afternoon will be very different from February when he tried to get the budget passed for the first time. He will now have to make up for the downgraded growth as well as the gap left by scrapping the VAT increase.
Tertia Jacobs, treasury economist at Investec, says the two VAT increases of 0.5% each would have raised R75 billion in revenue over the medium-term expenditure framework (MTEF), a three-year spending plan used by government to guide its budget process.
'Scrapping the VAT increase makes it necessary to reduce government spending to maintain a neutral impact on the budget deficit. The focus now will be on where spending will be lowered and the ability of the government of national unity (GNU) to craft a way forward that both demonstrates its priorities and allows for consensus.'
ALSO READ: Budget 3.0: Time to fix our economy – BLSA
What has changed between Budget 2.0 and Budget 3.0?
Jacobs says this has changed from Budget 2.0 to Budget 3.0:
Global growth and South Africa's macroeconomic forecasts have been revised lower.
A VAT increase is not available to finance an increase in new spending.
The GNU is committed to stabilising the debt-to-GDP ratio.
Operation Vulindlela Phase 2's agenda has been announced and Budget 3.0 will allocate more funding.
There is additional cash from a higher closing balance and possibly the Gold and Foreign Exchange Contingency Reserve Account (GFECRA) valuation, depending on a formulaic allocation which has to be agreed to.
'The May 2025 budget will be trying to balance new expenditure measures and lower tax revenue. The commitment to fiscal consolidation is likely to remain, with the debt-to-GDP ratio sitting uncomfortably at 76% of gross domestic product (GDP).'
She says tax measures, such as the bracket creep that Budget 2.0 resorted to to finance new expenditure, are currently required to fill a potential shortfall in the baseline October 2024 medium-term budget policy statement (MTBPS) forecast, which exposes the main budget deficit to the political decision on how much and what types of new spending South Africa can afford.
ALSO READ: Budget 3.0: will it be third time lucky for Godongwana?
Clock is ticking to approve budget
'The clock is ticking and in addition, three bills in the fiscal framework must be passed. The Appropriations Bill must be finalised within four months of the start of the new financial year in April 2025. There is currently a spending cap of 45% based on the 2024/2025 budget.
'Funds withdrawn from the Revenue Fund may be used only for services for which funds were appropriated in the previous annual budget or the adjustments budget. Thereafter, it may not exceed 10% of the total amount appropriated in the previous budget,' she warns.
Jacobs points out that the outcome for the 2024/2025 revenue and expenditure numbers are better now and these will be included in Budget 3.0, showing a higher closing cash balance of R15 billion.
'Gross revenue receipts were R9 billion better than the February 2024 forecast and R15 billion ahead of the October 2024 MTBPS forecast. The contributory factors were a meaningful improvement in corporate income tax collections of R16 billion more than expected and a larger withdrawal from the two-pot retirement fund system of R45 billion, which raised R13 billion in tax, although personal income tax missed the target by R9 billion.
'Sars's effort to improve efficiencies and compliance also played a role in closing the forecast gap and this effort is expected to become more prominent over the MTEF period. On the expenditure side, the target was missed by R6 billion. The implication is a higher closing cash balance of R15 billion.'
ALSO READ: Economic activity slows in April as economy struggles
Budget deficit slightly smaller
Therefore, she says, the main budget deficit consequently beat estimates (of 4.7% of GDP) at 4.5% of GDP, as it declined from an estimated R356.1 billion to R336.7 billion.
However, there are new macroeconomic forecasts in a changing global landscape, Jacobs says. 'South Africa's structural reform programme's manifestation in higher fixed investment is materialising only very incrementally. In April 2025, the IMF revised its global growth forecasts to 2.8% for 2025 and 3.0% for 2026, down from 3.3% predicted for both years.
'The Trump administration's policy agenda of raising trade barriers already caused upheaval in global financial markets, with a toned-down tariff version to be followed as bilateral trade and investment deals are negotiated.
'While a trade war between the US and China appears to have been avoided – a risk scenario that the markets moved to price in in early April – US trade tariffs will be higher and this will have an impact on global trade and economic growth in many countries in Europe and China, South Africa's major trading partners.'
For example, she says, the weighted average tariff on US imports from China may have been reduced from more than 100% to 43% for the next 90 days, way above the 9% tariff increase in 2018/19. In South Africa, ICIB and Bloomberg consensus forecasts for economic growth have been lowered to 1.4%, from 1.9% and 1.7% in late 2024.
ALSO READ: Minister of finance says no to wealth tax
Budget 3.0 will also show National Treasury's updated GDP forecast for 2024 of 0.6% from its projection of 0.8%, with 1.9% in 2025 to be more aligned with market consensus. Inflation has consistently surprised on the downside in the past six months, leading to a revision in the market and the Sarb's inflation forecast.
National Treasury's 2025 forecast of 4.4% (0.8 percentage points higher than the consensus of 3.7%) will also be lowered. For 2026, the market consensus is at 4.5%, with National Treasury at 4.6%. The combination of lower growth and inflation implies slower nominal GDP growth. National Treasury's 7.0% and 6.4% are too high compared to ICIB's projection of 5.1% and 6.0%, Jacobs says.
'The revision to the macroeconomic forecast lowers the gross tax revenue forecasts. Our analysis shows that when the October 2024 MTBPS revenue forecast for FY25/26 is used as the baseline forecast, tax revenues could be R35 billion less, when assuming a gross revenue-to-GDP ratio of 24.7% of GDP.
'We think there are two ways of returning the forecast to the October 2024 baseline. These consist of bracket creep of R18.0 billion, announced in Budget 2.0, with carry-over effects of R19.1 billion and R20.3 billion in the outer years over the MTEF and increased reliance on Sars.'
ALSO READ: SA's economic growth outlook growing increasingly dim
Spending challenge?
'The removal of a 0.5% increase in VAT this year and another next year, which would have raised R80 billion to finance new spending on frontline services, means a R75 billion spend shortfall which will have to be reprioritised or reduced.
'The carry-over total from bracket creep raises R58 billion over the MTEF period. The focus point is how spending on frontline services and infrastructure can be balanced, in addition to an above-inflation increase of 5.5% in public sector wages of R23.4 billion, other spending of R37.7 billion and infrastructure spending of R46.7 billion.'