
HIQA to be called before the Public Accounts Committee over nursing home inspections
The decision to invite the quality authority comes after an RTÉ Investigates undercover exposé showing neglect of residents in two nursing homes, including Beneavin Manor in Glasnevin, which the watchdog had previously assessed.
At a meeting of PAC on Thursday, the committee members agreed that the watchdog would be invited before the committee.
'I think it's been eight years since [HIQA] came before the Public Accounts Committee, and I think it's about time to do again. I think it's a failure of the state, really, that our older people are being treated in this way when they should be given the dignity and respect they deserve as they age,' Labour TD Eoghan Kenny said.
'If a person across the country had an older person, a member of their family in a nursing home, I think they would have been really struck by the fact that inspectors from HIQA actually came to a number of those nursing homes and found no fault and I think that has to be questioned,' he added.
Fianna Fáil TD Paul McAuliffe, whose constituency area includes Beneavin Manor, said he had received a number of calls from the public who were concerned for the people and relatives in the nursing home after seeing the programme.
'I think we can say, very easily, it's a neglect in basic care and there has to be accountability. Individual accountability for staff, there has to be accountability within the company, the corporate entity, and I think we shouldn't allow any investigation we carry out to absolve those people of what happened,' Mr McAuliffe said.
Mr McAuliffe said while HIQA's examination of nursing homes must be questioned, the Nursing Home Support Scheme must also be scrutinised.
'I think the funding of the Nursing Home Support Scheme, which is the 'Fair Deal' scheme, I think has to also be examined, because my understanding is far in excess of €6 million was paid into the Beneavin campus, and that's a significant amount of money,' Mr McAuliffe said.
'And if you don't have basic material, if you don't have basic hygiene products to hand, I have to ask myself a question, is that a matter for HIQA, or is that a matter for the company, who are actually running the organisation?' he added.
A gap in the committee's schedule in July was the proposed date put forward by Social Democrats TD Aidan Farrelly, and the committee agreed to invite HIQA to attend.
The RTÉ Investigates programme showed a litany of care failings.
They included the inappropriate handling of some residents of the nursing home, lack of supply for basic supplies and a chronic level of staff shortages.
While Emeis Ireland, the company that runs Beneavin Manor, issued an apology to residents and their family members, HIQA is now reviewing all nursing homes run by the company.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Extra.ie
an hour ago
- Extra.ie
People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy detained in Egypt
People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy has been detained in Egypt ahead of a pro-Palestinian peace march, his party has claimed. The Irish politician was among a group of people who are travelling through Egypt to reach Rafah on the Global March to Gaza, when the incident took place. The party reports that Mr Murphy and the group had their passports confiscated by Egyptian authorities and are attempting to have them board a bus, which they have refused. People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy at Leinster House with his bag packed ahead of his trip to Cairo. Pic: X In a post on X, Mr Murphy wrote: 'We have had our passports confiscated and are being detained. 'It seems Egyptian authorities have decided to crack down on the #GreatMarchToGaza. 'We are refusing to board the deportation bus,' he added. These are the final seconds we have from phone has been taken, and his passport. We urgently need Minister for Foreign Affairs @SimonHarrisTD to intervene, demand he is freed, his passport & phone returned and the protesters are allowed to peacefully #MarchToGaza — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 13, 2025 Wicklow county councillor Mark Barry, of the Social Democrats, is also on the march, however he was not detained, but was turned around at a checkpoint in Ismailia. Mr Murphy's video on X saw protesters chanting 'Free, free Palestine' and 'From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.' A final tweet from the TD's account reads: 'These are the final seconds we have from Paul. His phone has been taken, and his passport. We urgently need Minister for Foreign Affairs @SimonHarrisTD to intervene, demand he is freed, his passport & phone returned and the protesters are allowed to peacefully #MarchToGaza.' The Irish politician was among a group of people who are travelling through Egypt to reach Rafah on the Global March to Gaza, when the incident took place. Pic: X People Before Profit's National Secretary Matt Collins called on the Government to demand Egyptian authorities release Mr Murphy along with the others who have been detained. He said: 'They are on a peaceful march to demand that humanitarian aid is delivered to starving people in Gaza. There is no reason for them to be detained. 'We also call on the public to contact the Egyptian embassy to demand that people on the Global March to Gaza are allowed to travel unhindered.' Hundreds of people came to Egypt this week for the Global March to Gaza, an international initiative involving people from 54 nations, who will march from Cairo to the Rafah Crossing at the border of Egypt and Palestine on Friday demanding aid be allowed in. Mr Murphy is one of 50 Irish people who is participating in the global march.


Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
HIQA to be called before the Public Accounts Committee over nursing home inspections
The decision to invite the quality authority comes after an RTÉ Investigates undercover exposé showing neglect of residents in two nursing homes, including Beneavin Manor in Glasnevin, which the watchdog had previously assessed. At a meeting of PAC on Thursday, the committee members agreed that the watchdog would be invited before the committee. 'I think it's been eight years since [HIQA] came before the Public Accounts Committee, and I think it's about time to do again. I think it's a failure of the state, really, that our older people are being treated in this way when they should be given the dignity and respect they deserve as they age,' Labour TD Eoghan Kenny said. 'If a person across the country had an older person, a member of their family in a nursing home, I think they would have been really struck by the fact that inspectors from HIQA actually came to a number of those nursing homes and found no fault and I think that has to be questioned,' he added. Fianna Fáil TD Paul McAuliffe, whose constituency area includes Beneavin Manor, said he had received a number of calls from the public who were concerned for the people and relatives in the nursing home after seeing the programme. 'I think we can say, very easily, it's a neglect in basic care and there has to be accountability. Individual accountability for staff, there has to be accountability within the company, the corporate entity, and I think we shouldn't allow any investigation we carry out to absolve those people of what happened,' Mr McAuliffe said. Mr McAuliffe said while HIQA's examination of nursing homes must be questioned, the Nursing Home Support Scheme must also be scrutinised. 'I think the funding of the Nursing Home Support Scheme, which is the 'Fair Deal' scheme, I think has to also be examined, because my understanding is far in excess of €6 million was paid into the Beneavin campus, and that's a significant amount of money,' Mr McAuliffe said. 'And if you don't have basic material, if you don't have basic hygiene products to hand, I have to ask myself a question, is that a matter for HIQA, or is that a matter for the company, who are actually running the organisation?' he added. A gap in the committee's schedule in July was the proposed date put forward by Social Democrats TD Aidan Farrelly, and the committee agreed to invite HIQA to attend. The RTÉ Investigates programme showed a litany of care failings. They included the inappropriate handling of some residents of the nursing home, lack of supply for basic supplies and a chronic level of staff shortages. While Emeis Ireland, the company that runs Beneavin Manor, issued an apology to residents and their family members, HIQA is now reviewing all nursing homes run by the company.


Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Dáil spending watchdog to examine civil service and ministerial pension errors
The Dáil's public spending watchdog is to examine errors in pension payments for civil servants and ministers. It has agreed to issue an invitation to the national office at the centre of the controversy to be quizzed by TDs. The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) wants representatives of the National Shared Services Office (NSSO) to face questions on the matter as early as next month. On Tuesday, it was revealed that a pool of 13,000 retired civil servants who were on work-sharing arrangements are to have their pension deductions checked for underpayments. Current Government ministers may also either owe or be owed money running into the thousands as a result of incorrect pension deductions, while former ministers are believed to be impacted as well. READ MORE There is also an issue in relation to the pensions of 30 retired senior civil servants. One of them could owe as much as €280,000 as a result of NSSO errors. Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers has announced an external audit of NSSO systems and processes and a broad external review of its capacity and structures. Social Democrats TD Aidan Farrelly, a member of the PAC, said there is 'really significant worry' over the issues that have arisen. At a committee meeting on Thursday, he proposed that representatives of the NSSO be brought in alongside the Department of Public Expenditure (DPER), which already is due to appear at the PAC on July 10th. Mr Farrelly told The Irish Times the committee has questions about how far back the issues go and which civil service grades are affected. PAC chairman, Sinn Féin TD John Brady, said the invitation is to be issued to the NSSO 'given the emergence of serious issues' there. Separately, the PAC also agreed to invite the Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) as well as the Department of Health and the Health Service Executive (HSE) to appear before them next month to be asked about oversight of private nursing homes. This follows on from an RTÉ Investigates programme last week that showed undercover footage at two private nursing homes . Distressing scenes included older people allegedly being manhandled as well as residents being ignored when they pled for help to go to the toilet. Mr Brady said the PAC 'has serious concerns' in the wake of the programme. The PAC agreed to invite Hiqa – which inspects nursing homes – to appear before it following requests for this to happen from Labour Party TD Eoghan Kenny and Fine Gael's James Geoghegan.