Could Trump's tariffs force NZ to rethink its trade diversity?
On the other hand, the likes of Australia and the UK have secured a 10% tariff.
So, how will the duties actually affect Kiwi businesses? Or is it really American consumers who'll pay the price?
University of Auckland Emeritus Professor of Law Jane Kelsey told The Front Page it's hard to know the impact.
'It's very hard to be specific about what the consequences would be, and when people put figures on that, you should be quite skeptical.
'Tariffs are kind of blunt instruments, so it will mean that exports from New Zealand imports into the US will have a higher cost for importers in the US and consumers in the US. That could affect how much New Zealand goods they buy,' she said.
She said New Zealand has a 'pretty basic export commodity model' and suggests that recent events should serve as a 'wake-up call to start thinking differently' about the diversification of our domestic market.
'There are real opportunities here, and we seem to have an aversion to taking those opportunities.
'It's not simply about diversifying to other markets, but it's also about rethinking our domestic economic model, which is currently based largely on the housing market and secondly on relatively low-value-added exports to a relatively small number of countries.
'But, we have a great difficulty generating that discussion here. There was a Productivity Commission report several years ago, before it was disbanded, that set out a process for diversification, which would thicken our domestic production, and that, unfortunately, seems to have fallen on deaf ears,' she said.
Listen to the full episode to hear more about:
Why the World Trade Organisation is 'in chaos';
The erosion of the rules-based trading system over successive US governments;
And why it might be a mistake to view Trump's tariffs as purely economic.
The Front Page is a daily news podcast from the New Zealand Herald, available to listen to every weekday from 5am. The podcast is presented by Chelsea Daniels, an Auckland-based journalist with a background in world news and crime/justice reporting who joined NZME in 2016.
You can follow the podcast at iHeartRadio, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
13 minutes ago
- Otago Daily Times
Prices shouldn't depend on postcode: consumer group
Fair prices for groceries should not depend on a shopper's postcode, a consumer advocacy group says The Commerce Commission's Grocery Report - released yesterday - highlighted the fact that areas like Auckland enjoyed more competition and cheaper prices. The Grocery Action Group said the commission's report had no good news for consumers. Chair Sue Chetwin said the lack of competition in smaller centres meant markups were much higher, even though overheads such as rent were much lower. "In rural areas and smaller towns where New Zealand's supermarket choices are narrow or non-existent, the report confirms what those living there already know - that consumers pay a premium for the lack of competition. "This kind of geographic price gap is unacceptable. Fair prices shouldn't depend on your postcode." Chetwin said on top of the 4.6% increase in grocery prices for the year to May, there were other findings in the report that were thoroughly alarming. "For instance, it notes we are paying higher than the OECD average for groceries even though we earn well below the average OECD wage. "Another disturbing fact is the prices that the supermarket chains pay their suppliers are subsidised by around $5 billion in rebates, discounts and promotional payments paid by suppliers." The report confirmed Kiwi consumers were paying way over the odds for their groceries, she said.
NZ Herald
43 minutes ago
- NZ Herald
Trump and his team are bending the criminal justice system to the US President's agenda
Bruce Fein, who served in the Justice Department under Presidents Richard Nixon, Gerald Ford, and Ronald Reagan, said Trump is trying to make the department a political arm of the White House, sending lawyers into court to make implausible arguments on issues such as deportation. 'It's totally, completely unprecedented,' Fein said. 'The whole effort is to turn the department from being a professional organisation into one where you are told that unless you are an echo chamber of what Trump wants you to say, you will get fired.' Trump is not the first president to be accused of trying to inappropriately sway the Justice Department. John F. Kennedy appointed his brother Robert as the attorney-general. Nixon fired an attorney-general and his deputy when they refused to dismiss Watergate special prosecutor Archibald Cox. However, Trump's actions have been more far-reaching. The White House argues that it was Biden's Administration that politicised the Justice Department, going after Trump for matters that include allegedly seeking to overturn the 2020 election and taking classified files to Mar-a-Lago after he left the presidency. Trump is seeking to depoliticise the department and hold the wrongdoers from previous administrations accountable, White House officials said. 'President Trump is restoring integrity to the Department of Justice after four years of weaponisation, hoaxes, and attempts to imprison him,' said White House spokesman Harrison Fields. 'The DOJ is upholding Lady Justice and working to execute President Trump's Make America Safe Again agenda, which is lowering crime, holding criminals accountable, and empowering our law enforcement community.' The White House's influence over the Justice Department has been highlighted in recent days as Trump seeks to extricate himself from the furore over the Administration's handling of the files on convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. The department transferred Epstein associate Ghislaine Maxwell to a minimum-security prison camp - a move that many experts say is unusual for someone with a 20-year prison sentence for sex crimes. Deputy Attorney-General Todd Blanche, the Justice Department's second-highest official, interviewed Maxwell last month, giving rare attention to a single case from such a prominent official. Blanche was formerly Trump's personal lawyer. Administration officials say it is not uncommon to shift prisoners from one facility to another, and that it is natural for a prominent official like Blanche to get involved in a high-profile case. The Justice Department has always been a unique part of the federal government, answering to the president but often with an unusual measure of independence. Equality under the law is enshrined in the Constitution, and the department was designed to be free to investigate everyone impartially, including personal friends and foes of the president. President Trump with Deputy Attorney-General Todd Blanche and Attorney-General Pam Bondi during a press briefing at the White House on June 27. Photo / Demetrius Freeman, The Washington Post Trump signalled from the outset his contrasting view that the department's mission is to carry out his orders. Still, many lawyers and legal scholars have been startled by the extent and reach of the control he has imposed. Trump named two of his personal lawyers - Blanche and Emil Bove - to top Justice Department positions, and Bove has since been nominated and confirmed as a federal judge. The President pardoned virtually all of those convicted for offences related to the attack on the US Capitol on January 6, 2021. His Administration then fired dozens of career prosecutors, many of them apparently because their job was to prosecute January 6 defendants. Before Trump, career prosecutors were virtually never fired without cause. 'In the name of absolute executive authority, they are trying to turn US Attorney's offices, and the federal enforcement system generally, into a straightforward instrument of presidential power to be used for political or personal goals,' said Daniel Richman, a former federal prosecutor who teaches at Columbia Law School. 'That is antithetical to the notion of a Justice Department that stands for something other than what the President wants.' The President has also sought to extend his reach to the justice systems of other countries. He ordered tariffs of 50% on goods from Brazil because he was unhappy that the country was prosecuting former President Jair Bolsonaro, who like Trump was charged with seeking to overturn an election. Congressional Republicans have sought to bolster Trump's pursuit of his perceived adversaries, although since Congress is an inherently political body, its actions are arguably less of a break from precedent. Representative James Comer (Republican-Kentucky), chairman of the House Oversight Committee, has launched an investigation into whether Biden staffers improperly used an autopen to approve presidential documents due to what the congressman described as Biden's 'cognitive decline'. Trump has made that assertion and ordered a federal investigation. White House officials say it was clear that Biden was cognitively unfit at the end of his term, so it is appropriate to investigate whether actions were improperly taken in his name. There have been no credible assertions that Biden was unable to make decisions or understand issues, though some Democrats and Republicans have said he was clearly ageing and had occasional memory lapses. Yesterday, Comer issued subpoenas for communications between Biden and members of his Administration about Epstein. He also subpoenaed prominent officials from past Republican and Democratic administrations, including Bill and Hillary Clinton, on issues related to Epstein. Comer issued the subpoenas after one of his panel's subcommittees, with some GOP support, voted to compel the Justice Department to release the files. Under House rules, Comer was then obligated to issue the subpoenas. Congressional Republicans agreed with the White House assertion that Trump has been the victim, not the perpetrator, of the justice system's politicisation. 'History will show that the Obama and Biden administrations' law enforcement and intelligence agencies were weaponised against President Trump,' Senator Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa), chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, said recently. 'The new Trump Administration has a tremendous responsibility to the American people to fix the damage done and do so with maximum speed and transparency.' Grassley made his comments in announcing the release of additional material on the FBI's investigation of ties between the 2016 Trump campaign and Russia. The Administration has fired or investigated a string of individuals who were involved in building cases against Trump after the end of his first term. The White House contends that those investigations were political, but Trump's critics say he committed obvious offences and is now punishing those who sought to hold him accountable. The independent Office of Special Counsel said recently it is investigating Jack Smith, the former Justice Department special counsel named in 2022 by Attorney-General Merrick Garland to investigate Trump for allegedly seeking to overturn the 2020 election and for keeping classified files after his presidency. Federal prosecutors have also launched criminal probes into former FBI director James Comey and former CIA director John Brennan, two frequent Trump targets who were involved in the investigation of the 2016 Trump campaign's ties to Russia. Maurene Comey, Comey's daughter and a federal prosecutor who worked on the Epstein case, has also been fired, without a clear reason. 'The Justice Department has been captured by partisan politics,' said Barbara McQuade, a former US Attorney for the Eastern District of Michigan. 'When I worked at the Justice Department through various administrations, Democratic and Republican, the people working as prosecutors were completely insulated from politics. We focused on facts and law, and nobody got in our way politically.' McQuade, who was appointed by President Barack Obama and now teaches law at the University of Michigan, said the decision to reopen a probe into the former president over a matter that has already been investigated was dismaying. 'It feels like exactly what President Trump promised - vengeance against his opponents,' McQuade said. 'Hardball politics is one thing, but using the justice system for political reasons is different.' Early in his term, Trump targeted major law firms that had done things like hiring lawyers the President considered hostile to him, threatening to end their federal contracts and bar them from government buildings. Several of his orders have been thrown out by the courts. Others have grown concerned about the Administration's regular attacks on judges. Trump has long made a habit of publicly criticising or mocking judges who have ruled against him, but in recent days the Justice Department raised the stakes by filing a misconduct complaint against US District Judge James Boasberg. Boasberg has overseen cases involving the Administration's efforts to deport alleged Venezuelan gang members. The complaint said he acted improperly by raising concerns at a recent judicial conference that the Administration would disregard court rulings. Legal experts said the ethics rule cited by the Justice Department was aimed at a judge's public comments - not private remarks at a closed-door judge's conference. Trump and his Administration have been accused of flouting numerous court orders in the more than 160 cases that have been filed against them. McQuade said the complaint against Boasberg appeared to be an effort to cow him. 'While he and other judges may say they will not be intimidated, it sends a message,' McQuade said. 'Even if the complaint goes nowhere, there will be those in the public who will send threats and harass him, just because he was attacked by the Trump Administration.' Some of the most scathing criticism came from US Circuit Judge Harvie Wilkinson, a conservative Reagan appointee who wrote an opinion in April on the Administration's efforts to deport Maryland resident Kilmar Abrego Garcia. Wilkinson warned that attacking the courts, as the Administration had been doing, could result in serious damage. 'The Judiciary will lose much from the constant intimations of its illegitimacy, to which by dint of custom and detachment we can only sparingly reply,' Wilkinson wrote. 'The Executive will lose much from a public perception of its lawlessness and all of its attendant contagions.' Fein, the former Republican Justice Department official, said Trump is trying to end the courts' ability to block presidential actions. 'He basically, in my judgment, is attempting to eliminate the judicial branch as a check on executive usurpation, over-reach and manipulation,' he said. 'The whole idea of equilibrium between the branches - it wasn't perfect before, but now it's at a new level.'
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Contact boss wants Kiwis to be more adaptive in push for renewable energy
Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Kiwis need to get over themselves when it comes to accepting renewable power projects in their area, an energy boss says. Contact Energy is ramping up its renewable energy supplies, saying investment in that area is critical to the economy. It's just lodged resource consent to expand a battery for power storage it's built on the outskirts of Auckland, which will power another 220,000 homes. Its chief executive Mike Fuge told Morning Report: "Batteries are a great technology, the price of lithium is coming down rapidly. We see batteries as a key part of the system - they take care of the morning and evening peaks." It has 100 megawatts being installed at Glenbrook, it had received consent for another 500mW at Glenbrook and intends to apply for another 500mW for Stratford. "So yes they will form very much part of the new ecosystem and they are part of that solution." However, he was not a supporter of the Onlow battery project proposed by the last Labour government in part because its cost was so high at $24 billion. In response to discussion of a proposed wind farm for Southland which has attracted opposition, Fuge said Kiwis needed to be more receptive to change and adapt to the renewable energy boom. "We're going to have to make trade-offs. Wind farms - they are visual. If you're Dutch you've learned to live with wind farms over a 500-year period and so it's just change, and so we just have to step into that change and make some very deliberate choices as a country that this is what we want to do." Contact's focus was on building new baseload renewable energy and geothermal. It had spent $1.5 billion on Tohara and Tohuka 3 which had brought on 5 percent. Te Mihi 2A which would replace Wairakei was underway as was the country's biggest solar farm, Kowhai Park, in Christchurch and there were plans for a wind farm. "This is our opportunity to move the market to reliable renewable energy which isn't going to just serve us, it's going to serve our tamariki and our mokopuna." The Te Mihi power station. Photo: Contact Energy Asked if all the plans and projects should have advanced faster, he responded: 'Jeez, how could I go faster?" Contact had been accepted into the government's fast track process and he hoped this would lead to faster resource consents. He said increased lines charges were around 6 or 7 percent to bills but the company had committed to the energy component of the increase would be no higher than the inflation rate. "We know that Kiwi homes are doing it tough at the moment and we know that electricity at the best of times is not something people love paying for ... we're doing our best to keep those prices moderated." Four of the 10 highest peaks have occurred this winter while wholesale prices have been 70 percent lower than last year. "Just the calmness is so important." Fuge said Contact was working with a range of industries such as dairy and meat processing to get them converted to electricity at reasonable prices. The country's energy supply was in a much better position than last year when a dry year coincided with outages and some industries were closing although the dramatic drop in gas supply had caught everyone off guard. Another six terrawatt hours of renewable energy had been added in the last six years which was the equivalent of two-thirds of Maui at its peak and around 15 percent of the country's supply. It was made up of wind, solar and baseload geothermal. As well there was the Huntly HFO so that a large coal stockpile (amassing up to 600,000 tonnes) could be used "in an extreme dry year". Long-term gas supply had also been secured. "So I've always argued that in terms of security of supply it's never a magic solution out there .... you've got to do all these things in quick order and that's what we've done that but underpinning this is the renewable energy supply." The removal of the government's oil and gas ban would be "helpful", he said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
