Angel investors in India will become rarer than tigers
Until recently, affluent individuals who placed small bets on long shots were targeted with a bizarre 'angel tax,' which viewed startups' fundraising as taxable income. Now that the government has finally scrapped the draconian levy, the Securities and Exchange Board of India has sown fresh seeds of disquiet for people who want to try early-stage allocations via collective investment plans: It wants them to get accredited.
Explore courses from Top Institutes in
Please select course:
Select a Course Category
Product Management
Finance
Others
Leadership
Degree
Digital Marketing
Project Management
Cybersecurity
Design Thinking
MBA
Management
Public Policy
PGDM
others
healthcare
Operations Management
CXO
MCA
Data Analytics
Technology
Healthcare
Artificial Intelligence
Data Science
Data Science
Skills you'll gain:
Product Strategy & Competitive Advantage Tactics
Product Development Processes & Market Orientations
Product Analytics & Data-Driven Decision Making
Agile Development, Design Thinking, & Product Leadership
Duration:
40 Weeks
IIM Kozhikode
Professional Certificate in Product Management
Starts on
Jun 26, 2024
Get Details
Skills you'll gain:
Creating Effective Product Roadmap
User Research & Translating it to Product Design
Key Metrics via Product Analytics
Hand-On Projects Using Cutting Edge Tools
Duration:
12 Weeks
Indian School of Business
ISB Product Management
Starts on
May 14, 2024
Get Details
Skills you'll gain:
Product Strategy & Roadmapping
User-Centric Product Design
Agile Product Development
Market Analysis & Product Launch
Duration:
24 Weeks
Indian School of Business
Professional Certificate in Product Management
Starts on
Jun 26, 2024
Get Details
Commitments into angel funds have swelled by 44% over the past year, and investments have surged by a third. These are reasonable growth rates, but the SEBI seems to believe that it can give a further boost to the 'ease of doing business.'
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Flat in Chattarpur South Delhi
A D Infra
Learn More
Undo
Although that's a welcome sentiment, some caution is warranted. As a risk-taking culture spreads beyond established business families, new sources of finance must emerge. If angel funds exit the scene because their investors don't want to seek accreditation, many promising entrepreneurs may have to drop out before their first meeting with venture capital or private equity.
The regulator means well. It wants to unshackle angel investors from India's Companies Act, which limits participation in private placement of securities to 200 subscribers. Any more will require public offerings. But this rule is unfair to regulated funds, where professional managers are required to have skin in the game. Plus, the risks are explained in a memorandum, and explicit investor consent is needed for each bet. There's clearly a need to distinguish between private placements and angel investing. But how does the regulator sidestep a law made by parliament?
Live Events
It has come up with a plan. From next year, individuals who invest in angel funds will be treated as Qualified Institutional Buyers. Since the law exempts QIBs from the 200-person rule, managers will no longer have to limit participation. This 'would allow angel funds to show opportunities to a wider pool of eligible investors, while staying in conformity with the Companies Act,' the SEBI said last month.
There's a catch, however. Since individuals aren't really institutions, the SEBI wants them to become
accredited investors
like in the US to qualify for the exemption. They will have a year to adjust to the new regime. Trouble is that while 13% of Americans meet the thresholds for buying private securities, so far only 650 Indians have successfully applied for accreditation, according to ET Wealth. That makes them rarer than the Bengal tiger, an endangered species.
Bloomberg
Do only 0.00005% of Indians earn more than 20 million rupees ($230,000) annually, or have a net worth in excess of $860,000? Not really. Counting just the top tax payers, at least 60,000 people should easily meet those minimum standards. But to get accredited, people have to provide proof to third parties. In a country where authorities send tax bills to roadside vegetable vendors by tracing QR-code-based payments, it's in nobody's interest to furnish documentation showing how rich they are. Not when the memory of the disastrous 'angel tax' is still fresh.
Even if the goal is to drive accreditation, why single out startup investors who are doing something worthwhile with their money and time? That already sets them apart from the nine out of 10 Indian retail traders betting on equity options and being taken to the cleaners by big whales like Jane Street. The public-market casino is where the regulator needs to police participation. Private markets don't need the same level of scrutiny beyond ensuring that the capital entering fledgling firms is not tainted.
At present, angel investors only self-certify a minimum net worth to their fund manager. The thresholds are low, as is the compliance burden. It is a lax process. Not everyone who is being invited to dabble in unlisted securities has the risk appetite for it. But as long as they are giving informed consent, they can be safely left alone. It's the insurance and banking regulators that have to put a stop to much more widespread deceptive selling in their industries. Why's the SEBI rushing to fix what isn't broken?
The $1.2 billion that angels have committed so far may not produce superstar enterprises. That's fine, as long as a growing pot of money helps nurture some gritty entrepreneurs. As I wrote last week, millennial and Gen Z billionaires among India's traditional family-owned firms are bored with business. They don't fancy their chances against either large tycoons, or smart startup founders. But the latter need financing.
The SEBI's other ideas are laudable. Relaxing the floor and cap on investments, doing away with concentration limits on exposure, and allowing funds to keep backing startups as they mature will improve returns. But forcing investors to get accredited by third parties? That's sure to backfire, unless the SEBI itself obtains their permission to query the tax returns database. A simple yes or no answer to the eligibility question, based on information they have already shared with tax authorities, could help increase the number of 650 accredited investors manifold. The rich in India are far from endangered, but they don't want to flaunt their stripes any more than they have to.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Lenskart's files Rs 7,500-8,000 cr IPO papers with Sebi
BENGALURU: Lenskart Solutions is gearing up for one of the largest consumer-tech listings of the year, with its initial public offering (IPO) expected to raise between Rs 7,500 crore and Rs 8,000 crore, people aware of the matter said. The final size will depend on valuations at the time of listing. The company filed its draft red herring prospectus (DRHP) with the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) on Tuesday. The IPO consists of a fresh issue of shares worth Rs 2,150 crore and an offer for sale (OFS) of up to 13.23 crore shares by existing investors and promoters. A pre-IPO placement of up to Rs 430 crore has also been proposed, which could reduce the fresh issue size. Proceeds from the fresh issue will be used for the expansion of company-owned (CoCo) stores in India (Rs 272.62 crore), lease-related payments (Rs 591.44 crore), technology and cloud infrastructure (Rs 213.38 crore), and brand marketing (Rs 320.06 crore). The remainder will be allocated for inorganic acquisitions and general corporate purposes. As of March 31, 2025, Lenskart operated 2,723 stores globally, including 2,067 in India and 656 overseas. Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Remember Him? Take A Deep Breath Before You See Him Now The Noodle Box Undo by Taboola by Taboola The company sold 27.2 million eyewear units in FY25, up from 21.2 million in FY24 and 15.9 million in FY23. Annual transacting customer accounts rose from 7.7 million in FY23 to 12.4 million in FY25, while its paid membership program, Lenskart Gold, reached 6.77 million members in India. Financially, the company swung from losses to profitability in FY24. In FY25, Lenskart reported revenue of Rs 6,653 crore, up from Rs 5,428 crore a year ago. Net profit rose more than fivefold during the same period, from Rs 59 crore to Rs 297 crore, driven by operating leverage and higher repeat purchases. Lenskart's apps have seen more than 100 million cumulative downloads, while its websites drew 105 million visitors in FY25. New customers, on average, purchased 3.62 pairs of glasses within two years, the filing revealed. The case of the missing degree Buried in Lenskart's DRHP is an oddly specific risk: one of its promoters, Sumeet Kapahi, who also heads global sourcing at the company, can't find his (Hons) degree or marksheets from the University of Delhi. He has emailed, written letters, and even applied through the university's online portal, but is still waiting for a response. Until then, Lenskart and its bankers have relied on the certificates he submitted for the IPO filing. The company admits there's no guarantee the university will ever send the documents, making this one of the more unusual disclosures in a multi‑thousand‑crore IPO draft. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . Discover stories of India's leading eco-innovators at Ecopreneur Honours 2025
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
UBS steps up contingency planning as it tries to tame Swiss rules, sources say
ZURICH/HONG KONG, - UBS is briefing senior staff that the need to examine moving its HQ from Switzerland has grown since the government proposed new capital rules, a source with knowledge of the matter said, while another pointed to London as a favourite alternative. The Swiss government proposed reform measures in June that envisage that UBS - as Switzerland's sole remaining global bank with a balance sheet about double the size of the economy - should capitalise its foreign subsidiaries by 100% rather than 60% currently, to cover potential losses abroad. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Orthopedic Knee Surgeon: Suffering From Pain After Age 50? Do This Every Morning Wellnee Undo That could mean the bank has to carry an extra $24 billion in capital. A review by UBS looking at contingency planning has concluded that London is one of the best options for an alternative location should the bank try and move, one of the sources said. Live Events Britain has similar rules on foreign subsidiaries but a third source said authorities outside Switzerland may show more flexibility. Two sources familiar with the bank's thinking said UBS was also warning internally that it could be vulnerable to a future takeover by a foreign rival if it were weakened by the rules. The sources spoke on condition of anonymity because the discussions are confidential. UBS, which is due to release second quarter earnings on Wednesday, has intensified lobbying with parliament since June 6 to push back against the proposed capital changes, two lawmakers said. Even insiders at the Zurich-based wealth manager say UBS - whose leadership argues it came to the rescue when it bought Credit Suisse in a government-engineered deal - does not intend to leave Switzerland. All agree that UBS's principal objective is to soften the regulations. Even so, UBS executives think the government's demands mean that if no compromise is reached, it may need to respond radically, one source familiar with the lender's thinking said, pointing to a possible relocation. UBS told Reuters it would engage in the consultation process for the new rules while evaluating appropriate measures "to address the negative effects that extreme regulations would have on its shareholders." Its Swissness was a "differentiating element", it said, adding that UBS - which has been running an advertising campaign themed "A bank like Switzerland" - wanted to be based in Switzerland "leveraging the mutually beneficial relationship." Switzerland's finance ministry declined to comment on what it said were internal UBS decisions. FINMA, the Swiss regulator, declined to comment. UBS earlier this year started warning about the possibility of shifting its headquarters, but the latest deliberations are reported here for the first time and highlight a political tug-of-war between UBS, led by CEO Sergio Ermotti, and the government about what is best for the bank and for Switzerland. Representatives for the UK Treasury, Bank of England and the Financial Conduct Authority declined to comment. Swiss Finance Minister Karin Keller-Sutter said in June that the new rules would make it more costly for the bank to grow abroad but that she hoped UBS would stay in Switzerland. DIFFICULT MOVE As for any large bank, relocation would be costly and difficult and industry insiders say Switzerland's global renown as a wealth management centre has been central to UBS' business model. Pressure is, however, growing on the bank. UBS's shares have underperformed rivals, gaining 7% in 2025 against the wider sector's 37% as investors fear the new rules will impede shareholder payouts and growth prospects. One UBS shareholder, speaking on condition of anonymity, told Reuters it would be difficult for the bank to attract investors if the capital rules talks dragged on for three or four years without the bank making progress in softening them. The ball "is in UBS's court" to find a solution, the investor said. Under the proposed capital requirements, UBS's Common Equity Tier 1 capital ratio, a key measure of bank capital, of 14.3% could reach 17%. That would put it above rivals like JPMorgan at 15.8%, Morgan Stanley at 15.7%, and Goldman Sachs at 15.3%, the government estimated in June. Outside experts say like-for-like comparisons are difficult. PERSUADING INVESTORS Switzerland's parliament is not due to receive a draft law on the rules until well into 2026. But UBS executives want to reassure investors by early 2026 they can soften the final legislation, two of the sources said. If it cannot placate investors coming into 2026, UBS may try to repatriate more than the $5 billion in capital it already plans to return to its parent bank, which could eventually fund payouts, analysts say. UBS's efforts have already yielded fruit. Last month a parliamentary committee backed a motion to make the government send all the new banking rules to parliament instead of issuing some directly. "We have to find the right balance between capital that minimises risks but also maintains UBS's competitiveness," said Beat Walti, the lawmaker who proposed the amendment.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
More options for SE Asia travel this Nov with three-class low cost airline ops to Bangkok
1 2 Kolkata: Kolkata will get a taste of a three-class configuration in a low-cost airline for the first time this Nov when Thai Vietjet Air connects the city to Bangkok. The announcement on Tuesday came days after full-service carrier Etihad launched its four-class configuration flight between Kolkata and Abu Dhabi. Announcing the launch of the four-times-a-week service from Nov 16, Vietjet Air vice-president (commercial & customer service) Pinyot Pibulsonggram said the airline would offer three configurations: Economy, Deluxe, and Skyboss. "We are a low-cost airline but have three-class service at different Economy, only free 7 kg carry-on baggage is offered. Additional baggage and all other services, including seat selection, will cost extra. The Deluxe service, which has a premium of 7-20% depending on the season of travel, offers priority check-in, free seat selection, 20 kg checked baggage, 7 kg carry-on baggage, and free flight change. The Skyboss service, which comes at a 7-20% premium over the Deluxe class, offers 10 kg hand baggage and 30 kg checked baggage, luxurious lounges, dedicated priority check-in, exclusive shuttle service to the aircraft, premium seat selection, and F&B on board," Pibulsonggram explained. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Libas Purple Days Sale Libas Undo You Can Also Check: Kolkata AQI | Weather in Kolkata | Bank Holidays in Kolkata | Public Holidays in Kolkata Vietjet Air will operate four days a week. While the incoming flight will land in Kolkata before midnight every Monday, Wednesday, Friday, and Sunday, the departing flight will be in the early hours on Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday, and Monday. Bookings for the sector commenced from July 17. At present, there are five airlines that operate between Kolkata and Bangkok: IndiGo Airlines, Thai Airways, Bhutan Airlines, Thai AirAsia, and Lion Air. IndiGo also has a daily flight between Kolkata and Phuket. Vietjet Air vice-president (corporate affairs) Sayada Benjakul said the airline would look at increasing the frequency on the Kolkata-Bangkok sector to a daily service once loads pick up and also evaluate opportunities to introduce flights on other sectors, including Phuket.
