Questions from hip audit to take many months to answer
It will bring a period of great worry for parents and young children waiting to see if they are part of the patients where it was deemed surgery was not indicated.
The issue first emerged after concerns were raised with Children's Health Ireland by a whistleblower about the thresholds being applied when making the decision to undertake surgery for children with Developmental Hip Dysplasia (DHD).
Around 1,800 children and young adults will be offered a review and some of these are already under way. However, the process is expected to take around six months and will use external experts.
One of the major findings from the audit is that the percentages of pelvic osteotomies not reaching the criteria at Temple Street and Cappagh are so high that it mandates further inquiry.
The audit author, UK paediatric orthopaedic surgeon Mr Simon Thomas, also found that while there is worldwide variability between surgeons, the variance identified here cannot be accounted for by measurement error or observer variability alone.
Asked about this on RTÉ Radio today, Dr Colm Henry, the Chief Clinical Officer, said the surgeons believed the interventions were necessary and had evolved based on research.
Bernard Gloster, the HSE Chief Executive, described the variance as being of very serious concern and said measures will be taken to ensure this kind of variation cannot recur.
Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill said she is moving now to strengthen governance and oversight structures at Children's Health Ireland and Cappagh.
She said this will be done with the appointment of two members of the HSE Board to the Board of CHI.
Lawyers representing some of the families said the report makes for difficult reading and that the percentage of affected children is very high.
They want speedy access to orthopaedic surgeon reviews and to establish what remedies are needed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
3 hours ago
- Sunday World
Parents of boy (9) who waited years for surgery vow to continue campaigning after his death
'OUR ROCK STAR' | 'We have to continue to campaign for other kids, because if we didn't we would be doing Harvey a disservice.' Harvey Morrison Sherratt. 'We are devastated, Harvey was our rock star, and we will continue to campaign for other children in similar situations as Harvey,' his father, Stephen Morrison, said. 'We have to continue to campaign for other kids, because if we didn't we would be doing Harvey a disservice.' 'After a while we will go strong again in our campaign. There are so many other children like Harvey and families like ours who need help and support,' Mr Morrison said. 'Harvey was our Little Rock star, he would burst into a room, he wanted to let everyone know he was in the room. 'Anyone who met him said he had these big wide beautiful eyes that would draw you into him, a lot of people said to us that they felt like Harvey was here before, that he was an old soul.' 'Harvey was battling for so long, we are absolutely devastated,' Stephen said. Harvey Morrison Sherratt. News in 90 Seconds, Friday August 1 Little Harvey's remains will repose at Massey Bros Funeral Home, Clondalkin, Dublin, from 3pm-5pm, Friday, August 1. Harvey will be remembered at a public cremation service, at Newland's Crematorium Chapel, Newlands Cross, Dublin, (D22 EOCO), at 1pm, Saturday. Harvey, from Clondalkin, was waiting three years for scoliosis surgery as the curvature on his spine continued to extend to a life-threatening 130 degrees. The spinal curve grew so serious that it was crushing Harvey's ribcage and lungs and putting severe pressure on his heart. His severe condition was highlighted in February 2024 when his parents, Gillian Sherratt and Mr Morrison, shared a heartbreaking video of their vulnerable son struggling to breathe due to the curve on his spine. The boy's story of perseverance in the face of his worsening condition and delays in his surgery, as well as growing spinal waiting lists for children's surgery nationally, were all later highlighted in the Dáil. Despite long demanding action over their son's surgery, Ms Sherratt discovered during a routine enquiry last August that, in fact, Harvey had been removed from Children's Health Ireland's active scoliosis surgical waiting list without their knowledge. Read more While not directly involved in their son's care, orthopaedic surgeon David Moore, emailed Ms Sherratt in response and told her: "I apologise for any misunderstanding that appears to have occurred in respect of Harvey's case." Mr Moore also explained in the email that Harvey was not a candidate for surgery abroad, but that he was "happy to facilitate' Harvey being reviewed by two Irish-based surgeons. Harvey eventually had his surgery last December, however as his curve had grown to such a significant size, it was impossible to completely correct it. Professor Damian McCormack, lead consultant surgeon in paediatric orthopaedic surgery at Temple Street Children's Hospital, performed the surgery reducing some of the pressure on the boy's lungs and heart. Ms Sherratt said at the time that she and Mr Morrison had 'huge respect' for Prof McCormack, and that they were 'so thankful to Professor Damian McCormack for being the only person that was actually willing to operate on Harvey'. In a statement on Tuesday, Ms Sherratt said: 'It is with the heaviest of hearts that myself and Stephen (Morrison) have to announce that our little rockstar Harvey passed away this morning with us by his side, arrangements to follow and it will be open to any and all of you who have supported him throughout his short life.' In a poignant joint tribute to their son, in his obituary notice, they wrote: 'Words cannot convey the heartbreak we feel in announcing that on 29th July after a very short illness, our little rockstar Harvey passed away in the arms of mum and dad.' 'He will be dearly missed by anyone who was lucky enough to know him…In his short life Harvey faced more challenges than most, and was the bravest, strongest and most courageous boy.' 'To know him was to love him, and he definitely left his mark on this world. 'If love could have saved you, you would have lived forever'.' Harvey's parents invited friends and the wider public 'to join us to celebrate Harvey's life, and dress in colour' at his cremation service, and they asked that mourners make a donation, if desired, to Child Vision In Memory of Harvey, in lieu of flowers. Harvey Morrison Sherratt is survived by his parents Gillian and Stephen, his sister Lyla and brother Remy, grandparents Ann, Gordon, Christina and Thomas, and his aunts, uncles and cousins.
Agriland
3 hours ago
- Agriland
HSE advises public not to touch sick or dead wild birds
The Health Service Executive (HSE) is advising the public not to touch or handle any sick or dead wild birds, because of the risks of avian influenza (bird flu). The warning follows confirmation from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) that bird flu had been discovered in a backyard flock in Co. Donegal. There are no trade implications for the Irish poultry industry in relation to this detection, due to the very small size of the flock. Bird flu is a type of influenza that primarily affects wild birds and poultry, and which can also occasionally infect some mammals and humans. Highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) is a type of avian influenza that can cause high levels of illness and deaths in birds. Of the many strains of HPAI viruses, the H5N1 virus is widely regarded as the most serious for both birds and humans. Since 2003, there have been nearly 1,000 human cases of H5N1, half of whom have died. According to the HSE it is "very unusual for people to catch bird flu, but it can happen". "Currently, it is hard to catch avian influenza from a bird or animal, and there is no evidence that it can be passed between people, but if the virus mutates (changes) this may happen in the future," the executive said. As the H5N1 HPAI virus is circulating in wild birds in Ireland, the HSE is reiterating the advice issued by DAFM to the public, including: Do not to touch sick or dead wild birds; Do not touch wild bird feathers or droppings; Avoid contact with surfaces contaminated with wild bird droppings; DAFM requests that all sick/dead wild birds are reported via the Avian Check app. While not all dead birds will be collected for testing, reporting is greatly appreciated and provides important information to support surveillance and risk assessment activities. The HSE added that if a person picks up or handles sick or dead wild birds that are found to be infected with avian influenza, they will be monitored for a period of 10 days. The person may be offered antiviral medication and vaccination if they are considered to be at risk.
Agriland
20 hours ago
- Agriland
Bird flu case detected in Donegal backyard flock
Avian influenza, otherwise known as 'bird flu' has been discovered in a backyard flock in Co. Donegal. Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Martin Heydon has today (Thursday, July 31) confirmed that there are no trade implications for the Irish poultry industry in relation to this detection, due to the very small size of the flock. Minister Heydon said: 'A bird from a very small backyard flock in Co. Donegal has tested positive for the H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza, following a post-mortem examination carried out in my department's Regional Veterinary Laboratory in Sligo. "Following this result, the other birds in the flock have now been euthanised. I would like to extend my sympathies to the flock owner.' Moving to reassure poultry farmers and the Irish poultry industry, Minister Heydon stated: 'As this flock was very small and was not involved in commercial poultry activity, under the legislation this incident is not an outbreak of avian influenza. "Therefore, this does not affect Ireland's disease-free status in respect of avian influenza and there are no trade implications or restriction zones," the minister added. He has emphasised the importance of biosecurity as the single most effective way to prevent the virus spreading from wild birds into poultry, or between poultry flocks. "This incident highlights the ongoing risk posed by avian influenza and is a reminder to all who keep poultry, whether commercial holdings or those who have some backyard hens, to stay aware and take precautions to prevent contact with or contamination from wild birds," Minister Heydon said. People are advised to report any suspicions of avian influenza to the local Regional Veterinary Office without delay. In recent weeks, there have been a number of cases of avian influenza detected in wild birds in Ireland, mainly sea birds in coastal areas. In 2025, a total of 41 cases of avian influenza in wild birds have been detected. The minister has reiterated the importance of taking precautions to protect public health: 'I have a clear message for the public, especially for those who may encounter dead birds on beaches this summer - do not touch or pick up dead wild birds, and keep pet dogs on a leash in areas where there are sick or dead wild birds.' The HSE-HPSC has advised that the risk to public health from the strain of avian influenza currently circulating (Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza subtype H5N1) is considered low for the general public, and low to medium for occupationally exposed people.
