JP McManus has 'highly emotional' meeting with Limerick Council over Rugby Expo 'gift' snub
BILLIONAIRE HORSE RACING mogul JP McManus fought back tears at a highly charged meeting with Limerick City and County Council after it snubbed his offer of the debt-free €30million International Rugby Experience (IRE) and a €1.2million donation.
McManus sought the private meeting with council executives and elected representatives to ask why the local authority turned down his offer.
Reliable sources said an apology was offered to McManus and his family at the closed meeting, but that the gift was no longer on the table 'as things stand' but that it could yet be salvaged, they said.
McManus has disputed the manner in which the gift was presented to councillors and told executives of his 'hurt' over the controversy.
In 2001, the council presented McManus with the prestigious title of Honorary Freeman of Limerick.
In 2011 the council included McManus's name in a medallion added to the mayoral chain, after he won the 2010 Aintree Grand National with his horse Don't Push It.
In 2016 councillors held a Civic Reception for him for his 'outstanding contribution' to local communities.
However, sources said the once close relationship has now soured over the IRE controversy.
'JP made a presentation to the chamber today and he got emotional as he spoke of his love of Limerick and he spoke about the fact that he was made a Freeman of the City by the council, and that it had been the proudest moment of his life,' said a source.
'It was highly emotional, he stopped talking and got choked up. A few councillors at the meeting were also wiping away tears.'
The €30m building was renovated and fitted out for the expo.
McManus told the closed meeting he was 'mystified' and 'disheartened' at the Council's declining of his debt-free gift.
'He was offering the people of Limerick city and county this gift – the IRE and €1.2million funding – through the council, and he found it mystifying and disheartening and how it was turned down.
'He said he was very disappointed that the heads of terms of agreement were not honoured. He saw it as a gentleman's agreement.
'So the offer is no longer on the table as things stand, but I would hope there can be a positive outcome,' another source said.
Advertisement
Sources claimed that councillors expressed 'embarrassment' at the controversy however a number of councillors who attended the meeting declined to comment to waiting reporters who were not allowed inside.
Limerick City and County Council also declined to comment, citing the meeting was held behind closed doors.
Afterwards, McManus would not be drawn on the outcome of the meeting, he simply waved at journalists after he was asked 'did you get a deal?'
The €30million sports attraction closed last December after just 12 months in operation, with the loss of 50 jobs.
Earlier this week councillors apologised to McManus for the debacle.
Outgoing District Cathaoirleach and Fianna Fáil Councillor Kieran O'Hanlon said prior to the meeting: 'I'm extremely disappointed and annoyed at the way the whole thing was handled.
'We have one of the biggest gifts coming to us from the greatest person Limerick ever had – JP McManus. Not only did we refuse it, but we insulted the McManus family in the process.
'I would like to apologise to JP McManus on behalf of the councillors for the way it was handled,' O'Hanlon also told the Limerick Post newspaper.
Speaking on his way into today's meeting former Limerick mayor, Councillor Michael Collins, said councillors were 'not happy with the way things have happened with the IRE, and today is about JP setting the record straight'.
'It has been very disappointing for the McManus family because they have been very good to Limerick down through the years,' Collins said.
Ahead of today's meeting, Limerick's first-ever directly elected mayor John Moran, who could not attend as he was abroad, said he had recently held meetings with McManus.
He said he hoped there would be 'further open and constructive dialogue…to find a sustainable solution to secure the future' of the IRE building.
The IRE said it delivered an estimated €7.8million boost to the local economy in its first year.
Last year the Council said it was 'disappointed' with the IRE's decision to close its doors, and that it had made 'every effort' to secure the deal.
The Council said it would have had to find 'substantial operational and capital funding' to continue running the Experience.
Prior to today's meeting, a counter offer from Mayor Moran to utilise €300,000 of his Mayoral Fund to help keep the facility open for the next three years was rejected by the IRE.
IRE chief executive Barry Hannon previously claimed that costings presented to councillors were 'over-inflated and were not included in the heads of agreement' which he said both parties had agreed in principal in August 2023.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
'He's not the minister any more': FF and FG row over Simon Harris remarks on student fees
A row has erupted between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael over a significant 'difference of opinion' on student fees ahead of the budget. Tensions between the two main Coalition parties are rising, with Fianna Fáil frustrated that Tánaiste Simon Harris is overly fixated on his former department. 'He is not the minister [for higher education] any more,' one senior Fianna Fáil source said. Mr Harris outlined a number of budget priorities, including measures to reduce the cost of education, at a private Fine Gael meeting this week. While the Tánaiste told party colleagues that no decision on third-level fees has been made yet, he outlined that if a further reduction is rolled out it would apply to the second installment of fees, which would be due early in the new year. Three months ago, James Lawless said universal cuts of €1,000 to the student contribution fee in the last two budgets 'may not be the best use of public monies'. Picture: Niall Carson/PA However, higher education minister James Lawless has already publicly claimed that universal fee cuts are 'not fair or proportionate' and would take hundreds of millions from universities and colleges. The Fianna Fáil minister previously said universal cuts to the student contribution fee 'may not be the best use of public monies'. One Fianna Fáil source suggested that Mr Harris may be 'setting a trap' for the current minister, as previous cuts to student fees came out of a cost-of-living pot which will not be available as part of this autumn's budget. The source said: There is no cost-of-living package this year, so he might even be setting him [Mr Lawless] up to fail. The student contribution was cut by €1,000 on a temporary basis as part of once-off measures to help with the cost of living over the last three budgets. This cost just under €100m each year. 'The mood music coming out of both parties is very different,' one source added when asked about the approach to third-level measures. Another senior source sarcastically remarked: It's not like the Tánaiste to be flying kites around. While a cut to fees would be politically popular, a senior Fianna Fáil source warned that its universal nature would mean even the wealthiest students would benefit. It is understood that Mr Lawless wants to focus on spending his department's allocated money on targeted supports, such as simplifying the grants system and widening it out to more families who are under the most financial strain. As an alternative to a universal cut to fees, the main priority for Mr Lawless will be reducing the cost of books, laptops, student accommodation, and travel for those in third-level education. However, countering this, a Fine Gael senior minister claimed that Mr Lawless should 'read the programme for government' which commits to continuing to reduce the student contribution fee over the lifetime of the Government to ease the financial burden on students and families.
The Journal
4 hours ago
- The Journal
JP McManus has 'highly emotional' meeting with Limerick Council over Rugby Expo 'gift' snub
BILLIONAIRE HORSE RACING mogul JP McManus fought back tears at a highly charged meeting with Limerick City and County Council after it snubbed his offer of the debt-free €30million International Rugby Experience (IRE) and a €1.2million donation. McManus sought the private meeting with council executives and elected representatives to ask why the local authority turned down his offer. Reliable sources said an apology was offered to McManus and his family at the closed meeting, but that the gift was no longer on the table 'as things stand' but that it could yet be salvaged, they said. McManus has disputed the manner in which the gift was presented to councillors and told executives of his 'hurt' over the controversy. In 2001, the council presented McManus with the prestigious title of Honorary Freeman of Limerick. In 2011 the council included McManus's name in a medallion added to the mayoral chain, after he won the 2010 Aintree Grand National with his horse Don't Push It. In 2016 councillors held a Civic Reception for him for his 'outstanding contribution' to local communities. However, sources said the once close relationship has now soured over the IRE controversy. 'JP made a presentation to the chamber today and he got emotional as he spoke of his love of Limerick and he spoke about the fact that he was made a Freeman of the City by the council, and that it had been the proudest moment of his life,' said a source. 'It was highly emotional, he stopped talking and got choked up. A few councillors at the meeting were also wiping away tears.' The €30m building was renovated and fitted out for the expo. McManus told the closed meeting he was 'mystified' and 'disheartened' at the Council's declining of his debt-free gift. 'He was offering the people of Limerick city and county this gift – the IRE and €1.2million funding – through the council, and he found it mystifying and disheartening and how it was turned down. 'He said he was very disappointed that the heads of terms of agreement were not honoured. He saw it as a gentleman's agreement. 'So the offer is no longer on the table as things stand, but I would hope there can be a positive outcome,' another source said. Advertisement Sources claimed that councillors expressed 'embarrassment' at the controversy however a number of councillors who attended the meeting declined to comment to waiting reporters who were not allowed inside. Limerick City and County Council also declined to comment, citing the meeting was held behind closed doors. Afterwards, McManus would not be drawn on the outcome of the meeting, he simply waved at journalists after he was asked 'did you get a deal?' The €30million sports attraction closed last December after just 12 months in operation, with the loss of 50 jobs. Earlier this week councillors apologised to McManus for the debacle. Outgoing District Cathaoirleach and Fianna Fáil Councillor Kieran O'Hanlon said prior to the meeting: 'I'm extremely disappointed and annoyed at the way the whole thing was handled. 'We have one of the biggest gifts coming to us from the greatest person Limerick ever had – JP McManus. Not only did we refuse it, but we insulted the McManus family in the process. 'I would like to apologise to JP McManus on behalf of the councillors for the way it was handled,' O'Hanlon also told the Limerick Post newspaper. Speaking on his way into today's meeting former Limerick mayor, Councillor Michael Collins, said councillors were 'not happy with the way things have happened with the IRE, and today is about JP setting the record straight'. 'It has been very disappointing for the McManus family because they have been very good to Limerick down through the years,' Collins said. Ahead of today's meeting, Limerick's first-ever directly elected mayor John Moran, who could not attend as he was abroad, said he had recently held meetings with McManus. He said he hoped there would be 'further open and constructive dialogue…to find a sustainable solution to secure the future' of the IRE building. The IRE said it delivered an estimated €7.8million boost to the local economy in its first year. Last year the Council said it was 'disappointed' with the IRE's decision to close its doors, and that it had made 'every effort' to secure the deal. The Council said it would have had to find 'substantial operational and capital funding' to continue running the Experience. Prior to today's meeting, a counter offer from Mayor Moran to utilise €300,000 of his Mayoral Fund to help keep the facility open for the next three years was rejected by the IRE. IRE chief executive Barry Hannon previously claimed that costings presented to councillors were 'over-inflated and were not included in the heads of agreement' which he said both parties had agreed in principal in August 2023. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Examiner
10 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
JP McManus meets councillors to 'clear the record' on Limerick rugby experience
Limerick councillors say they were 'surprised' to hear the chronology of events leading up to the closure of the International Rugby Experience (IRE), after JP McManus 'cleared the record' during a private meeting. Mr McManus met with the councillors for a 'workshop' to present the International Rugby Experience's 'side of things'. It is understood he initially read from a prepared speech and told councillors he had no intention to proceed 'any further discussions' with the council regarding his gift. He later on indicated he would reconsider, after being asked to by some councillors. According to one councillor, who wished to remain anonymous, 'nothing was confirmed either way". 'We could be told a definitive no in the weeks to come,' they said. The attraction, which welcomed 60,000 visitors in the 12 months it was open, closed its doors in December 2024, leading to the loss of 50 jobs. Mr McManus had offered the €30m building and additional funding of €1.2m to Limerick City and County Council — a gesture which had been refused by the council following worries about the costs of operating the attraction. It is understood that the aim is for the building to be used as a civic space in the future. According to some councillors, the situation was handled very poorly and there was 'misinformation' on what was happening. Elisa O'Donovan said she and her fellow councillors were not made aware or informed of the gift proposed by Mr McManus until a decision was already made by the council to decline the offer. After the meeting with Mr McManus, she said: 'It was a very productive workshop. We got a lot of clarification and answers on questions regarding the gifting of the IRE as a civic space for the people of Limerick. 'I believe that there is a commitment from Limerick council now for a positive way forward to use this gift as a central civic space for Limerick City. Ms O'Donovan stood by comments she made earlier, saying that there was 'a real level of misinformation' in relation to previous discourse. According to several councillors, the costs and figures which would be needed to run the building were 'not discussed'. A councillor who wished to remain anonymous said there was 'little to no anger' in the room during the meeting. 'It was a very regretful tone on all sides. The communication between the parties in springtime last year changed momentum and the energy dissipated. In my own view, it was handled badly. Councillors were surprised to hear the chronology of events,' they said. The councillor added there were 'no outcomes' to the meeting and it was 'all very much about the chain of events'. They just wanted to clear the record and present their side of things. It is understood Mr McManus and members of his family were there for about three hours, with councillors holding a follow-up meeting for an extra hour to discuss the workshop. Earlier this week, Limerick Metropolitan District cathaoirleach Kieran O'Hanlon apologised to Mr McManus and his wife on behalf of councillors. 'I'm extremely disappointed and annoyed at the way the whole thing was handled,' he said. 'We have one of the biggest gifts coming to us from one of the greatest people Limerick ever had — Mr McManus. Not only did we refuse it, but we insulted the McManus family in the process.' Due to prior commitments, Limerick mayor John Moran could not attend the meeting but said he recently had a meeting with Mr McManus and members of his family. Mr Moran had previously made it clear he wished a solution could be found to the closure of the museum, and had previously said he was willing to offer €300,000 from his mayoral fund — an offer which was rejected by the International Rugby Experience.
