Deceptive claims: CCP imposes Rs40m fine on Al-Ghazi Tractors
In a detailed final order passed by a two-member bench comprising Dr Kabir Ahmed Sidhu (Chairman) and Salman Amin (Member), the Commission found that Al-Ghazi Tractors Limited (AGTL) advertisement published on January 24, 2022, falsely claimed that its new Holland tractor models offered 'up to 30 percent extra diesel savings compared to any competitor's tractors.'
The misleading claim was widely circulated in media and referenced a report by the Agriculture Mechanization Research Institute (AMRI), Multan, giving it an air of official credibility. However, the Commission's investigation revealed that AMRI never endorsed the claim, nor did its report support the fuel-saving comparison being advertised. In rural Pakistan—where over 60% of the population relies on agriculture—tractors are long-term investments, and such exaggerated claims can have serious financial consequences for small farmers.
These communities are particularly vulnerable to misleading advertisements due to limited access to technical verification or alternative sources of information. A 30 percent fuel-saving claim could mean thousands of rupees of projected savings to a farmer—yet no such advantage existed.
After receiving complaints from stakeholders and conducting a thorough investigation, the CCP determined that the AMRI report only compared AGTL tractors to those of one other manufacturer (Millat Tractors) in limited settings.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
11 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan govt alarmed by over Rs6trn losses in state-owned enterprises
ISLAMABAD: Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb has termed as alarming the government figures suggesting that State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) have incurred losses of nearly six trillion rupees, saying, eight SOEs would be privatised this year. 'This is alarming indeed,' he said, speaking on a calling attention notice in Senate on Tuesday regarding the 'alarming figures revealed in Biannual Performance Report issued by the Finance Division that state-owned enterprises have incurred losses of Rs 5.89 trillion during first half of financial year 2024-2025.' Samina Mumtaz Zehri from Balochistan Awami Party (BAP) was the original mover of the calling attention notice, but was absent from the House when the calling attention notice was taken up on the maiden day of the Senate's 353rd session. Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Parliamentary Leader in Senate Sherry Rehman then took up the issue regarding the reported losses incurred by the SOEs. 24 SOEs to be privatised in 3 phases: minister Last year, the revenue was recorded at Rs 12 trillion. 'But 50 percent has been lost as result of losses incurred by the SOEs,' Aurangzeb said. 'This flow is very high—the government is taking different steps to reduce expenditure—like we introduced pension reforms—to cut down on the expenses,' the minister said. He said 24 SOEs have been finalised for privatisation. 'They were referred to the Cabinet Committee on Privatisation, and then finally referred to the Privatisation Commission. Eight SOEs would be privatised this year—the rest would be privatised thereafter,' he said. The Sindh government, Aurangzeb said, is following 'very good' formula of public-private partnership. The chairpersons of the board of directors of the SOEs are being appointed from private sector to involve private sector to improve the affairs at the SOEs, said the minister. 'Three DISCOs (distribution companies) have been put to the process of privatisation—it's yielding good results,' he said. The finance minister said that the cabinet committees on SOEs and rightsizing, under his leadership, are working on the privatisation in 43 ministries and 400 government departments. Aurangzeb said he regularly appears before the finance committees of the Senate and the National Assembly for 'accountability.' Earlier, the Senate unanimously passed the Anti-Dumping Duties (Amendment) Bill, 2025. The bill gives retrospective effect to cover the period from financial year 2020-2021 and onwards to exempt products imported for foreign grant in-aid projects from payment of anti-dumping duty through Anti-Dumping Duties (Amendment), Act 2022. Meanwhile, the opposition senators strongly protested against the convictions of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) lawmakers by anti-terrorism courts (ATCs), and walked out of the House. Presently, the Senate is without an opposition leader following the conviction of Shibli Faraz by an ATC in the context of 9 May riots, and his subsequent disqualification from the Senate by the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP). The Senate was adjourned till Friday. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
13 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Stocks stay strong
KARACHI: The Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) navigated a turbulent session on Tuesday, closing at a record high despite heavy profit-taking by investors keen to lock in recent gains. The benchmark KSE-100 Index ended just 75.48 points, or 0.05 percent up at 147,005.32 points, as compared to the previous session closing of 146,929.98 points. The index touched an intraday peak of 147,977 points and a low of 146,895 points before ending at record close. BRIndex100 closed at 15,035.17, down 37.65 points or 0.25 percent, with a total volume of 543.26 million shares. BRIndex30 fell 103.75 points, or 0.24 percent, to 42,521.63 points, with 259.14 million shares traded. According to Topline Securities, gains in BAFL, HBL, and SYS added a combined 295 points to the benchmark, partly offsetting losses from FFC, MARI, OGDC, PSO, and BAHL, which together eroded 527 points — underscoring sectoral divergence and investor caution. Market breadth remained negative, with 208 scrips advancing against 242 decliners and 32 remain unchanged in the ready market. Turnover in the ready market rose to 691.65 million shares from 611.20 million in the previous session, while traded value inched up to Rs 44.58 billion from Rs 44.00 billion of yesterday. Yousuf Weaving led the volumes with 46.27 million shares, closing at Rs 6.09. Kohinoor Spinning followed with 39.94 million shares at Rs 6.47, while Invest Bank finished the day at Rs 9.68 on 34.39 million shares. Among the top gainers, PIA Holding Company surged Rs 156.85 to Rs 29,000, and Khyber Textile Mills gained Rs 69.71 to Rs 1,477. On the flip side, Nestle Pakistan fell Rs 88.57 to Rs 8,762.79, while Unilever Pakistan Foods dropped Rs 79.40 to Rs 32,020.61. Sectoral performance was mixed — strength in banking supported the index, while oil, gas, and fertilizer stocks weighed on sentiment. The Oil and Gas sector remained under pressure amid selling in OGDC, PSO, and PPL futures. Market capitalization edged down to Rs 17.524 trillion from Rs 17.529 trillion a day earlier, reflecting the limited net effect of the day's choppy trade. The BR Automobile Assembler Index closed at 23,639.61 points, up 154.78 points or 0.66 percent, with a turnover of 3.12 million shares. The BR Cement Index rose 124.58 points, or 1.1 percent, to 11,483.55 points, on 41.59 million shares. The BR Commercial Banks Index gained 269.64 points, or 0.62 percent, to close at 43,604.32 points, with 92.97 million shares traded. The BR Power Generation and Distribution Index slipped 96.50 points, or 0.42 percent, to 22,765.22 points, on 35.82 million shares. The BR Oil and Gas Index dropped 206.53 points, or 1.54 percent, to 13,197.93, with 56.19 million shares changing hands. The BR Technology & Communication Index added 32.17 points, or 0.98 percent, to 3,329.63, on 42.18 million shares. Ahsan Mehanti of Arif Habib Corporation said the market's strength was underpinned by a robust earnings outlook and rupee stability, while speculation over Pakistan–US trade and investment deals, government moves to secure additional export tariff incentives, and rising business confidence acted as catalysts for the record close. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
13 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Cotton market remains firm
LAHORE: The local cotton market on Monday remained firm and the trading volume remained satisfactory. Cotton Analyst Naseem Usman told Business Recorder that the rate of new cotton in Sindh is in between Rs 16,300 to Rs 16,500 per maund and the rate of cotton in Punjab is in between Rs 16,300 to Rs 16,500 per maund. The rate of Phutti in Punjab is in between Rs 6,800 to Rs 7,600 per 40 kg and the rate of Phutti in Sindh is in between Rs 7,000 to Rs 7,600 per 40 kg. The rate of cotton in Balochistan is in between Rs 16,300 to Rs 16,400 per maund. The rate of Phutti in Balochistan is in between Rs 6,800 to Rs 7,400 per maund. 200 bales of Tando Adam, 800 bales of Khadro, 800 bales of Hala, 600 bales of Shah Pur Chakar, 600 bales of Mirpurkhas were sold in between Rs 16,200 to Rs 16,400 per maund, 1200 bales of Sanghar, 1600 bales of Shahdadpur were sold in between Rs 16,300 to Rs 16,400 per maund, 200 bales of Rasoolabad, 200 bales of Halani were sold at Rs 16,450 per maund, 200 bales of Jam Sahib were sold at Rs 16,300 per maund, 600 bales of Nuabad, 600 bales of Jhole, 400 bales of Ahmed Pur East, 600 bales of Layyah, 400 bales of Haroonabad, 600 bales of Chichawatni were sold in between Rs 16,200 to Rs 16,300 per maund, 1000 bales of Nawabshah, 1000 bales of Kotri, 400 bales of Dour, 800 bales of Hyderabad were sold in between Rs 16,000 to Rs 16,300 per maund, 400 bales of Dera Ghazi Khan were sold at Rs 16,000 per maund (Balochi) per maund, 400 bales of Rajanpur were sold at Rs 16,450 per maund, 600 bales of Ghazi Ghat were sold at Rs 16,400 per maund, 400 bales of Hasilpur were sold in between Rs 16,250 to Rs 16,300 per maund, 200 bales of Sahiwal were sold at Rs 16,200 per maund, 600 bales of Vehari were sold at Rs 16,100 to Rs 16,125 per maund, 600 bales of Khanewal were sold in between Rs 16,200 to Rs 16,400 per maund, 200 bales of Kasowal were sold at Rs 16,200 per maund, 600 bales of Faqeer Wali were sold at Rs 16,000 per maund, 400 bales of Pattoki and 400 bales of Gojra were sold at Rs 15,800 per maund. The Spot Rate remained unchanged at Rs 16,300 per maund. Polyester Fiber was available at Rs 330 per kg. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
