MTA's claims of 40% boost in LIRR service derailed by new audit— with nearly half of new trains never leaving Brooklyn
The MTA's claims that it boosted Long Island Rail Road service by more than 40% with the launch of the Grand Central Madison station is being derailed by a new state audit.
State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli's report examined LIRR post-pandemic ridership — between January 2021 and November 2023 — and looked into the period both before and after the $11 billion Grand Central Madison station, the LIRR's newest Manhattan stop, which opened in early 2023.
While the MTA touted a 41% spike in the number of LIRR trains operating each day — from 665 to 936 daily — the late May audit found the actual increase was more like 23%, noting the stats were padded by nearly half of those additional service trains making short shuttle runs between Jamaica and Brooklyn.
Advertisement
5 While the MTA touted a 41% spike in the number of LIRR trains operating each day, the late May audit found the actual increase was more like 23%.
Christopher Sadowski
The additional service runs were meant to help slash commute times and increase the flow of riders from across Long Island into the Big Apple. Instead, the audit found riders experienced the opposite — excessive delays and longer commutes.
'Some passengers may have been required to change their travel times, increasing wait times and adding more steps to their trips where direct service was eliminated,' the audit found, also citing the LIRR's poor job of applying customer feedback to their service changes.
Advertisement
5 The additional service runs were meant to help slash commute times and increase the flow of riders from across Long Island into the Big Apple.
Gregory P. Mango
The MTA disputed the findings in a statement to The Post, claiming it counted additional trains in service between Penn Station and Jamaica but 'discounted 118 additional trains to East New York, Nostrand Avenue and Atlantic Terminal, important stations in the City Terminal Zone.'
'Ridership has grown 10 percent over the last year, and riders … are enjoying more trains and reverse-commuting options that didn't exist before,' the statement added.
'And at a time when the number of available East River tunnels is being reduced for repairs, Grand Central Madison delivers operational flexibility to ensure Long Islanders can get where they need to go.'
Advertisement
5 Instead, the audit found riders experienced the opposite — excessive delays and longer commutes.
Anthony Behar/Sipa USA
LIRR president Robert Free also pushed back on DiNapoli's findings and pointed to a recent spike in ridership and a 'post-pandemic record' in customer satisfaction as signs that many commuters were on board with the plan rolled out in conjunction with the opening of Grand Central Madison, according to Newsday.
The additional Brooklyn trains were defended by MTA policy chief John McCarthy, who said they still serve an important role for riders — since Brooklyn is located on Long Island — and noted it's not uncommon for some LIRR trains to start or end at Jamaica.
5 LIRR president Robert Free also pushed back on DiNapoli's findings and pointed to a recent spike in ridership.
Seth Gottfried
Advertisement
But Peter Haynes, a former LIRR systems project specialist, was 'glad to see' the agency get called out, he told the outlet.
'The railroad has a very long history of counting trains and equipment, rather than people,' said Haynes, who is also the founder of the advocacy group, The LIRR Commuters Campaign.
'So I'm not … surprised that someone has finally noticed that passenger experience is really not being addressed at all.'
5 Peter Haynes, a former LIRR systems project specialist, was 'glad to see' the agency get called out, he told the outlet.
Brandon Cruz / NY Post
Jeremy Burd, a lighting-designer who frequently travels from Long Island to Penn Station for work, told The Post that he opts for the simpler route, which often has him avoiding Grand Central Madison.
'It's usually just easier to go to Penn,' Burd said. 'I just wish they would lower the fare, but that will never happen.'
DiNapoli's office issued several recommendations aimed at improving transparency and rider engagement, including developing a formal system to manage commuter feedback.
'It's my hope that this audit provides some constructive insights into ways to improve how LIRR riders' concerns are handled and their riding experience enhanced,' DiNapoli said in a statement.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
MTA's claims of 40% boost in LIRR service derailed by new audit— with nearly half of new trains never leaving Brooklyn
The MTA's claims that it boosted Long Island Rail Road service by more than 40% with the launch of the Grand Central Madison station is being derailed by a new state audit. State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli's report examined LIRR post-pandemic ridership — between January 2021 and November 2023 — and looked into the period both before and after the $11 billion Grand Central Madison station, the LIRR's newest Manhattan stop, which opened in early 2023. While the MTA touted a 41% spike in the number of LIRR trains operating each day — from 665 to 936 daily — the late May audit found the actual increase was more like 23%, noting the stats were padded by nearly half of those additional service trains making short shuttle runs between Jamaica and Brooklyn. Advertisement 5 While the MTA touted a 41% spike in the number of LIRR trains operating each day, the late May audit found the actual increase was more like 23%. Christopher Sadowski The additional service runs were meant to help slash commute times and increase the flow of riders from across Long Island into the Big Apple. Instead, the audit found riders experienced the opposite — excessive delays and longer commutes. 'Some passengers may have been required to change their travel times, increasing wait times and adding more steps to their trips where direct service was eliminated,' the audit found, also citing the LIRR's poor job of applying customer feedback to their service changes. Advertisement 5 The additional service runs were meant to help slash commute times and increase the flow of riders from across Long Island into the Big Apple. Gregory P. Mango The MTA disputed the findings in a statement to The Post, claiming it counted additional trains in service between Penn Station and Jamaica but 'discounted 118 additional trains to East New York, Nostrand Avenue and Atlantic Terminal, important stations in the City Terminal Zone.' 'Ridership has grown 10 percent over the last year, and riders … are enjoying more trains and reverse-commuting options that didn't exist before,' the statement added. 'And at a time when the number of available East River tunnels is being reduced for repairs, Grand Central Madison delivers operational flexibility to ensure Long Islanders can get where they need to go.' Advertisement 5 Instead, the audit found riders experienced the opposite — excessive delays and longer commutes. Anthony Behar/Sipa USA LIRR president Robert Free also pushed back on DiNapoli's findings and pointed to a recent spike in ridership and a 'post-pandemic record' in customer satisfaction as signs that many commuters were on board with the plan rolled out in conjunction with the opening of Grand Central Madison, according to Newsday. The additional Brooklyn trains were defended by MTA policy chief John McCarthy, who said they still serve an important role for riders — since Brooklyn is located on Long Island — and noted it's not uncommon for some LIRR trains to start or end at Jamaica. 5 LIRR president Robert Free also pushed back on DiNapoli's findings and pointed to a recent spike in ridership. Seth Gottfried Advertisement But Peter Haynes, a former LIRR systems project specialist, was 'glad to see' the agency get called out, he told the outlet. 'The railroad has a very long history of counting trains and equipment, rather than people,' said Haynes, who is also the founder of the advocacy group, The LIRR Commuters Campaign. 'So I'm not … surprised that someone has finally noticed that passenger experience is really not being addressed at all.' 5 Peter Haynes, a former LIRR systems project specialist, was 'glad to see' the agency get called out, he told the outlet. Brandon Cruz / NY Post Jeremy Burd, a lighting-designer who frequently travels from Long Island to Penn Station for work, told The Post that he opts for the simpler route, which often has him avoiding Grand Central Madison. 'It's usually just easier to go to Penn,' Burd said. 'I just wish they would lower the fare, but that will never happen.' DiNapoli's office issued several recommendations aimed at improving transparency and rider engagement, including developing a formal system to manage commuter feedback. 'It's my hope that this audit provides some constructive insights into ways to improve how LIRR riders' concerns are handled and their riding experience enhanced,' DiNapoli said in a statement.
New York Post
6 hours ago
- New York Post
NYC biz leaders left shaking over prospect of Zohran Mamdani mayoral win: ‘It would be disastrous'
They want none of his business. Big Apple business leaders are shaking in their boots that socialist Zohran Mamdani will pull off an upset win in Tuesday's Democratic mayoral primary and coast into Gracie Mansion, The Post has learned. Frightened movers and shakers said that a Mayor Mamdani would be 'disastrous' for New York City — with some loath to speak out publicly for fear of ticking off progressives and galvanizing the Queens assemblyman's lefty, anti-business base. 'It would be disastrous for the city,' said startup entrepreneur John Borthwick — who recently met the surging candidate during a Partnership For New York City meeting. Mamdani, who spent just three years in the workforce between graduating college in 2014 and being elected to the state Assembly in 2020, struck Borthwick as out of his depth. 'He's a very nice charming human who I think who has absolutely no idea what it would take to run a city government,' Borthwick, the CEO of Betaworks, said. 3 Zohran Mamdani's surge in the Democratic mayoral primary has some business leaders running scared. LP Media 'Given the challenges the city faces with the state budget and federal government, they will eat him for breakfast.' The business community's fear has been rising along with Mamdani's standing in the polls — culminating with an Emerson College Polling/Pix 11/The Hill survey Monday shockingly finding him edging out former Gov. Andrew Cuomo in eight rounds of ranked-choice voting. Mamdani's surge in the polls has been driven by his unabashedly socialist, freebie-heavy platform promising free buses, city-run grocery stores and higher taxes on the rich. But many business leaders such as billionaire John Catsimatidis — who threatened to close his Manhattan-based grocery chain Gristedes if Mamdani wins — have claimed that the Democratic socialist's proposals will lead to an exodus from the city. 3 Billionaire John Catsimatidis threatened to move his Gristedes grocery chain out of New York City if Mamdani wins. Stefan Jeremiah for New York Post Florida's Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis gleefully weighed in on the recent poll showing a Mamdani win by boasting of boon for the Sunshine State — at least for the well-to-do. 'Just when you thought Palm Beach real estate couldn't go any higher…' he wrote on X. Frank Garcia, national chairman of the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce, who lives in New York, bluntly said business leaders were very concerned about Mamdani getting elected. 'He's like Bill de Blasio. He's anti-business,' Garcia said. One New York business industry leader, who spoke with The Post under the condition of anonymity out of concern that Mamdani may actually win, said the outspoken progressive would bring 'uncertainty.' 'Uncertainty is never good for businesses, it's never good for the market,' he said, even going so far as comparing Mamdani to President Trump and his erratic tariff policy. 'It's almost like Trump in reverse,' he said. One of Mamdani's people-pleasing planks is a promise to raise New York City's minimum wage to $30 an hour by 2030. 'In the world's richest city, making the minimum wage shouldn't mean living in poverty,' his campaign's platform states. Tom Grech, president of the Queens Chamber of Commerce, said his borough's merchants — of whom 90% have 10 or fewer employees — are worried about Mamdani's promises. 'A $30 minimum wage is unsustainable,' he said. 'The average merchant can't afford a minimum wage increase now. That would kill the bottom line. They'd have to cut employees.' But other business leaders have publicly kept their concerns to themselves. 3 Kathryn Wylde, CEO for the Partnership For New York City, said business leaders have stayed silent in the Democratic primary because their 'kind words' are not helpful. Bloomberg via Getty Images Kathryn Wylde, CEO for the powerful Partnership For New York City nonprofit business group, said their silence isn't necessarily unusual, noting they don't typically comment on political races. 'Plus, they are not plugged into social media, so few were forewarned about the possible far-left direction of the mayoral race,' she said. 'Many have some history with Cuomo — as some pundit put it 'the devil they know' — who was looking for their dollars but not for public endorsement in a Democratic primary, where kind words from the business community are not helpful.'
New York Post
7 hours ago
- New York Post
Billionaire Dem donors slam ‘ineffectual' DNC, say they won't fork over more cash for now
Billionaire Dem donors including Barry Diller and Michael Bloomberg are refusing to fork over more cash for now to the party's main fundraising committee because there's now a 'broad consensus' it's 'ineffectual,'' sources said. The Democratic National Committee has been plagued by infighting and defections as the party remains virtually leaderless since President Trump's victory over Vice President Kamala Harris in the 2024 election — prompting some once-reliable and deep-pocketed donors to yank funding for the time being. 'For a variety of reasons, I have no intention of donating to the DNC,' media mogul Diller told The Post last week. 6 Billionaire Democratic donors aren't forking over any more cash to the party's main fundraising committee because there is now 'broad consensus' that it's been 'ineffectual,' sources said. Tamara Beckwith/NY Post Diller, chairman of such holdings as the Internet and media behemoth IAC, seethed in his just-released memoir 'Who Knew' that former President Joe Biden and his administration used a bait-and-switch tactic when it came to his promise of restoring the 'soul of the nation.' 'I think the biggest crime of the Biden administration is that it came in with a pledge to restore a more civilized, selfless, and uplifting manner of governance and instead let us all down with its progressive elitism, personal ego, and cynical behavior. Such a shame,' Diller wrote. Sources close to Bloomberg, a news tech titan and New York City's former mayor, said he also is wary of giving to the DNC again, while others have expressed skepticism that hedge-fund manager Marc Lasry is in a hurry to make up the shell out funding. During the 2023-24 election cycle, Bloomberg gave $413,000 to the DNC; Diller donated $330,400; and Lasry contributed $133,400. Lasry hinted that ultimately he will give again to the DNC — but didn't specify when. A rep for Bloomberg declined to comment. 6 'For a variety of reasons, I have no intention of donating to the DNC,' media mogul Barry Diller told The Post last week. Getty Images 'There is just a broad consensus that the DNC is ineffectual and not where we should be giving money,' said a longtime former donor. 'But it's not surprising,' the source said. ''I don't belong to an organized party, I'm a Democrat' is a longtime joke for a reason. 'We're so decentralized,' the source added. 'The DNC has always been a joke. If you are a megadonor looking to shape the direction of the party, don't give to the DNC. At this point, the shape of the DNC is just embarrassing.' The drop-off in fundraising has left some party bosses questioning whether the committee will have to take out loans, though DNC Chairman Ken Martin has expressed doubt that will happen. A DNC rep said that many long-time donors have already contributed to the DNC this year as part of a record-breaking donation drive in the first four months under Martin. 6 Former New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg is another billionaire who has opted not to support the fundraising committee at the moment, sources said. AP But another donor who told The Post his wallet is now closed to the committee said Martin may have his head in the sand. 'People are too embarrassed to admit this,' the source said. 'I'm a lifelong Dem who raised a ton of money, and I won't give them a nickel — and I'm not alone. 'I'm not even a Democrat anymore. The Dems should kidnap Elizabeth Warren and take her to Mexico,' the source said of the lefty Massachusetts senator. 'This is how Trump got [his win] — not because Trump is loved but because his ideas are popular.' Other sources pointed out that recent Democratic fundraising has been largely channeled into the New York City's mayoral race, with party leaders increasingly concerned about the prospect of self-described socialist Zohran Mamdani overtaking ex-Gov. Andrew Cuomo in the primary contest. 6 The drop-off in fundraising has left some party bosses questioning whether the committee will have to take out loans, though DNC Chairman Ken Martin has expressed doubt that will have to happen. AP The DNC's most recent financial filings, released last week, revealed that it bled nearly $3 million alone from its already dwindling reserves during the month of May, with the committee's pot of gold now standing at a precarious $15 million. Should Mamdani win, that could further erode support for the DNC from big donors who are concerned their money will simply go to socialists, sources noted. For its part, the DNC has denied that donor support is wavering. In a statement released Friday, it touted what it called 'record fundraising' and the 'highest in DNC history under any chair's first four months' for Martin. 6 Hedge fund manager Marc Lasry isn't in a hurry to help the DNC right its balance sheet, either, sources said. Sportico via Getty Images The DNC told Axios that the nearly $40 million it garnered between February and May of 2025 'surpasses the $37 million raised under Jaime Harrison's leadership in those same months in 2021.' 'In the early and mid 2010's, some big-money donors already tried not funding the DNC and state parties, instead funding groups outside of the Party, which hollowed out the critical work that the Party does while putting us behind the eight-ball when it came to critical coordination during the 2016 presidential election,' warned on Democratic strategist. 'We all know how that story ended — Donald Trump won the Presidency and the Democratic Party fell to an all-time low at every level of government. The Democratic Party needs a fully-funded Party to fight Donald Trump.' 6 Former President Joe Biden and his administration are under fire for vowing to restore the 'soul of the nation' — then allegedly going so progressive that they only widened rifts. AP The Republican National Committee, on the other hand, had a net-positive cash flow for May. It added more than $5 million to its treasure trove, bringing its total funds to more than $72 million. These new numbers put the RNC's cash stash at almost five times the size of the DNC's. And it's welcome news for Republicans. Home Depot founder Ken Langone, a longtime GOP donor, was thrilled by the accounting and said to friends, 'We don't have to worry as the GOP party because the Dem positions are so stupid they'll never raise money again,' sources said.
